Deleting Post can reduce the merit we got?

[Arenga pinnata]

I think many beginners are also thinking about the same question about this. Because personally I also had time to question it in my own mind. But then I read a topic on Meta Boards and found the answer.

This thread ( FAQ: Everything you need to know about forum 'activity, account ranks and merit) provides all the answers to common questions asked by many beginners. So I hope this thread can also be pinned to the Beginner and Help boards. Because sometimes beginners don't dare to visit meta boards. Because that's how I've felt.

[1714523653]

1714523653

[1714523653]

1714523653

[cryptoaddictchie]

Deleting that particular post will have any impact on our total of merits like will its reduce or still remain as same as before? I thought i should ask it to the community so that it will add up to my knowledge and Information. If Anyone of you know about this please do lemme know Many Thanks

No of course not received merits retain in your account but reduces your post activity and count. If ever you also hit below the specific rank requirement youll be demoted I believed and rank up again once you hit that specitic requirement.

I had a lot of posts before and deleted those unquality post like social links for campaign prerequisites but didnt reduce my merits. I think deleted few post too with merits, forgot though why I deleted those :p

[Pingrapole]

Experience has given the answer, but you know it will work for you Thank you very much.As far as I know merited posts are usually not deleted, if they are, they will still have merit.Only your activity can slow down.

[Fuso.hp]

The merit you get on your profile will never be deleted from your profile. If you make a post and you get merit in that post, if the moderator deletes your post for any reason, then even if only one post is removed from your total post, your merit number will remain unchanged.  Even if the merit is not deleted from the profile because of the post, always try to post quality and for any reason so that your post is not deleted by the moderator. If multiple posts are deleted from the profile and if the posts are irrelevant then your account may be banned for a certain period of time so definitely try to post good quality from active.

[DdmrDdmr]

<…> I don't know for sure whether those who have reached full member rank and above when they delete their posts until the number of activities decreases at the lower rank limit stage, whether their ranking will also decrease. <…>

Activity may be reduced when posts are deleted (self,mod, self-moderated) and can lead to the account being de-ranked. You can see some of the examples I track on this tab of the Merit Dashboard. The most extreme case is this profile, that likely went from Legendary to Newbie.

Though, as stated, received Merits do not get deleted from the account when one’s (merited) post gets deleted, there have been some historical occasions in which the Forum’s Admin reverted some Merit TXs due to abuse or such. I haven’t seen that happen for quite a while now (years).

[letteredhub]

<…> I don't know for sure whether those who have reached full member rank and above when they delete their posts until the number of activities decreases at the lower rank limit stage, whether their ranking will also decrease. <…>

Activity may be reduced when posts are deleted (self,mod, self-moderated) and can lead to the account being de-ranked. You can see some of the examples I track on this tab of the Merit Dashboard. The most extreme case is this profile, that likely went from Legendary to Newbie.

Though, as stated, received Merits do not get deleted from the account when one’s (merited) post gets deleted, there have been some historical occasions in which the Forum’s Admin reverted some Merit TXs due to abuse or such. I haven’t seen that happen for quite a while now (years).

.
I am appraised in detail that one's merits can't delete when a merited post is deleted but never knew that forum admins can revert merits based on abuse or any faulted reasons, and am just getting to know of this for the first time.  You said it's a historical case's which means it's very very rare. But for the sake of knowledge my interest is in this question; the reverted merits by a forum admins does it return back to the owner (the abuser), or somewhere else like to the admin, or it's reverted to no one at all?

[JunaidAzizi]

hope y'll having a good today. i was in confusion like if we delete any previous post from Account on which we have got some merits....Deleting that particular post will have any impact on our total of merits like will its reduce or still remain as same as before? I thought i should ask it to the community so that it will add up to my knowledge and Information. If Anyone of you know about this please do lemme know Many Thanks

At first, I had the same question in my mind what would happen if I deleted my post, My merits go forever or not I started looking in the forum and reading a post in some threads after some days I found a thread I(i forgot that thread if i found that i will post it here) think on this in which the Op of that thread shared a Screenshot of person who's rank was hero but his activity is very low when I read the replies then I found that the person the Op was mentioned deleted his post but the merits he got on that post has remained. So I think you will get your answer from this as well as many of the forum users give their own experiences and knowledge.

[DdmrDdmr]

<…>

In some cases, the Admin sent a sMerit TX with a negative value, such as most of the TXs that figure on this list, and due to the reasons explained in this post:

