Merit source application of Coolcryptovator

[ronnis.gomes]

I support Coolcryptovator as a source of merit too. He contributes a lot with his various useful posts. In addition, there are many messages from him that warn us about scams. I am an assiduous reader of his posts

[stompix]

I will like to see you in DT as well.
With QuestionAuthority removed as Merit source, we are reduced by 1000 source Merits.

When did he get removed?  Was it mentioned in a thread of its own or did I just miss it in another thread? 

Probably because of this:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5050263.msg47050953#msg47050953

[Welsh]

I wouldn't worry about that: it took me 3 months, many endorsements and almost daily bumping to get a (positive) response from theymos.

Yeah, I think its just catching him at the right time. All of my interactions with theymos have been under 24 hours including my application for a merit source. I guess I'm just really good at catching him at the right time.

[Coyster]

<snip>....

I'm surprised your application is yet to be acted upon,theymos added a few merit sources to the list yesterday,i think we have about 123 merit sources at the moment,but apparently you weren't one of'em
Sorry about that mate
Probably in the next inclusion,your application may be approved.
Or probably there's something wrong with your application,we could never know the reason.

[Harlot]

I will like to see you in DT as well.
With QuestionAuthority removed as Merit source, we are reduced by 1000 source Merits.

When did he get removed?  Was it mentioned in a thread of its own or did I just miss it in another thread?  I'm not trying to derail this thread--and I've already lent my support to Coolcryptovator--but I don't want to make a new thread just about that.  

I don't know why he got removed as a source, but I think he was far too liberal handing out merits.  It was something like 10-20 merits per post that he'd hand out, and while there may be some posts deserving of that amount I think it was way too much.  

Sounds like there's an opening, then.  May the best man/woman win if Theymos decides to replace QA.  Good luck, Coolcryptovator.

Edit:

Probably because of this:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5050263.msg47050953#msg47050953

Ah yes, thank you--and to LoyceV who sent me a link via PM.

I just knew it by now as well, he was the most generous merit sender here in the forum but his action for giving away 150 merits for just posting first is really a mistake. I just wish the forum will give him another chance to prove himself maybe he won't be careless the second time around.

Anyways I am in support of Coolcryptovator being a merit source here in the forum. Not only he post great but also he is a good scam hunter in the forum, he had cleaned up the Altcoins section from various scams now.

[tranthidung]

I support to add Coolcryptovator as a new merit source for the forum.
That guy is a self-made Senior member, and also added into list of DT1 members.

UPDATED ON 29/01/2019

• New rules are here https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5095156.0
• Old thread is here https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5080581.0
• DT1 are now 51 DT1 up from 10

THE NEW DT1 LIST

_____________________	_____________________	_____________	___________________________	_____________
PROFILE	ID NUMBER°	BPIP	LAST ACTIVITY	NUMBER OF TRUSTS
Coolcryptovator	1980983	BPIP	January29,2019	9

Additionally, days ago, that guy published the topic:
Alt of DuckDice.io which was tagged for scam
Fastly warned that DuckDice.io is a scam one for community.

[cryptohunter]

Bump, I am fully out of smerit now,

Good we can't have more colluders and noob ass kissers machine gunning merit to their masters.

https://bpip.org/profile.aspx?p=Coolcryptovator

LOL yeah lets have all the merit sources who are pals and just give it to each other. No thanks.

Hmm was just looking at your top 10 fans and recipients

suchmoon the pharmacist moronbozo  

yeah all the known cyclers


Whilst you're about it can you present some of your greatest posts that demonstrate you have produced some genuine original thought provoking contributions here?

No way should you be a merit source. Let's get some of the older legends on to being merit sources that have made huge contributions here.

[The Cryptovator]

No way should you be a merit source. Let's get some of the older legends on to being merit sources that have made huge contributions here.

Most of legendary like you still newbie to me. Whoever got merit by airdrop does it mean they are able to become merit source ? Never mind what is the rank.
Come on man don't behave like childish, make a list who is self made legendary then submit to theymos. Theymos should add you as merit source ? If you are a good contributor then why did you received only 92 merit on your life time ? I can't consider you as my competitor. Earn first 450 merit then come on this thread to comment. Better to stay away from thread.  S_Therapist better then you, he have earned lot of merit even still new on the forum.

[cryptohunter]

No way should you be a merit source. Let's get some of the older legends on to being merit sources that have made huge contributions here.

Most of legendary like you still newbie to me. Whoever got merit by airdrop does it mean they are able to become merit source ? Never mind what is the rank.
Come on man don't behave like childish, make a list who is self made legendary then submit to theymos. Theymos should add you as merit source ? If you are a good contributor then why did you received only 92 merit on your life time ? I can't consider you as my competitor. Earn first 450 merit then come on this thread to comment. Better to stay away from thread.  S_Therapist better then you, he have earned lot of merit even still new on the forum.

Are you completely moronic. Obviously you are so i will break it down to you.

