vlad230 (OP)
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 01, 2018, 02:59:47 PM Last edit: October 02, 2018, 07:42:30 AM by vlad230 |
|
I was challenged by a user yesterday, in my [Merit Analysis] "Self Made" Jr. & Member users that have earned merit thread and promised I would deliver by today. Since I'm a big fan of challenges, I couldn't refuse ![Cheesy](https://bitcointalk.org/Smileys/default/cheesy.gif) Here's what user cryptovigi asked me to deliver: I like your analysis and have another challenge for you ;-)
Ranked Members - Member and above who was given merit airdrop (while introducing merit system) according to their ranks and didn't earn even one "by themself" this one maybe interesting!!!
So, let's see how this looks like in our forum. The questions I will find answers to are: 1. How many Sr. Member & up users exist that have not earned any merit?1078 Sr. Members 476 Hero Members 224 Legendary Members
There are 1778 users ranked Sr. Member & up that have not earned any merit, they just got "airdropped" merit from when the merit system was implemented. I was caught a bit off guard by this number, as I didn't think there could be so many users that have not earned any merit. This could signal some problems with the distribution of merit as these users should be knowledgeable enough to produce quality posts & get merited. Another possible explanation could be that some of the users here might not be active anymore, thus didn't come in contact with the merit system at all. Sadly, I do not have access to more information about the users like "last date active" to be able to produce more accurate data, yet. Since there are a lot of users and decided to limit myself to the post max size, I have analyzed Sr. Members & up. Let me know if someone would be interested in seeing the rest of the user categories and I will created another thread. 2. Who are the Sr. Member users that have not earned any merit?UserName Rank $Darkloard$ Sr. Member $anounimus$ Sr. Member -Joni- Sr. Member 19Nov16 Sr. Member 232drialf Sr. Member 24core Sr. Member 2tang Sr. Member 320hz Sr. Member 4rzun4 Sr. Member 8rch7 Sr. Member 93_didan Sr. Member @boutiuqe Sr. Member AK47- Sr. Member ATAK T-129 Sr. Member Aceeakell Sr. Member Acguy Sr. Member Adbitco Sr. Member Adya Sr. Member Adykingcity Sr. Member Affilate User Sr. Member AiloveYouks21 Sr. Member AjithBtc Sr. Member Aleator Sr. Member Aleya Sr. Member Alns Sr. Member AltsBoom Sr. Member AmXProX Sr. Member Amalker Sr. Member AmericanBit Sr. Member AmunRa Sr. Member AncilVTwo Sr. Member Andergriff Sr. Member Andrey Smirnov Sr. Member Anegg Sr. Member Apes Sr. Member Ariess Sr. Member Arksun Sr. Member Arsenyo Sr. Member Arumi.Bilqis Sr. Member Ashong Salonga Sr. Member Asi4btc Sr. Member Asimmo Sr. Member Atdhe Sr. Member Aura689 Sr. Member Autto Sr. Member Awalt541 Sr. Member Aying Sr. Member BERKUTcryp Sr. Member BETAWI Sr. Member BTC-Graphicdesigns Sr. Member BTCBusinessConsult Sr. Member BTCGOLD Sr. Member BTCdude007 Sr. Member Baby Dragon Sr. Member Bacchu Sr. Member Badboy[BTC] Sr. Member Bakemat Sr. Member BarbieCasino Sr. Member Bastime Sr. Member Bedebah Sr. Member Beijideluotuo Sr. Member BekantanSejagatTeamPenipu Sr. Member Ber86 Sr. Member BetcoinPoker Sr. Member BicolIsarog Sr. Member Bikers Sr. Member BitTeo Sr. Member BitcoinLoan Sr. Member Bitinator Sr. Member Bitum Sr. Member BlackWidow Sr. Member Blackdeath Sr. Member Blackwhite69 Sr. Member Blizzhard Sr. Member Bloodxtz Sr. Member Boathouse Sr. Member BobBct Sr. Member Bondho Kompeni Sr. Member Bonenx14 Sr. Member Braino Sr. Member Brama Jasa Sr. Member Brattavito Sr. Member BtcVolcano Sr. Member Bulletdodger Sr. Member Bunsomjelican Sr. Member ButtCrack Sr. Member CC23 Sr. Member CODE200 Sr. Member CRYPTONAIRE Sr. Member Caesar-Giulius Sr. Member Calangaman Sr. Member Carmen_Sandiego Sr. Member Cashcash Sr. Member Celendion Sr. Member Chainsmokers Sr. Member Chasoid Sr. Member Cherylstar86 Sr. Member Chinesegandalf Sr. Member Cimmy_revenger Sr. Member Clavulanic Sr. Member CloudStrife Sr. Member ClutchThese Sr. Member CoinTasker Sr. Member Colt81 Sr. Member ComponY Sr. Member Coroline Sr. Member Cortes_Cripto Sr. Member Cossack Sr. Member CrowdFunder Sr. Member Crypt1x Sr. Member CryptoRekt Sr. Member Cryptorast Sr. Member Crypviser Sr. Member CyanFox Sr. Member CyberCombat Sr. Member D4RK5T4R Sr. Member DLCseller Sr. Member DStefanov Sr. Member Daha19 Sr. Member Daneal Sr. Member Dank Frank Sr. Member DannyBOfficial Sr. Member DaveWave Sr. Member DavidSantamaria Sr. Member Davids123 Sr. Member Decksperiment Sr. Member Defloration Sr. Member Delaforetnoire Sr. Member Delicieuxz Sr. Member Delinquency Sr. Member Denov Setu Sr. Member DevSoft Sr. Member DevilSlayer Sr. Member DidiMidi Sr. Member DimaKHV Sr. Member Distraction Sr. Member Do4a Sr. Member Docent85 Sr. Member Domenc Sr. Member DonYo Sr. Member DragonETH Sr. Member DrearyUrbanite Sr. Member Drobek Sr. Member DroomieChikito Sr. Member Duzter Sr. Member ECore Sr. Member Easteregg69 Sr. Member EbenTheva Sr. Member Eclipse26 Sr. Member Eldest Sr. Member EleGiggle Sr. Member Elsonbol Sr. Member Etanllah Sr. Member EuSouBitcoin Sr. Member Experia Sr. Member Factmine Sr. Member Faiyz Sr. Member Fasdartin Sr. Member FaucetKING Sr. Member Faxmate Sr. Member Fidemoga Sr. Member Fishbones78 Sr. Member Flapmin Sr. Member Flexibit Sr. Member Flooks Sr. Member FlorentineNobleman Sr. Member ForeverFener Sr. Member Frank0209 Sr. Member Frank37 Sr. Member Fredii Sr. Member FreshB Sr. Member FridaKallo Sr. Member Fulmand Sr. Member Fundamentals Of Sr. Member FundsMoney Sr. Member GSpgh Sr. Member Gabri Sr. Member Ganlok Sr. Member Gargo Sr. Member GatotKaca Sr. Member Geekphazm Sr. Member Ghris Sr. Member Ginger Ninja Sr. Member GlacierBIT Sr. Member Glen Hoddle Sr. Member Gold.Boriska Sr. Member Golstrim Sr. Member GriTBitS Sr. Member HV3S Sr. Member HabiebRiziq Sr. Member Heimer Sr. Member Heishehui187 Sr. Member Here4Trades Sr. Member High Plains Drifter Sr. Member HopeCrypto Sr. Member HyperLup Sr. Member HyunBin Sr. Member Ignacia Sr. Member Images21 Sr. Member Infinity7 Sr. Member IntelligentIdiot Sr. Member Invester Sr. Member Iserviceman Sr. Member JC btc Sr. Member JDS1000 Sr. Member Jackling Sr. Member JahriMeayer Sr. Member James_H Sr. Member Jammalan the Prophet Sr. Member Jekwizor Sr. Member Jelly0621 Sr. Member Jembut Ireng Sr. Member Jerzzz Sr. Member Jian_Liux Sr. Member JimmieA Sr. Member Joe200 Sr. Member Joker07 Sr. Member Jose Mourinho Sr. Member Joshapat Sr. Member JumperN Sr. Member KDjr Sr. Member Kamayulka78 Sr. Member Kand1990 Sr. Member Karolina26 Sr. Member Kasperiko Sr. Member KawaBunGa Sr. Member Kawasanz Sr. Member Kazkar Sr. Member Kennedy Sr. Member Kersh768 Sr. Member Kevinatin Sr. Member Kewatia Sr. Member KickItDown Sr. Member Kienbui Sr. Member Killerpotleaf Sr. Member Kimi80 Sr. Member Kizaki Sr. Member Kj1 Sr. Member Klausi Sr. Member KnightElite Sr. Member KnightRiderus Sr. Member KoBaTeJIb Sr. Member Koppa Sr. Member Krista Sr. Member Kupid002 Sr. Member LIghtvelocityCoin Sr. Member Larion94 Sr. Member Larva14 Sr. Member LastKiss Sr. Member Lauren Smith Sr. Member Lazada Sr. Member Lebraam Sr. Member Lecam Sr. Member LegendOF45 Sr. Member Lesya2015 Sr. Member LilitKha Sr. Member Linuld Sr. Member Lone Shark Sr. Member Lontongmie Sr. Member Looarn Sr. Member LordMeowMeow Sr. Member Lorilikes Sr. Member Lubang Bawah Sr. Member LukkasG Sr. Member MMysterious Sr. Member MOSSAD Sr. Member MSZCoin Sr. Member MXXWLL Sr. Member Macrochip Sr. Member Magkirap Sr. Member Magnavox Sr. Member Mame89 Sr. Member Mang86 Sr. Member Marc De Mesel Sr. Member Mark81 Sr. Member Maryshka91 Sr. Member Masyudhi Sr. Member McKane Sr. Member MehdiBmm