[NXT] Decentralized Asset Exchange Discussion Thread

[bitcoinpaul]

Don't be so touchy, CfB.

[Come-from-Beyond]

So you *want* to see the Asset Exchange launch crash NXT and cause us all to be labelled as scammers?

U make a mountain out of a molehill.

[bitcoinpaul]

It could be a deal breaker. We can at least talk about how to make it better for the user.

[Come-from-Beyond]

It could be a deal breaker. We can at least talk about how to make it better for the user.

We need name anyway. If we don't show the name but the id instead then people will call assets using first 3-5 digits. And someone will create an asset with the same first digits.
Asset registration fee is set to 1000 NXT to counteract squatting.
Ian worries about someone squatting "CIYAM", well, it's a world of cryptoanarchy and laws don't work here, live with it.

[CIYAM]

Ian worries about someone squatting "CIYAM", well, it's a world of cryptoanarchy and laws don't work here, live with it.

No *I do not* (don't put words into my mouth please).

I worry someone uses "my name" to rip people off (and this *will* happen - and you know it but don't care).

[bitcoinpaul]

Let's see if some good ideas are out there (main thread).

[Come-from-Beyond]

Ian worries about someone squatting "CIYAM", well, it's a world of cryptoanarchy and laws don't work here, live with it.

No *I do not* (don't put words into my mouth please).

I worry someone uses "my name" to rip people off (and this *will* happen - and you know it but don't care).

Sorry, I meant that someone would squat CIYAM to rip ppl off.

While we have no a better solution it's better to change nothing, imo.

[CIYAM]

While we have no a better solution it's better to change nothing, imo.

I *gave* you a better solution.

Allow multiple Assets with the same name.

This will cause average Joe to go "what the fuck" and stop him losing his NXT.

Why do you need to ignore my solution (your bosses are "telling you to ignore it")?

[Come-from-Beyond]

I *gave* you a better solution.

Allow multiple Assets with the same name.

This will cause average Joe to go "what the fuck" and stop him losing his NXT.

Why do you need to ignore my solution (your bosses are "telling you to ignore it")?

I think ur solution is worse. People will see legit "CIYAM" and fake "CIYAM", they won't read numbers, coz numbers r much harder to "read".

[Isildur23]

Wasn't there gona be a reputation system? Won't this help?

p.s. Don't bother to answer me if my question is irrelevant. Your time is very valuable for me!

[bitcoinpaul]

Reputation will not work.

[bitcoinpaul]

CfB, CIYAM. Don't crush your heads together. CIYAM thinks his solution is better and CfB thinks the solution is worse.

Let's vote

Just kidding. Maybe there is a good solution out there...

[Come-from-Beyond]

Maybe there is a good solution out there...

Users should use their own brain, it's the solution.

[bitcoinpaul]

Maybe there is a good solution out there...

Users should use their own brain, it's the solution.

Why will wesleyhs GUI be very good for Nxt? Ever heard of a good user experience?

This is similar.

[Come-from-Beyond]

Why will wesleyhs GUI be very good for Nxt? Ever heard of a good user experience?

This is similar.

U can't create an idiot-proof system. Any attempt to do so will lead to bad experience for people with average IQ.

[CIYAM]

U can't create an idiot-proof system. Any attempt to do so will lead to bad experience for people with average IQ.

So your solution is to "trick those who are stupider".

Good luck with AE - I know it is going to *fail terribly* if done your way.

[bitcoinpaul]

That's right. But maybe we can get a better system without only pleasing underaverage Joe.

Btw CIYAM's solution would force users to use their brain and compare other details of the asset to choose the right one. Isn't that what you want?

Please don't be so reluctant to a good user experience. Maybe we find a good solution.

[Come-from-Beyond]

So your solution is to "trick those who are stupider".

Don't put words into my mouth please

[Come-from-Beyond]

Please don't be so reluctant to a good user experience. Maybe we find a good solution.

It's a client side task and has nothing to do with the core.

[bitcoinpaul]

I feel a negative energy in this thread and am really sad about that.

You two are smart and talented but you don't leverage this.