lol

[jitty2]

drop the stupid posting requirements.

[schnell]

No. It helps stop spammers like you from joining just to attempt trolling, and just annoy people with irrelevant threads/posts.

[jitty2]

It didn't stop anything. Now instead of making legitimate posts I'm forced to make worthless ones in a forum that is never used/viewed after the first 5 posts. If anything this has increased spam, moderation, and overhead when scarce resources could be used elsewhere!

[Matthew N. Wright]

It didn't stop anything. Now instead of making legitimate posts I'm forced to make worthless ones in a forum that is never used/viewed after the first 5 posts. If anything this has increased spam, moderation, and overhead when scarce resources could be used elsewhere!

Actually, no. As much as I hate the ridiculous newbie jail, you're absolutely wrong about it being useless. What you've done is basically shown your intentions, your lack of quality posts and your annoying attitude in a closed environment that the more impatient users don't need to see and let us, the more patient and devoted trolls sniff you out easier, meaning that from this point on, regardless of what you post, we'll be following your every move, waiting for you to make a mistake so we can strike you down and remind you of all your ridiculousness.

Newbie jail is not about "earning" anything, it's about "surviving" undetected and unscathed. You've already failed. Best go make another ID.

[jitty2]

Actually you are wrong, I wouldn't have made this post to begin with, and this is the 'other' id. This further validates my point of increased useless posts and overhead when resources should be used to moderate substantive forums.

[Matthew N. Wright]

Actually you are wrong, I wouldn't have made this post to begin with, and this is the 'other' id. This further validates my point of increased useless posts and overhead when resources should be used to moderate substantive forums.

[schnell]

I was new when I first signed up, so I asked questions about bitcoin in the newbie section. People often browse there to help others.
After a few posts discussing bitcoin and asking questions, I was out. It only took me a day to get out.
I then went straight to the lending section and asked for a 75BTC loan XD

[jitty2]

What was the cash equivalent and did you provide identification? That's a pretty large sum between strangers.

[schnell]

What was the cash equivalent and did you provide identification? That's a pretty large sum between strangers.

Around 450 dollars at the time.
Not that that is any of your business.
The point is, that I believe the newbie jail should be raised to 25 posts and 24 hours online, so people have longer to learn how the forum works(ie they dont ask for a 450 dollar loan as soon as they are out)

[jitty2]

So everyone should be punished for you lack of etiquette or general ignorance?

[Fiyasko]

How about NO you fuckhead. It was a ShitShow in Bitcointalk.org when the posting reqiurment didnt exsist. Deal with it.
It deters trolls
Deters scammers
Deters Idiots.

Whats the negative factor of it? That you have to post to be allowed to post where you want to? That doesnt sound so bad considering the benefeits.

ALSO YOU CAN BE WHITELISTED, Skipping the requirements compleately

Edit: Anyone else think that the poll is being spammed with "yes" votes from Crap accounts?

[Matthew N. Wright]

Edit: Anyone else think that the poll is being spammed with "yes" votes from Crap accounts?

Even more likely is that non-newbies seldom care about newbie posted threads so there is an obvious partiality towards not needing to be a newbie from the newbies posting. I voted just to break it even though.

[donking]

The prison system is important. It creates jobs.

[RodeoX]

It is easy to hate the post requirements when you have not seen what lead to it. It was so bad that I personally supported a requirement to pay to be here. 

[tonto]

I'd pay a (small amount) of bitcoin annually for posting rights.  It was horrible before.
 
I'd rather I didn't have to pay, but if it came to that I would.

[edit: and I posted "no"]

[schnell]

So everyone should be punished for you lack of etiquette or general ignorance?

I could think of many, many responses to this. But, as I am a mature adult, I will end this pointless argument you decided to start. Just be glad you didn't assault someone more popular, because everyone will hate you then.

Oh, and before I go, why do you want out of noob jail? You have made no useful or relavent posts thus far, so you can hardly point out my flaws, because that would be just hypocritical.

[Trader Joe]

Newbie jail sucks.

[dog]

I understand why it's here, but it'd be nice to have a recommendation system (with penalties for the recommender if the recomendee scams, to discourage sales) so that joke accounts of established members, like this one, can make it through quickly

[Maged]

I understand why it's here, but it'd be nice to have a recommendation system (with penalties for the recommender if the recomendee scams, to discourage sales) so that joke accounts of established members, like this one, can make it through quickly

And, as you found out, that's exactly what we have. In fact, I specifically mention it in the OP of the whitelist request sticky:

If you learned of Bitcoin through a currently established member of this forum who feels that you are ready to be released to the rest of the forum or who is willing to mentor you, or if you want to make a new account that is separate from your already-existing established forum account, have the existing user/account vouch for you after you have made your request.