Sr. Member Meowth05 Sr. Member Meteeray Sr. Member Mihaylovic Sr. Member MoonJeina Sr. Member Moondreams Sr. Member MorGan-id Sr. Member Mr. Legendaris Sr. Member MrBAU Sr. Member MrData Sr. Member MrZ28s Sr. Member MtRev Sr. Member Myfe Sr. Member Myra4 Sr. Member NASdaq Sr. Member NH Sr. Member NJB18 Sr. Member Nathan047 Sr. Member NathanJB Sr. Member Nboramir Sr. Member Neo501 Sr. Member Nevsky Sr. Member Newton90 Sr. Member Ngewex Yuk Sr. Member Nicol3 Sr. Member NikuSH Sr. Member Nobtcoin Sr. Member Noidor Sr. Member NoiseBoy Sr. Member Nordblitcer Sr. Member Northa Sr. Member Noruka Sr. Member ONCF Sr. Member ORiN Sr. Member Obito Sr. Member OrsonJ Sr. Member Osmanli42 Sr. Member Oumal Sr. Member P4ndoraBox Sr. Member PM.coins Sr. Member Paritor Sr. Member Pejoh Asu Sr. Member Periodik Sr. Member PeterTheGrape Sr. Member PinkHead Sr. Member Pinkris128 Sr. Member Pipshunter Sr. Member Poloherb Sr. Member Prettygirl01315 Sr. Member Pride97 Sr. Member Primal Base Sr. Member Prodigan786 Sr. Member Pulithey1986 Sr. Member Pump N Dead Sr. Member Pumuckel21 Sr. Member QFT Sr. Member QueenOf Sr. Member Quietman Sr. Member R4v37 Sr. Member RACT Sr. Member RAGEmond Sr. Member Ragnarcoin Sr. Member Rahman11 Sr. Member Raizou Sr. Member Rana590 Sr. Member RandyMagnum Sr. Member Rapidgator Sr. Member Rasel5209 Sr. Member Raven91 Sr. Member Reatim Sr. Member Reavon Sr. Member Republicofizmir Sr. Member Roidz Sr. Member RonMank Sr. Member Ronin_sv Sr. Member Rora Sr. Member RouletteRun Sr. Member RussiaCoinDotInfo Sr. Member RussianTranslator Sr. Member Ryker1 Sr. Member SNS Sr. Member SUM2dev Sr. Member SacriFries11 Sr. Member Saidmod Sr. Member Sam San Sr. Member Sarisang Sr. Member Sate Jamu Sr. Member SateRebus Sr. Member Satorus Sr. Member Scyntech Sr. Member SeaSoul Sr. Member Selly Arumsari Sr. Member Senja Kemuning Sr. Member Serco Sr. Member Servantes Sr. Member Shanto Sr. Member Sharkzz1 Sr. Member Sifat33 Sr. Member Silvercell Sr. Member SimonBeCoinin Sr. Member SimonJones Sr. Member Sir Lagsalot Sr. Member Sir Legend Sr. Member SistaFista Sr. Member Smoker00 Sr. Member Sniar Sr. Member Snipe85 Sr. Member SoeNan89 Sr. Member SomeRelax Sr. Member Soots Sr. Member Sorros Sr. Member Sosaso75 Sr. Member Sponsoredby15 Sr. Member Spotswood Sr. Member Squirrel Dearing Sr. Member Starving_Marvin Sr. Member StinkyLover Sr. Member StonerStanley Sr. Member Stormspirit Sr. Member Sundoor Sr. Member Surrapatt Sr. Member Sven11 Sr. Member TRONTON Sr. Member TaShoKi Sr. Member Take the red pill Sr. Member TaliskerDarkStorm Sr. Member Taner Sr. Member Tara11 Sr. Member Tcher_L Sr. Member Termin4tor Sr. Member TexasofblackseA Sr. Member Tg87 Sr. Member TheClownSong Sr. Member TheCoinGrabber Sr. Member The_Don Sr. Member ThomasVeil Sr. Member Tidsdilatation Sr. Member TitanGEL Sr. Member Tommot Sr. Member TonTon Sr. Member TravelsAsia Sr. Member Tribizz Sr. Member Turkoin Sr. Member TyfrTR Sr. Member UNOE Sr. Member UltraPlay Sr. Member Umbrella Holdings Sr. Member VINSIN Sr. Member Vanderbleek Sr. Member Vasilije69 Sr. Member VeiweiLo Sr. Member Vesperion Sr. Member VforVictory Sr. Member ViceOfBTC21 Sr. Member Victoo Sr. Member Vika26 Sr. Member Vilchaco Sr. Member Vinaa77 Sr. Member Virman01 Sr. Member Viscera Sr. Member Vlegale Sr. Member Voidcrafter Sr. Member Vovka4 Sr. Member WackMack Sr. Member Wandika Sr. Member Wayan_Pedjeng Sr. Member Wesimon Sr. Member White Christmas Sr. Member Whitly Sr. Member WhyMe Sr. Member Willeampere Sr. Member Wipeout2097 Sr. Member Wolframio Sr. Member Wong Gendheng Sr. Member Wysi Sr. Member Xsinx Sr. Member Yamifoud Sr. Member Yoshi Livo Sr. Member YourMom420 Sr. Member Yza_azY Sr. Member Zaizoun Sr. Member Zechis966 Sr. Member ZeroFossilFuel Sr. Member ZhuldyzKaladinova Sr. Member Zorik Sr. Member [BTC]Girl Sr. Member _Django05_ Sr. Member _Lucky_ Sr. Member ___TR___ Sr. Member _noname_ Sr. Member aagert Sr. Member abdulmad Sr. Member abramovich Sr. Member acedia Sr. Member aces777 Sr. Member acharias Sr. Member acpr23 Sr. Member adabau Sr. Member adorid Sr. Member adpinbr Sr. Member aeternus Sr. Member agentx44 Sr. Member ahmia39 Sr. Member airdnasxela Sr. Member ak49er Sr. Member akar87 Sr. Member al7878 Sr. Member alankasman Sr. Member alexsandria Sr. Member alfaisal890 Sr. Member aligator2017 Sr. Member alucard20724 Sr. Member amy1284455127 Sr. Member andibongkol Sr. Member andriarto Sr. Member anehh Sr. Member angryswamp Sr. Member anticolay26 Sr. Member apolok Sr. Member appbox Sr. Member arikassuja Sr. Member arin_muah Sr. Member armlock Sr. Member arus Sr. Member aryana42 Sr. Member ashuawei Sr. Member asus09 Sr. Member asyakashi Sr. Member auctioneeeeer Sr. Member autada Sr. Member avp2306 Sr. Member awas Sr. Member awsses Sr. Member ayoubouni95 Sr. Member aysg76 Sr. Member ayu07 Sr. Member babaya Sr. Member babos8383 Sr. Member babysweetTiger0401 Sr. Member badungs Sr. Member baga105 Sr. Member bagera Sr. Member bagikoin Sr. Member bambazamba Sr. Member basesaw Sr. Member baskanx Sr. Member bere3kin Sr. Member bestBTCdomains Sr. Member betMaster Sr. Member betterangels Sr. Member bettercrypto Sr. Member betudontbet Sr. Member bgaf Sr. Member bhabygrim Sr. Member bigon Sr. Member bitboxxer Sr. Member bitcampaign Sr. Member bitcasino Sr. Member bitcoinbelieve Sr. Member bitcoineverything Sr. Member bitcub Sr. Member bitillionaire Sr. Member bitofc Sr. Member bitvalak Sr. Member bizzargin Sr. Member blah01 Sr. Member bleachX Sr. Member blockchain.hk Sr. Member bmxakias Sr. Member boller Sr. Member boo50 Sr. Member borntorun Sr. Member bosian Sr. Member brjameng Sr. Member brontosaurus Sr. Member btc4peace Sr. Member btcdamnit Sr. Member btcjocan Sr. Member btcsharehub Sr. Member btmtb Sr. Member bubblebit Sr. Member budiartha Sr. Member budlo Sr. Member bustedsynx Sr. Member butcherboss Sr. Member byteminr Sr. Member calya Sr. Member capcaypro Sr. Member carcassone Sr. Member cashundone Sr. Member castiloros Sr. Member cattani30 Sr. Member cbIpok Sr. Member cbtc Sr. Member cbw Sr. Member cercitolga4545 Sr. Member chadtn Sr. Member chaosagent Sr. Member charles2k Sr. Member cherry11800 Sr. Member chikiuso Sr. Member chromosoma Sr. Member cijulangboy Sr. Member cisA Sr. Member cleygaux Sr. Member clint25n Sr. Member codenamethisNutz Sr. Member coin2.0 Sr. Member coinpool_de Sr. Member contactmike1 Sr. Member cozytrade Sr. Member cramcram21 Sr. Member crazybtrade Sr. Member crazyhashmanz Sr. Member creepyjas Sr. Member croTek4 Sr. Member crocozino Sr. Member cryp24x Sr. Member cryptocyprus Sr. Member cryptogaga Sr. Member cryptogeek101 Sr. Member cryptojoe Sr. Member cryptomad Sr. Member cryptospreader_temp Sr. Member cryptotore Sr. Member crzybilly Sr. Member dacosta Sr. Member dadach Sr. Member dadas15 Sr. Member dannygroove Sr. Member dannyjr89 Sr. Member deathmul Sr. Member deddod Sr. Member deep4u Sr. Member deepcoreotc Sr. Member deliveryman Sr. Member dellzxd Sr. Member dentldir Sr. Member devid2017btc Sr. Member devil11 Sr. Member devlin Sr. Member dgigit Sr. Member dgmon Sr. Member dieselmeister Sr. Member digaran2 Sr. Member dimastegar Sr. Member dimb Sr. Member dimonarka Sr. Member disam Sr. Member djgtr Sr. Member djuragan Sr. Member dmamigo Sr. Member dmgta Sr. Member dmty.0809 Sr. Member dnz gns Sr. Member domoy77 Sr. Member doothewop Sr. Member dragonares Sr. Member drumamat Sr. Member drumingspz Sr. Member drwoo Sr. Member duyduc256 Sr. Member dycell Sr. Member dzkrb Sr. Member eP Sr. Member ePesoInitiative Sr. Member eagle10 Sr. Member earnbitcoins Sr. Member edutBTC Sr. Member edwardspitz Sr. Member eerygarden Sr. Member einsteinium Sr. Member emrek Sr. Member entropi Sr. Member erep Sr. Member erickastella Sr. Member erik777 Sr. Member europesss Sr. Member