Code:

amount         user_to        converted_date                          name                     url
-10            358020         2019-02-05 22:07:10.000                 Quickseller              https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=358020
-10            15728          2019-02-05 22:07:10.000                 TECSHARE                 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=15728
-10            2536607        2019-02-05 22:07:10.000                 gwsukabokepjepang        https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=2536607
-9             249872         2019-02-05 22:07:10.000                 TheCoinFinder            https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=249872
-7             249436         2019-02-05 22:07:10.000                 Tupsu                    https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=249436
-8             165478         2019-02-05 22:07:10.000                 LiQio                    https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=165478
-2             9645           2019-02-05 22:07:10.000                 mich                     https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=9645
-4             1246188        2019-02-05 22:07:10.000                 Bazinga442               https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=1246188
-10            355462         2019-02-05 22:07:10.000                 Thule                    https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=355462
-2             92110          2019-02-05 22:07:11.000                 cryptohunter             https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=92110
-5             81995          2019-02-05 22:07:10.000                 peloso                   https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=81995
-2             1316028        2019-02-05 22:07:10.000                 Deena                    https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=1316028
-9             290351         2019-02-05 22:07:10.000                 hoop                     https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=290351
-1             289011         2019-02-05 22:07:10.000                 Rmcdermott927            https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=289011
-10            92110          2019-02-05 22:07:10.000                 cryptohunter             https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=92110

The Merits were sent by a Merit Source at the time, and since this status was withdrawn due to abuse, the Merits were not really sent back to anyone (the receiver receives a positive Merit TX and a subsequent negative Merit TX to cancel the effect of the former).

The last case on the above list is slightly different, and occurred on a different date. What it did is effectively set the earned Merits back to 0 for this account by issuing a -44 sMerit TX. The account has received 25 sMerit TXs previously from multiple users over a period of time of over a year and a half. Apparently, PIOUPIOU99 asked for those Merits to be deleted on his account, and his wish came true …

This other case is different (see this thread): an account got hacked and the hacker sent 3 different 50 sMerit TXs to other accounts. Going over the sMerit TXs, and from what I recall, the sMerit TXs were deleted on that occasion (no negative TXs to counter), and I believe that the sMerit/Merit counters were manually adjusted for the implicates accounts.

[BIT-BENDER]

The merit you get on your profile will never be deleted from your profile. If you make a post and you get merit in that post, if the moderator deletes your post for any reason, then even if only one post is removed from your total post, your merit number will remain unchanged.  Even if the merit is not deleted from the profile because of the post, always try to post quality and for any reason so that your post is not deleted by the moderator. If multiple posts are deleted from the profile and if the posts are irrelevant then your account may be banned for a certain period of time so definitely try to post good quality from active.

Any post that gets deserved merit would hardly be deleted by moderators, if the post isn't appropriate for the board it was posted then they can move the post but hardly will it be deleted.

In terms of personal decision from the Owners of such post, it is not often you see someone deleting a post that got merit most times is spam posts that is cleaned up, but regardless OP you have gotten your answer by now I guess.

[freedomgo]

If your post has been given merit and it is deleted, the merit that you were given will not be deleted. If your post has been deleted and it was given merit, go to your profile merit page and you will see the merit but the post as deleted.

That’s right. Once you have received merit for a certain post, even if you decide to delete it or it was deleted by the forum later on, your number of merits received will never change. However, the number of activity might lessen but the merit count is still the same. But as much as possible, try to avoid deletion in the future.

[Zoomic]

hi there!

hope y'll having a good today. i was in confusion like if we delete any previous post from Account on which we have got some merits....Deleting that particular post will have any impact on our total of merits like will its reduce or still remain as same as before? I thought i should ask it to the community so that it will add up to my knowledge and Information. If Anyone of you know about this please do lemme know Many Thanks

Kind Regards

Snowpega 

I don't think that anything can reverse the merit given you. Whether the post is deleted or trashed, your merits stand. Even if you are banned, your merits remain with you. Maybe the only person that has the ability to demerit you is the admin and I doubt that he will have reasons to do that.
I have read a threat about freezing smerits in the future if not spent. Has this happened to anyone before?

[Crypt0Gore]

Good question.

The answer is NO because your merits will remain the same until someone ends you another, it will only increase in number, not decrease.

I was merited on post that got deleted too and my merit number never decreases, so even if a post get deleted someday and you already earned a merit, it stays the same.

Though there is a saying on the forum that there is no reason to hold your Smerit when you have one, I think they have an expiration date on something, so if you have sendable merits it's better to find good posts to send them to.

I think you have gotten the right answer for this topic OP, it will be better to lock this down or you will keep getting the same answer over again.

[acroman08]

The last case on the above list is slightly different, and occurred on a different date. What it did is effectively set the earned Merits back to 0 for this account by issuing a -44 sMerit TX. The account has received 25 sMerit TXs previously from multiple users over a period of time of over a year and a half. Apparently, PIOUPIOU99 asked for those Merits to be deleted on his account, and his wish came true …

This is news to me, thanks for sharing! I have heard that Theymos can remove merits from users in special circumstances but I never knew that he also removes merits if someone requested it, and looking at the surprised response from other members, they never expected Theymos would grant it.

-snip

@OP, though your merits will not decrease if you delete posts with merits but, as you can see from DdmrDdmr(which is very informative) merits can be deleted/removed by the admin in special circumstances, though I am not sure if Theymos will still grant merits to be removed if a user requests it.

I have read a threat about freezing smerits in the future if not spent. Has this happened to anyone before?

I have not seen someone post about their sMerits being frozen or have decayed.