Bitcoin puzzle transaction ~32 BTC prize to who solves it

[Tepan]

02c584e2cb49a5aabd9ceb1e5128cecd0a7ca96628e76b1491950f021a4852d8ec ?
figure this out guys

What seems to be the problem?

The pubkey i found it's used to trans the Bitcoin to all puzzle with huge bitcoin last time, maybe we can search from that pubkey ? it's possible ?
just ask, because i need to figure out and learn, thx.

[1715350272]

1715350272

[1715350272]

1715350272

[1715350272]

1715350272

[Evillo]

https://towardsdatascience.com/random-seeds-and-reproducibility-933da79446e3

And how does this random.seed() work?

set some value and then Mersenne twister...

Mersenne twister 19937 bit (624·32 (2^32 = 4294967296) — 31)

for example, we take 3 random

random.seed(blablabla)
random.randrange(1,10)
random.randrange(1,10)
random.randrange(1,10)

we get for each of the 3 in order from the vortex of the first three?

                                 1— 31
random.randrange(1,10) 1,4294967296 (624·2)
random.randrange(1,10) 1,4294967296 (624·3)
random.randrange(1,10) 1,4294967296 (624·4)

and if we take 624 random.randrange(1,10) period ends and a new one begins again

                                 1— 31            next period
random.randrange(1,10) 1,4294967296 (625)624·2
random.randrange(1,10) 1,4294967296 (626)624·3
random.randrange(1,10) 1,4294967296 (627)624·4

and if we have a large sample of random.randrange(36893488147419103232,73786976294838206464) he spends 1 period for 1 sample or 624 and a new one (then why are they not repeated 2^32?)

or he these 19937 bit takes it all at once

in other words, to complete all puzzles with 1 seed() we need to iterate over this seed() to iterate over all variations of this 2^19937 bit ((2^32)^624)?

and seed() itself doesn’t matter (with brute force) you don’t need old computers to run it randomly in order to pick up the date and time, etc. to create the same bitcoin address.


random.seed(1, 2^19937) and all pz

random.randrange(36893488147419103232,73786976294838206464) 66
...
random.randrange(21267647932558653966460912964485513216,42535295865117307932921825928971026432) 125
...
random.randrange(730750818665451459101842416358141509827966271488,1461501637330902918203684832716283019655932542976) 160

and the puzzles themselves need to be multiplied 2^160×2^159×2^158...×2^66

and if it turns out that there may be collisions here , If 2^19937 the most options to open all the puzzles at once through 1 seed()

One of the most interesting topics I've read in a while.. but what makes you think this was the way the creator used to generate the puzzles' sequence? There could be a million ways to be used for this?

[whanau]

I am the creator.

You are quite right, 161-256 are silly.  I honestly just did not think of this.  What is especially embarrassing, is this did not occur to me once, in two years.  By way of excuse, I was not really thinking much about the puzzle at all.

I will make up for two years of stupidity.  I will spend from 161-256 to the unsolved parts, as you suggest.  In addition, I intend to add further funds.  My aim is to boost the density by a factor of 10, from 0.001*length(key) to 0.01*length(key).  Probably in the next few weeks.  At any rate, when I next have an extended period of quiet and calm, to construct the new transaction carefully.

A few words about the puzzle.  There is no pattern.  It is just consecutive keys from a deterministic wallet (masked with leading 000...0001 to set difficulty).  It is simply a crude measuring instrument, of the cracking strength of the community.

Finally, I wish to express appreciation of the efforts of all developers of new cracking tools and technology.  The "large bitcoin collider" is especially innovative and interesting!

The 'creator' created a wallet and increasingly changed the front bits to zero's
I wonder why there are still some who don't believe this?

[Evillo]

I am the creator.

You are quite right, 161-256 are silly.  I honestly just did not think of this.  What is especially embarrassing, is this did not occur to me once, in two years.  By way of excuse, I was not really thinking much about the puzzle at all.

I will make up for two years of stupidity.  I will spend from 161-256 to the unsolved parts, as you suggest.  In addition, I intend to add further funds.  My aim is to boost the density by a factor of 10, from 0.001*length(key) to 0.01*length(key).  Probably in the next few weeks.  At any rate, when I next have an extended period of quiet and calm, to construct the new transaction carefully.

A few words about the puzzle.  There is no pattern.  It is just consecutive keys from a deterministic wallet (masked with leading 000...0001 to set difficulty).  It is simply a crude measuring instrument, of the cracking strength of the community.

Finally, I wish to express appreciation of the efforts of all developers of new cracking tools and technology.  The "large bitcoin collider" is especially innovative and interesting!

The 'creator' created a wallet and increasingly changed the front bits to zero's
I wonder why there are still some who don't believe this?

Lol it's like we need a banner 😁 but the thing is some people are trying to find a pattern out of this HD sequence .. so they can unlock all puzzles at once

[hhhhugi]

Keyhunt with bsgs is giving me 1 Exakeys/second speed. Its 1,000,000,000,000 Megakeys/s in 125 bit range which is quite impressive, Its almost identical to searching 66th puzzle with decent gpu. Correct me if i'm wrong.

what's your system? gpu ? cpu?

Its combined 6 Google 300$ trial vm instances of 16 core cpu 64gb ram, and plus my pc. Each vms get ~160-180petakeys/s. Eventually google trial will expire, but worth to try.

My pc i5 12500F cpu with 32gb ram can take 50Petakeys/s.

Keyhunt is only cpu, resource, electric cost friendly option out there.

[hhhhugi]

Keyhunt with bsgs is giving me 1 Exakeys/second speed. Its 1,000,000,000,000 Megakeys/s in 125 bit range which is quite impressive, Its almost identical to searching 66th puzzle with decent gpu. Correct me if i'm wrong.

I get 2 petakeys/s which is the biggest number I've ever reached in any cracking program. Uses 32 gb of ram .. imagine what you would get with 512 gigs 😍

BSGS cuda gets more speed, but that is with GPU.

I was getting 2^62.04 keys per second; but I know those with 3090s were getting more. I was limited on system RAM to 16GB.

Interesting. What was the gpu?

It's the future of bitcoin hidden treasure hunters

[Gianluca95]

Hi there guys,

Considering your experience, how many keys a pc can scan in 1 second?

No kangaroo, no BSGS, but only random combination.

[WanderingPhilospher]

Hi there guys,

Considering your experience, how many keys a pc can scan in 1 second?