ex33s Sr. Member ezehy2014 Sr. Member fairbee Sr. Member faridkifly Sr. Member fearofsalt Sr. Member febriyana Sr. Member fenghush Sr. Member findblocks.com Sr. Member finist Sr. Member finity Sr. Member finzyoj Sr. Member fivejonnyfive Sr. Member fkod Sr. Member fndsr Sr. Member formator Sr. Member franss Sr. Member frozenking Sr. Member fuer44 Sr. Member fulcare Sr. Member fullcointalk Sr. Member funchiestz Sr. Member gavrilo Sr. Member gawuk Sr. Member george888055 Sr. Member getmoremonline Sr. Member ghost15 Sr. Member ghostfaceuk Sr. Member gielbier Sr. Member glavos Sr. Member glax1983 Sr. Member gobisirom Sr. Member golder1 Sr. Member goldkey0070 Sr. Member grermezter Sr. Member gri0 Sr. Member gtzanap Sr. Member halker2010 Sr. Member hanlieuiypm9832 Sr. Member hansen.ng Sr. Member hashtag101 Sr. Member hellsingfan Sr. Member hellyeahent Sr. Member heppot Sr. Member hikky22 Sr. Member himozavr Sr. Member hovrah Sr. Member ibuddy122505 Sr. Member iged_war Sr. Member ikm Sr. Member inanilujimi Sr. Member indika Sr. Member indo1 Sr. Member infarterr Sr. Member inthelongrun Sr. Member ipsec Sr. Member ironm@n Sr. Member isen Sr. Member isprofits Sr. Member itsonlikedonkeykong Sr. Member ivandu Sr. Member ivanovmoscow Sr. Member ivanpoldark Sr. Member iyan33 Sr. Member izotoniq Sr. Member izunuy Sr. Member jackchun Sr. Member jackflag Sr. Member jaksone Sr. Member jambul_kribo Sr. Member jaybny Sr. Member jc89 Sr. Member jcpone Sr. Member jeeb Sr. Member jelma Sr. Member jems Sr. Member jesselivermore Sr. Member jezus Sr. Member jh0w4n1z Sr. Member jimhsu Sr. Member johan11 Sr. Member jommy99 Sr. Member joosep Sr. Member jorenpo Sr. Member jovi18 Sr. Member jovs Sr. Member judeafante Sr. Member judypug1956 Sr. Member juhakall Sr. Member jw_industry Sr. Member jyotianand01 Sr. Member kalenen Sr. Member kaltar Sr. Member kamrulhasan001 Sr. Member kanayaTabitha Sr. Member kawacaki Sr. Member kaycyrpto23 Sr. Member kayvie Sr. Member kbhutto Sr. Member kelseydustin Sr. Member ken thung Sr. Member kendedes Sr. Member kenelmark Sr. Member kheein Sr. Member kikiyo Sr. Member kirdin Sr. Member kissmarx Sr. Member klychmen Sr. Member knuckey Sr. Member kojektea Sr. Member kololo Sr. Member konstant111 Sr. Member kotakamal Sr. Member krack-r Sr. Member kralkral Sr. Member kumala_abi Sr. Member kuverty Sr. Member kynaz Sr. Member kyori Sr. Member l3ocky Sr. Member lagharto Sr. Member lankyman Sr. Member leetcoiner Sr. Member leexhin Sr. Member lehard Sr. Member lenyro Sr. Member lesom Sr. Member lider1971 Sr. Member ligator19840208 Sr. Member lind82 Sr. Member linkme Sr. Member linyhan Sr. Member liqidoxgen Sr. Member lisasteca Sr. Member loading... Sr. Member lolgato1 Sr. Member lombok Sr. Member longyenthanh Sr. Member lovewiki Sr. Member loveyouforever Sr. Member loveys Sr. Member lukmandog Sr. Member lusiaga Sr. Member mackenzied Sr. Member magmar Sr. Member makerst Sr. Member maleemk Sr. Member maman09 Sr. Member mamesso Sr. Member mandor Sr. Member martinholly167 Sr. Member marufnang Sr. Member masterkiller Sr. Member masternode Sr. Member mattmct Sr. Member maursader Sr. Member mbah Sr. Member medsi2 Sr. Member meemiinii Sr. Member megacrypto Sr. Member megadeth Sr. Member megynacuna Sr. Member melisande Sr. Member meph Sr. Member merle Sr. Member meyer Sr. Member mig5000 Sr. Member mig6r Sr. Member mihaisav Sr. Member mikewirth Sr. Member millgates Sr. Member minairia3 Sr. Member mine2slow Sr. Member miramax-10 Sr. Member mitsarasss Sr. Member miztaziggy Sr. Member mkhadazz Sr. Member mlindjo Sr. Member mmedinas Sr. Member mmkiwi Sr. Member mmo_online_1981 Sr. Member mohammedfaiz143 Sr. Member mone99 Sr. Member monkeybars Sr. Member moonfrog Sr. Member mrbanjo Sr. Member mrvision Sr. Member mt55 Sr. Member naira Sr. Member namjar Sr. Member necromastery Sr. Member neite99 Sr. Member neleonele Sr. Member nelmari Sr. Member nelson4lov Sr. Member nesso Sr. Member nethan1btc Sr. Member ngerok Sr. Member nhaila Sr. Member nhfccbhjdrf Sr. Member nhminer Sr. Member nicomedya5 Sr. Member nicster551 Sr. Member nid125 Sr. Member nihilnegativum Sr. Member ninjaskip Sr. Member nmaryrai Sr. Member noashh Sr. Member nogoodcoin Sr. Member noninum Sr. Member nu1mlock Sr. Member nubbins7 Sr. Member number37 Sr. Member nur1labs Sr. Member nyteo Sr. Member oginiimaoyani Sr. Member okissabam Sr. Member oleg1984a Sr. Member olesya Sr. Member olloman Sr. Member ololajulo Sr. Member ongahawak Sr. Member oogone Sr. Member optigon Sr. Member orarider Sr. Member ottogary Sr. Member oxygen88 Sr. Member paladium Sr. Member pastan Sr. Member patrickus Sr. Member paulk11087 Sr. Member pavan@hosur Sr. Member pdogg147 Sr. Member pentol86 Sr. Member peschi Sr. Member piccionipier Sr. Member pikachuy Sr. Member pikkie Sr. Member pisston Sr. Member platinum4 Sr. Member poiseulle Sr. Member pokerjet Sr. Member pokeviktor Sr. Member polemarhos888 Sr. Member poulembertus Sr. Member prashanta Sr. Member preda Sr. Member proride Sr. Member psyx80 Sr. Member puffmais Sr. Member pumawolf Sr. Member pushyk Sr. Member putradaerah Sr. Member quake313 Sr. Member quang99 Sr. Member quantum Sr. Member quintiilieo Sr. Member raes Sr. Member rainingbitcoins Sr. Member ranggenga Sr. Member rayday11 Sr. Member rchstr Sr. Member reflexmk Sr. Member renbit Sr. Member rizkyrz Sr. Member rjp55 Sr. Member rlm42 Sr. Member rmyg5907 Sr. Member robertiv2 Sr. Member rocketron Sr. Member rod1234 Sr. Member roncar Sr. Member rossr1 Sr. Member rubiprojects Sr. Member ruptan Sr. Member ryjin1007 Sr. Member sairji Sr. Member sammrheza Sr. Member santygo777 Sr. Member saymissme Sr. Member sconklin321 Sr. Member scott btc Sr. Member sealofsun Sr. Member secdark Sr. Member seddik Sr. Member sekalitas Sr. Member sellrai Sr. Member sellscript Sr. Member septi.JR Sr. Member sergiorus Sr. Member sergsen Sr. Member sert Sr. Member shadowdio Sr. Member shams Sr. Member shenxirrwya1582 Sr. Member shimbark123 Sr. Member sidodadii Sr. Member silverleafy Sr. Member skarais Sr. Member skiorf Sr. Member skish85 Sr. Member skypeTeo Sr. Member slackcryptoz Sr. Member smic Sr. Member snowcrawl Sr. Member snowyNNN Sr. Member soham Sr. Member sokusimafuckusima Sr. Member sonic212 Sr. Member sorji Sr. Member spacelab Sr. Member spadormie Sr. Member spartanrules Sr. Member speedy1987 Sr. Member speedy963 Sr. Member spike420211 Sr. Member spin Sr. Member sprinkles Sr. Member stas Sr. Member stasyk411 Sr. Member steinkopf Sr. Member step_mike Sr. Member stephanirain Sr. Member stepwilli Sr. Member stil55 Sr. Member strasboug Sr. Member stryker Sr. Member summonerrk Sr. Member supto005 Sr. Member surfer43 Sr. Member suryana Sr. Member sva_h4cky0 Sr. Member taibas Sr. Member taidulvseh78044 Sr. Member tanghere02 Sr. Member tansoft64 Sr. Member tarolog Sr. Member tbonetony Sr. Member tekno Sr. Member temeler Sr. Member tetra Sr. Member tezcatcatl Sr. Member thefaucetrunner Sr. Member thesims Sr. Member thms Sr. Member thunderbitz2717 Sr. Member tianglistrik Sr. Member tigz Sr. Member tittensor Sr. Member titteringtacos Sr. Member tommy163 Sr. Member toodamntired Sr. Member tosmartak Sr. Member travwill Sr. Member trickyriky Sr. Member ttoroie Sr. Member tukang_rosok Sr. Member tukangkopi Sr. Member tunctioncloud Sr. Member ubeing Sr. Member ucliktea Sr. Member udecker Sr. Member ugr_erkn92 Sr. Member ullikume Sr. Member umbara ardian Sr. Member uniquehero Sr. Member unlock.mk Sr. Member usamamalik555 Sr. Member utkuy Sr. Member valuater Sr. Member verb Sr. Member vinc3 Sr. Member vincentvincent Sr. Member vindicare Sr. Member vivland Sr. Member voltesbit777 Sr. Member vvu351 Sr. Member wakier Sr. Member wallstone Sr. Member wawan99 Sr. Member weav Sr. Member weisonghypsp291 Sr. Member welshy9 Sr. Member wendelllee Sr. Member wenzuo Sr. Member what1005 Sr. Member whiteblue Sr. Member wiak2 Sr. Member wickedsick Sr. Member wildey Sr. Member will_k Sr. Member wiss19 Sr. Member wnfmzm74 Sr. Member wolverine5pl Sr. Member worthyou Sr. Member wowok Sr. Member wry Sr. Member www.www Sr. Member xLays Sr. Member xapwxrm5742 Sr. Member xonecoinlovers Sr. Member xvids Sr. Member xx-man Sr. Member xx63245613 Sr. Member xypos Sr. Member xyzzyx Sr. Member ya.knf Sr. Member yatogami Sr. Member yohananaomi Sr. Member yrreg ger Sr. Member yslyv Sr. Member yuLyaS Sr. Member yudi09 Sr. Member yulionoo Sr. Member zaisha Sr. Member zhongzy Sr. Member zidanw Sr. Member zombie6 Sr. Member zoom_rich Sr. Member zucknail Sr. Member zuzuca Sr. Member zxl912157 Sr. Member 左 Sr. Member
