MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:(

[kingcrimson]

Been waiting 5 days now, sent a dozen support ticket requests and got no response.

[1715599409]

1715599409

[1715599409]

1715599409

[1715599409]

1715599409

[1715599409]

1715599409

[joesmoe2012]

Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take?

It is recommended by Mark @ irc to break large withdraws into multiple small ones (i was told to keep it under 100 BTC each).

[Rampion]

Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take?

It is recommended by Mark @ irc to break large withdraws into multiple small ones (i was told to keep it under 100 BTC each).

That could only mean they are nearly broke and having liquidity problems. Otherwise, what does it change for the blockchain if the withdrawal is 100 or 1000? AFAIK the blockchain has no "limits" and in fact, AS WE ALL KNOW, dust is discouraged and for the network "the bigger the better" as it reduces blockchain bloating.

[snioctib]

Update: took 2 1/2 days, but I received my bitcoin (under a different transaction).

[joesmoe2012]

Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take?

It is recommended by Mark @ irc to break large withdraws into multiple small ones (i was told to keep it under 100 BTC each).

That could only mean they are nearly broke and having liquidity problems. Otherwise, what does it change for the blockchain if the withdrawal is 100 or 1000? AFAIK the blockchain has no "limits" and in fact, AS WE ALL KNOW, dust is discouraged and for the network "the bigger the better" as it reduces blockchain bloating.

Actually it has nothing to do with them being 'broke,' but rather with the way they form transactions using many different inputs. A very large transaction will have hundreds of inputs @ mtgox, causing significant delays before it is processed.

Smaller transactions have lss inputs and are thus processed more quickly.

[pinger]

Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take?

One person here withdrew 700btc. It took him five days to receive I think.

According how the withdraws works on gox, I would make 7 withdrawals to take that 700, not a direct 700 withdrawal. Is better to be stocked with 300 btc than 700 btc.

I hope you can understand what I'm trying to say, my english is becoming worst every day

Today I was not able to withdraw 1500 euros, I ever get an error. I'm not happy with Gox now, I never had a problem until now.

BTW my 150 euros sent before, are still on the road, but I'm not able to found it on the log of gox.

My transfer just arrived, but not 150, just 136.62 €.

[GreenBits]

This just happened to me attempting to transfer 9.43573859 BTC from MTGox to Cex.io. Only been about an hour but I have very dim hopes for getting access to my btc in a timely fashion.

Oh, and I missed buying into the damn dip on Cex... icing on the cake.

So, if you can read this, Goxians, and are in a position to help, please review

Ticket #173858 Stuck/Incomplete BTC Withdrawal

Its not showing up on skanner.net, but I have screenies so I'm not too concerned, just annoyed.

~Green

[GreenBits]

Does Gox answer support on Sat/Sun?? Live chat is anything but. My support ticket hasn't been supported yet. This does not augur well for my weekend.

Will keep the folk updated. 

BTW, is there no forum member that acts as technical support/ PR liason for Gox?

^{Now, perhaps if I had put my support request in a bottle, and violently flung the fucker into an ocean, maybe someone would have looked at it by now.}

[HeliKopterBen]

Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take?

It is recommended by Mark @ irc to break large withdraws into multiple small ones (i was told to keep it under 100 BTC each).

That could only mean they are nearly broke and having liquidity problems. Otherwise, what does it change for the blockchain if the withdrawal is 100 or 1000? AFAIK the blockchain has no "limits" and in fact, AS WE ALL KNOW, dust is discouraged and for the network "the bigger the better" as it reduces blockchain bloating.

Actually it has nothing to do with them being 'broke,' but rather with the way they form transactions using many different inputs. A very large transaction will have hundreds of inputs @ mtgox, causing significant delays before it is processed.

Smaller transactions have lss inputs and are thus processed more quickly.

Then why don't they just post a simple message stating that large withdrawals will take longer.  I just withdrew 1 btc and then another withdrawal of 50 btc and both went through within a few minutes.  I then tried a 100 btc withdrawal and still waiting 1.5 hrs later.  I would gladly have broken it up if I knew this ahead of time but there was nothing alerting me to large withdrawal delays.

[bakada]

,,

[joesmoe2012]

Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take?

