Bitcoinary.com - The new smart way to buy and sell Bitcoins.

[thezerg]

Seems to be an issue "entering into trade".  There's basically an issue around that whole thing which is that in one trade I managed to do the whole thing over PM and never got the chance to "enter into a trade" and therefore leave a review (I assume).

In the other txn I get a button but when I click through the "yes I agree" screen I get this 404:

The page you were looking for doesn't exist.

You may have mistyped the address or the page may have moved.


Also a way to remove trades would be nice! :-)  But anyway, great site!

[HostFat]

If you add the tag system correctly ( as I'm suggesting ), it doesn't matter which currency is on postepay or any others ( like dwolla )
No one is going to add "postepay" with "usd" currency.
It will works everytime, without any other action by you/developer.
Users will add by themself their own-country money-services.

[Bimmerhead]

The website looks terrific, and the concept is excellent as well, but it won't let me register.

Says "Something went wrong" after hitting Create an Account.

[giszmo]

The website looks terrific, and the concept is excellent as well, but it won't let me register.

Says "Something went wrong" after hitting Create an Account.

Same here. That's no fun to try to register Little Bobby Tables when the service doesn't work at all

[giszmo]

Ok now I linked my diverse accounts but how do I register my other 4 prepaid phones and my other 4 email addresses to add extra trust? I also would like to add my 150 facebook accounts that I bought cheap last year and the twitter accounts. Actually I happen to have access to 6.5 million linkedin accounts I'd like to add

Ok, seriously, these trust thingies are nice and well integrated but I saw I was logged in with my January-2012 twitter account while I have also a 2009(?) account. How can I change it.
Also why not link the facebook account openly when you already use the facebook hosted profile pic that via tineye would lead to the facebook account even if self-hosted without the facebook-id plain open in the image source?

Should I be thankful you did not disclose my twitter and email like you disclosed my facebook id or is disclosing these just not yet implemented?

Ok, great, now that I tested you and found you don't treat my privacy with the due respect, I would like to delete my facebook connection and as this does not work I would like to delete my account. Great, even that does not work. Maybe there is some undocumented way to do that? Hmm …

I want a service where I can disclose a set of information only to my direct trading partners upon request but your site discloses them to even google crawlers.

[Bitcoin Oz]

Ok now I linked my diverse accounts but how do I register my other 4 prepaid phones and my other 4 email addresses to add extra trust? I also would like to add my 150 facebook accounts that I bought cheap last year and the twitter accounts. Actually I happen to have access to 6.5 million linkedin accounts I'd like to add

Ok, seriously, these trust thingies are nice and well integrated but I saw I was logged in with my January-2012 twitter account while I have also a 2009(?) account. How can I change it.
Also why not link the facebook account openly when you already use the facebook hosted profile pic that via tineye would lead to the facebook account even if self-hosted without the facebook-id plain open in the image source?

Should I be thankful you did not disclose my twitter and email like you disclosed my facebook id or is disclosing these just not yet implemented?

Ok, great, now that I tested you and found you don't treat my privacy with the due respect, I would like to delete my facebook connection and as this does not work I would like to delete my account. Great, even that does not work. Maybe there is some undocumented way to do that? Hmm …

I want a service where I can disclose a set of information only to my direct trading partners upon request but your site discloses them to even google crawlers.

I didnt want everyone having my facebook details either so I deleted the bitcoinary app untill I can choose to only share it with the people I am trading with

[dogisland]

how does the site make $?  Is there a fee?

I've not implemented the fees yet. Current thinking is 0.5 - 1% paid by the market maker.

At the moment it's free while I iron out any issues and add the features people are already asking for.

Is 1% a promised max? If your fees exceed 1% I would not bother registering. Actually I just registered but don't get my activation mail.

edit: thinking of it, as long as you don't handle money yourself, I don't see why you should take such a high cut at all. 1% capped at 1$ would seam more reasonable to me. Also I don't see how you would enforce any fees if the deals happen person to person for cash.

I've got a make a living, so 1% capped at $1 would be great if volumes are huge. I don't see any need to go over 1%.

[giszmo]

I didnt want everyone having my facebook details either so I deleted the bitcoinary app untill I can choose to only share it with the people I am trading with

I think I remember I granted access, but at https://www.facebook.com/bookmarks/apps it is not listed!? Do I have to block it? What's its name?

