[ANN][BMR] Bitmonero - a new coin based on CryptoNote technology - LAUNCHED

[thankful_for_today]

fix coming soon, it looks like get_block_reward doesn't work as intended.

i will pm thankful_for_today with some c code to disable adaptive block sizing and set blocksize limits to those similar in bitcoin, then we should be back on track with a hardfork i hope.

Hello!

It's allright
I have a fix and I will deploy it now.
Hardfork is not required. The problem is in mining code not in protocol rules.

10 minutes, please

cool, sounds good

The problem is in block generation code. In one of last updates in Bytecoin there was a bug introduced: it calculates extra-size penalty the wrong way. As a result we see that a mined block isn't accepted by the network. I will consume the big transaction now into correct block. As soon as network accepts this block I will release new mining code to git.

Here is the tx that caused the problem:

id: <f1d8e3391161e4e98566c746d605f97cf432cbd19c83d8b0444e02748f54117e>
blob_size: 20534

[1714896072]

1714896072

[1714896072]

1714896072

[1714896072]

1714896072

[1714896072]

1714896072

[1714896072]

1714896072

[1714896072]

1714896072

[thankful_for_today]

I'm seeing a ton of red in bitmonerod - presumably this is the issue displaying itself.

Do I need to re-download the blockchain? Download a new wallet  or bitmonerod? Just leave it mining and it will fix itself?

Thanks.

It's a soft fork so prior blocks should be OK, just need to recompile

Yes. No actions from node operators is needed just now. As soon a fix will be pushed to repo you need to replace old binaries to new ones. But in any way this will not be an urgent issue. The problem now is that nobody can include that transaction in block As soon as it will be accepted network will continue normal operations.

[tacotime]

The problem is in block generation code. In one of last updates in Bytecoin there was a bug introduced: it calculates extra-size penalty the wrong way. As a result we see that a mined block isn't accepted by the network. I will consume the big transaction now into correct block. As soon as network accepts this block I will release new mining code to git.

Here is the tx that caused the problem:

id: <f1d8e3391161e4e98566c746d605f97cf432cbd19c83d8b0444e02748f54117e>
blob_size: 20534

Funnily this is my tx

Hope to see the commit soon!

edit: looks like your patch worked, as the tx now exists in the main chain.

[eizh]

The problem is in block generation code. In one of last updates in Bytecoin there was a bug introduced: it calculates extra-size penalty the wrong way. As a result we see that a mined block isn't accepted by the network. I will consume the big transaction now into correct block. As soon as network accepts this block I will release new mining code to git.

Here is the tx that caused the problem:

id: <f1d8e3391161e4e98566c746d605f97cf432cbd19c83d8b0444e02748f54117e>
blob_size: 20534

Funnily this is my tx

Hope to see the commit soon!

First notable event in the history of BMR.

[thankful_for_today]

Looks like it's fixed now. Big tx gone into blockchain. You can see blocks in the network at normal speed.

1. Sorry for inconvenience.

2. I'll post about git changes soon.

[thankful_for_today]

The problem is in block generation code. In one of last updates in Bytecoin there was a bug introduced: it calculates extra-size penalty the wrong way. As a result we see that a mined block isn't accepted by the network. I will consume the big transaction now into correct block. As soon as network accepts this block I will release new mining code to git.

Here is the tx that caused the problem:

id: <f1d8e3391161e4e98566c746d605f97cf432cbd19c83d8b0444e02748f54117e>
blob_size: 20534

Funnily this is my tx

Hope to see the commit soon!

edit: looks like your patch worked, as the tx now exists in the main chain.

Thank you for this problem. This is the way software becomes better.

[eizh]

It's up on git. Can someone compile the Windows binary?

[x0rcist]

The problem is in block generation code. In one of last updates in Bytecoin there was a bug introduced: it calculates extra-size penalty the wrong way. As a result we see that a mined block isn't accepted by the network. I will consume the big transaction now into correct block. As soon as network accepts this block I will release new mining code to git.

Here is the tx that caused the problem:

id: <f1d8e3391161e4e98566c746d605f97cf432cbd19c83d8b0444e02748f54117e>
blob_size: 20534

Funnily this is my tx

Hope to see the commit soon!

edit: looks like your patch worked, as the tx now exists in the main chain.

Thank you for this problem. This is the way software becomes better.

Thank you for fixing it. But also, come join us on freenode.
We where just discussing this tx bug before you got back

[eizh]

The problem is in block generation code. In one of last updates in Bytecoin there was a bug introduced: it calculates extra-size penalty the wrong way. As a result we see that a mined block isn't accepted by the network. I will consume the big transaction now into correct block. As soon as network accepts this block I will release new mining code to git.

Here is the tx that caused the problem:

id: <f1d8e3391161e4e98566c746d605f97cf432cbd19c83d8b0444e02748f54117e>
blob_size: 20534

Does BCN still possess this issue?