I am saying merit means nothing and is cycled meaningless (such moons says) rubbish mostly on meta board. You then seek to ask me why I do not have much merit as if i need to defend that statement or my point is invalid.  Just employing this logic makes you a full on retarded. Now go review your bpip and your DT inclusions exclusions kiss more ass and hope for more merits so that by your broken logic you are a valuable net postive member. When really you are completely net negative.

Now go ask, gjhiggins, davidzimbeck , smooth, any other host of real legends with minds 1000x more useful than your own limited and broken mass of misfiring junk why you have so much more earned merit than they have. I mean surely these noobs who are nothing to your because you have been ass kissing since you joined for merit dregs are going to struggle in any debate with someone of your calibre. LOL  I could bring many legends here with under 80 merit that are magnitude smarter and more valuable than you ... get it??

Can you point me to some of your great posts. Let me take a look at these original thought provoking contributions.

Hurry up.

[cabalism13]

Most of legendary like you still newbie to me. Whoever got merit by airdrop does it mean they are able to become merit source ? Never mind what is the rank.
Come on man don't behave like childish, make a list who is self made legendary then submit to theymos. Theymos should add you as merit source ? If you are a good contributor then why did you received only 92 merit on your life time ? I can't consider you as my competitor. Earn first 450 merit then come on this thread to comment. Better to stay away from thread.  S_Therapist better then you, he have earned lot of merit even still new on the forum.

At the bottom-left of his post you can find a magical button "Ignore". You can use this all the time whenever you like it is needed, just to prevent you seeing things that isn't right. And always remember this magical thing is quite abusive in the eyes of douchebags, they find this thing so offensively that they might want to go rampage.

After using the magical tool, you will see a better environment:

This user is currently ignored.

@cryptohunter

Would you mind stopping bitching some else's post just to get some attention here? Doesn't know what you're speaking but I can feel that you're also shittin on me right now, anyways doesn't care about that.

To OP, sorry for some off topic here,BTW Congrats mate for becoming one of the DT even though your account was just made last year, same like nullius, if he didn't go anywhere he would be one too. Good Luck on your Application, NVM the pajeets around here.

[cryptohunter]

Most of legendary like you still newbie to me. Whoever got merit by airdrop does it mean they are able to become merit source ? Never mind what is the rank.
Come on man don't behave like childish, make a list who is self made legendary then submit to theymos. Theymos should add you as merit source ? If you are a good contributor then why did you received only 92 merit on your life time ? I can't consider you as my competitor. Earn first 450 merit then come on this thread to comment. Better to stay away from thread.  S_Therapist better then you, he have earned lot of merit even still new on the forum.

At the bottom-left of his post you can find a magical button "Ignore". You can use this all the time whenever you like it is needed, just to prevent you seeing things that isn't right. And always remember this magical thing is quite abusive in the eyes of douchebags, they find this thing so offensively that they might want to go rampage.

After using the magical tool, you will see a better environment:

This user is currently ignored.

Wow this is a noob trash ass kissing convention in here. You guys are sickening. I never seen noob merit scavenging so blatant and desperate. Here come post some of your great posts calblosim13 I will merit some that are worthy. I mean I have zero smerit left but that will be more than enough.

[bones261]

Can you point me to some of your great posts. Let me take a look at these original thought provoking contributions.

Actually, this post of his is actually pretty good.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5004397.msg45150042#msg45150042

[cryptohunter]

Can you point me to some of your great posts. Let me take a look at these original thought provoking contributions.

Actually, this post of his is actually pretty good.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5004397.msg45150042#msg45150042

Yes it is an okay post. Let's call this a nice presentation of the quite obvious with some questionable reasoning behind some subheadings. Net positive on the whole I guess.

Imagine though that post has more earned merit that gjhiggins smooth, david zimbeck and 100's of other great legends that have earned in total. Please get serious.

Go read some of their posts they are not simply the presentation of the mostly obvious mixed in with some questionable reasoning.

The most valuable poster to examine real ico value is banned. Who can you ask now for a detailed analysis of some complex white papers conceptual design entirely for free?

 

[bones261]

Can you point me to some of your great posts. Let me take a look at these original thought provoking contributions.

Actually, this post of his is actually pretty good.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5004397.msg45150042#msg45150042

Yes it is an okay post. Let's call this a nice presentation of the quite obvious with some questionable reasoning behind some subheadings. Net positive on the whole I guess.

Imagine though that post has more earned merit that gjhiggins smooth, david zimbeck and 100's of other great legends that have earned in total. Please get serious.

Go read some of their posts they are not simply the presentation of the mostly obvious mixed in with some questionable reasoning.

The most valuable poster to examine real ico value is banned. Who can you ask now for a detailed analysis of some complex white papers conceptual design entirely for free?

 

Well, perhaps the next time Theymos determines who should be new merit sources, he should pick some distinguished regulars that post on the altcoin boards. The problem with this though is most people are only interested in a limited set of altcoins. If at all. So the selected merit source would probably only distribute their merits in the threads talking about the coins they are either interested in or have serious concerns with.