No kangaroo, no BSGS, but only random combination.

Too many variables, but I will give you a short and sweet answer...

It will depend on your CPU, but on an i7-6700, for straight cracking, for one address, each core does a little over 5 Million keys per second. So if I use 4 cores = 20 Million per second, ect.

[lordfrs]

Hi there guys,

Considering your experience, how many keys a pc can scan in 1 second?

No kangaroo, no BSGS, but only random combination.

Code:

import time

def calculate_pi(n):
    start_time = time.time()
    s = 0
    for i in range(n):
        s += 4.0 * (-1) ** i / (2 * i + 1)
    end_time = time.time()
    return s, end_time - start_time

n = 1000000
pi, elapsed_time = calculate_pi(n)
print("Pi: %f" % pi)
print("Elapsed time: %f seconds" % elapsed_time)
print("Digit production speed: %f rakam/saniye" % (n / elapsed_time))

[Evillo]

Hi there guys,

Considering your experience, how many keys a pc can scan in 1 second?

No kangaroo, no BSGS, but only random combination.

Code:

import time

def calculate_pi(n):
    start_time = time.time()
    s = 0
    for i in range(n):
        s += 4.0 * (-1) ** i / (2 * i + 1)
    end_time = time.time()
    return s, end_time - start_time

n = 1000000
pi, elapsed_time = calculate_pi(n)
print("Pi: %f" % pi)
print("Elapsed time: %f seconds" % elapsed_time)
print("Digit production speed: %f rakam/saniye" % (n / elapsed_time))

My android capability is 1.1 million/sec lool

[zahid888]

https://towardsdatascience.com/random-seeds-and-reproducibility-933da79446e3

And how does this random.seed() work?

set some value and then Mersenne twister...

Mersenne twister 19937 bit (624·32 (2^32 = 4294967296) — 31)

for example, we take 3 random

random.seed(blablabla)
random.randrange(1,10)
random.randrange(1,10)
random.randrange(1,10)

we get for each of the 3 in order from the vortex of the first three?

                                 1— 31
random.randrange(1,10) 1,4294967296 (624·2)
random.randrange(1,10) 1,4294967296 (624·3)
random.randrange(1,10) 1,4294967296 (624·4)

and if we take 624 random.randrange(1,10) period ends and a new one begins again

                                 1— 31            next period
random.randrange(1,10) 1,4294967296 (625)624·2
random.randrange(1,10) 1,4294967296 (626)624·3
random.randrange(1,10) 1,4294967296 (627)624·4

and if we have a large sample of random.randrange(36893488147419103232,73786976294838206464) he spends 1 period for 1 sample or 624 and a new one (then why are they not repeated 2^32?)

or he these 19937 bit takes it all at once

in other words, to complete all puzzles with 1 seed() we need to iterate over this seed() to iterate over all variations of this 2^19937 bit ((2^32)^624)?

and seed() itself doesn’t matter (with brute force) you don’t need old computers to run it randomly in order to pick up the date and time, etc. to create the same bitcoin address.


random.seed(1, 2^19937) and all pz

random.randrange(36893488147419103232,73786976294838206464) 66
...
random.randrange(21267647932558653966460912964485513216,42535295865117307932921825928971026432) 125
...
random.randrange(730750818665451459101842416358141509827966271488,1461501637330902918203684832716283019655932542976) 160

and the puzzles themselves need to be multiplied 2^160×2^159×2^158...×2^66

and if it turns out that there may be collisions here , If 2^19937 the most options to open all the puzzles at once through 1 seed()

========================== One Seed Derived From TimeStamp ==========================

 Timestamp : 2015-01-01 00:00:01 | Seed : 1420050600
 Count : 1
 Found : 0
 Address256 : 1BTJjk5AY3FctsNrU1U69naHq5TzCWdZsi | Private Key : e4bac8f82a587ee91d294e75b8d3d3709cd8d25f5c07ff2be79fdd33206e6df0
 Address 66 : 1Az6JLDmaWgtF5sYnvrFdhKExqxy5GQqS5 | Private Key : 2548d5d1dfbafa7a9
 Address 67 : 1MmHWFLysUAteVryaph6WxJ3iRfyhHywAC | Private Key : 42f91b5148d678531
 Address 68 : 1KWTDhmdDdgGvxZEApk3YkSXqWFEgkJznf | Private Key : f4b172d3db6ee38d7
 Address 69 : 1LAJRWvYhs4ZKhRM8trRs9i2vftAvJqj97 | Private Key : 1a2f7296830db802e4
 Address 71 : 1MQU6h7oxW7mbpfj9HBDXkgDsZKA7GtVoX | Private Key : 5cf86d09fd55eba007


========================== One Seed Derived From TimeStamp ==========================

 Timestamp : 2015-01-01 00:00:02 | Seed : 1420050601
 Count : 2
 Found : 0
 Address256 : 1Dr8p5nYbJpfyG2RQkeVxhYSWhUXcd7L41 | Private Key : 92dca344ec8b94cea9736003b01af257d326343362bc6b3ef8d914c9343329c8
 Address 66 : 1MfgFePHYmY6wkT6ZUQ2ZqdS3BDXXvxa2T | Private Key : 3d962e874b00304d4
 Address 67 : 1AZgq8rXd5AS7bc9FmZxf92ujgT2Docznh | Private Key : 5f498f58243cbde45
 Address 68 : 1H7KXbrnQYLM8NEZuM9pRNiHeoETE4ree3 | Private Key : afc5c580ca9b1c078
 Address 69 : 17WxmkhcmEXMznN1TRpC9bWqbbrQGnRc3n | Private Key : 16dcaebf3d685ccae5
 Address 71 : 1CPb6h6HCoTnoTXhjnjkm36nLQgvgbNaE9 | Private Key : 71b88613957aa44424


========================== One Seed Derived From TimeStamp ==========================

