smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 09:36:32 AM |
|
...
Of course since everything is open source you can't hard code anything really, since people can just modify it or take it out.
Not if you are putting it in the blockchain. The blockchain is only validated by the software people use. If people modify the software, we can't prevent that at all, nor would we even try to force anything on the community. This is getting a bit off topic though, but I'd encourage you to read http://hackingdistributed.com/2014/06/19/bitcoin-and-voting-power/ (even though I don't 100% agree with it -- but it gets at the relevant issues). Ultimately we can't put anything in the blockchain, only you, the community can do that.
|
|
|
|
|
user2
Member


Activity: 92
Merit: 10
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 09:56:37 AM |
|
...
This is getting a bit off topic though
Okay, to stay on the topic. I'm community as you rightly noted and I'm a miner and I think that's a great idea. To split (or tax or whatever) block reward to finance development or whatever the said community deems necessary. If only the proceeds would go to some special address and can be spent by some voting system hardcoded in the client (and some special transaction put in the blockchain). Something akin multisig only for all coin holders . If community can't decide on what she wants money is unspent, no harm done. Edit grammar
|
▒ NOW token ▒ by ChangeNOW ▒ Get the WIN! ▒ ChangeNOW - an instant Non-custodial Exchange Service (( changenow.io ))
|
|
|
fluffypony
Donator
Legendary

Activity: 1274
Merit: 1069
GetMonero.org / MyMonero.com
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 10:25:38 AM |
|
Okay, to stay on the topic. I'm community as you rightly noted and I'm a miner and I think that's a great idea. To split (or tax or whatever) block reward to finance development or whatever the said community deems necessary. If only the proceeds would go to some special address and can be spent by some voting system hardcoded in the client (and some special transaction put in the blockchain). Something akin multisig only for all coin holders . If community can't decide on what she wants money is unspent, no harm done.
Edit grammar
The problem is that in these early stages we (as in the core team) need to take the role of "benevolent dictator". The reason is that "design by consensus" has never worked - invariably someone or some group will be able to swing the vote in favour of what "they" want. By having a "benevolent dictator" that the community trusts will act in the best interested of the cryptocurrency (and not in the best interests of individuals with voting / buying power), AND who will revert a change / proposition if there is sufficient kickback, you allow for a more unified vision to be realised. As a core team we have a pretty concrete vision, but it's hard to put it down on paper and look ahead when we're scrabbling to fix urgent things right now. What I think would work is for us to raise funding to sort out the short-term urgent issues, and then longer-term we can raise funds for specific features / aspects.
|
|
|
|
XDO
Newbie

Activity: 17
Merit: 0
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 10:35:54 AM |
|
Haven't heard anything on per kb fees for a while. The current high transaction fees are really damaging mining profitability for small miners like me, and are also exposing us to greater risk as we move coins to the exchange less frequently.
It would be great if the new fee structure could be implemented sooner rather than later. I see lots of check-ins recently implementing the TestNet, hopefully this is the last necessary prerequisite for the change in fees?
|
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 10:39:08 AM Last edit: September 18, 2014, 11:00:54 AM by smooth |
|
It would be great if the new fee structure could be implemented sooner rather than later. I see lots of check-ins recently implementing the TestNet, hopefully this is the last necessary prerequisite for the change in fees?
Yes, exactly. We need to test the per-KB fees code on a testnet. The code for per-KB fees has been largely done for a while, but we're not going to release it without testing. (We've been fairly lucky about releasing some changes without a testnet before, largely out of necessity, but let's not press our luck.) EDIT: typo testing->testnet
|
|
|
|
|
XDO
Newbie

Activity: 17
Merit: 0
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 10:56:39 AM |
|
Yes, exactly. We need to test the per-KB fees code on a testnet. The code for per-KB fees has been largely done for a while, but we're not going to release it without testing. (We've been fairly lucky about releasing some changes without a testing before, largely out of necessity, but let's not press our luck.)
Great. Thanks for the update. Hope the testing goes without a hitch.
|
|
|
|
|
oda.krell
Legendary