[cryptohunter]

Can you point me to some of your great posts. Let me take a look at these original thought provoking contributions.

Actually, this post of his is actually pretty good.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5004397.msg45150042#msg45150042

Yes it is an okay post. Let's call this a nice presentation of the quite obvious with some questionable reasoning behind some subheadings. Net positive on the whole I guess.

Imagine though that post has more earned merit that gjhiggins smooth, david zimbeck and 100's of other great legends that have earned in total. Please get serious.

Go read some of their posts they are not simply the presentation of the mostly obvious mixed in with some questionable reasoning.

The most valuable poster to examine real ico value is banned. Who can you ask now for a detailed analysis of some complex white papers conceptual design entirely for free?

 

Well, perhaps the next time Theymos determines who should be new merit sources, he should pick some distinguished regulars that post on the altcoin boards. The problem with this though is most people are only interested in a limited set of altcoins. If at all. So the selected merit source would probably only distribute their merits in the threads talking about the coins they are either interested in or have serious concerns with.

Well that is a reasonable post and I do agree with you.

That could be a problem. This is why merit can never really be treated as a valuable metric. I mean imagine that we even introduced strict criteria for giving merit. That would be a HUGE upgrade to merit. However we still have the HUGE issue of making sure everyones posts get fair review or opportunity for merit. That has been my major gripe with merit being used for anything other than holding back account farmers and bots.  You simply can not relate merit to trust it is not at all possible and has broken the entire system.

This is why theymos needs to stop making merit sources that are closely connected and give it to lots of unconnected persons like very great posters from the alt boards. Really I believe the most users are from the alt boards. So you need lots of dedicated merit sources that are also given criteria for giving out merits. I only ask for what is fair nothing more. I do not request ever to be DT or merit source myself. However lots of the older legends that are incredibly smart and respectable should be on DT and merit sources themselves. You need a broad spectrum but all must stick to a fair criteria that is applied fairly to all posters.

[bones261]

Well, I can see your concern. However, we are getting a bit off topic for this thread. However, anyone is welcome to apply to become a merit source. However, theymos does also just recruit people. That's how I got to be a merit source.  I only cared very little about the forum politics until I was drawn into meta, since many of the threads are about the merit system and I want to see what other people consider to be a good way to distribute merits. Of course, I am not perfect at the task and only venture in the boards that I am interested in. However, I have expanded my horizons quite a bit since being made a merit source and continue to expand. Unfortunately, there is only so much that I can read in a day.

[cryptohunter]

Well, I can see your concern. However, we are getting a bit off topic for this thread. However, anyone is welcome to apply to become a merit source. However, theymos does also just recruit people. That's how I got to be a merit source.  I only cared very little about the forum politics until I was drawn into meta, since many of the threads are about the merit system and I want to see what other people consider to be a good way to distribute merits. Of course, I am not perfect at the task and only venture in the boards that I am interested in. However, I have expanded my horizons quite a bit since being made a merit source and continue to expand. Unfortunately, there is only so much that I can read in a day.

Yeah I am in full agreement actually. Of course persons can not be expected to find every good post then work out where to give merits. So I think it is good to not have people that are all in close circles to each other and share views because then only the same posts will attract merit.

The best way would be

1. make a set of criteria that each person applies to the posts they review
2. make a very wide set of merit sources a lot from the alt boards too

actually if you had a strict set of criteria that removed subjectivity as much as possible it would not matter who was the merit source because only the post would determine the merit awarded so it would be very fair. Of course still you should have a wide spectrum concerning areas of interest because we should aim to give all post the same opportunity of review.

However I think most people should favour a fair system like this that is why I can not understand the resistance to it from those that already have the most merit. Just create a fair system that can not be gamed. I can not see why such strong hate for this idea.

The same goes for DT - fair system that brings in the most trustworthy persons.

Anyway yes don't want to go off topic but now I do not support his merit source application because we need to broaden it to other areas of the board as much as possible. Find some old legends who make great posts and that are fair and give them merit source.

Also tell them never to come to meta and get involved in a war so no need to take sides just give merit to posts they think are deserving.

Or of course bring strict criteria for merit worthy posts (which i was trying to define in my what makes a valuable post thread) and then anyone can be a merit source until they don't stick to the criteria.

[The Cryptovator]

Can you point me to some of your great posts. Let me take a look at these original thought provoking contributions.

Hurry up.

I don't want argue with you and don't like off topic as well. Take a look on this post by the way: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5053066.0, this is my portfolio that I have combined, do you think I have contributed something for forum?

[S_Therapist]

Up. I am out of smerit.

Wondering why you are still not on the list, I think you should be there. You are active and I think you are putting merit on deserving posts (except 1 fact, lol). Maybe theymos didn't notice your application on last source implementation.

[Daniel91]

Bump for visibility

I'm sorry that you still didn't receive answer from the admin.
In my opinion, you are very good candidate for the merit source and I wish you good luck with your application.
In fact, I received answer for my merit source after 3 months in pm from admin so don't loose hope.