[self-moderated] Report unmerited good posts to Merit Source

[cryptovigi]

This guy has a really good posting quality. He is one of the key members of the Polish community. Active everyday and everyday has something interresting to add. Just short of 16 merits to become a Senior Member.
...

Aha! Now I do realized how did I get my promotion so fast. @Tytanowy Janusz - it was very nice of you to think about me and put some of my posts here. @suchmoon - thanks for boosting me up (even disagreeing with my point of view  )

[1714933082]

1714933082

[1714933082]

1714933082

[The Cryptovator]

Re: Bitcoin is a scam based on language manipulation  (By stortz)
Description : Discussion about Bitcoin scam & manipulation
Category : Defensive.
Section : Bitcoin Discussion board.

[TheBeardedBaby]

Ran out of sMerit and I'm sure Sutters Mill deserves some.

Re: This users email address changed
Description : Gave good information regarding the email change notification duration.
Category : informative post
Section : Meta

[The Cryptovator]

Re: Bitcoin 2020 Halving  (By omone1)
Description :  Bitcoin Halving 2020
Category : Explanation.
Section : Speculation

[The Sceptical Chymist]

Ran out of sMerit and I'm sure Sutters Mill deserves some.

Gave him some merits.

Re: Bitcoin 2020 Halving  (By omone1)

Also gave this member some merits, and from what I could see his other posts weren't too bad either.  Not exceptional, but probably better than the average Jr. Member.  It's a very low bar, to be sure, but at least he puts in some effort and doesn't look like he's blatantly signature spamming.

[CryptopreneurBrainboss]

[Guide] Identify scam projects by hidden premined coin indicator via explorer
Description :  Topic says it all.
Category : Guide
Section : beginner and help


I haven't been actively reporting post since I have merits to merit them but this OP is very active and one of the users trying his best in the beginner and help board just like myself and few others. he lacks merits {8} to rank up to snr member. You can check his (started) post history

[wwzsocki]

We are struggling on Polish local forum because of the lack of merit sources and of course merits.

I want to ask merit sources to look a little closer to member @TytanowyJanusz because he is a key member of our local community and many of his post and some threads are not merited at all.

Few examples here but I encourage everyone to look deeper in the history of this member's posts because he frequently writes high-quality texts and there are a lot of them.

System kreacji pieniądza. Czy dotyczy to również bitcoina?
Description : Money creation system - is bitcoin creation resistant?
Category : Analisys
Section : Local - Polish

Why we want btc etf and bakkt?
Description : discussion about Bakkt and ETF's
Category : opinion, question
Section : Economics

Vechain - speculative buy - binance pump
Description : Vechain technical analysis
Category : Analysis
Section : Trading Discussion

[Konkus] Wytypuj cenę bitcoina lub rozbaw społeczność (edycja druga)
Description :  Predict the price of bitcoin or entertain the community (second edition)
Category : Contest
Section : Local - Polish

Here a few very good posts from @TytanowyJanusz:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5052605.msg49561059#msg49561059
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5094172.msg49965921#msg49965921
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5101623.msg49735130#msg49735130
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5104531.msg50041060#msg50041060
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5088602.msg49734568#msg49734568
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5082267.msg48556485#msg48556485
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5078841.msg48398347#msg48398347
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5094172.msg49480752#msg49480752

[1miau]

I'm out of sMerit, so feel free to drop here a few of them:

Some useful links for BBCODE Signature design etc.
Description: compilation of useful links for BBcode design
Category: compilation of useful links
Section: Beginners and Help

Re: MLM – a dangerous marketing strategy
Category: opinion
Section: Beginners and Help

Re: Be careful, Google knows more about you than you can imagine!
Category: technical answer
Section: Serious Discussion

[julius caesar]

Ano nga ba ang MACD?
Description : Implementation/Application of MACD
Category : guide, technical topic
Section : Local - Pilipinas

Ang Relative Strength Index (RSI)
Description : Implementation/Application of RSI
Category : guide, tecnhical topic
Section : Local - Pilipinas

[khaled0111]

The wallets which support lightning network
...

Copy pasted from here:
5 Popular Wallets to Experience Bitcoin Lighting Network

He deserves a ban not merits unless he can prove he is the same person who wrote the original article

Also I noticed that some members are reporting newly written posts, I don't know what LoyceVt hinks about that, but I suggest to give them more time and only report old posts.