Activity: 1470
Merit: 1007
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 11:34:17 AM |
|
plus 1 for classical fundraising, minus... a lot for a forkraiser. As if we don't have enough detractors, just imagine what will happen if we build a payout into the protocol.
Who exactly is detracting BBR for it? I think we will have detractors for being (slightly) successful no matter what we do. I don't think the mining fundraiser is necessarily a bad idea nor would have any material change on the degree of hate directed against us. Got no problem with an optional payout (and even setting it to non-zero as default in the official client). The proposal I reacted to made no mention of it being a setting, i.e. optional, however.
|
Not sure which Bitcoin wallet you should use? Get Electrum!Electrum is an open-source lightweight client: fast, user friendly, and 100% secure. Download the source or executables for Windows/OSX/Linux/Android from, and only from, the official Electrum homepage.
|
|
|
|
SlyWax
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 12:19:11 PM |
|
Today In POW cryptocurrency, we give the money creation to the people that are securing the network. So how this money is distributed : - Chipset makers - Electricity - Cloud server service - Miner margins In the beginning the miners margin is big ( using already owned hardware, idle cycle, not a lot of concurrence, etc... ), then when the coin get noticed, the miner margin tend to shrink. Why is that ? Well mainly because there is no human value added in mining (basically you set up your node and the rest is just computer running), so you can scale it up without much work. In this tread I read that the miner margin is around 5%. So that leaves us to 95% is given to actors that aren't involved in crypto at all. So when you are defending the miner part, you are basically defending this 95% ! But there is much more about a cryptocurrency than securing the network. And that bring us to development. Maybe it's time to realize that this money creation should be used to this extent too ! So setting a % of money creation to support development is the road to sustained growth of features and code security.The problem is, we have a commonly accepted way of distributing money to the network securer (you should note that I didn't say fair, because the more it goes the less it's fair), but not yet for the developers part. So the next step would be to figure out an acceptable way of distributing the developer incentive. And that would be the subject of another post.  SlyWax.
|
|
|
|
|
infofront
Legendary

Activity: 2688
Merit: 3150
Shitcoin Minimalist
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 12:40:48 PM |
|
As a miner myself, I would support a small mining tax. We could see how a crowd funding approach works first though.
|
|
|
|
|
binaryFate
Legendary

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1012
Still wild and free
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 12:46:50 PM |
|
... a small mining tax ...
That sounds awfully altcoinish.
|
Monero's privacy and therefore fungibility are MUCH stronger than Bitcoin's. This makes Monero a better candidate to deserve the term "digital cash".
|
|
|
fluffypony
Donator
Legendary

Activity: 1274
Merit: 1069
GetMonero.org / MyMonero.com
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 01:00:47 PM |
|
Got no problem with an optional payout (and even setting it to non-zero as default in the official client).
The proposal I reacted to made no mention of it being a setting, i.e. optional, however.
Ah ok, so just to make sure everyone's on the same page, this is the screenshot from the Missive:  The idea was to make it "ticked" by default, and it's a per-wallet setting, but if people want to disable it or increase/decrease the percentage they can at any time. Before the GUI is even released, though, we wanted to add this in to simplewallet / rpcwallet - again, prompted during wallet creation, and configurable at any time. Now I know this seems like a small amount, and it won't do much difference, and you're right. This is not going to satisfy the immediate and large funding requirements. Which is why this is more of a longer-term thing to make sure we always have budget for ongoing efforts / maintenance. It does not preclude fundraising for specific features / tasks.
|
|
|
|
oda.krell
Legendary

Activity: 1470
Merit: 1007
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 01:14:36 PM |
|
Got no problem with an optional payout (and even setting it to non-zero as default in the official client).
The proposal I reacted to made no mention of it being a setting, i.e. optional, however.
Ah ok, so just to make sure everyone's on the same page, this is the screenshot from the Missive:  The idea was to make it "ticked" by default, and it's a per-wallet setting, but if people want to disable it or increase/decrease the percentage they can at any time. Before the GUI is even released, though, we wanted to add this in to simplewallet / rpcwallet - again, prompted during wallet creation, and configurable at any time. Now I know this seems like a small amount, and it won't do much difference, and you're right. This is not going to satisfy the immediate and large funding requirements. Which is why this is more of a longer-term thing to make sure we always have budget for ongoing efforts / maintenance. It does not preclude fundraising for specific features / tasks. Has my support, as long as it will always remain optional. Leaving it as 'opt-out' is also fine with me, we're adults who should be able to read/decide 
|
Not sure which Bitcoin wallet you should use? Get Electrum!Electrum is an open-source lightweight client: fast, user friendly, and 100% secure. Download the source or executables for Windows/OSX/Linux/Android from, and only from, the official Electrum homepage.
|
|
|
oda.krell
Legendary

