144 Spartan6 LX150 FPGA cluster! 28.8 GH/s!!!

[stcupp]

Has anyone seen these before?

http://www.dinigroup.com/new/DNBFC_S12_12_Cluster.php

Any idea on what one of these would cost?
each board has 12 spartan6 LX150's
http://www.dinigroup.com/product/data/DNBFC_S12_PCIe/images/rev2frontb.jpg
http://www.dinigroup.com/product/data/DNBFC_S12_PCIe/images/DNBFC_S12_PCIe_blckv14.png

And 12 of these boards in a cluster

http://www.dinigroup.com/product/data/DNBFC_S12_12_Cluster/images/front.jpg
http://www.dinigroup.com/product/data/DNBFC_S12_PCIe/images/DNBFC_S12_12_Cluster_v100.png

144 Spartan6 LX150 * 200 MH/s = 28.8 GH/s!!!!

[Timbo925]

well I guess it's out of my price range 

[stcupp]

lol yeah mine too

http://www.fpga-faq.com/FPGA_Boards.shtml

this site lists each pcie board as $7950.00

$7950.00 * 12 = $95,400

so i'd say the whole cluster is around $110,000

[Mousepotato]

Ships in 4-6 weeks.

[Timbo925]

Ships in 4-6 weeks.

 Made me LOL 

[kais3r]

lol yeah mine too

http://www.fpga-faq.com/FPGA_Boards.shtml

this site lists each pcie board as $7950.00

$7950.00 * 12 = $95,400

so i'd say the whole cluster is around $110,000

wow, I believe with 110K you could make a much more efficient mining rig

[rjk]

I wonder how recent that price is though. I bet if someone contacted them, it could be had for cheaper.

[stcupp]

lol yeah mine too

http://www.fpga-faq.com/FPGA_Boards.shtml

this site lists each pcie board as $7950.00

$7950.00 * 12 = $95,400

so i'd say the whole cluster is around $110,000

wow, I believe with 110K you could make a much more efficient mining rig

Maybe more hashes but not more efficient... FPGA's don't use as much power

each card with 12 fpga's is probably only running around 1800mh/s at 120 watts

while a gpu runs around 750 mh/s at 400 watts or 350mh/s for 200 watts

also theres no where near as much heat output on these cards compared to gpu's

so FPGA's are alot more efficient less money in power, more mh/s per watt, and less money in cooling

[[Tycho]]

Power/cooling to handle up to 5W per FPGA

Not enough. Full-speed mining would require more than 8W per FPGA.

Also, it's at least 3 times more expensive than currently available Spartan-6 mining solutions.

[stcupp]

Power/cooling to handle up to 5W per FPGA

Not enough. Full-speed mining would require more than 8W per FPGA.

Also, it's at least 3 times more expensive than currently available Spartan-6 mining solutions.

I noticed this too.... its about $660 per spartan 6 there are cheaper solutions in the cards built just for mining

God I just wish i had the $ to play around with a huge fpga cluster.....

[zefir]

Anyone noticed this one:
http://enterpoint.co.uk/products/spartan-6-development-boards/xc6slx150-x2/
Shop: http://www.enterpoint.co.uk/shop/en/93-xc6slx150-x2-coprocessor.html
2 XC6SLX150, 400 MH/s, £300.00 tax excl. => ~1.2US$ / MH/s

This one is less cost-effective, but higher integrated:
http://enterpoint.co.uk/products/asic-development-high-performance-computing/merrick-3/
Shop: http://www.enterpoint.co.uk/shop/en/98-merrick-3.html (sold out)
24 XC6SLX150, 4.8 GH/s, £6,500.00 tax excl. => ~2.2US$ / MH/s

The first one got my heads-up, since it comes for a price comparable to Icarus, which currently is the most cost-effective and commercially available FPGA miner.

[Dexter770221]

No sign of high current regulators for VCCINT and no sign of holes to mount a heatsink, so this boards are poorly designed for mining and you will not achieve more than 50MH/s.

[zefir]

No sign of high current regulators for VCCINT and no sign of holes to mount a heatsink, so this boards are poorly designed for mining and you will not achieve more than 50MH/s.

