My first page was Mr. Frump's Awesome Web Page of Awesomeness, circa 2000, I WISH I had a copy of that one. Of course, created using the sloppy GUI, it was my first web site. It was awesome. I still think it was created in 97, but 2000 at the latest. But it's gone now.
It's gone but I still have the same set of bookmarks since the '90's and the bookmark still appears as if I went to it yesterday:
And now it will be further encapsulated in time via this post.
My oldest still active website is something I slapped together in about 2 seconds on Bravenet, it's funny because I forgot that I had made it and it's... somewhat awesome, a lot more work was put into the geocities site...
You have just wasted your time.