Cast Your Vote for your favourite Physical Bitcoin Designs – Ends 18th November

[Sarahiko]

Many of us feel cheated because of the vote system friends vote for friends. if only Mr. Coinographic have a staff or people behind him that can help him decide which one of the many submitted design can win the first place, all of this commotion would not happen. but i guess this how it is, so good luck to everyone  It sucks having no friends no vote for my design 

[1714763920]

1714763920

[1714763920]

1714763920

[1714763920]

1714763920

[1714763920]

1714763920

[1714763920]

1714763920

[1714763920]

1714763920

[JLynn171]

Design 9 by rugratz Gold

[Conqueror]

Many of us feel cheated because of the vote system friends vote for friends. if only Mr. Coinographic have a staff or people behind him that can help him decide which one of the many submitted design can win the first place, all of this commotion would not happen. but i guess this how it is, so good luck to everyone   It sucks having no friends no vote for my design  

I can be your friend maybe? I am so lonely in this cruel world

[Kimax]

Gold: Design Six by LitcoinCollector
Siver: Design Nine by LitcoinCollector

[Rollin.io]

Gold - Design Three by iawgoM
Silver - Design Nine by LitcoinCollector

[MrBAU]

I see I have no vote for the silver design yet others have people voting both designs the same time.
Am I or others who don't get a double vote bad designers and shouldn't do designs at all?

On another note, don't know what they said and I don't care, just want to point out the threads.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=850381.msg9466615#msg9466615
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=25215.msg9436877#msg9436877

[AT101ET]

There is something fishy going on.
I just got a PM from a user offering to sell me 32 votes for the competition.
Disgraceful.

[iawgoM]

I see I have no vote for the silver design yet others have people voting both designs the same time.
Am I or others who don't get a double vote bad designers and shouldn't do designs at all?

On another note, don't know what they said and I don't care, just want to point out the threads.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=850381.msg9466615#msg9466615
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=25215.msg9436877#msg9436877

Use Google translate before whining. You're still winning afaik...

[MrBAU]

I see I have no vote for the silver design yet others have people voting both designs the same time.
Am I or others who don't get a double vote bad designers and shouldn't do designs at all?

On another note, don't know what they said and I don't care, just want to point out the threads.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=850381.msg9466615#msg9466615
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=25215.msg9436877#msg9436877

Use Google translate before whining. You're still winning afaik...

Mr. iawgoM like I said I don't care what's in the post, the intention is what's bothering me.
This is not the first time you and some like you do competitions like this.

It's clear to all that even if you ask someone whom you have work before to go in this thread and vote for who he wants, that that vote will go to the one who worked with.
And the examples can go on.
I'm not whining like you imply it's just bothering me.

But I'm not in any position to do anything so I'm pointing out the obvious.

[bonksnp2]

Many of us feel cheated because of the vote system friends vote for friends. if only Mr. Coinographic have a staff or people behind him that can help him decide which one of the many submitted design can win the first place, all of this commotion would not happen. but i guess this how it is, so good luck to everyone  It sucks having no friends no vote for my design 

They tried this during the last competition and everyone who wasn't in the top 5 flipped out so voting was opened to all designs.

Original 5 Finalists Thread - https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=764623.0
Everyone is a Finalist Thread - https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=765337.0

Additionally, Coinographic has already stated that pointing others to the contest is fine as long as voters are not enticed.  I haven't personally done this, mostly because enticement is a huge gray area.  Plus I'd rather lose honestly than win dishonestly, but if I understand correctly it is allowed.

Should entrants refrain from pointing others to vote in this contest? I understand this can be a gray area, but the more clarification we can get on this the better.

Pointing others to vote in the contest is fine so long as voters are not enticed

We would all do well to remember that this is Coinographics contest and that they are contributing something to the community not many others can.  In fact, I don't know of any other Bit/Lite/Doge/etc coin producer who lets the community design AND decide on what coins get made.  If your design isn't getting votes, it's not necessarily because no-one likes it, it's because they like at least one other design a bit more.  Let the contest run its course and Coinographic decide what's fair and whats not.  he did for the last contest and I see no reason why he wouldn't for this one.

[jcoin200]

We would all do well to remember that this is Coinographics contest and that they are contributing something to the community not many others can.  In fact, I don't know of any other Bit/Lite/Doge/etc coin producer who lets the community design AND decide on what coins get made.  If your design isn't getting votes, it's not necessarily because no-one likes it, it's because they like at least one other design a bit more.  Let the contest run its course and Coinographic decide what's fair and whats not.  he did for the last contest and I see no reason why he wouldn't for this one.