3. Who are the Hero users that have not earned any merit?UserName Rank --DarkSecrets-- Hero Member ... ... Hero Member 007eminem Hero Member 727miner Hero Member 77kdub Hero Member @Hakermania@ Hero Member ACP Hero Member ADcoin.me Hero Member Ab-Soul Hero Member Ailmand Hero Member AirFlame Hero Member Ais08 Hero Member Aleister Crowley Hero Member AlexNeto Hero Member Altcoin Agent Hero Member Ambros Hero Member Amritt Hero Member Andre# Hero Member AndrewBUD Hero Member AndrewK Hero Member Andrey Hero Member Apened Hero Member Arcas Hero Member Arcteryx Hero Member ArdiPrabowo Hero Member Armstand Hero Member Askit2 Hero Member Asurmen Hero Member AuroraHF Hero Member BTCdoaA Hero Member BTcoint Hero Member Beans Hero Member BernieCoin Hero Member Bfljosh Hero Member BitcSeo Hero Member Bl4ckw00d Hero Member BlackPrapor Hero Member Bojcha Hero Member BtcCrazy1 Hero Member Burovik99 Hero Member Byte16 Hero Member CASlO Hero Member Cacingkemi Hero Member Camus Hero Member CapnBDL Hero Member Capuchino Hero Member CasinoBetGame Hero Member Cazkys Hero Member Chainger Hero Member CharlyKa Hero Member Cloudpost Hero Member Coinbuddy Hero Member Coindgr Hero Member Coiner.de Hero Member Colombina Hero Member Cosbycoin Hero Member Daffadile Hero Member Dammitt Hero Member DanWalker Hero Member Darker45 Hero Member Darwin02 Hero Member Dhoe Hero Member Digitalbitcoin Hero Member DocBones Hero Member Doging Hero Member DrkLvr_ Hero Member Dusty Hero Member Easy2Mine Hero Member ErikvanBreen Hero Member Evan Hero Member Ezravdb Hero Member FFI2013 Hero Member FastSlots Hero Member FeelTheBeat Hero Member Flep182 Hero Member FreedomCoin Hero Member Frenk Best Hero Member Frequency Hero Member FrictionlessCoin Hero Member Frizz23 Hero Member Furious 7 Hero Member Fuzzbawls Hero Member GHCoins45 Hero Member GideonGono Hero Member Google+ Hero Member GreenCoin22 Hero Member HarHarHar9965 Hero Member HardwarePal Hero Member HasHe Hero Member Hassan02 Hero Member ICOcountdown.com Hero Member IamNotSure Hero Member Icon Hero Member InVarianT Hero Member Inkdatar Hero Member Isildur (official) Hero Member J1mb0 Hero Member JGCMiner Hero Member JL421 Hero Member JakeThePanda Hero Member Jody.Drummer Hero Member JollyTrades Hero Member Kashif009 Hero Member Kazadar Hero Member KenChanYu Hero Member KennyR Hero Member KickAzzDude Hero Member Koadharber Hero Member Kolder Hero Member KosmoKisa Hero Member Kotone Hero Member LieXurui Hero Member Lion BItcoin Shop Hero Member LiskQH Hero Member Litejavichu Hero Member LoneRangir Hero Member M0ndialu Hero Member Mahanton Hero Member Martisor-Sobru Hero Member Master_dandosha Hero Member Mento Hero Member Mkmanik Hero Member MoneyIsDebt Hero Member Monkey1 Hero Member Morguk Hero Member Mountaingoat Hero Member Myr Hero Member NILIcoin Hero Member NaXxow Hero Member Nabilo Hero Member Nevis Hero Member Nibelung Hero Member Nightz Hero Member NikiForCrypt Hero Member OracionSeis Hero Member OrcaTech Hero Member Panzersin Hero Member Pattart Hero Member Penguen Hero Member PokerBetting Hero Member PonzyManCrazyLiar Hero Member Powerpuff Hero Member PrintMule Hero Member RB25 Hero Member Red_Evil Hero Member Rinder Hero Member Rizky Aditya Hero Member Russlenat Hero Member SISAR Hero Member SONG GEET Hero Member Selsonblue Hero Member SimpeleSimpele Hero Member Sjacmur Hero Member Snub Hero Member Soha Hero Member Stenull Hero Member Sumo Hero Member TERA Hero Member TGD Hero Member TR8888 Hero Member Tamilson Hero Member TeamDisaster Hero Member Text Hero Member TheGodFather Hero Member Thomas-s Hero Member Trial Hero Member U2 Hero Member USScrypto Hero Member V1saya Hero Member Varyg Hero Member VenMiner Hero Member Viva! Hero Member WalkerIVIV Hero Member Webcelerator. Hero Member Xantrax Hero Member Xtar Hero Member YIz Hero Member YinShuiSiYuan Hero Member ZeroTheGreat Hero Member Zoltan450 Hero Member aakashsangwan Hero Member abrakadabra Hero Member abvhiael Hero Member aceptamosbitcoin Hero Member acholagi Hero Member acs267 Hero Member adamvp Hero Member adi33 Hero Member ahoenk Hero Member ainv42 Hero Member akim Hero Member alamin99 Hero Member albert11 Hero Member alinda Hero Member amgomez Hero Member anami57 Hero Member andycarrol Hero Member axxo Hero Member badjacks99 Hero Member basket ball Hero Member battyKit Hero Member bclcjunkie Hero Member beckspace Hero Member beijihu Hero Member bennana Hero Member betlord90 Hero Member bigdude Hero Member bighobbit Hero Member biodieselchris Hero Member bitjoin Hero Member blastbob Hero Member blockman Hero Member bluedeep Hero Member bobcaticus Hero Member bogdan2323 Hero Member bomberb17 Hero Member bonosurgut Hero Member brother3 Hero Member btcney Hero Member butya Hero Member cabron Hero Member cacucacok91 Hero Member casinobonusgiveaway Hero Member cexylikepie Hero Member chickenado Hero Member chineseprancing Hero Member chixka000 Hero Member clickerz Hero Member coa032 Hero Member coin-investor Hero Member coinmenace Hero Member coinstatic Hero Member coldice Hero Member coynedterm Hero Member cozk Hero Member croato Hero Member crossabdd Hero Member cryptoheadd Hero Member cshelswell Hero Member cxboyminer Hero Member cyberpinoy Hero Member cypher21 Hero Member d@nte Hero Member dE_logics Hero Member dakota neat Hero Member danipay Hero Member dasana212 Hero Member daxiake Hero Member deadsilent Hero Member dearbesz1219 Hero Member deepocean Hero Member djjacket Hero Member doktor1897 Hero Member dopey Hero Member dustboy Hero Member dzonikg28 Hero Member eagleman Hero Member ebereon Hero Member eeX Hero Member ekoja Hero Member ensign_lee Hero Member error08 Hero Member esotericizm Hero Member expert4knowledge Hero Member eye4bd Hero Member f4tal1ty Hero Member fearcoka Hero Member fedmahnkassad Hero Member feedo Hero Member felixbrucker Hero Member filipe3x Hero Member flyer88 Hero Member francisdean Hero Member frankkkkkkk Hero Member freigeist Hero Member futurebit640 Hero Member gadado Hero Member garmin Hero Member gcoffie7 Hero Member generous Hero Member geoffreyqp Hero Member gidlark1 Hero Member gijoes Hero Member gomei Hero Member goodyang Hero Member hajimasan Hero Member helipotte Hero Member hicaribou Hero Member howardb Hero Member hugolp Hero Member hyudien Hero Member iluvpie60 Hero Member infazan Hero Member infested999 Hero Member instacalm Hero Member inushkin Hero Member ipanks Hero Member irlandescoin Hero Member isaevski Hero Member jasonjm Hero Member jd1959 Hero Member jeks Hero Member jets567 Hero Member jkminkov Hero Member joesmoe2012 Hero Member jokowi Hero Member josephdd1 Hero Member jpcfan Hero Member jpoker272727 Hero Member jt byte Hero Member junglist.massive Hero Member katrimans Hero Member kebabman Hero Member kendari Hero Member kiffner Hero Member klidex Hero Member kliown Hero Member kovaa Hero Member kr105 Hero Member krisnt80 Hero Member lab rat hoax Hero Member ladydark Hero Member laredo7mm Hero Member laris2 Hero Member