It is recommended by Mark @ irc to break large withdraws into multiple small ones (i was told to keep it under 100 BTC each).

That could only mean they are nearly broke and having liquidity problems. Otherwise, what does it change for the blockchain if the withdrawal is 100 or 1000? AFAIK the blockchain has no "limits" and in fact, AS WE ALL KNOW, dust is discouraged and for the network "the bigger the better" as it reduces blockchain bloating.

Actually it has nothing to do with them being 'broke,' but rather with the way they form transactions using many different inputs. A very large transaction will have hundreds of inputs @ mtgox, causing significant delays before it is processed.

Smaller transactions have lss inputs and are thus processed more quickly.

Then why don't they just post a simple message stating that large withdrawals will take longer.  I just withdrew 1 btc and then another withdrawal of 50 btc and both went through within a few minutes.  I then tried a 100 btc withdrawal and still waiting 1.5 hrs later.  I would gladly have broken it up if I knew this ahead of time but there was nothing alerting me to large withdrawal delays.

As i said, i was specifically told by karples that breaking large transactions into < 100 BTC chunks would make them go faster.

[HeliKopterBen]

Then why don't they just post a simple message stating that large withdrawals will take longer.  I just withdrew 1 btc and then another withdrawal of 50 btc and both went through within a few minutes.  I then tried a 100 btc withdrawal and still waiting 1.5 hrs later.  I would gladly have broken it up if I knew this ahead of time but there was nothing alerting me to large withdrawal delays.

You mean simple things like this splashed across the withdrawal page:

"BTC : You can still withdraw up to 100.00000000 BTC provided you have enough on your account (your limit is 100.00000000 BTC per 24 hours )"

Open your eyes.

It says I can withdraw up to 2000 per day.  Not 100.

[GreenBits]

Deposit made it into my CEX.io wallet sometime this morning. Thanks, if someone had to push any buttons/pull any levers to facilitate this. No response from support yet so I wonder if this just "unstuck" itself.


~Green

[GreenBits]

so, i have to ask, from veteran Gox users, how often does this happen? am i statistically over the hump as far as this occurring again? esp on sub 10 btc amounts?

another user contacted me via email, got hit for 13.8. denying access to funds in this time sensitive market is the cardinal sin in this space. i want to use Gox (volatility is off the chain) but I'd almost be a fool to send them my coins again.

Thoughts?

~Green
sorry to keep bumping this thread so hard

[pinger]

so, i have to ask, from veteran Gox users, how often does this happen? am i statistically over the hump as far as this occurring again? esp on sub 10 btc amounts?

another user contacted me via email, got hit for 13.8. denying access to funds in this time sensitive market is the cardinal sin in this space. i want to use Gox (volatility is off the chain) but I'd almost be a fool to send them my coins again.

Thoughts?

~Green
sorry to keep bumping this thread so hard

I get denied to extract fiat from Gox, and that is unacceptable for me.

[HappyBitCoinUser]

I sent a support ticket and getting no response too.

[bennybong]

I had this issue. Took about 2 days to finally show up. Not sure why, I guess we'll never know...

[X68N]

The Fiat withdraw delay thread has already 137 pages.
Expect bitcoin withdraw delay thread will make the same progress!

I cant understand why people still trust them.
Maybe because in most cultures a boy doesnt become a real man until he gets goxed? 

[bennybong]

The Fiat withdraw delay thread has already 137 pages.
Expect bitcoin withdraw delay thread will make the same progress!

I cant understand why people still trust them.
Maybe because in most cultures a boy doesnt become a real man until he gets goxed? 

Any idea when the last fiat withdrawal was received by anyone and how long it took? Waiting on 10k over here....

[HappyBitCoinUser]

The Fiat withdraw delay thread has already 137 pages.
Expect bitcoin withdraw delay thread will make the same progress!

I cant understand why people still trust them.
Maybe because in most cultures a boy doesnt become a real man until he gets goxed? 

Any idea when the last fiat withdrawal was received by anyone and how long it took? Waiting on 10k over here....

Over $10k probably got you flagged by the banks due to government regulations.

If you take out $9500 multiple times that'll get you flagged for "structuring" which a crime.

Its no-win. Just contact your bank or their bank, make sure its all authorized, etc.