Yes it seems like at the end of the day this is how Coinographic wants the contest to go.  Hopefully they are happy with the design that wins as they will be the ones spending their time and money to produce it and sell it.  Also hopefully any problems with the contest set up doesn't leave a bad taste in anyones mouth about the company/its products...

Seems like they could open voting to the public, and then they could choose a design to create from the top 3 vote recipients.  I know I would want the final say if I was going to mint a coin.

[iawgoM]

Mr. iawgoM like I said I don't care what's in the post, the intention is what's bothering me.
This is not the first time you and some like you do competitions like this.

Sorry Mr. BAU, but that just makes no sense, to say that you don't care what's in the post. I only informed people that there is voting, and specifically mentioned that I'm not asking people to vote for me, but any design they liked. Intention was to advertise the competition. I'd prefer to see 100s of people voting instead of just a few random persons who are passing by. That way we'd really get the best picture on what people like or don't like.

What, we should hide the effing voting thread in your opinion? Gimme a break. I've had enough of this crap in last contest and I'm tired of constantly defending myself. What do you all want? People to apologize to you every time someone gets a vote?

Should entrants refrain from pointing others to vote in this contest? I understand this can be a gray area, but the more clarification we can get on this the better.

Pointing others to vote in the contest is fine so long as voters are not enticed

This actually concludes everything. I won't discuss this further with you or anyone else.

I see I have no vote for the silver design yet others have people voting both designs the same time.

I'm not whining like you imply it's just bothering me.

Sorry, maybe I've misinterpreted the message above. Seemed to me like you are wondering and complaining how come noone voted for your silver design. To be honest, I think you really deserved to win 5 BTC design, it was far better than any other, and had a meaning, message of some kind. You are obviously very talented designer, and your two entries for both silver and gold coins look wonderful...but...they just don't have that "something" that 5 BTC design had...I don't know. Still, you are in the lead with gold coin if I counted well. Are you upset because you maybe won't win both this time? Do you think you are the only one who should have right to win all contests now or something? 10-15 BTC valued coin you won earlier isn't enough? Still plenty of time left...don't panic.

And please, leave this thread for voting...

[bithalo]

gold bonksnp2

I especially loved your 5 BTC gold design.  Would have loved to see that one again.

[bithalo]

silver iawgoM

[Saigonsmokes]

silver iawgoM

I just got this PM, I think this is starting to become a joke:

PolyCoin-Team
Jr. Member

« Sent to: Saigonsmokes on: November 11, 2014, 03:02:25 PM »
Reply with quoteQuote  ReplyReply  Remove this messageDelete 
Hi, are you interested in buying votes for the competition you have entered?
I can give you 32 votes in total - all active member accounts and higher.
PM me if interested.

[bithalo]

silver iawgoM

I just got this PM, I think this is starting to become a joke:

PolyCoin-Team
Jr. Member

« Sent to: Saigonsmokes on: November 11, 2014, 03:02:25 PM »
Reply with quoteQuote  ReplyReply  Remove this messageDelete  
Hi, are you interested in buying votes for the competition you have entered?
I can give you 32 votes in total - all active member accounts and higher.
PM me if interested.

I dont doubt what you say, but I can assure you, I'm voting for who I like best, and not being swayed by any member or thread.  Don't assume everybody voting is fraudulent.  The last 5 BTC gold coin voting was a complete mess, and its starting to feel the same way here all over again.

[bonksnp2]

gold bonksnp2

I especially loved your 5 BTC gold design.  Would have loved to see that one again.

I thought about it, but I wanted to challenge myself so I went a little outside my comfort zone.

Thanks for the kind words and the vote!

[bithalo]

gold bonksnp2

I especially loved your 5 BTC gold design.  Would have loved to see that one again.

I thought about it, but I wanted to challenge myself so I went a little outside my comfort zone.

Thanks for the kind words and the vote!

You're welcome.  I think you do great designs, and I'd love to see your earlier 5 BTC gold design show up in production somewhere.  

[Saigonsmokes]

silver iawgoM

I just got this PM, I think this is starting to become a joke:

PolyCoin-Team
Jr. Member

« Sent to: Saigonsmokes on: November 11, 2014, 03:02:25 PM »
Reply with quoteQuote  ReplyReply  Remove this messageDelete  
Hi, are you interested in buying votes for the competition you have entered?
I can give you 32 votes in total - all active member accounts and higher.
PM me if interested.

I dont doubt what you say, but I can assure you, I'm voting for who I like best, and not being swayed by any member or thread.  Don't assume everybody voting is fraudulent.  The last 5 BTC gold coin voting was a complete mess, and its starting to feel the same way here all over again.

Sorry I was not insinuating about you, i was supposed to press reply - not quote!

[AnonBitCoiner]

Gold Design : #14 by MrBAU