lastlove9091 Hero Member laugh2btc Hero Member lega46141 Hero Member legendbtc Hero Member lemfuture Hero Member leshutov Hero Member lg15x Hero Member lindin99 Hero Member loaddebitcard Hero Member longthu Hero Member luka1987 Hero Member masewild Hero Member mastica Hero Member mauriek Hero Member mega Hero Member meisner Hero Member mekar sari Hero Member mellorbo Hero Member merlyn22 Hero Member micher143 Hero Member micky123 Hero Member midnight_miner Hero Member minime0105 Hero Member miningnew Hero Member minionsgelato Hero Member mnightwaffle Hero Member mornabo Hero Member mrayazgul Hero Member mrbodz Hero Member mrjoy15 Hero Member mrkavasaki Hero Member mrongoz_imut Hero Member mv1986 Hero Member mwheeleruk Hero Member najzenmajsen Hero Member nasashi Hero Member neochiny Hero Member nession Hero Member nick777 Hero Member nik009 Hero Member nrigo Hero Member nxtZen Hero Member onlinedragon Hero Member pacifista Hero Member pashh Hero Member pcfli Hero Member phzi Hero Member pieppiep Hero Member pigheadbig Hero Member poetra2501 Hero Member popcoins Hero Member pr0d1gy Hero Member prix Hero Member prtty2gal2 Hero Member qory Hero Member raaajlucky Hero Member rancidgash Hero Member rapidleech Hero Member rekinthis Hero Member remistevens Hero Member rindo Hero Member risatrakib Hero Member rocku12345 Hero Member rolik2001 Hero Member ropyu1978 Hero Member rpg Hero Member sacskate Hero Member salsa321 Hero Member sandor111 Hero Member sapusapu Hero Member sasa9 Hero Member satria33 Hero Member savioroshan Hero Member sebungkus Hero Member senyorito123 Hero Member sevendust777 Hero Member sezyumx Hero Member shapeshiftscam Hero Member sinner Hero Member sir.humus Hero Member sirohige Hero Member smithAwesson Hero Member smokim87 Hero Member someonesomeone Hero Member sotoshihero Hero Member soul-impact Hero Member spartan82 Hero Member superscommessebitcoin Hero Member surfguy72 Hero Member sxafir Hero Member szafa Hero Member t39 Hero Member tamara163 Hero Member tarzan2 Hero Member teilwalL05 Hero Member teletobi Hero Member tema Hero Member template Hero Member temple Hero Member thebitstreet Hero Member thedue Hero Member thend1949 Hero Member thew3apon Hero Member thisappointed Hero Member thresher Hero Member timbereagle Hero Member tkon3 Hero Member tm2013 Hero Member tn211 Hero Member tobsnn Hero Member tommyj1 Hero Member tonnynguyen Hero Member torikan Hero Member tosha566 Hero Member totoy Hero Member truimpheriues Hero Member turkandjaydee Hero Member tw0rak Hero Member twicezeroiszero Hero Member twiifm Hero Member ubitcoin Hero Member ufaiz50 Hero Member unois Hero Member unusualfacts30 Hero Member uservalera Hero Member vigmar Hero Member vitvert Hero Member vondi1122 Hero Member vortex1878 Hero Member w0lf0. Hero Member warr1979 Hero Member wavesroom Hero Member wdnj Hero Member wearepoor Hero Member wenwen478 Hero Member wingding Hero Member wndrbr3d Hero Member wolfgb888 Hero Member worldinacoin Hero Member xeqoRameshAxueamExaqana Hero Member xleejohnx Hero Member xp.rie Hero Member xwebnetwork Hero Member xzhybbs Hero Member yokosan Hero Member yurez Hero Member zanzibar Hero Member zcxvp Hero Member zrunfeng Hero Member zuggu-1 Hero Member zupdawg Hero Member zurg Hero Member
4. Who are the Legendary users that have not earned any merit?UserName Rank 10000usdperbtc Legendary 2double0 Legendary 50cent_rapper Legendary 5ick3uffalo Legendary 7788bitcoin Legendary A L I E N Legendary AcoinL.L.C Legendary Akka Legendary Amel Legendary Anarchy101 Legendary AngusCanine Legendary Asatur Legendary BCEmporium Legendary Bimmerhead Legendary BitCoinNutJob Legendary BitNow Legendary BitcoinEXpress Legendary Boussac Legendary CrackedLogic Legendary DGulari Legendary Dewi Aries Legendary Dogedigital Legendary Dotto Legendary Dux2K Legendary Emerge Legendary FlensGold Legendary Geenstijl Legendary GhostPlayer Legendary Gianluca95 Legendary Gizfreak Legendary Googlulinks Legendary GreatOrchid Legendary Griffith Legendary HappyS Legendary Hyperjacked Legendary IBGigglin Legendary IMZ Legendary Jasad Legendary Jayjay04 Legendary Kepasa Legendary Kupsi Legendary Kushedout Legendary LastClingon Legendary Lebubar Legendary MaRSe Legendary Matt9301 Legendary Mervyn_Pumpkinhead Legendary MickGhee Legendary Micky25 Legendary MinermanNC Legendary Monnt Legendary MonsterV Legendary MsCollec Legendary Nahl Legendary ONLYfree Legendary Paraka Legendary Patel Legendary Pipesnake Legendary Prelude Legendary Republikcoin.com Legendary RoooooR Legendary Shkembe Legendary SmartIphone Legendary Snail2 Legendary Southpaw0 Legendary Strongkored Legendary SwingFirst Legendary Tauja Legendary Taxidermista Legendary TheKoziTwo Legendary Tony116 Legendary Tyke Legendary Undermood Legendary Winner Legendary Wusolini Legendary YarkoL Legendary Zadicar Legendary Zicadis Legendary Zich Legendary Zombie123 Legendary ZyTReX Legendary ahmedjadoon Legendary aikklond Legendary aistto Legendary aleandromagno Legendary andulolika Legendary anirgu Legendary anref Legendary anticlimax Legendary bassdude Legendary benthach Legendary bitcon Legendary bithalo Legendary bitmaster1x Legendary bittaitaliana Legendary bitwho Legendary bms2013 Legendary boestin Legendary brian_nguyen Legendary bspus Legendary buygazprom Legendary cagrund Legendary chryspano Legendary corather Legendary crunck Legendary dadingsda Legendary danherbias07 Legendary dave111223 Legendary david1365 Legendary dbt1033 Legendary deblue Legendary dimox Legendary dinda22 Legendary djnocide Legendary dload.1 Legendary dnaleor Legendary dopecoindude Legendary dunfida Legendary e1ghtSpace Legendary edmundduke Legendary enhu Legendary eroxors Legendary escalicha Legendary etoque Legendary farl4web Legendary flower1024 Legendary frankenmint Legendary gnargnar Legendary goxed Legendary grandFX Legendary guigui371 Legendary hahay Legendary hazarun Legendary hdd3go Legendary helloge Legendary hiddensphinx Legendary hurricandave Legendary ifightformerkel Legendary innocent93 Legendary ivan1975 Legendary joele Legendary johny08 Legendary joksim299 Legendary keithers Legendary keyscore44 Legendary killerjoegreece Legendary klf Legendary kondiomir Legendary koshgel Legendary kronkodil Legendary lionheart78 Legendary liteon Legendary logocreator Legendary lolxxxx Legendary lottery248 Legendary louiseth1 Legendary lowbander80 Legendary makishart Legendary malekbaba Legendary mamamae Legendary mastertrader777 Legendary matveevka Legendary maxll Legendary maza5 Legendary mettalmag Legendary michietn94 Legendary moppang Legendary moxl Legendary nekochan05 Legendary neolinkhati Legendary nizamcc Legendary numismatist Legendary ny2cafuse Legendary oli123123 Legendary pandacoin Legendary pbleak Legendary pickupcoin Legendary piebeyb Legendary polynesia Legendary qwed Legendary rdnkjdi Legendary reb0rn21 Legendary redjedievolution Legendary roadbits Legendary rodrigobitcoin Legendary s1ng Legendary sana54210 Legendary sardokan Legendary schnötzel Legendary serje Legendary server Legendary shaklov Legendary silverbox Legendary snipsnoop Legendary splawik21 Legendary srgkrgkj Legendary stahanovec Legendary supermoney Legendary sureshnsnet Legendary tair85 Legendary takagari Legendary tarmi Legendary the_poet Legendary thefunkybits Legendary tiggytomb Legendary tiozes Legendary tobeaj2mer01 Legendary toptek Legendary uki Legendary unamis76 Legendary usao Legendary varanvaran Legendary viboracecata Legendary vladimirushev Legendary vokain Legendary wachtwoord Legendary wadili89 Legendary winter Legendary wonko86 Legendary wpalczynski Legendary wuqing78 Legendary xsentus Legendary yslyung Legendary zork Legendary
