Would you kill your own children if God commanded you to?

[Buffer Overflow]

Would you kill your own children if God commanded you to?
A perfectly valid legit question.

Please no attempts to derail the thread with nonsense like "God would never say that" or "God would never change the rules with murder" etc....

[darkangel11]

No, I wouldn't. If you're referring to the story of Abraham, if I remember correctly, it was said there that he attempted to kill his son because he was so afraid of god.
I'm not a religious person, but even If I were, the times have changed and people are no longer scared of the Old Testament god that was shown as a strict ruler and a being of power that liked to receive gifts in the form of sacrifices and didn't like when people worshipped other fake gods. This story wasn't really working out for the church in modern times.

[muffinbiller]

Would you kill your own children if God commanded you to?
A perfectly valid legit question.

Please no attempts to derail the thread with nonsense like "God would never say that" or "God would never change the rules with murder" etc....

Yes I would Kill them If God Asked. I'm not saying it will be easy taking the life of your own children. It is the most hardest thing to do. But here we are to Worship God.God Love us very much and for a Fact that he would not ask me in the first place.I would Obey him without questions.He is the one who created me from dust.

[yoseph]

In this modern day no God will command anyone to kill his son

[Mometaskers]

If I were religious it would probably be a yes. As already exemplified by Abraham, G values loyalty and obedience and those who fail to give it suffer - even if the request seem illogical or even cruel, such as murdering children.

Why is why I'm glad I'm no longer religious...

Would you kill your own children if God commanded you to?
A perfectly valid legit question.

Please no attempts to derail the thread with nonsense like "God would never say that" or "God would never change the rules with murder" etc....

Yes I would Kill them If God Asked. I'm not saying it will be easy taking the life of your own children. It is the most hardest thing to do. But here we are to Worship God.God Love us very much and for a Fact that he would not ask me in the first place.I would Obey him without questions.He is the one who created me from dust.

You mean if you hear a voice speak to you "Go kill this person and that..." you would obey without questions? Would you at least ask why or try to negotiate a deal a la Lot? Wouldn't you go to the doctor first to have your self, especially your brain, checked? Would you not at least google schizophrenia where people can't distinguish the source of thoughts, attributing internal to external? Who knows maybe you have the late-onset variety.

Oh, don't go anywhere near me or my family...

[Buffer Overflow]

In this modern day no God will command anyone to kill his son

Explain why? What's modern day got to do with anything? Every point in time is "modern day" to the people of that particular point in time.

[Janation]

If God commanded me too, obviously I will be asking why, what is the reason why we need to kill our child. And even if he answers me, I will never do it. That is child, my flesh and blood, I will not kill him just like that,and if He is a real God that we know of,he will not command it to us. The God himself said that we need to mulitply.

[digaran]

It's over dude no more God asking from people sending archangel to tell them what to do, it was only a test for one prophet it wasn't meant to be repeated, keep wishing for God to ask us but it wont happen.

Back then people used to sacrifice other people to please false gods but the one true God then asked one of his prophets and then stopped him to make an example that God doesn't really need people to sacrifice other humans and if it was him asking He would've stopped them just like He did.

God if wants sacrifice is for people to sacrifice sheep and feed orphans, poor and the hungry otherwise there is no actual need for such sacrifices.

Just like when Egyptians used to worship a son god Isis or something where they believed that he was the son of their god, then one true God created Jesus without male sperm to tell those idiots that He can do whatever He wants, now see which son became more popular? the fake Egyptian one or the real human one?

To answer your question, yes of course I would've without blinking because the God I know would provide me a way out before doing so.

[hermanhs09]

Would you kill your own children if God commanded you to?
A perfectly valid legit question.

Please no attempts to derail the thread with nonsense like "God would never say that" or "God would never change the rules with murder" etc....

Of course I would.

Only if i'm certain that the god is legitimate, and not someone random posing as god.

If God controls everything there must be a meaning of his command.

Obviously, it's sad to see yoru children go but again, it's what has created you said.

[Okurkabinladin]

Would you kill your own children if God commanded you to?
A perfectly valid legit question.

Please no attempts to derail the thread with nonsense like "God would never say that" or "God would never change the rules with murder" etc....

Whoever would DEMAND that is not a God, unless you worship Satan with unhealthy dose of heroin on top.

Stop asking manipulative questions, cameltoe.

