If you expand it to 1 year, he is the 13th most active poster on the Gambling board but 54th in merits earned on that board. To me that suggests his posts (in general) aren't particularly informative or interesting to most readers.
<snip>
Because this account is particularly lacking in certain areas. They use the same words to describe the same or similar concepts, repeatedly -- for years now, living largely in threads where not many people appear to be reading much of anything.
These are some of the reasons again I am yet to get on board with the way some of the sig bans are getting handed out. It relies heavily on subjective criteria that is almost impossible to argue with. I should clarify first that I have not gone through the post history here, cause I am not replying to this in particular.
I expect bans to be giving for clear reasons;
your posts are majorly spam so your signature rights have been revoked for xxxx period of time, if you need proof of that, here is a screenshot of 2-3 pages of your post history showing the regularity of said spam.
Highlighting 2 posts a month apart and suggesting to know what is interesting to others and what they read is not a reason for a ban, merit statistics isn't either, that is backwards inference. You should be saying;
"Your posts as you can see are mostly spam, further shown by your lack of merits from them" not,
"You do not get merits, so your posts must be spam"
What are these repetitive words? Are they by any chance core gambling words that will be used to explain most concepts in that area and were they applicable in the contexts they were used?
Agreed...
The judgement on giving one a sig ban should be direct and shouldn't leave any questions about the user's post quality. If nutildah keeps sig banning every boring poster around, soon there will be no more than 20 posters left in the whole forum.
What nutildah is doing also kind of interferes with the campaign managers' job... The manager already made his/her mind about the poster's post quality and hired him/her based on that.
nutildah is basically acting as a supreme court now. Managing the managers... Because managers themselves are apparently not capable of choosing the right posters.