56 Hardware Wallets, compared feature by feature

[dkbit98]

BREAKING NEWS
I deprecated the Google Spreadsheet and launched a new website comparing 32 Hardware Wallets

Bookmarked!
Very good update and I like left and right navigation arrows you added on this website.
I know we all have zoom features on out browsers, but maybe you could add custom zoom out button mode so we can see all wallets in one page.
There is Filter tab greyed out so maybe you could add more options for that later, based on wallet features and characteristics.

[maxirosson]

Thanks for the feedback. Yes, I plan to add some preloaded filters like BTC-only wallets.
Not sure if all the wallets can be visible at the same time. But I could try changing the column width so we can see more wallets at the same time.

Bookmarked!
Very good update and I like left and right navigation arrows you added on this website.
I know we all have zoom features on out browsers, but maybe you could add custom zoom out button mode so we can see all wallets in one page.
There is Filter tab greyed out so maybe you could add more options for that later, based on wallet features and characteristics.

[taufik123]

Great update.
From Google Sheets and finally migrated to a website that is quite responsive for desktop display.

But for the Mobile display, it seems that it is not fully compatible and needs a little improvement so that the mobile-specific display is more precise and suitable for mobile users.



And maybe some suggestions like a Search Button are needed when like me, a Safepal or Ledger user wants to see my wallet hardware information without having to navigate too far to the right.

Overall, this is a great update and makes it easier to find all types of Hardware wallets.

[maxirosson]

Thanks for the feedback. I am creating issues on Github issues for all the pending tasks.

I am a bit limited on mobile, it's not easy to display more than two wallets at the same time. Do you have any particular issue on your mobile device?

Great update.
From Google Sheets and finally migrated to a website that is quite responsive for desktop display.

But for the Mobile display, it seems that it is not fully compatible and needs a little improvement so that the mobile-specific display is more precise and suitable for mobile users.



And maybe some suggestions like a Search Button are needed when like me, a Safepal or Ledger user wants to see my wallet hardware information without having to navigate too far to the right.

Overall, this is a great update and makes it easier to find all types of Hardware wallets.

[Tibu]

BREAKING NEWS
I deprecated the Google Spreadsheet and launched a new website comparing 32 Hardware Wallets:

https://wallets.thebitcoinhole.com/

The site offers some advantages compared with the spreadsheet:
- Improved usability and look & feel
- Possibility to filter wallets so you can only see and compare the ones you are interested
- Added more contextual information about each compared feature
- Fixed some data errors.
- It is open source, so everyone can suggest changes or fix errors: https://github.com/thebitcoinhole/hardware-wallets


I plan to continue adding more features and wallets to compare.

 

Wow... Website is clean and well designed. Good job.
But its still missing Satochip hardware wallet (https://satochip.io), wen sir ?
Do you have a github page or something like that to allow contributions ?

And I have the same request for the seed storage solution part : https://thebitcoinhole.com/seed-backup/

Have a great day.

[taufik123]

-snip-
I am a bit limited on mobile, it's not easy to display more than two wallets at the same time. Do you have any particular issue on your mobile device?
-snip-

The only problem is that the display scale on smartphones is not precise and of course, CSS is still not supported for mobile display.
If you use WordPress maybe it will be easier to provide some slider templates that can be optimized according to the template for Desktop and mobile.

I also do not understand CSS, only know some basic knowledge, and have not managed a website for a long time.
But the Desktop display is good enough and responsive.

[SFR10]

BREAKING NEWS
I deprecated the Google Spreadsheet and launched a new website comparing 32 Hardware Wallets:

Great move

Few suggestions:
- A modular design to allow us to remove unwanted rows ^{[browser-side]}.
- Highlight the row and the column that our mouse pointer is currently hovering at ^{[useful when multiple hardware wallets are selected]}.
- A dark mode.

But for the Mobile display, it seems that it is not fully compatible and needs a little improvement so that the mobile-specific display is more precise and suitable for mobile users.

Until a better version comes, you might want to enable the "desktop site" mode on your mobile browser ^{[it improves it a little bit]}.

[maxirosson]

Thanks for the feedback. I loaded your suggestion on the issue tracker

[FatFork]

Thanks for the feedback. Yes, I plan to add some preloaded filters like BTC-only wallets.
Not sure if all the wallets can be visible at the same time. But I could try changing the column width so we can see more wallets at the same time.

