Thanks for your well thought out opinion.
No problem.
I have did not pay for the assay so was just a jewelry store assaying them
First, "I did not". Not "I have did not".
Secondly, how can you be so sure that the assay was truthful if it was not professional? I highly doubt you got the full assay service for free.
My proof was telling him the shop I went to and asking him to call to verify what happened (he declined and said it was probably my buddy)
While yes, it was a dick move for him to make, he is right about it possibly just being "your buddy".
He has acknowledged I am under by "$5 of silver" but has no interest in making it right.
Do you agree with this statement? Or do you believe he owes more? You don't make it very clear.
I have not disregarded it the Barber sent. It was a part of the deal in case he made a "slight mistake. I view a slight mistake as a percent or two, not 12%.
In my honest opinion, the barber should cover a bit more than a percent or two. Even if you do not view it as a slight mistake, I think a barber half was decent compensation.
Please see the screencap of the original thread. He didnt sell this as "Silver bars or around .925, maybe more maybe less. This is my first shot so no guarantees." He sold(and marked) these as .99. Hence the issue.
I can understand this issue from this point of perspective.
Honestly on reflection and based on his history (buying "Cohibas" which he thought were real in tj) I dont think JW intentionally ripped me off.
I agree with this statement.
But come on dude, I am the liar? I have offered multiple ways to either make this right or definitively prove me a scammer(and take home 25btc additional in the process). He hasn't taken any of them. If you really read through this thread and see me as the guilty party I doubt your judgement (or you are a shill for JW). I have offered multiple ways through this, he has offered none (well one which doesn't address the issue at hand).
The main reason I called you a liar is because you have no docs. If you manage to return with the assay docs, the case will probably be resolved much quicker.
Tell you what JW, If I go and get an assay printout and video the process will you finally do what is right(either refund or 1:1 trade for silver weight)?
I agree with this too. JW should answer to this.