Seeking reporter badge images

[bitart]

I don't think any member was awarded with this great new badges because I am eligible for the 1000+ reports badge and didn't receive any as you see.
...

This topic is about to gather as much idea for the badge as possible, so you won't find any badge for reporting yet...
As soon as the badge itself will be choosen and developed, we will have a new topic in Meta about it, I'm sure.
Until then, we can only continue to think about the possible icons for it

[Chris!]

I'm wayyyy late to the party but this would be great. A little recognition can go a long way and it can only lead to more posts being reported and less spam. I'm glad to see more and more initiatives coming out these past months.

Currently sitting at 751 good reports. I guess I'd better go hunt some shitposters 

[Veleor]

- 300 good reports
- 1000 good reports
- 5000 good reports

Example

[Vod]

Should any icon also indicate (by background or shading) the percentage of good reports?

0-25%   no background
25-75%   half background
75%-100%   full background

[mprep]

Should any icon also indicate (by background or shading) the percentage of good reports?

0-25%   no background
25-75%   half background
75%-100%   full background

From the report page:

Do not worry about your accuracy too much; one accurate report is worth many inaccurate reports

Which is why I doubt theymos would want to put any sort of emphasis on the percentage of good reports, even if it's just badges.

[Veleor]

- 300 good reports
- 1000 good reports
- 5000 good reports

Examples

[Vod]

Should any icon also indicate (by background or shading) the percentage of good reports?

0-25%   no background
25-75%   half background
75%-100%   full background

From the report page:

Do not worry about your accuracy too much; one accurate report is worth many inaccurate reports

Which is why I doubt theymos would want to put any sort of emphasis on the percentage of good reports, even if it's just badges.

Still, there is a difference between 300 reports where 1/4 are good, and 3/4 are good.  That difference increases at 2,000 reports...

I agree a small number of inaccurate reports don't mean anything - but should someone who posts 1,000 spam reports wear the same badge as someone who posts 1,000 accurate reports?

[mprep]

Should any icon also indicate (by background or shading) the percentage of good reports?

0-25%   no background
25-75%   half background
75%-100%   full background

From the report page:

Do not worry about your accuracy too much; one accurate report is worth many inaccurate reports

Which is why I doubt theymos would want to put any sort of emphasis on the percentage of good reports, even if it's just badges.

Still, there is a difference between 300 reports where 1/4 are good, and 3/4 are good.  That difference increases at 2,000 reports...

I agree a small number of inaccurate reports don't mean anything - but should someone who posts 1,000 spam reports wear the same badge as someone who posts 1,000 accurate reports?

I don't theymos is planning to include bad or unhanded reports in the badge calculation. From OP:

Maybe one for 300 good reports, one of 1000, and one for 5000

[Silent26]

I'm wayyyy late to the party

Actually the party is just about to start as Admin theymos is still not releasing any updates about the badges. It's been weeks already but seems like Admin is terribly busy at some business IRL these days or he's working on the badges. Well either way, let's just wait for his update. Just keep in touch so you won't be late 

[LoyceV]

I agree a small number of inaccurate reports don't mean anything - but should someone who posts 1,000 spam reports wear the same badge as someone who posts 1,000 accurate reports?

I can't really imagine anyone having more than 50% bad reports. If that happens after badges are created, I assume other action will be taken against the report spammer.

I'll probably add it next week sometime.

What happened to this statement?

[Silent26]

I can't really imagine anyone having more than 50% bad reports.

I can't also imagine if someone's having over 50% of bad reports. That's a horrible way of reporting if that happens. Well if this happens after the implementation of the badges, its too obvious that the reason is they're just trying to report just to get the badges without even thinking if the post/thread they are reporting were really deserves to be reported to Moderators which will be another problem for Moderators as it will be a tons of work to do.

Anyway, I still believe that our Moderators can handle it.

I'll probably add it next week sometime.

What happened to this statement?

This statement is now resting in peace.

[kirreev070]

300

1000

5000

Example:

[coinlocket$]

300

1000

5000
~

I do not like these very much, not because they are ugly for themselves but rather because according to my point of view they are not very practical.
I struggle to see the difference in color from a distance of one meter from my computer monitor.

[bitart]

It's been over a month now and still there are no selection or implementation of the feature!

You should wait patiently.
If something is really important, it can be done in a few hours/days here.
This is a kind of nice to have thing, so you can't be sure where it is on the priority list now.
Sooner or later it will be done, if it's really important for the forum

[mdayonliner]

Sooner or later it will be done, if it's really important for the forum

Community generated suggestions to improve the forum (+ eventual voting on them) - hilariousetc

[crypmike]

Rats



maybe wolves also would be nice..


and one more idea with a filling vessel

[hilariousetc]

Still, there is a difference between 300 reports where 1/4 are good, and 3/4 are good.  That difference increases at 2,000 reports...

I agree a small number of inaccurate reports don't mean anything - but should someone who posts 1,000 spam reports wear the same badge as someone who posts 1,000 accurate reports?

I don't theymos is planning to include bad or unhanded reports in the badge calculation. From OP:

Maybe one for 300 good reports, one of 1000, and one for 5000

Yeah, I think good reports will only be taken into consideration. Otherwise people wouldn't care what they reported good or bad as long as it counted towards their badge.

I'll probably add it next week sometime.

What happened to this statement?

These badges will be cool and all, but they're pretty far down on the list of things I'd like to see implemented here. I would much rather more mods be added (or current ones promoted to dedicated sub mods), and more importantly signatures removed from Newbs and Juniors and/or a merit requirement added for the latter.

300

1000

5000

Example:

I like them, but they're too hard to distinguish between.

[LoyceV]

These badges will be cool and all, but they're pretty far down on the list of things I'd like to see implemented here.

True, but this thread was opened by theymos, which requires a follow up.

I would much rather more mods be added

That would be good indeed! I've said before that I wouldn't mind having my own nuke button, but so far theymos only asked me to be a Mod by mistake.
*insert troll smiley*

[hilariousetc]

These badges will be cool and all, but they're pretty far down on the list of things I'd like to see implemented here.

True, but this thread was opened by theymos, which requires a follow up.

It's rare that theymos actually commits a deadline or time-frame to such things and this is probably why. I've asked him a couple of times over the years for a rough estimate of when the forum will be ready and never received a response. I would still like to know if it's something that will or won't be out this year, or even a 'maybe' or 'no' to next year, but again, he'd probably rather just not commit to saying something if he can help it because people will just hold him to it if that time passes. Would be nice to get a rough percentage of how finished it is from him though.

Still, I would much rather him spend his time on either coding the forum or implementing some of the other things that will benefit this forum and make it a better place rather than just adding some superficial badges.

I would much rather more mods be added

That would be good indeed! I've said before that I wouldn't mind having my own nuke button, but so far theymos only asked me to be a Mod by mistake.
*insert troll smiley*

How did he ask you by mistake? The forum could do with some extra mods or patrollers at least and if someone has reported thousands upon of thousands of posts then they will likely be beneficial to the forum (unless theymos knows something about them that I don't). All you can do is keep reporting and maybe one day you will become a chosen one.

[tactac]

I think that there should be a badge against the Top topic starter for each board as well as the badge for the reporter.
It seems that various opinions will come out more.

My badge idea is
　Top topic starter at Japanese board
  Top topic starter at Japanese board