Great work! That's quite an impressive project you've undertaken and it's great to see that you're continuing to improve and expand on your comparison tool, especially with the additional features you plan to include.

It's a good point that fitting all the wallets on one page might not be possible, especially with the total number of wallets. However, I do agree that adding more filter options would be a great way to make the website even more user-friendly.

Here are a few ideas:
Price range - this would allow users to filter wallets based on their budget.
Security features - this would allow users to filter wallets based on specific security features, such as secure element, biometric recognition, etc.
Display size - some people prefer larger screens for readability, while others prefer smaller screens for portability.
Another potential filter option could be based on the connectivity of the wallet, such as Bluetooth or USB.
etc

[maxirosson]

Here are a few ideas:
Price range - this would allow users to filter wallets based on their budget.
Security features - this would allow users to filter wallets based on specific security features, such as secure element, biometric recognition, etc.
Display size - some people prefer larger screens for readability, while others prefer smaller screens for portability.
Another potential filter option could be based on the connectivity of the wallet, such as Bluetooth or USB.
etc

Thanks for the feedback !!!

[maxirosson]

But its still missing Satochip hardware wallet (https://satochip.io), wen sir ?
Do you have a github page or something like that to allow contributions ?

Working right now to add Satochips.
The github repo: https://github.com/thebitcoinhole/hardware-wallets

[Synchronice]

Great, just great! To be honest, I even bookmarked it.
There are things that I think will improve the overall experience, for example, when I want to scroll right, I have to scroll down till the very end of list and then there is a scroll bar, which isn't comfortable. I think it will be better If there is an arrow or scroll bar at any moment when I read see the list.
Also, I think it's a good idea if it will be sorted by popularity, alphabet, release date, price.

[maxirosson]

There are things that I think will improve the overall experience, for example, when I want to scroll right, I have to scroll down till the very end of list and then there is a scroll bar, which isn't comfortable. I think it will be better If there is an arrow or scroll bar at any moment when I read see the list.

Thanks for your feedback.

There are arrows to horizontally scroll. You can see at the right and left of the wallets images (only on desktop)

[maxirosson]

Added Tangem wallet. Now comparing 33 Hardware Wallets feature by feature.

https://wallets.thebitcoinhole.com/

Still waiting for Satochip support team to answer me some questions, so I can add their wallet.

[maxirosson]

Added Satochip to the website. Now comparing 34 Hardware Wallets.

https://wallets.thebitcoinhole.com/

Also added some discounts you can get for some wallets. Working to add more deals.

[dkbit98]

Thanks for the feedback. Yes, I plan to add some preloaded filters like BTC-only wallets.
Not sure if all the wallets can be visible at the same time. But I could try changing the column width so we can see more wallets at the same time.

I forgot to say that I love that you added SATS value below USD prices.
What tool are you using to show live SAT prices since they are changing all the time?
I think that HW prices are also changing sometimes, so it would be cool to have someone tracking that, instead of doing everything manually.

PS
Adding responsive design update would probably fix most of the issues with various devices, and consider adding alternative dark theme switch.

[maxirosson]

What tool are you using to show live SAT prices since they are changing all the time?

I just use an API to get the BTC price when loading the site, and then calculate the wallet price in SATs.

I think that HW prices are also changing sometimes, so it would be cool to have someone tracking that, instead of doing everything manually.

Yes, but it's a lot of work to parse all the manufacturer's sites to get the prices.

Adding responsive design update would probably fix most of the issues with various devices, and consider adding alternative dark theme switch.

The site is responsive and looking fine on my pixel 6. Is difficult to compare wallets on a small screen, I would always recommend using your desktop for that. But maybe you are having issues that I am not seeing. Some screenshots could help me to understand those issues.

[maxirosson]

Added discount coupon codes for Arculus, Jade, Keystone, OneKey, Passport Batch 2, Satochip, and SecuX wallets.

[maxirosson]

Added SeedSigner

[dkbit98]

Added SeedSigner

Are you sure that Seedsigner can be purchased and assembled for $50 right now?
RaspberryPi are not always easy to find and they often have higher price, plus you have to buy additional parts, print or buy the case and assemble everything yourself.
This is not a problem for me, but most newbies wouldn't know what to do even with detailed instructions.
Few shops are selling prebuilt devices but they are priced around €100 ^{(on gobrrr.me)}.

Dimensions can also be very much different, because there are many cases (Open Pill, Orange Pill, Rugged Pill, etc).