Who makes more in the end? A good trader or a holder? Thoughts?

[Zyborg]

As the title said, Who makes more in the end? I been on trading for quite times,been scalping and learned a few lesson in technical analysis.
A trader or a holder , who earned a lot and takes more .

This is a very technical question and i would respond technically as listed below.

a.When market is extremely red and there is high fluctuations then short term trader can earn on daily basis a good profit.Short term trading is highly risky but also carries handsome profit as well.

b.When market is red its better to hold your investment because if you gonna toward sell you may earn less benefit or minimum loss as well.When prices are high later you can sell and earn a good profit.

As far as i am concerned a hodler earns a lot compared to trader but it also depends upon invested capital.

[Baoo]

Well, everything is related to how to take a good choice (Buy, Invest..) on the appropriate timing, for example, in this period, the currency price of Bitcoin is very low compared to the previous value and possibly this decline will continue in next days or maybe weeks, so when you will buy a large amount of Bitcoin and even the best cryptocurrecies (Ehtereum, Ripple, Tron, Cardano) then it is certain that you will make a huge profit in a long term because there is a big possiblity that this crisis is temporary and it will end after some period. So we must take advantage of this opportunity in order to ensure or guarantee an acceptable profit.
In addition to that, who makes more profit is the one who deal with every situation  ( pump, dump ) with the appropriate choice .

[Diablesfunis]

As the title said, Who makes more in the end? I been on trading for quite times,been scalping and learned a few lesson in technical analysis.
A trader or a holder , who earned a lot and takes more .

In my opinion a good holder will make more in the end, it is based on my experience on stocks market though so it might be different with crypto. Coin with great fundamental will have it's value increase in the long term so you can hold it and make profit later while in trading you have to do good trades a lot which is very unlikely to happen and you actually spend more time on trading while you can do something else if you just hold.

[Yakamoto]

As the title said, Who makes more in the end? I been on trading for quite times,been scalping and learned a few lesson in technical analysis.
A trader or a holder , who earned a lot and takes more .

In my opinion a good holder will make more in the end, it is based on my experience on stocks market though so it might be different with crypto. Coin with great fundamental will have it's value increase in the long term so you can hold it and make profit later while in trading you have to do good trades a lot which is very unlikely to happen and you actually spend more time on trading while you can do something else if you just hold.

It all depends on what you measure as success and what kind of market conditions are present at any given time. If the market is being consistently bullish for a long period of time, then your holders are going to make more overall. If the market is kind of stagnant aside from some occasional bounds up and down, traders will make more overall. Traders that are willing to trade altcoins right now will likely make more, provided they don't get caught in downtrends.

[FabiAdr76]

A holder need a good project and a lot of time to get profit.
A good trader (there aren't many good traders) whit a bullish market or bearish market will get a profit, no matter the situation, a good trader have advantage.

[Joemzz31]

Trading and HODL are one of the ways to earn income in cryptocurrency. I think the trader can make more incomes at the end since, trading is the best way to provide a huge income in daily process.

[dailythemmo]

Trust me, exchanges take it all, you can't win the exchanges btw no one, they're last winner

[bawa_23]

Both can be good on their own ends. Firstly a holder had to wait for for long time when his coins listed in ICO with good rates. On the other part Trader with his practical & technical knowledge at the end of day can produce a good money by sitting for full day his eyes on the market. Holder had wait for the bull to run. If you had good coins with you you should do some trading to some extent. As holding for months is also not good. You shouls also have experience of Trading also.

[littlebill16]

It's a bit hard to say which one would be more profitable at the end of a time. It is possible that a good trader would make more than a holder even if the markets are not well in a given day. I think overall a good trader would make more over time than a holder because it could take so long before they are able to make a profit out of their holdings.

[Asimmo]

I would say - proper mix of this two action is ideal thing.
Good trader knows when to hold and when to sell..
One action isn`t better then another..

[dukexox]

I would say - proper mix of this two action is ideal thing.
Good trader knows when to hold and when to sell..
One action isn`t better then another..

Couldn’t agree more with this one, it’s getting the balance right, learning and understanding basic ta to spot swing highs and lows etc to find some entry and exit points and leaving a few coins for the possible 50x is what I look for.

[gabbie2010]

In this era of instability in the price of Cryptos it will be difficult for hodlers to make profits however a good trader equipped with both technical and fundamental analysis will capitalized on the instability in the price and makes profits consistently thus having an edge over a hodler.

[darmin]

the hold will get unexpected results from on trade. If good condition indeed each trade will be able to produce, but if in a condition like this will be bad because certainly there will not be a rise which means so sure money in trade will be difficult. better hold your course in order to get maximum results.

[Gelesko]

As the title said, Who makes more in the end? I been on trading for quite times,been scalping and learned a few lesson in technical analysis.
A trader or a holder , who earned a lot and takes more .

I had an experience of trading and I think holders earn much more! Trader makes a lot of mistakes and they earn very little as when the market does go their way, they exit in hope to buy again, but it is too late and they are ready to buy at the price they have sold, but again it is too late and they start panicking and so many regrets, why they left a market that they were in to. Whereas holders don't make too much thinking, they just set a target, that suits them and they are waiting for their profit. My advise to everyone if you really believe in the asset you are holding, but you are bored or think you could earn more, split what you are holding, for example: you got 1000 whatever coin, leave 800/900 long term (hodl) and trade those 100/200 and that will make you happy.

[nicolesalv]

As the title said, Who makes more in the end? I been on trading for quite times,been scalping and learned a few lesson in technical analysis.
A trader or a holder , who earned a lot and takes more .

You can't really tell. It really depends on the situation and it really depends on how you are good in analyzing every situation here in crypto world. You can gain a lot if you are holding some coins for long term but it depends on the coins also that you are holding. You can also earn big in trading if you are good in studying in the flow of prices. So it is really hard to tell it really depends on the market situation. Both technique can be productive and we can gain but we must be aware of the situation.

[abake]

Someone won’t just jump into conclusion on this, any of the above may be the winner. If a holder is opportune to hodl what would be full of positivity at the end then it would Favour him and for a good trader, he would strategize and make profit on daily basis or short period.

[AlanShlafter]

Of course, the good trader makes more profit than the hodler, because trader sells at a high price and buys back from a cheap price. By that way, he increases bitcoin count with altcoin trading or gaining profit with bitcoin trading. But this is true only if he is really a "good trader" and don't make silly decisions while trading.

[cryptoadobo]

For me a good and experience day trader benefits the most in the income side. He can make profits even in a bearish market as long he have fundamental and technical analysis in the market. While holding your coin is good too but it takes long and sometimes you panic because the market go ups and down and tend to sell your token based on your emotion.

[veraro]

I suppose that very good trader makes more in the end. But the fact is the majority of people not good trader, not even close. The most people who think " i am good" lost everything in the end. So ,the holders makes more in the end.

[Btcvilla]

As the title said, Who makes more in the end? I been on trading for quite times,been scalping and learned a few lesson in technical analysis.
A trader or a holder , who earned a lot and takes more .

I think it depends on your experience and knowledge. traders and investors both contain high speculation that can deal with losses.
So, the most important role is experience and knowledge until you can do both.