Would you kill your own children if God commanded you to?

[FreelaBit]

man, this is one of the most twisted threads on this forums, here you can see how fckd up is our world, like all of these mindless people telling that they will follow a voice on their heads, cmmon people start taking your schizo meds asap, instead of killing your children do humanity a favor and kill yourselves, Im sure your "god" will smile at that.

Peace.

[rey.fudz15]

by far the best question about religion and belief, we should respect each others belief. but in my opinion, i would not do that, because i know God will never let to ask such thing

[prettyij]

If i would kill.my own children if God.commanded me to do so! Yes i will if is my maker ...He gave his only begotten son to die for me and that of my children....He shown us love first.

[Bram 666]

if God commanded you to?
yes because God is creator and who give me child and can give me other

[chelle5]

No.I can not do it even if He says.I cant hurt them.Much more killing them.

[gabmen]

If i would kill.my own children if God.commanded me to do so! Yes i will if is my maker ...He gave his only begotten son to die for me and that of my children....He shown us love first.

Isn't that a bit contradictory by itself? He's shown you love first, sacrificed his son for you, then commands you to kill your child? I wouldn't do it for anyone for any reason

[achikomimi]

If God would test my faith and will command me to obey my child, I won't have any second thought but to obey him. I know God has its purpose why He tells me to do that. and I trust Him. There's a story in the Bible that one disciple was commanded by God to kill his son, and he didn't hesitate. He do what God tells him then when He put the knife onto the child, when he looked it's a sheep. God won't let us to be in the wrong path. We just have to trust and him and have faith.

[chelle5]

Why will God command you to do so.To test your faith??I am not willing to sacrifice my child without any reason.only a heartless person and mother would be able to kill their own.

[falafelnut]

I saw few occations when people did like that. that terrible and they really said that God told it to do that. But I think its a bullshit. These people just nuts.
I won't do that

[denulh]

i will never do that, it is so wrong when parent want to kill our own children, like god want to kill all human, god love his child very much and so do i, i will never do such such a crazy thing.

[farida_y323]

off course ..as a muslim i will always prepare to obey my god`s command..if that will kill my own children or myself or anybody

[GOODNESS]

The question is if God  commanded me to kill my children, and i pray and confirm really is God that has commanded me to do that, i will obey him and carry out is commandment.The God i know will never visit any of His Children with Evil.If I may ask who gave the children to me, It is God, so why should i Disobey Him. Abraham obeyed God and God called Abraham not to lay his hands on the Lad. And He provided an alternative, What actually God want to see in us is our obedient to his words and commandments. Abraham and Isaac  did not commit sin, that led God to ask  Abraham to sacrifice his only son Isaac, also it was not the sin of Job that make God to allow all the children to perish at the time and date.

[mikel00]

no i dont kill my own children even if god command it because its your own blood and your own child  there's saying child is innocent we dont have the right take them away

[topse]

wow ! surprising question.
i never thought to kill my children.
and i don't believe that god will ask us to do it. because i know that i'm not the prophet.
i have ever known the story from one prophet in muslim, that he obey what god says.
one day god asked him to kill his son.
then he was doubt at the time. but that dream happened till three  times.
that's why he believe that it's from god.
then he did it.
before the sword touch his son's neck, god change son's position with sheep.
it means that, god just want check his belief.
 

[Ardan17]

no, because it can not be a loving god. Killing your own child in any way includes a big sin. Both kill him after the child is born into this world or still in the womb of his mother by way of abortion or the other.

[Gagayalano123]

No. I won't listen to God. My son/daughter is everything to me. Why would I kill him/her if with just a blink of his eye, he could kill someone? I'd rather rot in hell than killing my own kin.

[kodes88]

That is the command given by God to the prophet Ibrahim in the past and so great his Faith to God, he was willing, he was ready to slaughter his own son, the prophet Ismail. And the prophet Ismail was willing. But I do not feel I would be willing if God told me to do that too, I doubt will be willing.

[spongegar]

Would you kill your own children if God commanded you to?
A perfectly valid legit question.

Please no attempts to derail the thread with nonsense like "God would never say that" or "God would never change the rules with murder" etc....

It doesn't make sense but what He plans we cannot and may not comprehend. So yes, if God really wanted me to then i would do it, to the letter. I don't think my child's death in God's plan will bear fruit on my lifetime or even the lifetime of my neighbors, but i know it will bear fruit for the future generation. Also, it doesn't mean i won't be sad or feel bad.

[androidpobeditel]

Would you kill your own children if God commanded you to?
A perfectly valid legit question.

Please no attempts to derail the thread with nonsense like "God would never say that" or "God would never change the rules with murder" etc....

This is a very, very difficult question. But although I love them madly: maybe - Yes.
It's just that God did not ask for it, but only for a great purpose!

[Aladdin-Sane-83]

If I hear voices, I'd go to the doctor as soon as possible. Unbelievable what some people say here. We live in the year 2017, soon 2018, some are stuck in the dark age...