[Bitcoin Oz]

I didnt want everyone having my facebook details either so I deleted the bitcoinary app untill I can choose to only share it with the people I am trading with

I think I remember I granted access, but at https://www.facebook.com/bookmarks/apps it is not listed!? Do I have to block it? What's its name?

In your "account settings" there should be  a link to  "applications" and you can see which ones have access.

[hazek]

Also I don't see how you would enforce any fees if the deals happen person to person for cash.

Best strategy would be to charge the market maker for the ability to receive a rating. So say a market maker sells something but wants +rep for his account then he needs to pay a small fee to be able to receive +rep, if he doesn't pay, he can still make a trade, he just can't increase his reputation.

[dogisland]

I want a service where I can disclose a set of information only to my direct trading partners upon request but your site discloses them to even google crawlers.

I don't know why I didn't do it like that, I'll be changing it over to make it more private in the next few days. Thanks.

[dogisland]

Also I don't see how you would enforce any fees if the deals happen person to person for cash.

Best strategy would be to charge the market maker for the ability to receive a rating. So say a market maker sells something but wants +rep for his account then he needs to pay a small fee to be able to receive +rep, if he doesn't pay, he can still make a trade, he just can't increase his reputation.

Also a great idea, that's how I'll implement fees. Thanks for this.

[istar]

Also I don't see how you would enforce any fees if the deals happen person to person for cash.

Best strategy would be to charge the market maker for the ability to receive a rating. So say a market maker sells something but wants +rep for his account then he needs to pay a small fee to be able to receive +rep, if he doesn't pay, he can still make a trade, he just can't increase his reputation.

Also a great idea, that's how I'll implement fees. Thanks for this.

Another way would be to not get access to the reviews unless you pay.
Thus you are taking a risc by not paying.
Its in both the seller and buyers interest to get access to this info.

[HostFat]

Anyway, you should still show the number of transactions.

Also, I can't close/cancel a trade.

[giszmo]

I didnt want everyone having my facebook details either so I deleted the bitcoinary app untill I can choose to only share it with the people I am trading with

I think I remember I granted access, but at https://www.facebook.com/bookmarks/apps it is not listed!? Do I have to block it? What's its name?

In your "account settings" there should be  a link to  "applications" and you can see which ones have access.

Deep link should work also: http://www.facebook.com/settings?tab=applications (although it seams bitcoinary nuked itself so I can't check if it works to remove the pic.)

[dooglus]

I tried signing up but didn't get very far.  Observations so far:

* "Send Money To Another Country ?" has a space before the question mark which bugs me.

* https://www.bitcoinary.com/en/users/sign_up selects the 2nd input field by default, "email".  Why not start at the top?

* After filling in the signup form and submitting it, all I got was "We're sorry, but something went wrong."  Would be nice if you told me what kind of a something.  Was my 32 character password too long for you?  I tried again with 'fred' and it gave me a properly formatted error page, with "is too short (minimum is 6 characters)".  I tried using shorter and shorter passwords, but even a 6 character password still gives me the same "something went wrong" screen.

[gilgil]

Great site with great potential!

I would love to:
1. Be able to edit / remove a trade that I have opened
2. Search for a buy / sell trade with a filter (minimum reputation of counter-party, payment currency, etc.) and get an order book (similar to Mt.Gox's) based on open orders that qualify.

I'm sure that people will be willing to donate for you to be able to polish up the site full-time, and be refunded (or not) by fee discount later when things get going.

Keep up the good work!

[giszmo]

I would love to:
1. Be able to edit / remove a trade that I have opened

Editing! is most important in most things that I can enter in this shitty site. Sorry to call it shitty. I see potential but you failed to advertise it as "hey i need alpha testers". Don't go public without warning your users like that. I copied the Note of another user and forgot to delete his mail and phone number from it. Now I'm stuck not being able to fix that, delete this trade, delete my account!?!? WTF? Even trading with him to make the trade disappear does not work for a bug.

edit: it's trade 47. please remove the contact stuff or the whole #47.

[tbcoin]

The website looks terrific, and the concept is excellent as well, but it won't let me register.

Says "Something went wrong" after hitting Create an Account.

Same here

[MadSweeney]

This is a good idea. I hope the signup page gets fixed soon.