Would you kill your own children if God commanded you to?

[gabmen]

Would you kill your own children if God commanded you to?
A perfectly valid legit question.

Please no attempts to derail the thread with nonsense like "God would never say that" or "God would never change the rules with murder" etc....

I was not in this situation and I can not say how I would have acted, but I think it's unlikely that I would have done that, I would not have killed the children for anything

Same here. I could burn in hell for not heeding the instruction but i won't have my children's blood in my hands whatever the reason is. It  would be more acceptable for me to suffer any consequence than allowing any harm to come to my children

[1715604701]

1715604701

[1715604701]

1715604701

[1715604701]

1715604701

[1715604701]

1715604701

[1715604701]

1715604701

[noelwenceslao03]

I would obey, but I think that God would not let me total commit the crime. I believe that it is simply a test in order for God to see if I have the heart to obey Him even in the toughest of times. I believe that God would command me to stop the murder in the last second.

[Naoko]

everyone has his own relationship with God, and for every person his own God exists...I believe that the God who is in my heart would never have asked me for this...because God is happiness and murder can't bring me closer to God

[iCEBREAKER]

Aminazine would resolve that kind of issues without need to kill anyone.

ROFLOL. Good one!  I'm stealing it.

[tiar4dewie]

Yes I will do, but how does God deliver that command to me? now there are no more messengers.

[reyzel27]

No, I'm not  we are the people of god,and god will not do this.children is very important to your house children is very important to the couple.he is not god to kill any other children,he is a demon thats is my opinion.

[ashens93]

Yes I would do any thing that god orders me to do. It is because that god plans the whole scenario of my life. So if god recommends me to do any thing he will have the future planned for me. so I'm not afraid of doing what god requires from me to do.

[Karapul769]

No. I don't understand how questions like that are born in people's minds. It is your children. They are part of you and the part of this universe. They were born for something. People can not decide things like that. 

[Xising]

It’s probably a test of faith. Well honestly, if I am one hundred percent sure that He is the Almighty God the Creator and not just a figment of my imagination or the effect of high grade hallucinogenic drug; I would still NOT do it. I know in my heart that God is just testing me and his teachings would contradict this command. I love my children just like God loves all us, hence this is impossible to happen anyways.

[salinizm]

I would send God to hell! After all, these are my children and I have to protect them from death.

If so -called god commands me to kill my own child, I will do same thing with you. Human beings must protect their own child from any horrible situation. Even if creator of this horrible situation is God.

[icemantaurus]

No i rather not. I will protect my children at all cost. He must kill his child first.

[sp564]

No, never. Wouldn't want to obey a God that issued such demands. Besides, I'd be so scared that I was actually tripping, hallucinating, or dreaming, rather than hearing the word of God, and would never kill anyone over what a disembodied voice told me in such conditions.

[werpak321]

Would you kill your own children if God commanded you to?
A perfectly valid legit question.

Please no attempts to derail the thread with nonsense like "God would never say that" or "God would never change the rules with murder" etc....

For me i will just like abraham do to isaac he sacrifice his only son just to obey gods command but inside of me i cant but for gods command i will do even if its my own child yeah maybe it hurts when your child is gone but you should obey because everything happens for a reason and there a gods plan for you .

[RHMX]

No way,I won't do that.If this god ask me to kill my children he will confirm that he's a sadistic god or whatever he is.
So,for me he doesn't deserve my obedience .

[ynatopak14]

If God commands me to kill my children, if i can kill the god, i will if not i will just walk away from him.
i better be a Muslim than kill my children!
why dont god tell all human to kill those criminals especially rapist! why can't he kill those priests who are the sinner?

[hherwick]

No. I believe at that point my understanding of Islam would prove to be completely void. However, reaching a level of enlightenment that allows me to have an actual conversation with God would mean I'm already dead.

[Parodium]

It is deeply disturbing that 25% of people would kill their own children for the invisible sky daddy. Deeply disturbing indeed.

I honestly believe that organized religion is some sort of mental infection, that manages to spread from person to person, poisoning their mind.

[BlueMoonLight]

I don't know because reality is big different from story or theory. It is very hard to kill your own son and very hard also to disobeyed.

[Ems30]

no because its prophetic gods command purposes only even its prohecied  was also fulfilled so knowing god not request of this anyone ever
 do it gain constanly harm or kill your own child?,is not a luck of faith  but rather right understanding of god such a message or command sometimes could  only came from evil and deceptive spirit only ,,don't let atheist silly and unfounded question trip you up more often than not they are arguing from luck of understanding  or like in this case based on fact while ignoring the rest, 

[Vod]

Yes I would do any thing that god orders me to do. It is because that god plans the whole scenario of my life. So if god recommends me to do any thing he will have the future planned for me. so I'm not afraid of doing what god requires from me to do.

Something tells me you'll be in a courtroom someday charged with murder cause voices in your head told you to kill....  :/