Activity: 1470
Merit: 1007
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 01:16:36 PM |
|
Quote and my response from the speculation thread, where it was off-topic (thanks smooth for the heads-up) In my opinion the emission schedule should be decreased by 50 %. For example, the current block reward is around 14 xmr - better to change it to 7 xmr. It will help the dumping pressure and gives nice and steady growth for the coin. The existing balances and total number of coins should not be touched but just give 100 % more time for the rest of emission.
Some would call it a community-fastmine. Not like I'm saying it's fundamentally bad, but it doesn't look clean. If something like that were to be done, and I'm not saying it is even on the table, it would have to be for better reasons, like the long term viability of the coin. Every time the issue has come up, though, it is always presented as a way to manipulate the market. That is a total non-starter. We could convert to a PoS shitcoin if we wanted, and not have to deal with any dumping at all. There is zero interest in doing that. Move on to one of the 1000+ of those if you want to be free from dumping. Alright, I'd like to chip in on that. Preliminary remark: Please assume good faith in what is about to follow. You can sometimes react a bit too abrasively - understandable given the constant attacks against this project, but not necessarily always a justified reaction to what you respond to. a) There are good reasons for thinking that a different emission would be desirable, put forward by members of this community that are not interested in a quick p&d, but instead have a long-term interest in this project. Note: I am not saying they are necessarily better than the arguments of the opposing side, but they are not all to be dismissed as "pump and dumpers GTFO". b) No one in his right mind is suggesting a quick curve change to prevent price from dropping. This is not supposed to be a quick fix to a temporary problem (like a flash crash), if it were to considered. It is a complex question that has to be seriously discussed before considering implementing it. c) The April vote made it clear that there would be a very real problem with a 'smooth' curve switch, in the sense that it would require somehow giving back coins that were mined "ahead" of the new curve. I am going to go out on a limb here and say that's not really a realistic option anymore. d) Which would mean a change in the emission curve would be discontinuous, should it come to that. Which, correctly mentioned here already, would possibly open up the door to "community fast-mine" accusations coming from outside (and maybe even inside, by community members that came here later). I am not convinced if that is the end of it, though: I still think that, should the community / economic majority favor a change in emission, referring back to that community choice would leave those accusation mostly impotent, but I understand that there are now two open questions: - do we want a change in emission? (if so, what are the pros/cons?) - can we afford a change in emssion? (as in: will the negative reactions be prohibitively expensive).
|
Not sure which Bitcoin wallet you should use? Get Electrum!Electrum is an open-source lightweight client: fast, user friendly, and 100% secure. Download the source or executables for Windows/OSX/Linux/Android from, and only from, the official Electrum homepage.
|
|
|
|
nakaone
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 01:21:45 PM |
|
"benevolent dictator"
I think this cannot be overquoted - anomymint wrote some very reasonable posts about the importance of this role in the beginning of projects. I think the 1% solution for financing development is fair. that said I am not a miner but an investor and I think it is as crucial to design a system for investors not to freeride. maybe less utopian is a system which inventivecises non-free riding. I have a few ideas about that but little time.
|
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 01:22:07 PM |
|
- do we want a change in emission? (if so, what are the pros/cons?)
- can we afford a change in emssion? (as in: will the negative reactions be prohibitively expensive).
I'd say we have bigger fish to fry right now, like getting the development moving at a faster pace than it has for the past six months. If we can make that happen then we can take up this question at a later time. I agree with your general framework for asking the question.
|
|
|
|
|
|
skunk
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 01:22:59 PM |
|
imho we should incentivate donations instead of begging for donations... what about a weekly lottery where participating cost you eg. 1 xmr and the winner gets eg. 50% of the jackpot and the remaining 50% goes to developers? we could use the block hash to choose the winner like fairpumps.net is doing for choosing the coin to pump (just an idea)... it would be even better if it could be implemented directly into the gui (just to incentivate a little more the developers to finally release it  ). what do you think?
|
|
|
|
|
Triffin
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 01:37:34 PM |
|
You're making this harder than it needs to be .. Take a page from Wall Street ..
You can't have a successful project without adequate funding ..
How much money do you need ? When do you need it ? Is this a 'one off' funding request or an ongoing funding requirement ?
The easiest and quickest solution is a small secondary offering .. If you want to call it an 'instamine' then so be it .. Bottom line you've got devs that need to be paid and projects that need to get done ..
Take 100,000 Monero out of the back-end of the emmissions curve and sell them now at a slight discount to current market prices ..
Most current XMR holders will buy a 'proportional share' of the offering to maintain or increase their ownership position in the coin .. and you'll be offering new investors a chance to get in at a slight discount ..
Considering the development pace in Cryptoland you can't afford to wait ..
Triff ..
|
|
|
|
|
myagui
Legendary