 Timestamp : 2015-01-01 00:00:03 | Seed : 1420050602
 Count : 3
 Found : 0
 Address256 : 13G2J7ToPuk5HYZAunLmsBd68gbgDn8WK7 | Private Key : c7a1f0af3a6ef95406560f9bff2cef1ad62bcb6fb8ae9cbe664abe53d303b5e1
 Address 66 : 16aDAhtzLm8pJ9sRqvYvUQCrJQDhwopE66 | Private Key : 2e86287c26a8887d9
 Address 67 : 1Nyz4A1fpYTS6K1iRmxBJjo5FWdDW4Uo4H | Private Key : 4e3ee53ac1b9c76ca
 Address 68 : 19Lj3m4JgayDEfawp5CBVGsj2Ff9rvz4zX | Private Key : 8bc6e08137e96f54e
 Address 69 : 136pHyzsAPAnYbsLGu5FTTwdrSSGCLp2Bg | Private Key : 18b47eb0aed3c4c325
 Address 71 : 1xp4b7dTHndWjAtkDUN6kaP3D6Agua3Rv | Private Key : 55cc481b176a13d656


========================== One Seed Derived From TimeStamp ==========================

 Timestamp : 2015-01-01 00:00:04 | Seed : 1420050603
 Count : 4
 Found : 0
 Address256 : 18ncR82y9faFmyRhQtd6PbtX7pJD4KUXvV | Private Key : f11877114f334a08f7fdb88172a9679d2f9aa01cc8a3270a87f2d4ff2f0a6825
 Address 66 : 14CEWnB473oYfDrLQMsKTPyxxoxYXSYWSS | Private Key : 3cb4dfc04c0c37395
 Address 67 : 15sW9a5Fb5ev9yvPQty3FhYbLfdB5junt2 | Private Key : 4bf8b4d7f3553c912
 Address 68 : 167gaJXsrAccUc7sUrxtUQRuYz7kpDYDWx | Private Key : dd0f1f8aeb5e66a08
 Address 69 : 1GRffSkZC611mtfepDBR9hikq9yf6KQDv6 | Private Key : 1e9724128c1016829b
 Address 71 : 1Bwfh4NhULBcQby3QP8x9pghTdph2du9qq | Private Key : 6bfa24a7abf2a4d853


========================== One Seed Derived From TimeStamp ==========================

 Timestamp : 2015-01-01 00:00:05 | Seed : 1420050604
 Count : 5
 Found : 0
 Address256 : 1KMGps4o6HimXSNiTi3tLJuUHmrhQX6sG8 | Private Key : dce76ef2eaf10f347dbea7ae1a0389c510d4a65dd78e7227f29317ab19e0f86f
 Address 66 : 1JoKLNqP7EbVt22QHLddCshtZd6SkhbrCf | Private Key : 389d0e5d13cbda394
 Address 67 : 1FmYtDBKbqzMQq7GLevVXAXaFRoiFC4ueL | Private Key : 6263db47da3999618
 Address 68 : 19dsDu4HCF2e4L7SGcuPnM2KeEb9BRN76y | Private Key : f392c5f5daa1f30cf
 Address 69 : 12SwkUfXV4E8xSeXbj1CKrfKAAPPUqAaZ6 | Private Key : 1b746c0b93e5e2c50d
 Address 71 : 1M8firfDaEmwoJspfgw272gifA5jNZgK4B | Private Key : 440dca8c5d60624273


========================== One Seed Derived From TimeStamp ==========================

 Timestamp : 2015-01-01 00:00:06 | Seed : 1420050605
 Count : 6
 Found : 0
 Address256 : 19PQKenHPvw4YjFeKcb4XfBLvsr2QWePKs | Private Key : cdc290690d75235f71e9bb9f51eb1ffa35dd5b0e751703cf67dd12c82d412d58
 Address 66 : 1KfJNNGLtH5vLTp7vzoqggd4PzuFgWQSA | Private Key : 3183af05a713da50a
 Address 67 : 1DwqTjCmXKYW61z4h1pRjjqfhnWHgXx6qS | Private Key : 5fb19aadeb5e4aca7
 Address 68 : 1ENnei544BLZ8K68H1iXuwPhuFXxDTyW98 | Private Key : fb75384115c9ebd8b
 Address 69 : 1KNoDM4BoHH6hL8ySnWRRgEiY8HD9Cgxpj | Private Key : 1041559e3788666df4
 Address 71 : 1CFngHByQy9XXohG6UaHzpgZVxLabBt4zj | Private Key : 77e3945e27e8192f3a


========================== One Seed Derived From TimeStamp ==========================

 Timestamp : 2015-01-01 00:00:07 | Seed : 1420050606
 Count : 7
 Found : 0
 Address256 : 1P1zzdDkThSbvYm4TKw5L2rm5yTES126vT | Private Key : e754ce3531069f773f2a5518b3177aec0d08e26aaf4f844d49f44b1fa5ac1076
 Address 66 : 12xTD3Scr8iETSQXWWokUnqAem6RYgNpAp | Private Key : 3817fa2f65d364198
 Address 67 : 1PDt49D5P2BEKJVQBEi2Mbi1ki3ZTctJbu | Private Key : 4d5b1611e03d7cb6b
 Address 68 : 18nhxjmJu1tRM6fAE4Tv2aWug74UCkDPxh | Private Key : c32319307a6f27354
 Address 69 : 1AGiWsUu26JWzpWDSPErK2cNmn92w4yQya | Private Key : 183002e8154814db45
 Address 71 : 1ia6K1r4UypsvsFhXMZ7S2jTDLvcJG9dP | Private Key : 53ee8b01aa9c7d8332


========================== One Seed Derived From TimeStamp ==========================

 Timestamp : 2015-01-01 00:00:08 | Seed : 1420050607
 Count : 8
 Found : 0
 Address256 : 16SbXLUMQtzsELfbrtF3tCK3U7kEmJuPQF | Private Key : f21a44ee1b97803567465fc521e46816b00f5c41e86d0a48ac8a9efb5601525b
 Address 66 : 1GMPnqixgFuJ2NQs2zYvNshg7o38NANjQG | Private Key : 2454bb009a5c5207d
 Address 67 : 1uJgzmVFroM8YCV86YCo7fNm5s8aEcygv | Private Key : 5782c8d131968d48f
 Address 68 : 17sgVY5qjGC8FrGQqVBGJQH8KMi9kfpWmJ | Private Key : bbe2e2f12baaa41b7
 Address 69 : 17LRj6We1tan5nizjQH2BT4tXHe6uBppNQ | Private Key : 19fe56d7ba38f8c1eb
 Address 71 : 18gkGYgzteZwYYVXK7ZpCcLNdPDbpegM8U | Private Key : 53a53772befaf30af0


========================== One Seed Derived From TimeStamp ==========================