[thankful_for_today]

Looks like it's fixed now. Big tx gone into blockchain. You can see blocks in the network at normal speed.

1. Sorry for inconvenience.

2. I'll post about git changes soon.

Git updated. BUT: I don't recomment to update all nodes now due to following reasons:

- this patch isn't tested properly (=> can cause some other unknown problems)
- network operates normally without this patch (it doesn't change any protocol logic)

Let's wait 1-2 days before updating all nodes. Old code works the right way in most cases except transactions bigger than 20Kb.
In case such big (>20Kb) transaction will appear again it will be included by patched nodes and this will not influence network very much.

[thankful_for_today]

It's up on git. Can someone compile the Windows binary?

Please see my comments below: patch wasn't tested properly. It's better to stay 1-2 days with some node not patched. This will help in case of problems with this patch.

The absense of this patch doesn't influence miner's income in most cases.

[sussex]

It's up on git. Can someone compile the Windows binary?

Please see my comments below: patch wasn't tested properly. It's better to stay 1-2 days with some node not patched. This will help in case of problems with this patch.

The absense of this patch doesn't influence miner's income in most cases.

Sorry, I'm confused, can we continue mining with the wallet and bitmonerod from yesterday?

[eizh]

It's up on git. Can someone compile the Windows binary?

Please see my comments below: patch wasn't tested properly. It's better to stay 1-2 days with some node not patched. This will help in case of problems with this patch.

The absense of this patch doesn't influence miner's income in most cases.

Sorry, I'm confused, can we continue mining with the wallet and bitmonerod from yesterday?

The tx that was causing the problem has been accepted into a block, so yes you can keep using yesterday's version.

[smooth]

It's up on git. Can someone compile the Windows binary?

Please see my comments below: patch wasn't tested properly. It's better to stay 1-2 days with some node not patched. This will help in case of problems with this patch.

The absense of this patch doesn't influence miner's income in most cases.

Sorry, I'm confused, can we continue mining with the wallet and bitmonerod from yesterday?

Yes, you can.

The problem with the block chain being stalled was caused by no one having the patch. As long as some nodes have the patch, everyone else can continue using the old code.

[thankful_for_today]

The problem is in block generation code. In one of last updates in Bytecoin there was a bug introduced: it calculates extra-size penalty the wrong way. As a result we see that a mined block isn't accepted by the network. I will consume the big transaction now into correct block. As soon as network accepts this block I will release new mining code to git.

Here is the tx that caused the problem:

id: <f1d8e3391161e4e98566c746d605f97cf432cbd19c83d8b0444e02748f54117e>
blob_size: 20534

Does BCN still possess this issue?

Probably yes, but it doesn't influences network operations as much as in BMR. Why? I suppose that there is a number of BCN nodes using old or very old mining code. This bug has been introduced a week or two ago and BMR has been started from last snapshoot of BCN code and we met this problem.

This way there is no real problem with BCN even with a bug in last commits. But I've sent them an e-mail.

[the_darkness]

The problem is in block generation code. In one of last updates in Bytecoin there was a bug introduced: it calculates extra-size penalty the wrong way. As a result we see that a mined block isn't accepted by the network. I will consume the big transaction now into correct block. As soon as network accepts this block I will release new mining code to git.

Here is the tx that caused the problem:

id: <f1d8e3391161e4e98566c746d605f97cf432cbd19c83d8b0444e02748f54117e>
blob_size: 20534

Does BCN still possess this issue?

Probably yes, but it doesn't influences network operations as much as in BMR. Why? I suppose that there is a number of BCN nodes using old or very old mining code. This bug has been introduced a week or two ago and BMR has been started from last snapshoot of BCN code and we met this problem.

This way there is no real problem with BCN even with a bug in last commits. But I've sent them an e-mail.

Just wanted to say good job on a quick recovery and sorting out what sounds like a tricky problem.

[eizh]

You changed a lot of the code. What are the consequences? Previously the tx's were sorted more thoroughly.

[thankful_for_today]

It's up on git. Can someone compile the Windows binary?

Please see my comments below: patch wasn't tested properly. It's better to stay 1-2 days with some node not patched. This will help in case of problems with this patch.

The absense of this patch doesn't influence miner's income in most cases.

Sorry, I'm confused, can we continue mining with the wallet and bitmonerod from yesterday?

Yes, you can.

The problem with the block chain being stalled was caused by no one having the patch. As long as some nodes have the patch, everyone else can continue using the old code.

I confirm this is correct.

[thankful_for_today]

You changed a lot of the code. What are the consequences? Previously the tx's were sorted more thoroughly.

2 changed files with 14 additions and 47 deletions. I hope that nothing bad can happen. But we have to be careful

[sussex]

OK, prolly nothing, but I now have a sea of red complaining about found future peerlist all for the same IP..... it has complained about this six times in the last ten minutes.

On the upside, I found a block !!!!