Isn't this considered spamming?

[jacee]

Saw this guys posts and the majority of his posts are all one liner and doesn't even make a good statement. If you can view his posts you can see them. All like this.

Isn't this considered as spamming?
I hope the sig campaign he is in don't pay him with this crappy posts. Also don't he deserve a warning or something?

[Athertle]

Just for other users to see, here's the user's last posts (as well as his profile if you'd like): https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=140438;sa=showPosts

And people have already called him out in the signature campaign: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1167837.msg12591205#msg12591205

EDIT: He's almost definitely not going to be paid by the signature campaign with that kind of posts and, IMHO, deserves to be banned.

[Cyrus]

Thanks for the heads up.

[yahoo62278]

Hey guys im aware of the problem myself and I will be posting new rules for the MagicalDice campaign as well as taking care of some of these spammers personally tonight. I just took over as signature manager last friday and the next paydate is tonight around midnight. The spreadsheet is posted in the thread and for anyone who cares to have a look tonight you will see a very large number of rejected posts for alot of users.

To any of the staff or moderators who plan on patrolling the users in this campaign, if its possible coild i be Pmmed if you plan on banning users for sig spam so i may remove them from the campaign as well

[botany]

To any of the staff or moderators who plan on patrolling the users in this campaign, if its possible coild i be Pmmed if you plan on banning users for sig spam so i may remove them from the campaign as well

Just keep an eye out for accounts which suddenly go silent.
You can also create a thread where people can complain about accounts in your campaign which are spamming (refer my signature, there is a link)

[--Encrypted--]

To any of the staff or moderators who plan on patrolling the users in this campaign, if its possible coild i be Pmmed if you plan on banning users for sig spam so i may remove them from the campaign as well

Just keep an eye out for accounts which suddenly go silent.
You can also create a thread where people can complain about accounts in your campaign which are spamming (refer my signature, there is a link)

yes. also making a rule that goes like "2 weeks without posting and you're out" will work. most people get banned for 2 weeks anyway.

[Anmol_Verma]

I think spamming is that when some one posts unrelated to the topic.its our choice if we want to post one line or 1000 lines how can be short sentences be spamming?

[jacee]

I think spamming is that when some one posts unrelated to the topic.its our choice if we want to post one line or 1000 lines how can be short sentences be spamming?

Uhh... Posting a one liner sentences with the same thought on different thread. How is it not considered spamming? The guy was in a signature campaign where constructive post are being paid with bitcoins. Don't you think that is a bit unfair for people who post such crappy stuff? 

[mexxer-2]

I think spamming is that when some one posts unrelated to the topic.its our choice if we want to post one line or 1000 lines how can be short sentences be spamming?

Uhh... Posting a one liner sentences with the same thought on different thread. How is it not considered spamming? The guy was in a signature campaign where constructive post are being paid with bitcoins. Don't you think that is a bit unfair for people who post such crappy stuff? 

It is, but did you try reporting the thread instead of making a thread(probably for the sole purpose of earning from posts as well). The meta is getting cluttered with "Isn't this spamming?" type of threads, if you have a problem with someone's post quality either tell/report it to mods or the signature camapign the person is in, if applicable

[Anmol_Verma]

I think spamming is that when some one posts unrelated to the topic.its our choice if we want to post one line or 1000 lines how can be short sentences be spamming?

Uhh... Posting a one liner sentences with the same thought on different thread. How is it not considered spamming? The guy was in a signature campaign where constructive post are being paid with bitcoins. Don't you think that is a bit unfair for people who post such crappy stuff? 

The compaign manager will remove that person for spamming in the end yes posting same thing on multiple threads is considered spamming but not the one liners who post different on different topics

[hilariousandco]

I think spamming is that when some one posts unrelated to the topic.its our choice if we want to post one line or 1000 lines how can be short sentences be spamming?

No, spamming is also when people like you and 99% of everyone else on yobit just post 20 one lines of crap a day to get their max payout and you get it because yobit has no quality control at all.

I think spamming is that when some one posts unrelated to the topic.its our choice if we want to post one line or 1000 lines how can be short sentences be spamming?

Uhh... Posting a one liner sentences with the same thought on different thread. How is it not considered spamming? The guy was in a signature campaign where constructive post are being paid with bitcoins. Don't you think that is a bit unfair for people who post such crappy stuff?  

The compaign manager will remove that person for spamming in the end

Except they don't because campaigns like yobit and secondstrade don't do anything to manage their campaigns and just use bots to make the payouts so you can get paid for posting 20 one word responses in off topic everyday.

[jacee]

I think spamming is that when some one posts unrelated to the topic.its our choice if we want to post one line or 1000 lines how can be short sentences be spamming?

No, spamming is also when people like you and 99% of everyone else on yobit just post 20 one lines of crap a day to get their max payout and you get it because yobit has no quality control at all.

I think spamming is that when some one posts unrelated to the topic.its our choice if we want to post one line or 1000 lines how can be short sentences be spamming?

Uhh... Posting a one liner sentences with the same thought on different thread. How is it not considered spamming? The guy was in a signature campaign where constructive post are being paid with bitcoins. Don't you think that is a bit unfair for people who post such crappy stuff?  