But I see you already got enough autists eager to participate in this brain dead "what would you do" game. The asnwer is still "nothing", you dont know what would you say to your girlfriend if she noticed you of impending abortion, much less some voices you hear through misuse of drugs.

[crairezx20]

I think that thing is not in 10 commandments instead you can see there that don't kill so i think if you heard that in your mind and not a god better to dont do what they said and i think they are not god and maybe they are satanism. so be careful for that because its a big sin..

[Tyrantt]

In this day and age that would be considered schizophrenia.

Of course I would.

Only if i'm certain that the god is legitimate, and not someone random posing as god.

If God controls everything there must be a meaning of his command.

Obviously, it's sad to see yoru children go but again, it's what has created you said.

Dude, I have bad news for you. If you seriously think like this, you should be in a mental hospital. Even the thought of killing your own child just because god told you to is sad...

Obviously, it's sad to see yoru children go but again, it's what has created you said

lol "Obviously"... like that's a normal everyday thing. It's sad that you'd kill your own child. Well you created your child so does that make you his god?

[squatz1]

I know some people are probably going to come on this thread and say something along the lines of "Yes, because God knows the plan in the end" or something along those lines but I probably wouldn't be listening to god on this one, for godsake these children would be my flesh and bones and I wouldn't be able to do something like this without regretting it forever.

I'm not too religious and maybe this could simply be playing a factor in all of this as I don't feel a large connection to God even though I do beleive he is there, this is just something that I couldn't do for him and he'd have to just take it and understand.

So, no.

[Okurkabinladin]

In this day and age that would be considered schizophrenia.

Of course I would.

Only if i'm certain that the god is legitimate, and not someone random posing as god.

If God controls everything there must be a meaning of his command.

Obviously, it's sad to see yoru children go but again, it's what has created you said.

Dude, I have bad news for you. If you seriously think like this, you should be in a mental hospital. Even the thought of killing your own child just because god told you to is sad...

Obviously, it's sad to see yoru children go but again, it's what has created you said

lol "Obviously"... like that's a normal everyday thing. It's sad that you'd kill your own child. Well you created your child so does that make you his god?

And you can join him in the same ward, if you even take this question seriously 

The only God that ever wanted parents to sacrifice their children and vice versa was communism as practiced by Soviet Union, later China and nowadays left liberals ruling western Europe.

All abrahamic religions respect family unit as untouchable, basically promising hell to those who would disturb it from the outside.

[Sithara007]

This is a very stupid question. Who is going to harm their own children for some imaginary god? Although I identify myself as a Hindu, I am not that crazy to believe that god must be pleased with the murder of humans.

[Buffer Overflow]

Whoever would DEMAND that is not a God

Says who? You? Are you saying you know every facet of God's thoughts and ideas?

Stop asking manipulative questions, cameltoe.

No manipulative questions here. Uncomfortable question I agree, but uncomfortable doesn't make it manipulative or invalid.
So essentially what you just said was "Stop asking uncomfortable questions, cameltoe."
Stepping out of you're comfort zone once in a while will do you no harm. Trust me. In fact, it's a good thing.

Only on post #10 and the name calling trolls have started already.  

But I see you already got enough autists eager to participate in this brain dead "what would you do" game.

What's autism got to do with this thread?  

The asnwer is still "nothing"

Doing nothing is the same and answering no.

you dont know what would you say to your girlfriend if she noticed you of impending abortion

I do know and I know the response as well.

[bryant.coleman]

I was shocked to see one vote in favor of the first option. The person who voted for it must be sent to mental hospital, as he is a danger not only for himself, bu also for the other humans. This is one of the examples where ultra-religiosity develops in to some form of psychosis and schizophrenia. God is a hallucination. If someone is ready to take a human life as a result of this hallucination, then it is a very serious issue. 

[Buffer Overflow]

I was shocked to see one vote in favor of the first option.

Not sure if they was trolling or not with that vote.
Let's hope the authorites are monitoring them so they can respond quickley if that person starts doing anything silly.

[Slow death]

In this day and age that would be considered schizophrenia.

 


No. I'm not religious, but supposing God asked me to kill my son or kill anybody, I would not do that.

I have always helped people in need and i do not ask these people to do anything for me.

People help others and should not expect to be compensated for helping someone.

I think if there was a god, he should think so.

[Berns]

I would send God to hell! After all, these are my children and I have to protect them from death.