[tranthidung]

Copy pasted from here:
5 Popular Wallets to Experience Bitcoin Lighting Network

He deserves a ban not merits unless he can prove he is the same person who wrote the original article

I checked the topic again, there are links to original articles at the bottom, but I don't remember that hours ago, there were links to the articles or not (maybe not, if I remembered well).
If links posted hours ago, it is fine and don't violate plagiarism.
So, if it is just copy and & paste with links to original articles, there is no reason to give merits to that topic.

[The Sceptical Chymist]

Re: Be careful, Google knows more about you than you can imagine!
Category: technical answer
Section: Serious Discussion

I gave out a few merits for the above topic, as it was the only recent one that isn't too technical for me to grasp what people are saying.  I have a hard time giving out merits when I can't confidently evaluate whether a post is true and of good quality.  This is why I tend not to merit stuff in the technical discussion sections, and unfortunately that's what most members are linking to in this thread.

Good to see this is still going on.  I'd love to see more activity, more links to good posts.  When my computer was busted for a couple of weeks, I kind of built up a stockpile of sMerits which I'm now trying to unload.

[LoyceV]

Copy pasted from here:
5 Popular Wallets to Experience Bitcoin Lighting Network

Thanks, I've deleted tranthidung's post and reported the plagiarism. (in case anyone has any doubts when reading this later on: tranthidung wasn't the one who plagiarized)

Also I noticed that some members are reporting newly written posts, I don't know what LoyceVt hinks about that, but I suggest to give them more time and only report old posts.

I'm okay with the way this topic is going, in general the suggestions are good, there aren't too many entries, so I see no reason to be more restrictive.

I checked the topic again, there are links to original articles at the bottom, but I don't remember that hours ago, there were links to the articles or not (maybe not, if I remembered well).

The links were in the source article too, he just copied everything. Don't let this discourage you from reporting more good posts here, even if someone earns Merit with plagiarism, he's just going to be twice as sad when he gets banned

[tranthidung]

Shamed about myself with bad report (that plagiarised) yesterday, so I tried my report today. 

Collection of comprehensive guides on identify and avoid scam projects
Description : Help newbies to stay away from scam projects by guides on most effectively investigation methods to find out scam projects.
Category : Beginners & help; Scam Finding Techniques.
Section : Beginners & help

Tools for managers to check quality of posts (both merited & unmerited posts)
Description : Maximimize work efficiency for campaign managers.
Category : Statistics & Tools.
Section : Meta

[LoyceV]

The wallets which support lightning network
...

Copy pasted from here:
5 Popular Wallets to Experience Bitcoin Lighting Network

My report was marked as bad. Maybe the Mod didn't see the links at the bottom are also copied.

[1miau]

Re: Be careful, Google knows more about you than you can imagine!
Category: technical answer
Section: Serious Discussion

I gave out a few merits for the above topic, as it was the only recent one that isn't too technical for me to grasp what people are saying.  I have a hard time giving out merits when I can't confidently evaluate whether a post is true and of good quality.  This is why I tend not to merit stuff in the technical discussion sections, and unfortunately that's what most members are linking to in this thread.

I keep a small list of posts when I come over them but don't have sMerit to send as a reference to get back to them later. Most of them are more technical than the links posted above and some are posted on the German local board and received not enough Merit in my opinion since the allocation of our Merit source was cut from 600 to 300 per month due to spending not enough of them in December / January.

Here's another one from my list, it's not a very new post but considering the fact that Merit is also meant to be given for posts to highlight them (and here to underline that the advice should be noted) OP deserves some:

Warning !!! Read before you buy bitcointalk account.
Category: advice
Section: Beginners + Help

[mikeywith]

Heat evacuator through window for 12 asics

Category: Invention !
Section: Mining


might not seem like a good post at first glance, but his idea is amazing and can benefit home miners a lot.

[Retina]

How to Earn Bitcoins on Android: The Mining Scam

Description : Android fake mining app
Category : Guide, technical answer
Section : Beginners & Help

[khaled0111]

...
My report was marked as bad. Maybe the Mod didn't see the links at the bottom are also copied.

I reported it again after reading your reply and added a note explaining that those links are also copied. The report is marked as good and the post has been deleted.
That makes me wonder if the status of your report on your report history page will change to good too! (sorry for going off-topic).

[LoyceV]

That makes me wonder if the status of your report on your report history page will change to good too! (sorry for going off-topic).

It's still marked as "bad", I think it would require manual intervention from a Mod to change that. But it doesn't matter much anyway.