Please let me know what you think. Have you expected these results? Also, if you have any ideas on what would be interesting to see related to users & merit, please let me know ![Smiley](https://bitcointalk.org/Smileys/default/smiley.gif) Disclaimer: 1. The merit data is the latest one, from Friday, Sept 28th. 2. The user data is from Sept 24th. 3. The user data is comprised of 29039 users that have interacted with merit in some way (received or sent).
|
|
|
|
Findingnemo
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 01, 2018, 03:38:43 PM |
|
I hope few of the members deserves merit even if they don't have any because as you said there will be problem in the merit distribution is still persists.But there were lot of high ranked members actually shared merits between their alts at the very beginning so if we don't have any airdrop merits since the implementation of the merit system the four digit number of users who don't have any merits yet will go to five digit number even.
|
| | . .Duelbits. | │ | ..........UNLEASH.......... THE ULTIMATE GAMING EXPERIENCE | │ | DUELBITS FANTASY SPORTS | ████▄▄▄█████▄▄▄ ░▄████████████████▄ ▐██████████████████▄ ████████████████████ ████████████████████▌ █████████████████████ ████████████████▀▀▀ ███████████████▌ ███████████████▌ ████████████████ ████████████████ ████████████████ ████▀▀███████▀▀ | . ▬▬ VS ▬▬ | ████▄▄▄█████▄▄▄ ░▄████████████████▄ ▐██████████████████▄ ████████████████████ ████████████████████▌ █████████████████████ ███████████████████ ███████████████▌ ███████████████▌ ████████████████ ████████████████ ████████████████ ████▀▀███████▀▀ | /// PLAY FOR FREE /// WIN FOR REAL | │ | ..PLAY NOW.. | |
View ArchiveReport to moderator
|
|
|
virendarnagpal
Member
![*](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/star.gif)
Offline
Activity: 672
Merit: 12
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 01, 2018, 04:04:43 PM |
|
Nothing is 100% complete in this world. Whatever we create initially will be having some errors.
At the start there may be more irregularities but with the passage of time the drawbacks are identified and improvements are done. So after some time the the creators try to make their system more and more fool proof / efficient / error free.
|
|
|
|
LoyceV
Legendary
Offline
Activity: 3416
Merit: 17268
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 01, 2018, 07:04:37 PM |
|
There are 1778 users ranked Sr. Member & up that have not earned any merit, they just got "airdropped" merit from when the merit system was implemented. I would have expected a much higher number. Apparently there's less high ranking (inactive or spamming) members than I expected. Can you also produce the numbers for Full Members? I was caught a bit off guard by this number, as I didn't think there could be so many users that have not earned any merit. Considering that less than 1% of all users has received Merit, the percentage of high ranking accounts is much higher. Of course, many of them had sMerit to share with their alt accounts too, which means "merit received" doesn't necessarily mean the merit was "earned".
|
|
|
|
eddie13
Legendary
Offline
Activity: 2296
Merit: 2262
BTC or BUST
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 01, 2018, 07:18:56 PM |
|
Something is wrong making your list incomplete.. Must not cover all inactive users.. I was just looking at kwukduck https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=654Legendary, no merits, not on your list..
|
Chancellor on Brink of Second Bailout for Banks
|
|
|
DdmrDdmr
Legendary
Offline
Activity: 2422
Merit: 10978
There are lies, damned lies and statistics. MTwain
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 01, 2018, 07:39:20 PM Last edit: October 01, 2018, 10:05:53 PM by DdmrDdmr |
|
I think that the data in the OP is completely wrong. The lists are not members that were airdropped merit and have not sent any, but rather members that have given merit and not received any themselves.
I guess you wrote something like this on Piggy’s SQL:
select rank, count(*) nUsers from UserData u where (select sum(merit)from MeritData m where m.ToID = u.UserId)=0 group by Rank
or select rank, count(*) nUsers from UserData u where not exists (select 1 from MeritData m where m.ToID = u.UserId) group by rank
Rank nUsers Brand new 4 Copper Member 9 Full Member 2424 Hero Member 476 Jr. Member 29 Legendary 224 Member 2811 Newbie 13 Sr. Member 1078
The UserData table has 29039 records, one for each user that has merited or received merit. Therefore, excluding the merited you get the meriters that have not yet been merited…
You cannot know who got an initial amount of sMerit (less of all how much on an individual level), since the formula depends on their activity during the year previous to sMerit System kick-off, and you cannot know this since there is no available full DB snapshot (not just merited) dating one year before and on the date of the merit system kick-off.
|
|
|
|
vlad230 (OP)
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 01, 2018, 09:03:40 PM Last edit: October 01, 2018, 09:20:25 PM by vlad230 |
|
I would have expected a much higher number. Apparently there's less high ranking (inactive or spamming) members than I expected. Can you also produce the numbers for Full Members?
Sure, I'll create it as soon as I have some time on my hands, this week. Considering that less than 1% of all users has received Merit, the percentage of high ranking accounts is much higher. Of course, many of them had sMerit to share with their alt accounts too, which means "merit received" doesn't necessarily mean the merit was "earned".
Yes, there may be incomplete data in the UserData table so, there could be inconsistencies. Yeah... I agree with the "earned" part, for the sake of this experiment I considered all users to be fair and not cheaters. Obviously this can't be true ![Cheesy](https://bitcointalk.org/Smileys/default/cheesy.gif) Yes you are correct, that user is missing because it is not available in the DB. Unfortunately I do not control the DB. Most probably some users are missing. If you do a simple search in the DB, you won't find any data for him in the UserData table: SELECT * FROM UserData WHERE UserName = 'kwukduck'
Good catch though ![Smiley](https://bitcointalk.org/Smileys/default/smiley.gif) If you search for mine, you'll get a result: SELECT * FROM UserData WHERE UserName = 'vlad230'
I think that the data in the OP is completely wrong. The lists are not members that were airdropped merit and have not sent any, but rather members that have given merit and not received any themselves.
I guess you write something like this on Piggy’s SQL:
select rank, count(*) nUsers from UserData u where (select sum(merit)from MeritData m where m.ToID = u.UserId)=0 group by Rank
or select rank, count(*) nUsers from UserData u where not exists (select 1 from MeritData m where m.ToID = u.UserId) group by rank [..]
I understand your concerns but I believe my queries are correct. I'm using a more complicated approach, research SQL JOINS. It should be easy to check though, if you find any user listed in the OP that has received merit prior to Sept 28th (latest merit data date) then I'm wrong ![Smiley](https://bitcointalk.org/Smileys/default/smiley.gif) Regarding the queries you listed there, I'm sorry to say they are wrong. The first issue I see, is that you're trying to sum() something which does not exist (merit received for these users). You cannot know who got an initial amount of sMerit (less of all how much on an individual level), since the formula depends on their activity during the year previous to sMerit System kick-off, and you cannot know this since there is no available full DB snapshot (not just merited) dating one year before and on the date of the merit system kick-off.
