The justification behind the 2 billion coins is since PoB involves the destruction of coins, making them unusable again, if a relatively small limit is set, the coins could get exhausted and then people would not want to burn them anymore, thus making the entire PoB useless.
I'm not quite sure I understand your reasoning. I think maybe you are not explaining the incentive very well.
However I do appreciate this idea for reducing reliance on Proof of Work.
So people must first mine coins via PoW to obtain coins. Then these coins can be burned via PoB to obtain more coins than if they were just mining through PoW. If there comes a time when they would get less coins from Proof of Burn than they spent burning them,
obviously they should stop burning them. This has nothing to do with the max amount of coins. It would be exactly the same scenario if there were 200,000 coins rather than 2,000,000,000.
Regardless of how many max coins you have, there will come a time when you run out of PoW coins or when the multiplier will require so many PoW coins to be burned that it becomes uneconomical to burn PoW coins for PoB coins.
Also, there are certain vague points in your whitepaper that do not properly explain the exact functions of the system.
You make no mention of the specific formula that dictates how many PoW coins must be burnt to mine a PoB block.
I understand this changes over time in a linear fashion but some indication of the starting point would be nice.
Also, can we get a use-case example for the reduction formula?
Burn hashes are calculated by multiplying a multiplier to an internal hash.
The multiplier is also inversely proportional to the amount of coins burned. The multiplier is what
causes burnt coins to “decay”.
this is vague.Lets say 20,000 coins have been burned and then I burn 50 coins.
What is the formula for the multiplier? 0.0025 x internal hash?
Could you please provide a more in-depth example scenario?
As well, what is the benefit of burning big or small amounts of PoW coins? if the system is paced (i.e. you can only burn a PoB block every 3 minutes) wouldn't it make more sense to burn small amounts at a time? What is the relationship between number of coins burned and reward or reward schedule?
These are specifics that could greatly impact the success of such a system and so it would be beneficial to explain in more detail the exact functions.