Akhand Bharat - United India : Should it happen ?

[bryant.coleman]

Very rarely do you see Pakistani PMs completing their terms.
They either get deposed or executed. 

That is understandable. The Pakistani Prime Ministers and the other elected officials are just puppets of the army. So they are expected to obey whatever orders which are given to them. When they refuse to obey these orders and rebel, then the army will just kick them out, or worse eliminate them. It has been the case for the last 70-years or so, and in the near future also it will stay like that.

[legendster]

Very rarely do you see Pakistani PMs completing their terms.
They either get deposed or executed. 

That is understandable. The Pakistani Prime Ministers and the other elected officials are just puppets of the army. So they are expected to obey whatever orders which are given to them. When they refuse to obey these orders and rebel, then the army will just kick them out, or worse eliminate them. It has been the case for the last 70-years or so, and in the near future also it will stay like that.

How exactly are you coming to that conclusion? You can't see the future can you? By your response I can clearly see you dont even know the current constitutional amendments in Pakistan.

[ausbit]

Very rarely do you see Pakistani PMs completing their terms.
They either get deposed or executed. 

That is understandable. The Pakistani Prime Ministers and the other elected officials are just puppets of the army. So they are expected to obey whatever orders which are given to them. When they refuse to obey these orders and rebel, then the army will just kick them out, or worse eliminate them. It has been the case for the last 70-years or so, and in the near future also it will stay like that.

How exactly are you coming to that conclusion? You can't see the future can you? By your response I can clearly see you dont even know the current constitutional amendments in Pakistan.

I don't think that akhand bharat or the united india will happen again. Once the glass is broken, hearts is broken for any reason any benefits, its really very hard to fix it or stick together. Already its broken into pieces. Due to several reason, politics, religious issues with each other. First they need to short out their personnel problems.

[legendster]

Very rarely do you see Pakistani PMs completing their terms.
They either get deposed or executed. 

That is understandable. The Pakistani Prime Ministers and the other elected officials are just puppets of the army. So they are expected to obey whatever orders which are given to them. When they refuse to obey these orders and rebel, then the army will just kick them out, or worse eliminate them. It has been the case for the last 70-years or so, and in the near future also it will stay like that.

How exactly are you coming to that conclusion? You can't see the future can you? By your response I can clearly see you dont even know the current constitutional amendments in Pakistan.

I don't think that akhand bharat or the united india will happen again. Once the glass is broken, hearts is broken for any reason any benefits, its really very hard to fix it or stick together. Already its broken into pieces. Due to several reason, politics, religious issues with each other. First they need to short out their personnel problems.

Being someone from India and someone who's ancestral family line HAS been affected by the partition, I can tell you this, there would be nothing better for the future of India than an united India. Yes offcourse tensions are there, I mean the partition DID happen for a reason after all and if you've read through all these posts you would know that not everything was as clean as it may seem to an outsider. We do need to 'SORT' it out but that sorting out won't happen without cultural interactions.

[bryant.coleman]

I don't think that akhand bharat or the united india will happen again.

That is a foregone conclusion. India and Pakistan are like arch-rivals right now. Currently it is even difficult to imagine the scenario in which Pakistan merge with India, to create this "Akhand Bharat" utopia. The only possibility of a merger will arise, when India becomes a Muslim majority nation. And that will take quite a lot of time (probably not before AD 2100).

[ausbit]

I don't think that akhand bharat or the united india will happen again.

That is a foregone conclusion. India and Pakistan are like arch-rivals right now. Currently it is even difficult to imagine the scenario in which Pakistan merge with India, to create this "Akhand Bharat" utopia. The only possibility of a merger will arise, when India becomes a Muslim majority nation. And that will take quite a lot of time (probably not before AD 2100).

I agree with the subject that Akhand bharat united india. But it might happen when they start talking with each other about the benefits of united nation. Otherwise if there is war. Then those who wins they can rule other nation too.

[Gronthaing]

I don't think that akhand bharat or the united india will happen again.

That is a foregone conclusion. India and Pakistan are like arch-rivals right now. Currently it is even difficult to imagine the scenario in which Pakistan merge with India, to create this "Akhand Bharat" utopia. The only possibility of a merger will arise, when India becomes a Muslim majority nation. And that will take quite a lot of time (probably not before AD 2100).

I agree with the subject that Akhand bharat united india. But it might happen when they start talking with each other about the benefits of united nation. Otherwise if there is war. Then those who wins they can rule other nation too.

There wouldn't be a winner. They are both nuclear powers. It would be a disaster. And even if nuclear weapons weren't used the conflict would spread throughout the region. And other countries would back either side maybe leading to world war. By the way, was just watching this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ON-6vyQugw4 funny but both sides need to bring it down a little.

[legendster]

There wouldn't be a winner. They are both nuclear powers. It would be a disaster. And even if nuclear weapons weren't used the conflict would spread throughout the region. And other countries would back either side maybe leading to world war. By the way, was just watching this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ON-6vyQugw4 funny but both sides need to bring it down a little.

That is a show more than anything. Not all border guards have such.. lets say performances. But its something of national pride and something no outsider would understand.

Secondly, why would India have to become a muslim majority to unite with Pakistan? Pakistan was made to be a secular state?
Hyderabad united with India and still the majority religion didn't change, Sikkim and manipur were united with Indian Union.. we didnt change to budhism. Did we?

The 'idea' of India is to be the largest secular democracy in the world a country ruled by the people, for the people and a gov. made OF the people. To say any one person or a religious community would have influence over the another would be.. idiotic to say the least.

The 'idea' of Akhand Bharat is not an utopian fantasy, it was a land that actually existed before the seeds of communal violence were sown here. The idea does not propagate a single religious authority, maybe the RSS' version of Akhand Bharat does, but MY Akhand Bharat's idea is of a land that is united by tradition, culture and history. Definitely not by who has the biggest D.. I mean nuke arsenal.