 Timestamp : 2015-01-01 00:00:09 | Seed : 1420050608
 Count : 9
 Found : 0
 Address256 : 1CJmhz5jvVVhGkGW7hPuSNG5YnGxZ2eDth | Private Key : 8041c3ada06f578bbe89e14ef3937d61ab1ab693908c4ed0b354af4575da2877
 Address 66 : 1FDtQAsaKi99QvHUQwELMJegWRxV7fTQbF | Private Key : 2dfc0de4cd930a3e6
 Address 67 : 15rGfT4VW57q1k4HfAkw7XMASwoxL5vE36 | Private Key : 7fb4514f9e6f24ad8
 Address 68 : 1EQXLtaSYUssoNkZwN5JX5t7kkHEFLEkys | Private Key : f31ce989454af48db
 Address 69 : 19cLcc9XVydLrLSmjiQxc42xjqzfKU9vEv | Private Key : 1a9a598ab15e006ccf
 Address 71 : 1J9HVkWa4M5MdTKX4NvmdotkRdzaofPz8C | Private Key : 4f049bf53a6106b483
 .
 .
 .
 .
 .
 .
 .
 .
 .
 .
 .
 .
 .
 ========================== One Seed Derived From TimeStamp ==========================

 Timestamp : 2015-01-15 23:59:55 | Seed : 1421346594
 Count : 1295995
 Found : 0
 Address256 : 1ChwcnSgYXWpFZ5Xi61prnKTHxTBGj8dLN | Private Key : c3230c450baa2bc25b892cbab21a5969e5e0ea25f36cfb7b542bd55d18eba525
 Address 66 : 1KhZfx55GPjXqPW763tUop2GmCTxDdQ8wG | Private Key : 38f36c953b79c218a
 Address 67 : 15SeCivu2XAnhWj5tuLamiUvuEMdXj1DfP | Private Key : 6de525e51955a2528
 Address 68 : 15u6jJeiKKjqG6agg8C1H9qqCKArYitBb2 | Private Key : e23d4a6d6f66ea319
 Address 69 : 1DWupLQvoCJQ9VfF8ebNjdp1Lm9R8mttDw | Private Key : 1e9bb45f456c1a262f
 Address 71 : 1EjE3AyqPSMXsL3nmp2TjfsqsqgbdE2WNr | Private Key : 7cc6457dbbdf2b93bf


========================== One Seed Derived From TimeStamp ==========================

 Timestamp : 2015-01-15 23:59:56 | Seed : 1421346595
 Count : 1295996
 Found : 0
 Address256 : 1C65KRwEe8TxdHaeMKSsRub2DAW5EBeHuq | Private Key : 90d117c59dd13415a447b47b133369c04912af783a635fae2039d93fa3245e2f
 Address 66 : 1LoQhMpnytmYZCpA7wE3tjr4PqsWiauhfd | Private Key : 26dd7f242ae633fbb
 Address 67 : 12BtbdPbqXQvnJFmPtsYeopxwMXRph9cSU | Private Key : 5b836c6f45685b744
 Address 68 : 176u7edeZ4sMRWSE7zvtgjnEHCPpqb7C9Y | Private Key : 8cd451d9594e3cbc5
 Address 69 : 17Gjx4m9m8c5fkHntUoY7XroEZQgXAz5kS | Private Key : 16a59d474482109b2c
 Address 71 : 1PvfKDv1E66JXy4iP9tMQcmXE3Wh3GFQQG | Private Key : 475213c43a61cad86b


========================== One Seed Derived From TimeStamp ==========================

 Timestamp : 2015-01-15 23:59:57 | Seed : 1421346596
 Count : 1295997
 Found : 0
 Address256 : 186KHbfG3CDhawoGHgrN7hxHeDqHfZbQpF | Private Key : f3e4282862805cfae05e807b7d20cc6784e070f8c42cb2f638260686d49d63c9
 Address 66 : 1GFT1Q8kbFYwZ1SqFZ8YhhjEUsfXqUkfBA | Private Key : 20daaea084ed652f8
 Address 67 : 18uuasNQdFpRqqoCF1ddiS61exbXtXf2Eh | Private Key : 460190ef0c2a0ca22
 Address 68 : 183Fui8heV7qFNPrytveJtiPgLFTwQ7vEC | Private Key : cef7a7c13d3f4db54
 Address 69 : 1Xam2BcHCfGuNhLmNs4TRVuqmjHM8wfwm | Private Key : 183766a7ac3bacb498
 Address 71 : 1PDVfuRbA781zVA8cAQWfuBLHUV9rL9BY5 | Private Key : 77d201b8b80e8a14b8


========================== One Seed Derived From TimeStamp ==========================

 Timestamp : 2015-01-15 23:59:58 | Seed : 1421346597
 Count : 1295998
 Found : 0
 Address256 : 12atDLfb4KV3XXoLWPGokNd1t6azdZaUBV | Private Key : b14042b6e0cb268a91f6547da62af1aa484468be4d0f52fe9527a6b37eee2c7b
 Address 66 : 1Pc17d48VZQwpesMAeQYLXfN5ZVM7bzdYr | Private Key : 351c18c1ea25542fe
 Address 67 : 1G9322XXzN1CcDNvFuW7NZr3CyKNqgac98 | Private Key : 450c444707e064ab2
 Address 68 : 1KnbxSVasKafiFeShXLNJgW8ZC2R3297NR | Private Key : f69842966eee140fa
 Address 69 : 1BF6SzsPFKtg6iLE8VpUWXNH9YRpyxPk1C | Private Key : 1dd3df6ebe2d0149de
 Address 71 : 1K6KYQfocXLh3TeU7TjwnEgVuZhvugFheE | Private Key : 52b54cb0a381d483d4


========================== One Seed Derived From TimeStamp ==========================

 Timestamp : 2015-01-15 23:59:59 | Seed : 1421346598
 Count : 1295999
 Found : 0
 Address256 : 1BNQgon7i2tixwrF7omM6u6kNwcAPEtB9u | Private Key : b48ed5e51876e324c669af2118e2e751c7fb081d6ad5d50dbdf1e4441172a800
 Address 66 : 1FSLuYfNbmPjjiSfnKjWge99GkzbuAJyGp | Private Key : 3d704d25741791e1a
 Address 67 : 14Sg2BpFqEf9vtZeyoiBJDzccZVE5iNk5P | Private Key : 7241e9386058e0bb6
 Address 68 : 1CQ7AgzMUeB6gDcyDLZNdDRLEijFSebyp2 | Private Key : 9ceff97e446c38f0e
 Address 69 : 14Ter1E6azSYUnHfzUAGZXiMeVM6nyoLE3 | Private Key : 19febb496cf213d509
 Address 71 : 1CsJ3hKHV3BhiVVv3usMWjAbAHn8v59JqB | Private Key : 79a2d5a6cb2b9f52bc