Yes, that's true you don't have that info but you need to see it in a different way. We don't have any records of the initial merit that was airdropped but we do have the ranks of the users already so, that means they received airdropped merit (since they already have a higher rank) and we don't care how much they received either. Also, we need to keep into account that they didn't earn any merit and still have a higher rank. Let me know if you have any questions.
Just wanted to add that Piggy's tool is really nice but I could create far more complex data analysis queries if I had more data for the user table like activity, post count, latest date active, registered date etc. I hope he will add them soon but I know the limitation here is the size of the DB that is stored for free on github .
|
|
|
|
cryptovigi
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 01, 2018, 10:01:21 PM |
|
Man you are great!!! As I see you are really fan of stats!!! Anyway great work and thanks for taking my challenge... I find this results quite interesting... I'd like to play myself with such database... Few days ago i fonud only Bitcointalk Merit Dashboard by DdmrDdmr but the problem was i could download data to make some analysis on my own only in pdf format ;-( (which sucks for such purposes). Today I read here about Piggy's SQL https://albertoit.github.io/Merit-Explorer-SQL/ - I understand that this is the source of your analysys?
|
|
|
|
Quickseller
Copper Member
Legendary
Offline
Activity: 2968
Merit: 2370
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 01, 2018, 11:49:02 PM Last edit: October 02, 2018, 12:01:10 AM by Quickseller |
|
I think your list might be incomplete. See https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=357263 a hero user who has not received any merit but is not on the list. I suspect the number is far greater than what you say. If memory serves me correctly, well under 1% of all active accounts have received at least one merit as of a month or two ago.
|
|
|
|
TeQuiero
Member
![*](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/star.gif)
Offline
Activity: 120
Merit: 38
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 02, 2018, 04:16:39 AM Last edit: October 02, 2018, 05:35:18 AM by TeQuiero |
|
|
|
|
|
mu_enrico
Copper Member
Legendary
Offline
Activity: 2436
Merit: 2206
Slots Enthusiast & Expert
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 02, 2018, 05:04:58 AM |
|
You know what is more interesting? Demoting them back to newbie ![Grin](https://bitcointalk.org/Smileys/default/grin.gif)
|
| │ | ███████████████████████ ███████████████████████ ███████████████████████ ███████████████████████ ███▀▀▀█████████████████ ███▄▄▄█████████████████ ███████████████████████ ███████████████████████ ███████████████████████ █████████████████████ ███████████████████ ███████████████ ████████████████████████ | ███████████████████████████ ███████████████████████████ ███████████████████████████ █████████▀▀██▀██▀▀█████████ █████████████▄█████████████ ████████▄█████████▄████████ █████████████▄█████████████ █████████████▄█▄███████████ ██████████▀▀█████████████ ██████████▀█▀██████████ ▀███████████████████▀ ▀███████████████▀ █████████████████████████ | | | O F F I C I A L P A R T N E R S ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ ASTON VILLA FC BURNLEY FC | | | BK8? | | | . ..PLAY NOW.. |
|
|
|
DdmrDdmr
Legendary
Offline
Activity: 2422
Merit: 10978
There are lies, damned lies and statistics. MTwain
|
<…>I understand your concerns but I believe my queries are correct. I'm using a more complicated approach, research SQL JOINS.<...>
Maybe I didn’t explain my point clear enough. Let’s put it this way: What your OP wants to list: “Ranked Members - Member and above who was given merit airdrop (while introducing merit system) according to their ranks and didn't earn even one "by themself" this one maybe interesting!!!” What you are really listing: Members in the UserData table, that have not earned a single merit. Now the key is in understanding what is in the UserData table: I use a very similar table as @Piggy’s, with exactly the same number of records: 29.039.Those 29.039 people in the table are those involved in a sMerit TX at any point in history. That is, those that have either sent sMerit, receives sMerit, or both. Any user that has never sent nor received sMerit is not in the UserData table, which is likely the majority of cases that you are looking for. So my point is that you are listing a different set of users to the intended objective (a subset really). Note: There’s nothing wrong with Piggy’s database (it's rather similar to mine). It’s a good starting point for people that want to query and not download data themselves, buy we need to understand exactly what the tables hold. It is not a SQL issue, but a comprehension on the data in the DB.
|
|
|
|
vlad230 (OP)
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 02, 2018, 07:38:41 AM |
|
I think your list might be incomplete. See https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=357263 a hero user who has not received any merit but is not on the list. I suspect the number is far greater than what you say. If memory serves me correctly, well under 1% of all active accounts have received at least one merit as of a month or two ago. Yeah, please refer to the previous posts. I have checked the UserData table, as DdmrDdmr said, it has only 29039 records which is a lot less that the current 2 mil members. @Piggy, any chance we could have a more detailed UserData table to be able to extract more information? I can also help with this task. So, indeed, a lot of users are missing from the DB and this could only reflect a small portion of the users. I have updated the disclaimer. Man you are great!!! As I see you are really fan of stats!!! Anyway great work and thanks for taking my challenge... I find this results quite interesting... I'd like to play myself with such database... Few days ago i fonud only Bitcointalk Merit Dashboard by DdmrDdmr but the problem was i could download data to make some analysis on my own only in pdf format ;-( (which sucks for such purposes). Today I read here about Piggy's SQL https://albertoit.github.io/Merit-Explorer-SQL/ - I understand that this is the source of your analysys? Thanks a lot! Yes, that's where I'm getting the stats from. What you are really listing: Members in the UserData table, that have not earned a single merit. Now the key is in understanding what is in the UserData table:
I use a very similar table as @Piggy’s, with exactly the same number of records: 29.039.Those 29.039 people in the table are those involved in a sMerit TX at any point in history. That is, those that have either sent sMerit, receives sMerit, or both. Any user that has never sent nor received sMerit is not in the UserData table, which is likely the majority of cases that you are looking for. So my point is that you are listing a different set of users to the intended objective (a subset really).
Note: There’s nothing wrong with Piggy’s database (it's rather similar to mine). It’s a good starting point for people that want to query and not download data themselves, buy we need to understand exactly what the tables hold. It is not a SQL issue, but a comprehension on the data in the DB.
Ok, I understand what you're saying now and yes, you are correct. The SQL is correct but the DB is not listing every user, I wasn't aware of this. Anyways, even if this is a subset of the data here, we still have an idea on what is going on. You know what is more interesting? Demoting them back to newbie ![Grin](https://bitcointalk.org/Smileys/default/grin.gif) I wouldn't go that far... They hanged on here for years and raised the activity. That has to be worth something.
|
|
|
|
LoyceV
Legendary
Offline
Activity: 3416
Merit: 17268
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 02, 2018, 08:07:53 AM |
|
I use a very similar table as @Piggy’s, with exactly the same number of records: 29.039.Those 29.039 people in the table are those involved in a sMerit TX at any point in history. That is, those that have either sent sMerit, receives sMerit, or both. This makes sense. It also means my initial assumption that I expected much higher numbers was correct. I could quite easily produce a complete list of all higher ranked accounts with no Merit, especially since the number of accounts involved will never go up again, but I don't really want to download 2.5 million profiles just for this. It doesn't feel right to download 120 GB from the forum for something that isn't really important. Maybe @Vod can provide a list of all user ranks since the Merit system, it would be easy to cross-reference this list with the list of merit receivers.