Activity: 1154
Merit: 1001
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 01:38:00 PM |
|
Rounding things up, it looks like we can/will fund development by: - mining at a pool with a % going to development fund - donate on personal initiative (thus joining the hall of fame) - by setting up a donation % on top of transaction fees, soon(tm)
Initiatives like MEW might/will come up with their own funding strategies as well. As stated upthread, nothing precludes a crowd funding initiative that might take place.
I think this already gives participants from all quadrants, the opportunity to take their part in assuring that development doesn't stagnate and is properly rewarded. Not all these bits are fully in motion yet, so it looks like we don't have a realistic funding quantification at this time.
There's one participant in particular that benefits largely from the Monero community, and should be in a position to 'give a little back', and that is Poloniex, which has an apparent dramatic increase in popularity and trading activity, in no small part thanks to Monero. Just my 2 cents, but I think that it would be great if they would donate a small % of their Monero trading fees to the development fund.
@ fluffy: I don't know if this has been considered yet, but perhaps it is worthwhile having a couple of different development fund accounts, in order to separate donation sources? I'm thinking that it would be useful, if long term, one could perform some statistical analysis on donations per source (% of donations made from pool fees, % of donations from individuals, % of auto-donations from the client software, etc).
Cheers, ~ Myagui
|
|
|
|
dEBRUYNE
Legendary

Activity: 2268
Merit: 1141
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 01:45:51 PM |
|
Got no problem with an optional payout (and even setting it to non-zero as default in the official client).
The proposal I reacted to made no mention of it being a setting, i.e. optional, however.
Ah ok, so just to make sure everyone's on the same page, this is the screenshot from the Missive:  The idea was to make it "ticked" by default, and it's a per-wallet setting, but if people want to disable it or increase/decrease the percentage they can at any time. Before the GUI is even released, though, we wanted to add this in to simplewallet / rpcwallet - again, prompted during wallet creation, and configurable at any time. Now I know this seems like a small amount, and it won't do much difference, and you're right. This is not going to satisfy the immediate and large funding requirements. Which is why this is more of a longer-term thing to make sure we always have budget for ongoing efforts / maintenance. It does not preclude fundraising for specific features / tasks. Isn't it possible to make such a thing for mining also? Something like: auto-donate 1% of block-reward to development fund. Miners that would like to contribute enable the option and miners that won't just put it off. Sorry if this was already proposed, not enough time to read through the thread.
|
|
|
|
|
nakaone
|
 |
September 18, 2014, 01:46:11 PM |
|
There's one participant in particular that benefits largely from the Monero community, and should be in a position to 'give a little back', and that is Poloniex, which has an apparent dramatic increase in popularity and trading activity, in no small part thanks to Monero. Just my 2 cents, but I think that it would be great if they would donate a small % of their Monero trading fees to the development fund.
I also thought about poloniex role in this process but did not come to a proper solution. there are basically two scenarios: 1.) busoni keeps his place as basically the monopoly of xmr trading - in this situation he should support xmr in the best possible way. I think if he does this position would be self enforcing. 2.) a bigger exchange overtakes his position (btc-e?), in this case he would be worse off. that said - it could be a marketing idea of an exchange to say it funds the development of xmr
|
|
|
|
|
|