========================== One Seed Derived From TimeStamp ==========================

 Timestamp : 2015-01-16 00:00:00 | Seed : 1421346599
 Count : 1296000
 Found : 0
 Address256 : 1LKf6GtJp8uinFjvjjvQgycqAiVL4Lp2qK | Private Key : e3c4af8815712f4df235c75cf2734b544c2cea136f68e51e8e4820bec10a5709
 Address 66 : 1HEDwUEhMtFks4yKqYLgCc5kjzGVDo473X | Private Key : 24affb0b21a726a4a
 Address 67 : 145vwRaHA5twVc745PA7eF2xS7hyYDnPMh | Private Key : 7426c73d1bc846b60
 Address 68 : 17ZxFWr17RX1QmJckpru3ZXmHARViQxtT9 | Private Key : 839a767615aaada03
 Address 69 : 1PSnpF4mKwUpMWGU8Gu7MAwzScFsqRDfxb | Private Key : 10f57bb37dbf89429a
 Address 71 : 1CXLHACQ99SdkKTG8tUvLpbCJNhiGpjTko | Private Key : 4748ac961061615bf7

 
 Timestamp is definitaly not
 

[Andzhig]

zahid888 He also wrote that he used a "It is just consecutive keys from a deterministic wallet (masked with leading 000...0001 to set difficulty)" this means that he could use anything, but most likely a regular random 2^256 address. He could create the keys a month before filling, or a week. And one time is not enough to shove all the devilry there, the clock counters... all this nonsense has a range "Mersenne twister 2^19937 bit (624·32 (2^32 = 4294967296) — 31)".

***

test

it took to open the first 3 puzzles through seed()

        a = random.seed(1,15000000)

        a1 = random.randrange(512,1024)
        if a1 == 514:

            a2 = random.randrange(256,512)
            if a2 == 467:                

                a3 = random.randrange(128,256)
                if a3 == 224:

14429208 seed-steps, 514, 467, 224

for 4 it's been a long time to search 1,1000000000...

because when finding the first one, it is necessary to iterate over all the first ones until it suits the second one, etc.

1024×1024×1024 =          1073741824        for 3pz
2048×2048×2048×2048 = 17592186044416  for 4pz
etc...

probably needed for the whole puzzle 160-66=94, (2^160)^94 ~ 2^15040

2^15040 all pz
2^19937 twister

[Evillo]

zahid888 He also wrote that he used a "It is just consecutive keys from a deterministic wallet (masked with leading 000...0001 to set difficulty)" this means that he could use anything, but most likely a regular random 2^256 address. He could create the keys a month before filling, or a week. And one time is not enough to shove all the devilry there, the clock counters... all this nonsense has a range "Mersenne twister 2^19937 bit (624·32 (2^32 = 4294967296) — 31)".

***

test

it took to open the first 3 puzzles through seed()

        a = random.seed(1,15000000)

        a1 = random.randrange(512,1024)
        if a1 == 514:

            a2 = random.randrange(256,512)
            if a2 == 467:                

                a3 = random.randrange(128,256)
                if a3 == 224:

14429208 seed-steps, 514, 467, 224

for 4 it's been a long time to search 1,1000000000...

because when finding the first one, it is necessary to iterate over all the first ones until it suits the second one, etc.

1024×1024×1024 =          1073741824        for 3pz
2048×2048×2048×2048 = 17592186044416  for 4pz
etc...

probably needed for the whole puzzle 160-66=94, (2^160)^94 ~ 2^15040

2^15040 all pz
2^19937 twister

Holy shhhit .. that's even waaaay harder than cracking a full 256 bits key.

[zahid888]

@Andzhing @Evillo I believe that the person who created this puzzle did not put much thought into it. They simply selected a random number in a very ordinary manner to create the puzzle, and we may be unnecessarily complicating it. My point is that we should also consider these aspects when attempting to solve it. below in lime green text.

I am the creator.

You are quite right, 161-256 are silly.  I honestly just did not think of this.  What is especially embarrassing, is this did not occur to me once, in two years.  By way of excuse, I was not really thinking much about the puzzle at all.

I will make up for two years of stupidity.  I will spend from 161-256 to the unsolved parts, as you suggest.  In addition, I intend to add further funds.  My aim is to boost the density by a factor of 10, from 0.001*length(key) to 0.01*length(key).  Probably in the next few weeks.  At any rate, when I next have an extended period of quiet and calm, to construct the new transaction carefully.

A few words about the puzzle.  There is no pattern.  It is just consecutive keys from a deterministic wallet (masked with leading 000...0001 to set difficulty).  It is simply a crude measuring instrument, of the cracking strength of the community.

Finally, I wish to express appreciation of the efforts of all developers of new cracking tools and technology.  The "large bitcoin collider" is especially innovative and interesting!

[Andzhig]

@Andzhing @Evillo I believe that the person who created this puzzle did not put much thought into it. They simply selected a random number in a very ordinary manner to create the puzzle, and we may be unnecessarily complicating it. My point is that we should also consider these aspects when attempting to solve it. below in lime green text.

I am the creator.

You are quite right, 161-256 are silly.  I honestly just did not think of this.  What is especially embarrassing, is this did not occur to me once, in two years.  By way of excuse, I was not really thinking much about the puzzle at all.

I will make up for two years of stupidity.  I will spend from 161-256 to the unsolved parts, as you suggest.  In addition, I intend to add further funds.  My aim is to boost the density by a factor of 10, from 0.001*length(key) to 0.01*length(key).  Probably in the next few weeks.  At any rate, when I next have an extended period of quiet and calm, to construct the new transaction carefully.

A few words about the puzzle.  There is no pattern.  It is just consecutive keys from a deterministic wallet (masked with leading 000...0001 to set difficulty).  It is simply a crude measuring instrument, of the cracking strength of the community.

Finally, I wish to express appreciation of the efforts of all developers of new cracking tools and technology.  The "large bitcoin collider" is especially innovative and interesting!

