Is finding this guys number and just calling him all the time till he gives the money back too chidish? 1200 is some serious money and a grand larceny threat might be enough.
No but don't be stupid about it.
Call these numbers and ask for Everton Deslandes.
(845) 629-2445 incorrect.
(845) 471-4427* Left a message. This is also a fax number.
If they ask who's calling tell them your name and tell them someone named Everton Deslandes purchased a money packs at the Rite Aid on Main Street and this same person who goes by the nickname Jermaine also defrauded you on the internet and you are trying to track him down to get your money back.
one of these numbers surely belongs to Everton's mother or father or brother or sister or cousin and you can be sure then even if they say they don't know him they are going to pick up the phone can call him and ask him what he is up too. Eventually we'll get someone who knows him or we'll get Everton himself and you can discuss a payback.
If you do call be civil and polite. This is essentially an attempt to collect a dept and there are very specific laws about that in each state and threatening physical violence or other slimier efforts can be just as illegal as the fraud.
If you do call let us know how it goes.