I don't think this is a good idea. So a "no" from me.
Accurate judgement is the key not trades.
Yep i agree with all your points specially the first one and the problem is that people on default trust list are not that trusted, some of them dont even have trades done, some dont even have more than 1 or 2 trust ratings from other people, im not saying thats a reason for them not to be on default trust list, im just wondering what made them get into the list.
Accurate judgement is the key not trades.
I agree somewhat, but trades are also a very good indicator of honesty around here. I trust someone more who has proven time and time again via trading/escrows that they are honest. I do not just trust someone because a user from D1 has added them into their list. I think the default network is currently pretty solid with public disputes and CITM's list removed.
Also multiple lists is too confusing - most people are already confused with the current system.