That's right, but we don't know what he specifically did and in what program. What entropy was used 128-256 bit. 128bit enropy 12 words, still get 256bit private key. Let's say we start iterating over the entire enropy of 128bit and, by derivation, generate 256 addresses and cut them off in front, as the creator of the puzzle did. We have to iterate over all 128bits (12 worlds, 2048^12). https://github.com/Mizogg/python-mnemonic For each of 2048 to 2048^11 etc.But the generation itself (if he did not use the words brainwallets) 128bit number was caused by some data for seed() ("some garbage" > Mersenne twister 2^19937 bit > seed() > 128bit > address), what size of "some garbage" for the swirl was used. Maybe the size of the "some garbage" was less than 128bit, maybe more. If he manually cut 256 addresses for the deep puzzle, then how did he get addresses from them.

***


https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1306983.msg58670653#msg58670653

combinatorics method, placement with repetitions, select from a set of 100 elements of 2 characters [00,01,02,03...97,98,99]

we get the number 22 characters long blablabla 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 99
or 9999999999999999999999 ((100; 11) 5653408585997652480000) ~2^73

9999999999999999999999/2^65 ~271 collisions, 2^73/2^65 = 256 collisions

1 collision when sampling from 100 if we do not take into account the exact number (we will rearrange it to get the right one)

we don’t care how we get the right numbers in what order we will rearrange them anyway to find the right one, blablabla 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 99 , 01 00 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 99, 02 00 01 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 99 etc...

11! 39916800

271 collisions 39916800×271 = 10817452800

this is for a seed of 2 characters, we can use any combination to create a seed Aa Ab Bb BA bA etc...

"Aa" 11! 39916800, 271 collisions 39916800×271 = 10817452800
"Ab" 11! 39916800, 271 collisions 39916800×271 = 10817452800
"BA" 11! 39916800, 271 collisions 39916800×271 = 10817452800

10817452800×1000(seed Aa Ab Bb BA bA etc...) = 10817452800000

made a selection of 50 out of 100

(100; 50) 3068518756254966037202730459529469739228459721684688959447786986982158958772355 072000000000000/2^65 (or 2^73) 83172367546103805632956336834744831338220102860894879569529077863864324986 collisions



of these 50 selected, one more sample

(50; 25)  1960781468160819415703172080467968000000/2^65 (of 2^73) 53147088188731933817 collisions

etc

(25; 11)  177925144320000/2^65 0,0000048226... collisions

ok. take (50; 25) 1960781468160819415703172080467968000000/2^65 53147088188731933817 collisions

53147088188731933817/10817452800000 = 4913087, factorial 11 must be sorted out all over 4913087×39916800=196114711161600  there is already a chance to calculate


['75', '45', '51', '72', '06', '38', '89', '88', '16', '20', '88', '38', '12', '16', '41', '43', '12', '22', '81', '33', '38', '12', '81', '60', '20', '89', '52', '13', '88', '08']
screening out...
['88', '81', '06', '89', '16', '88', '33', '81', '13', '33', '72', '52', '60', '13', '13']
loop start...
1 5288168860138933063313 hhEEEEhhhEEEhEEEEhEEEhEhhEhEhhhEhhEhEEhEEEEhhhhEhhEhEhEhEhEhEEhhhEEEhhhEhhhE <seed, bit> 0101000110101000110110100111010000100000110100000101111011100001101101111111011 0000101111110111001011110011001100010010011100011101001000100100111001001100110 00
2 5260130613883313811689 hhEEEEhEhEEEhhEhEEhhhhhhhhEEhhEhEhEEhEEEhhEEEhEhEhhhhhhEhEEhhEhEhEEEEhhEEhEE <seed, bit> 0011111011100101011001100100000001010100101111100111001101010011101111011100100 0101000001100000101000000000011100011111101010100100001011011000110011111010001 01
3 3360133306161389815281 EhhhhhEEEhhhhhEhhEhhhEEEEhEhhEEEhhhhhEEEEhEEEhhEEEEEEhEhhEEEEEhhhhEhEhEEhhhE <seed, bit> 0101011010111011011000011101011111111101001001101011011101111000011001110101110 1001111101101111000010000001011011001100011000011000001010011001011110110100011 10
4 3388168881136013890652 EhhhhhEhhEEEhEEEhhhhEhhhhEEEhhhhhhhhEEEhhEEEhEEEhhhEEhEEEhEEEEEEEEhEEhhhEEhh <seed, bit> 0111111000101000010111001101011110011100000011101101110111110100101010000000010 0101000110011010111000101011110111000111011101011010000110100111011100100000011 10
5 681131333131660725288 EEEhhEhEhhEhEEEEhhhhEhEhEEhEhhhEhEhhhEEhhEEEhEhhhEEhEhhEEhhhEEEhEEEhEEhEhhhE <seed, bit> 0100110011101111000000010100010100011000101100101010100001010111100101100010110 1100011101100100000101100011001101100111000110100010010001000011011111110011011 10
6 3381135206603388721381 EhhhhhEhEhEEEEhhEhhhEEEhEhhEhEhEhhEEEEEhEEEhhEhhhhEhEhhhEhEEEEEEhhhEhhEEEhhE <seed, bit> 1000001100110001101010011111110101011001000011100100001110010001111011111110001 1100100110101110010101101101001010001010100001100001011101101111001011010100011 10
8 660133381888913527233 EEEhhEhEEEEEhhhhEEhhhEhhEhEEhEhhEEhhhEhhhhhhhhEEEhhEEEEhEEhEEhEEhhEEhEEEEhhh <seed, bit> 1111101101011101100011010111100100011110110011000111001100001111110100110110110 0101000011000000010001010111111101010010111011010010110111110101110101001011011 10
10 1388721381893388066013 EEhhEhEEhhEEhhhEEEhEhEhhEhEEhhhhEhhhEEhhhEEEhhEhEEEhEEEhEhhhEEEhEEhhEEhhhEhE <seed, bit> 0110011100111110101000100010000000001001000011000100101010111110000110001010010 1010010010100001100110000111111101001110100001101100110111100110010100000111100 00
11 1381168113608889728806 EEhhEhEEhEEEhEhEhEhEhhEhhEEhEhhhhEhEhhEhhEEhEEEhEEEEhhEEhhEhEhEhEhhEhEhEEhhh <seed, bit> 1001111100001000001110001110101110110000100010101101111000111111001110101010101 0101100000100001101000110100011001100111100101001110101001011101001101001001010 10
15 3388527288608106331389 EhhhhhEhhEEEhhEEEEhEhhhhhEhhEEEhEEhhhhEhhhEEEEhhhhEEhEEEEEhhEEEhEEEEhEEhhhhE <seed, bit> 0100001000011000110100000101110001111111010000110011110001011011000010110001011 0100100111010011001110010100000010100110010010001100010000000111010001101011000 00
18 1652338960880633728881 EEhhhhhEEEhEhhEhEEhhEhhhhEEEhhEEhEEEhhEhhEEEhhhEhhhEEEhEhhEEEhEEhEEhhEEhEhhE <seed, bit> 0000101010111001101000101000011011110011110111000110011110100101101100010100011 1110011110100100101001001100101101110010101001110000100111101000000000100111100 10
19 3352811389720616818860 EhhhhhEEEEhhhEhhEEhEhhhEEEhEhhhEEEhEEEhEEhhhEhEEhEhhEhEhEEEhEhEEhhhhhEhEEEhE <seed, bit> 1110010010101101001111111110100010001000110111110011111111011111100101111010001 0010010000010011011111100111101100010100010110011110110010111110110101001111111 11
20 5288810688166072891381 hhEEEEhhhEEEhhEhhhEhEhhEhhhEhEhEhhEEEhhhEEhhhhEEhEEEhhhEEEhhEEEEhEEhhEEEhhEE <seed, bit> 1000001101100001000010000001000111000001101111101000010111110100000010101011011 0111100101111001010100000111011010000111011101000000101111001010110001000000011 01
22 1313896013883316815288 EEhhEEhEEEhEEEhEhhhhhEEhhEhhhEEEhhEEhhhhhEhEEhEhhEhEEEhhEEEhhEhEhhhEhhEEEEhE <seed, bit> 0010100010111100101100011001001100001100010000110110111010110100010001010010111 1101110100111111000111100101001101110001011101001110010101001011101100111000100 00
25 3381725288131388130660 EhhhhhEhEhEEhEEEhEhEEhhhhhhEEEEEEhhEEhhEhEEEEhhhhEEhEhhhhEEEhEEEEEhEhhEhhEhh <seed, bit> 0101111011010111100110110001100000100111000001100001011100100011001101100111000 0011101111110000101111011000001100110011011000101100000000010001110001011001110 11

