Common Foundry (CMFD) is not a mainnet — it is a marketing campaign wearing a blockchain costume...
Thanks for the criticism. Technical scrutiny is welcome, especially for a new network, but several claims in this post are either incorrect or do not describe Feelcoin.
First, a basic point: your post begins by referring to "Common Foundry (CMFD)." This thread is about Feelcoin (FEEL). If you intended these claims to apply to Feelcoin, they should be evaluated against Feelcoin's actual blockchain, source code and infrastructure.
A few factual corrections:
1. Feelcoin was not privately launched or premined.There was no ICO, presale, private coin allocation or developer premine.
Mining began from genesis through Proof of Work under the same network rules available to everyone.
Feelcoin does have a transparent protocol treasury, but that is not a premine. Beginning at block 590, 2% of the existing block subsidy is directed to the development treasury while 98% goes to miners. Transaction fees remain with miners.
The treasury rule and address are public and verifiable on-chain and in the source code.
2. Feelcoin is an independent mainnet.Feelcoin has its own:
- genesis block
- blockchain history
- network configuration
- address namespace
- mainnet ports
- consensus parameters
- emission rules
It is not a token deployed on another blockchain and it is not a testnet.
3. RandomX is CPU-oriented, not a secret GPU-optimized algorithm.The claim that the network used an algorithm optimized for hardware known only to insiders is incorrect.
Feelcoin uses RandomX, a publicly documented Proof-of-Work algorithm designed primarily around general-purpose CPUs.
There is nothing secret about the mining algorithm or the software used to mine it.
4. The pool "-p" value is not a security PIN.The password parameter used by mining software is the conventional Stratum worker/password field.
Using values such as:
does not grant administrative access, control consensus, authenticate ownership of the blockchain, or provide privileged mining capability.
5. The blockchain can be audited from genesis.Early blocks are not "permanently unauditable."
Anyone can run Feelcoin Core and independently inspect the blockchain from the beginning, including:
- block hashes
- heights
- timestamps
- coinbase transactions
- rewards
- outputs
- difficulty
- treasury allocation
If you believe an abnormal reward, hidden allocation or premine exists, please provide the specific block height, transaction hash or source-code rule demonstrating it.
Those are objective claims that can be checked.
6. Feelcoin no longer depends on a single public node.The network currently has two published bootstrap nodes:
node1.feelcoin.org:35780
node2.feelcoin.org:35780
Feelcoin Core v0.2.1 includes these bootstrap nodes directly, allowing a fresh daemon to discover the Feelcoin network without requiring users to manually configure the original server.
This does not mean Feelcoin has already achieved ideal decentralization. It means infrastructure redundancy is being built progressively and transparently.
7. The official pool does not control participation in consensus.The official pool exists to make mining easier, particularly while the network is young.
It is not permissioned infrastructure.
Anyone is free to:
- run a Feelcoin node
- solo mine
- operate another mining pool
- build the software from source
- verify the blockchain independently
- inspect or modify the open-source code
No permission from the Feelcoin project is required to participate in the network.
8. The Windows antivirus issue was handled publicly rather than bypassed.The original Windows cryptocurrency binaries triggered antivirus detections.
Rather than telling users to disable security software or create antivirus exclusions, the Windows release was temporarily withdrawn while the release process was reviewed.
The current stable release is Feelcoin Core v0.2.1 for Linux x86_64.
Source code, the tagged release, binary package and SHA256 checksum are public.
Current Feelcoin infrastructure:Website:
https://feelcoin.orgExplorer:
https://explorer.feelcoin.orgMining Pool:
https://pool.feelcoin.orgWeb Wallet:
https://wallet.feelcoin.orgPaper Wallet:
https://paper.feelcoin.orgSource:
https://github.com/feelcoin-org/feelcoinCore v0.2.1:
https://github.com/feelcoin-org/feelcoin/releases/tag/v0.2.1I agree with one broader point in your criticism:
Feelcoin is a very young network, and infrastructure and mining distribution are naturally more concentrated today than we want them to be long term.
We do not claim otherwise.
More independent nodes, independent pools, miners, reviewers and contributors are desirable, and the project is actively moving in that direction.
What we will not do is pretend that early-stage infrastructure concentration is the same thing as a hidden premine, private blockchain or unauditable consensus.
Feelcoin's approach is simple:
Don't ask users to trust claims that can instead be checked in code, releases or on-chain data.If you find an actual consensus flaw, hidden allocation, invalid reward or other verifiable technical problem, please post the block, transaction, commit or source-code line.
That kind of criticism is useful and welcome.
— Feelcoin
In Feels We Trust.