-
So basically we could be witnessing a battle between lobbyist, some in favor of Kalshi and Polymarket to compete within the ecosystem of sportbetting and other lobbyist which got hired by FIAT and traditional betting platforms, because their market dominance is getting put on testing because of the popularity of Kalshi and Polymarket.
I don't know what you think about all this scenario, but I think there is a very high chance those FIAT bookies will succeed in convincing those lawmakers to exclude polymarket and Kalshi, they have more time in the market, they are more regulated and they alledgelly have more money than these new competitors.
It would be a serious strike against them.
This is a good question and at first glance I thought you are probably correct that FIAT bookies have more leverage and will push lawmakers towards banning or strictly limiting competing platforms like Polymarket and Kalshi, but then it came to my mind again that it is not just the ordinary guys using those prediction markets. Around all those major events in the last few months, like the Iran war and other things that happened, analyses have shown that strange things are going on on those prediction market platforms. Unusually high amounts were placed on outcomes that nobody except for insders could have known about.
I believe this tells us that powerful people like politicians or businessmen or whoever else with influence in the world, actually have an incentive to have these platforms up and running. The US administration knows no limits right now and you probably about Trump's plans to sell early "
access to posts from influential Truth Social accounts, such as President Donald Trump’s, whose posts often move global markets."
Further, there were those reports about Polymarket accounts making millions with information that had not yet been public back then as I mentioned above. As long as these platforms offer advantages for those with early access to crucial information, I don't think they will ever be shut down or regulated to a point where continuations is not sustainable.
Regardless of how the fight between prediction market platforms and FIAT bookies ends, I am curious to see how courts will decide. Kalshi and Polymarket argue that their products are financial contracts whereas the bookmakers say that it is no different from sports bets. I can see both sides having good points here, but I believe that Kalshi and Polymarket will have to accept some losses at court along the way because right now under the regulation of the CFTC, they benefit from some advantages and the government is probably mostly interested in taxes, and right now, if I understand it correctly, Kalshi and Polymarket have tax advantages because of how they have positioned themselves thus far. In other words, the government has a strong incentive to crack down on them but only to the point until where they can maximize tax income.