['32', '22', '67', '57', '86', '21', '55', '39', '48', '86', '46', '40', '41', '64', '23', '74', '85', '48', '11', '75', '94', '64', '03', '29', '86', '71', '07', '65', '46', '81']
screening out...
['67', '22', '86', '64', '48', '11', '48', '22', '71', '64', '48', '57', '94', '40', '40']
loop start...
1 4894716748644822402286 3[33[3[[3[333[[[[3333[33[3[[[3[[[[3[333333[[3[[[3[333[3[3[[[3333[[[[33[[[[33 <seed, bit> 0111001000000010100100110100100111010001110101110110000001000101101100110110101 0010000011100000000111101000011000001100110111001111001111100001000011100010100 10
2 6411574886224048946740 333[33[[3[[[33[3[[3[[[[333333[3[[[3[[3[333[[33[[33[[33[[333333[[3[33[[[[3[[[ <seed, bit> 1101001101100101100110000101010010100000111100111110010101011110101111001110000 0110001011101101000101100011110111100001001010100000001100101111100000001100011 00
3 1148228622487167649464 [[3[33[[[[[333[333[[[[33[3[3[333333[[3[33[[[[[33[33[3[[[3333[[[[3[33[333[3[[ <seed, bit> 0010100000101011000101000011100101001001010110101111000001001101111111111110011 0111011010101011001001011100000101110000000101100111110101001000101111101010110 11
4 6422718611674822404864 333[33[[3333[33[[3[3[[[[33[[[3[333[[[3[33[3[[33[3[[3[3[[33[[[33[[3[[[[[33333 <seed, bit> 0000111111101100010101010101111111000010000001011100110101011100110011101010111 0000100010110011110011001001001010010110011010011111110010011000101100001011011 00
5 4064716711484822578640 3[[3[33[33[[3[3[33[[33[3[[3[[3[[[33[[33[3[333[3[[3[3[[[3333333[[[[[[[[[33333 <seed, bit> 1100110010001111101011110101000101111111101001011111100011000000101101110000110 0100111000000101000111010110101000100111111110000010111011100111000101101010100 00
6 4840644886225722716411 3[33[[3[33[[3[3[3[[3[3[[3[[[[[[[333[3[3[[33[3[[3[333[[3333[33[333[[[[3[3333[ <seed, bit> 1001110010011010110011101110000101011000101011000100111000110001010100000110010 0100001101001111101010101011011010101111010110001000001000101010010111100000011 01
7 6764226440864848941171 33333[3[[[33[3[[[3333[[[33333[[[[3[33[[3[3[33[[[[333[[[[[3333[[[3[3[[33[[3[3 <seed, bit> 1000100111011000010110011001101010011101101111100010101101110010110010111000100 0101010001001011111011000011111011110001010001100101110010111100011101010101011 10
8 5794866748114864226448 33[3[3[33[3[33[[3[[3[333333[[[[3[33[3[[3[3[[3333[33[[[[[[[[[33[3[3[333[[33[[ <seed, bit> 0010000010001111001101111010000111001110011000010110101111001101110001000001001 1010101000110000010100011001111111011001101111111100111100100011100011001001111 01
10 6494487140228648644811 333[3333333[[3[[[33[333333[[[[[3[3[[33[[[333[3[[[3[[[[[33[33[33[[3[33[[[[3[[ <seed, bit> 1110001100101111111110001001111000001011100101110000010011111110111110011101110 0011000100100110100100100100100111101010000111111100110101111000001000011101010 00