|
|
|
|
Veleor
Legendary
Offline
Activity: 1484
Merit: 1654
Rêlêå§ê ¥ðµr MïñÐ
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 02, 2018, 11:49:07 AM |
|
4. Who are the Legendary users that have not earned any merit?UserName Rank 10000usdperbtc Legendary 2double0 Legendary 50cent_rapper Legendary 5ick3uffalo Legendary 7788bitcoin Legendary A L I E N Legendary AcoinL.L.C Legendary Akka Legendary Amel Legendary Anarchy101 Legendary AngusCanine Legendary Asatur Legendary BCEmporium Legendary Bimmerhead Legendary BitCoinNutJob Legendary BitNow Legendary BitcoinEXpress Legendary Boussac Legendary CrackedLogic Legendary DGulari Legendary Dewi Aries Legendary Dogedigital Legendary Dotto Legendary Dux2K Legendary Emerge Legendary FlensGold Legendary Geenstijl Legendary GhostPlayer Legendary Gianluca95 Legendary Gizfreak Legendary Googlulinks Legendary GreatOrchid Legendary Griffith Legendary HappyS Legendary Hyperjacked Legendary IBGigglin Legendary IMZ Legendary Jasad Legendary Jayjay04 Legendary Kepasa Legendary Kupsi Legendary Kushedout Legendary LastClingon Legendary Lebubar Legendary MaRSe Legendary Matt9301 Legendary Mervyn_Pumpkinhead Legendary MickGhee Legendary Micky25 Legendary MinermanNC Legendary Monnt Legendary MonsterV Legendary MsCollec Legendary Nahl Legendary ONLYfree Legendary Paraka Legendary Patel Legendary Pipesnake Legendary Prelude Legendary Republikcoin.com Legendary RoooooR Legendary Shkembe Legendary SmartIphone Legendary Snail2 Legendary Southpaw0 Legendary Strongkored Legendary SwingFirst Legendary Tauja Legendary Taxidermista Legendary TheKoziTwo Legendary Tony116 Legendary Tyke Legendary Undermood Legendary Winner Legendary Wusolini Legendary YarkoL Legendary Zadicar Legendary Zicadis Legendary Zich Legendary Zombie123 Legendary ZyTReX Legendary ahmedjadoon Legendary aikklond Legendary aistto Legendary aleandromagno Legendary andulolika Legendary anirgu Legendary anref Legendary anticlimax Legendary bassdude Legendary benthach Legendary bitcon Legendary bithalo Legendary bitmaster1x Legendary bittaitaliana Legendary bitwho Legendary bms2013 Legendary boestin Legendary brian_nguyen Legendary bspus Legendary buygazprom Legendary cagrund Legendary chryspano Legendary corather Legendary crunck Legendary dadingsda Legendary danherbias07 Legendary dave111223 Legendary david1365 Legendary dbt1033 Legendary deblue Legendary dimox Legendary dinda22 Legendary djnocide Legendary dload.1 Legendary dnaleor Legendary dopecoindude Legendary dunfida Legendary e1ghtSpace Legendary edmundduke Legendary enhu Legendary eroxors Legendary escalicha Legendary etoque Legendary farl4web Legendary flower1024 Legendary frankenmint Legendary gnargnar Legendary goxed Legendary grandFX Legendary guigui371 Legendary hahay Legendary hazarun Legendary hdd3go Legendary helloge Legendary hiddensphinx Legendary hurricandave Legendary ifightformerkel Legendary innocent93 Legendary ivan1975 Legendary joele Legendary johny08 Legendary joksim299 Legendary keithers Legendary keyscore44 Legendary killerjoegreece Legendary klf Legendary kondiomir Legendary koshgel Legendary kronkodil Legendary lionheart78 Legendary liteon Legendary logocreator Legendary lolxxxx Legendary lottery248 Legendary louiseth1 Legendary lowbander80 Legendary makishart Legendary malekbaba Legendary mamamae Legendary mastertrader777 Legendary matveevka Legendary maxll Legendary maza5 Legendary mettalmag Legendary michietn94 Legendary moppang Legendary moxl Legendary nekochan05 Legendary neolinkhati Legendary nizamcc Legendary numismatist Legendary ny2cafuse Legendary oli123123 Legendary pandacoin Legendary pbleak Legendary pickupcoin Legendary piebeyb Legendary polynesia Legendary qwed Legendary rdnkjdi Legendary reb0rn21 Legendary redjedievolution Legendary roadbits Legendary rodrigobitcoin Legendary s1ng Legendary sana54210 Legendary sardokan Legendary schnötzel Legendary serje Legendary server Legendary shaklov Legendary silverbox Legendary snipsnoop Legendary splawik21 Legendary srgkrgkj Legendary stahanovec Legendary supermoney Legendary sureshnsnet Legendary tair85 Legendary takagari Legendary tarmi Legendary the_poet Legendary thefunkybits Legendary tiggytomb Legendary tiozes Legendary tobeaj2mer01 Legendary toptek Legendary uki Legendary unamis76 Legendary usao Legendary varanvaran Legendary viboracecata Legendary vladimirushev Legendary vokain Legendary wachtwoord Legendary wadili89 Legendary winter Legendary wonko86 Legendary wpalczynski Legendary wuqing78 Legendary xsentus Legendary yslyung Legendary zork Legendary
Three legendaries from the list have been banned: [BPIP] 10000usdperbtc[BPIP] chryspano[BPIP] hdd3go
|
|
|
|
manfredmann
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 02, 2018, 02:35:04 PM |
|
I was really inspired by your post especially in technical aspects. If you may I would like to ask you on how did you extract the data for this forum? Is it really alright for the admin if one will going to do like this? I am not against this type of post taking some technical aspects of the forum in fact I was curios on one how to extract data for this forum? Is the forum not secured and could be access its system or breaching the system?
|
|
|
|
vlad230 (OP)
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 02, 2018, 06:26:11 PM |
|
I was really inspired by your post especially in technical aspects. If you may I would like to ask you on how did you extract the data for this forum? Is it really alright for the admin if one will going to do like this? I am not against this type of post taking some technical aspects of the forum in fact I was curios on one how to extract data for this forum? Is the forum not secured and could be access its system or breaching the system?
There is a public data dump which was published (it gets refreshed every Friday). Piggy took it and created a MySQL DB from it & a basic UI to query it here: https://albertoit.github.io/Merit-Explorer-SQL/If you're not familiar with SQL you can find a lot about it online. It's the most common DB querying language available right now. A good place to start would be: https://www.w3schools.com/sql/
|
|
|
|
vphasitha01
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 02, 2018, 06:33:03 PM |
|
You know what is more interesting? Demoting them back to newbie ![Grin](https://bitcointalk.org/Smileys/default/grin.gif) I wouldn't go that far... They hanged on here for years and raised the activity. That has to be worth something. I don't agree with both of you because just hanging on here but not giving anything to other members for years wouldn't mean anything at all to me. Demoting them back to the newbies by just simply disregarding the activity they achieved through their career is not an option too. What I think is the answer is laying between above two options. How about if we implement a system for trigger( having opptunity to award merits)the airdrop merits only when a user earned some predefined merits. By that way we can reduse most of the merit abuse cases where users tends to giving away merits for their alt accounts. Any user that has never sent nor received sMerit is not in the UserData table, which is likely the majority of cases that you are looking for. So my point is that you are listing a different set of users to the intended objective (a subset really). I don't know why people are so worrying and anylizing about the never sent portion since it's nothing to do with the number of users ranked Sr. Members & up that have not earned any merit. Why we just couldn't consider the received sMerits part only because I have seen that some members still didn't shared their intial airdrop merits at least once.
|
|
|
|
cryptovigi
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
October 04, 2018, 12:17:36 AM Last edit: October 10, 2018, 05:03:47 PM by cryptovigi Merited by DdmrDdmr (2), taikuri13 (1), vlad230 (1) |
|
1. How many Sr. Member & up users exist that have not earned any merit?1078 Sr. Members 476 Hero Members 224 Legendary Members
There are 1778 users ranked Sr. Member & up that have not earned any merit, they just got "airdropped" merit from when the merit system was implemented. ... As you know I was the one who challenged vlad230 to make this analysis. Unfortunately I’ve read that this results due to a limited only data source (only given and received merits) its results may be far from the reality. I was really interested in the results, so I was looking for a way to make this analysis in a more appropriate way. I didn’t find a database which contains all users who was airdropped a merit, I didn’t find also a database with current number of users and their ranks and the number of merits held…. But I found some further threads by mazdafunsun who scraped first 2 million users of Bitcointalk in July this year https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=4901670.0;all and decided to take take this numbers to make some comparison…. I took this number than checked how many users has ranked up since July. To check it I took all users who has received any merit from https://albertoit.github.io/Merit-Explorer-SQL/ than checked current merit number on the bitcointalk.com site. After deduction I got the number of airdropped merit to each user (who have received at least one merit). Then I checked once again on merit explorer number of merit given till July. Thanks to that I was able to correct mazdafunsun’s result with rank promotions by merit since July (there still be some inaccuracy because probably some users has been promoted since July by activity, unfortunately I have no way to check it...) After comparing these results with given merit in merit explorer I’ve received such set of data: Rank | number of users | number of users received at least 1 merit
| number of users with who didn’t earn any merit
| Member | 27 918 | 4 744 (17%) | 23 174 (83%) | Full Member | 18 181 | 3 173 (17,45%) | 15 008 (82,55%) | Sr. Member | 9 016 | 1 818 (20,16%) | 7 198 (79,84%) | Hero Member | 4 143 | 1 105 (26,67%) | 3 038 (73,33%) | Legendary | 2 145 | 1 133 (52,82%) | 1 012 (47,18%) |
As you can see, my results differ significantly from vlad230's and the numbers are few times bigger. @vlad230: I think that case you should update numbers or description in your opening post...
It looks like there are really plenty of high ranked users who hasn't earn even one merit yet. Probably some of them are "dead souls" - users who aren't active for many month or even years, but for sure there are as well a lot of "ranked" users who simply didn't deserved any merit yet. This number decreases (percentage) with the increase of rhe rank, but its level in all groups (maybe exept Legendary) remains high. So guys look at these numbers and be little more lenient for newbies and jr. members as you see the rank not always it determines their value...
|
|
|
|
dumedoiiph
Member
![*](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/star.gif)
Offline
Activity: 97
Merit: 12
|
![](https://bitcointalk.org/Themes/custom1/images/post/xx.gif) |
November 05, 2018, 03:34:04 AM |
|
The results of merit data analyis made by @cryptovigi, shown that there are un-significant difference between lower- and higher-ranked users in the forum in terms of ability to earn at least one merit via their really construtive stuffs. Only Ledgendary rank is different from other ranks. It means there are so many shitty Senior and Hero users around the forum. They have been unable to earn at least 1 merit point almost 10 months after the day merit system and new rank requirements implemented.
|
|
|
|
|