... knew there is a catch. Anyhow my BitForces are to ship soon

[ArtForz]

Anyone noticed this one:
http://enterpoint.co.uk/products/spartan-6-development-boards/xc6slx150-x2/
Shop: http://www.enterpoint.co.uk/shop/en/93-xc6slx150-x2-coprocessor.html
2 XC6SLX150, 400 MH/s, £300.00 tax excl. => ~1.2US$ / MH/s

This one is less cost-effective, but higher integrated:
http://enterpoint.co.uk/products/asic-development-high-performance-computing/merrick-3/
Shop: http://www.enterpoint.co.uk/shop/en/98-merrick-3.html (sold out)
24 XC6SLX150, 4.8 GH/s, £6,500.00 tax excl. => ~2.2US$ / MH/s

The first one got my heads-up, since it comes for a price comparable to Icarus, which currently is the most cost-effective and commercially available FPGA miner.

First one has a shared 10A reg for 2 LX150s -> max of 5A vccint each.
Second has a 12A for 4 LX150s -> 3A each
My early LX150 miner prototypes had a 60A switcher for vccint for 8 chips -> 7.5A each... and that later turned out to be not enough.
Btw, one thing that made me go WTF when looking at interior pics of copacobana a few years ago... a single massive AC->1.2V converter for vccint and really heavy cables + busbars to route it around...

[zefir]

First one has a shared 10A reg for 2 LX150s -> max of 5A vccint each.
Second has a 12A for 4 LX150s -> 3A each
My early LX150 miner prototypes had a 60A switcher for vccint for 8 chips -> 7.5A each... and that later turned out to be not enough.
Btw, one thing that made me go WTF when looking at interior pics of copacobana a few years ago... a single massive AC->1.2V converter for vccint and really heavy cables + busbars to route it around...

At least it's good to know that you get what you pay for (even if the price premium might be slightly disproportional). Don't really know what they charge for the Copacobana, but speculate it should be in the 6-digit range.

[Inspector 2211]

My early LX150 miner prototypes had a 60A switcher for vccint for 8 chips -> 7.5A each... and that later turned out to be not enough.

So, how come the German guy (Stefan) of ZTEX gets by with a [very compact] 8 Amp converter for VCCINT?
His dynamic clocking now achieves > 200 MH/s on a -3 device.
Impressive.
(Even more impressive considering the fact that he has less than half of the Xilinx-mandated amount of bypass capacitors surrounding the Spartan-6.)

Btw, one thing that made me go WTF when looking at interior pics of copacobana a few years ago... a single massive AC->1.2V converter for vccint and really heavy cables + busbars to route it around...

Here's a picture: http://www.copacobana.org/photos/photo_b4.jpg

[ArtForz]

My early LX150 miner prototypes had a 60A switcher for vccint for 8 chips -> 7.5A each... and that later turned out to be not enough.

So, how come the German guy (Stefan) of ZTEX gets by with a [very compact] 8 Amp converter for VCCINT?
His dynamic clocking now achieves > 200 MH/s on a -3 device.
Impressive.
(Even more impressive considering the fact that he has less than half of the Xilinx-mandated amount of bypass capacitors surrounding the Spartan-6.)

Btw, one thing that made me go WTF when looking at interior pics of copacobana a few years ago... a single massive AC->1.2V converter for vccint and really heavy cables + busbars to route it around...

Here's a picture: http://www.copacobana.org/photos/photo_b4.jpg

Well, 7.5A/core was ok for a 192-205MHz 122-round 2-stage-per-round pipeline design. Just my later designs needed more power.
Also, unless I misremember, he uses ultra-low-esl 0306 caps for vccint, xilinx recommended #s are for caps with ESL values similar to 0402s... so... prolly fine.
Yep, that's the picture... Still don't get why on earth they did it that way. A AC->12V PSU and half a dozen or so point-of-load converters would've saved a whole lot of copper (and prevent accidentally welding holes in your chassis...)

[RandyFolds]

No sign of high current regulators for VCCINT and no sign of holes to mount a heatsink, so this boards are poorly designed for mining and you will not achieve more than 50MH/s.

... knew there is a catch. Anyhow my BitForces are to ship soon

See mousepotato's comment...

[DeathAndTaxes]

I wonder how recent that price is though. I bet if someone contacted them, it could be had for cheaper.

Probably not.  They are custom built and have tons of high speed connectivity, and banks of ram.  Totally useless for Bitcoin but expensive and useful for other applications.

[[Tycho]]

Btw, one thing that made me go WTF when looking at interior pics of copacobana a few years ago... a single massive AC->1.2V converter for vccint and really heavy cables + busbars to route it around...

Why they don't need any heatsinks on their FPGAs ?