The compaign manager will remove that person for spamming in the end

Except they don't because campaigns like yobit and secondstrade don't do anything to manage their campaigns and just use bots to make the payouts so you can get paid for posting 20 one word responses in off topic everyday.

Burned.

Anyway, shouldn't those kinds of campaigns be moderated and give them some rules to follow? I think that could help to prevent the over crowding of people who will just keep on posting spammy posts just because their campaign manager don't do such action against them. 

[hilariousandco]

Anyway, shouldn't those kinds of campaigns be moderated and give them some rules to follow? I think that could help to prevent the over crowding of people who will just keep on posting spammy posts just because their campaign manager don't do such action against them. 

Several things have been suggested to try deal with problem campaigns but discussion has seemingly stalled but it's also difficult to effectively force them to do anything. Personally I think those campaign managers should be temp and then perma banned if they can't get on top of their campaigns and do their job properly. It's just a couple of campaigns that are spoiling it for everyone because the ones that actually have active campaign managers who do what they're supposed to and check posts produce little spam and they usually take approriate action and refuse payment with ones that do but then those users that get kicked off just move to one of the campaigns like yobit or secondtrade that will take them and pay them for anything they post regardless of quality.

[Anmol_Verma]

I think spamming is that when some one posts unrelated to the topic.its our choice if we want to post one line or 1000 lines how can be short sentences be spamming?

No, spamming is also when people like you and 99% of everyone else on yobit just post 20 one lines of crap a day to get their max payout and you get it because yobit has no quality control at all.

I think spamming is that when some one posts unrelated to the topic.its our choice if we want to post one line or 1000 lines how can be short sentences be spamming?

Uhh... Posting a one liner sentences with the same thought on different thread. How is it not considered spamming? The guy was in a signature campaign where constructive post are being paid with bitcoins. Don't you think that is a bit unfair for people who post such crappy stuff?  

The compaign manager will remove that person for spamming in the end

Except they don't because campaigns like yobit and secondstrade don't do anything to manage their campaigns and just use bots to make the payouts so you can get paid for posting 20 one word responses in off topic everyday.

Yobit bot generally don't accept low quality posts and spammy post.
Their automaic post counter only count constructive posts.i have seen that on my own account.
No short posts are counted

[hilariousandco]

Yobit bot generally don't accept low quality posts and spammy post.
Their automaic post counter only count constructive posts.i have seen that on my own account.
No short posts are counted

HAHA don't make me laugh. They accepted you didn't they or do you not expect to get paid for most of your posts? You quite clearly don't know what you're talking about. They accept everyone and pay everyone regardless of content. The majority of posters on their campaign post drivel. Your stats just haven't updated yet as other people told you.

Please someone help me
I posted more then 20 posts today but in yobit its showing New posts as only 4
It's been 3 hours already still not stats updated
Please tell me why my 20 posts are not counted by the bot and just 4 posts counted?

Hey i did more then 20 posts today but on yobit it's just showing 4 new posts even the 3 hour time is passed

Just wait until the next update on yobit site and probably you will see all your 20 posts are paid. I used to join yobit in the past and i didnt get any problem on them except the send to balance button

[Anmol_Verma]

Yobit bot generally don't accept low quality posts and spammy post.
Their automaic post counter only count constructive posts.i have seen that on my own account.
No short posts are counted

HAHA don't make me laugh. They accepted you didn't they or do you not expect to get paid for most of your posts? You quite clearly don't know what you're talking about. They accept everyone and pay everyone regardless of content. The majority of posters on their campaign post drivel. Your stats just haven't updated yet as other people told you.

Please someone help me
I posted more then 20 posts today but in yobit its showing New posts as only 4
It's been 3 hours already still not stats updated
Please tell me why my 20 posts are not counted by the bot and just 4 posts counted?

Hey i did more then 20 posts today but on yobit it's just showing 4 new posts even the 3 hour time is passed

Just wait until the next update on yobit site and probably you will see all your 20 posts are paid. I used to join yobit in the past and i didnt get any problem on them except the send to balance button

You are right now i see my balance just updated!
If there is a way that bot can count the no of posts..isn't there such a way that only constructive posts bigger then 75 characters are counted?

[hilariousandco]

You are right now i see my balance just updated!
If there is a way that bot can count the no of posts..isn't there such a way that only constructive posts bigger then 75 characters are counted?

There are campaigns that do that but yobit isn't one of them and no bot can dedect whether a post is 'constructive' or not and that's why you need someone who actually manages the campaign to check. 75 characters isn't a lot either and it doesn't stop people posting rubbish, just rubbish in 75 characters, but it's not about how short people's posts are but the content which is usually hollow if there's nobody checking them and paying automatically because people quickly realise they can get away with it and they continue on day after day when there's no repurcussions.

[LFC_Bitcoin]

The posts that the OP has taken a screenshot of are low quality but they're not spamming imo. If the signature campaign he is in pays based on quality then he should perhaps get paid the lowest rate that they offer for his rank but those posts aren't spam imo.

I was under the impression bans for non constructive posts or spamming had to be 2 or 3 words, I mean like really crap.