['05', '20', '99', '07', '11', '00', '21', '92', '92', '99', '20', '92', '78', '88', '26', '25', '54', '62', '70', '37', '34', '54', '78', '59', '08', '49', '59', '64', '06', '37']
screening out...
['05', '49', '99', '78', '54', '05', '99', '34', '06', '92', '78', '54', '08', '99', '59']
loop start...
1 4906999954590592053499 1+11+1+1++1++1111+++++1111++1+111+1+++++++1+11+11+11++++1111++1+11+++1+111+1 <seed, bit> 1011100110110111100001100010010101111001100000111110111100001101000000011100010 0010111100000111011111110010001100000010100101110011101101010111010111101110101 01
7 4999345408990692055978 1+111+++1++1+++111+1+1++++++11++111+11+1+1+11+11++1++1+1+111+11+++1+1+111+1+ <seed, bit> 1101111011011110101001110001001100001000101111100101111101100001010100010101000 0000111001101111001010001111100101100001011001110001001110111011100100100001011 10
8 878345999990554065478 ++1+++1+++11+++1++111+111+1+1++1+1++1+1+1+11+1+111++11+11++111+11++11+1++1+1 <seed, bit> 0000111101110011100010110100110101111000010011101011000011000100011000011011011 0110001110111000001011110011111111110011101110000010111010110100110101011010010 00
12 899785934057854069992 ++1+++11+++++++11+++1111++111+1111111+111+11++++1++1+1+11+++11+111++++11+11+ <seed, bit> 1100010101110110101011110100010011010000100110100111110111101110010111001000001 1000001010111010100010011100000100010111110010110110011110101011011100101011010 10
13 4906929954990534995459 1+11+1+1++1++11+111+1+1++1++1++11++1+111++++1++++1+1++1++1+11+1+11111+1+1+11 <seed, bit> 1001000100101111001101111100110100011001011111010000101100111001011111000111001 0110101101001000011001000001001100010111001101111001001110011001010110000110101 00
14 678545408053499927859 +++11+1+1+111++111+++1++11111++++1+11++1111+1111111+1+++++++1+1++1+11+++1++1 <seed, bit> 1001001000000100111011110000001001111111110011011110001001101100001000010001011 0011011001110111010101001110100011110001010101000111111010001110000010111111100 10
15 699080554345449990559 +++11+11+111+++1+1+11+1+1+++1+1+1++1111+++1++1+11111+++11+++111++++1+1111++1 <seed, bit> 0100111110010110100001001111110101111010011110000110010101011111101000101110111 0100001001110111111001111100111000011010101000001101100000110000111100010101001 00
17 892065478990578594905 ++1+++1+1+111+1+1+1++++1+11+1++1++++++11+1111+111+1++11+1++11111+11+1+11+++1 <seed, bit> 0001111001111000001001101001111111110011001111010011101100001001110111110011101 1111011110100000000101000000010111001110101110001000000110010010100011011111011 00
19 878340599544959929906 ++1+++1+++11+++1++1+1+11+1++11+11111+1+11111++++11++1++++11+11+111+1+1111+++ <seed, bit> 1001110000101001001110010111101010000101010110110110011010100000001001001000000 1110000010010111000110000010101011110101100100011101101101000001000101001011000 01
21 899499954590592785405 ++1+++1+1111111+++1++1++11+++++1+111+1++1++1+111+11+1++11+11+11++11+++1111++ <seed, bit> 0100001100011011110011010011100010001101011001111010000000010100111001000001100 1100111101000001011000111011011111100100011101101111000001011011110011111110000 10
22 692499954780559780554 +++11+11++11+111+11++11+111+1+++11++++111++++++++1+1++++1111+11+11+1111+11++ <seed, bit> 0011100110010011110010010001000001110010111111111100111111101010010000111001001 0001110010010111110101011110011011110110001111100001010000000100100111010001110 11
24 4959990878995499059234 1+11+111+++1++1+1111111+1++11++1+++++11+1+1111+111+1++++++1+1+1+11+++11+++1+ <seed, bit> 0111001111011000010011011111011100001111011101111110110111101111110110001100101 1010110100000001010100101100111101110111011100011010111001111110010100111010010 10
26 5405990649780599085992 11+++1111+11++1+1+1111+1111+++1+++11++11++1++11+11+1++++111++1+11++++1++11++ <seed, bit> 1110100001110111010111100101100011011011001100111011000101111110001110111001111 0101111100000101111000111011111101111110011101100100100101110111101001000001111 00
28 5999089206493454547899 11+111+1++11+111+++1+1+1++11++1+1111+1+1111+++111+1+1+11+++++++1++1++11+++1+ <seed, bit> 1100010110011000111011101101010000010000000000111100010000101111010010111100111 1000001000011101100010100101001011011110101110100011001001100100110000000100011 11
30 3405065454499278990599 +111111+++11+1+1+111+111++1++11++1+1+++1++11++1++++++111+11+++111+++11+111++ <seed, bit> 0111111001001010100100110100011100101010111011111101111001100010101100100101010 1001010000101010111101110000110000000100011110011000000101101011110111011010100 11
31 5478590806789205999999 11++1+1++1+1++++++11++1+1+1++1++++1+1++1111111+1+11+++1+1++1111+++1+1+111111 <seed, bit> 0101000100000010101111101011110010110010101101110011110000000110100010110011011 0001100110111011001000000011110010010110101010101000100100000000110101000101100 11

[GR Sasa]

speak english guys or at least some human language to understand what you are guys writing.

[zahid888]

speak english guys or at least some human language to understand what you are guys writing.

So have you stopped begging?

[zahid888]

So have you stopped begging?

Damn son, you're actually right.

Thank you for reminding me.. I was really stressed out because my boss is destorying me and my free time every day at work...

#Day 4 Dear Satoshi, Here i'm asking you again my meister for some BTC BTC
 
32NYX3o1FDegf6nJiqKLi4DE25LYzSd72B

Thanks Satoshi

lol Keep it up.. there is no way apart from yours 👍🏼 👍🏼

Perhaps I may also have to adopt your method after paying this month's electricity bill as well.

[GR Sasa]

Perhaps I may also have to adopt your method after paying this month's electricity bill as well.

Maybe if you follow my tipps and stop trying to waste electricity hoping to get the 6.6 bitcoins haha...

Yes, go a head let's beg Satoshi together. Eventually maybe he'll react to us and throw at us some bitcoins.

We all know he's here on the thread reading our posts secretly. If he wasn't reading the posts here, he surely wouldn't have funded his puzzle addresses again by 10x.

[citb0in]

Yes, go a head let's beg Satoshi together. Eventually maybe he'll react to us and throw at us some bitcoins.

begging for what? he has already donated dozens of bitcoins worth over a million dollars. They are just lying around and need to be collected. It's not that hard to do. Use your brain and get the coins if you have earned them.