admins in bitfinex telegram - the matching engine is down, funds are safu
on proof of key day
coincidence
nothing to see
What do the people that watch the cold wallets say?
Any exchange cold wallets significantly impacted? Or proportionally more than the rest?
I am afraid that participation levels are not enough to actually get the job done that "proof of keys day" was designed to do.. (YET?)
Kinda tricky for exchanges running lending and margin trading too.
For it to truly work near on everyone needs to be on-board...
Really for it to work, exchanges need to fully participate, perhaps even force(?) encourage(?) customers to withdraw..
It would cut the chaff that is for sure.
That being said so far I heard that at one point or another in past 24 hours there have been questions surrounding Hitbtc suspending withdrawals, Kucoin had at one point suspended withdrawals, and Bitfinex has this glitch...(which despite the general sentiment around Finex, I tend to think is probably just a glitch, those guys have been under a fair bit of scrutiny of late (but who knows you never can tell) ................. anyone heard of any other potential incidents?
TBH there are some other exchnages that I would like to see stats from, for example CoineBene, Zb, and including Binance, Okex and Bithumb etc..
If anything it seems that proof of keys could be very effective, if not somewhat clunky and awkward, perhaps a even better way would simply to be to utilise the blockchain and have fully transparency of custody the entire time, you have control of your keys, right up until the moment you press "sell" in a decentralised custody solution, but with trades matched and cleared by a centralised trade engine..
It seems to me that fully decentralised exchanges, could have a tough time regulatory wise, though I guess compliance could be built in to dex too, but I think that for an exchange to be huge, and do serious volumes and integrate with the current ecosystem and the new evolving ecosystem, that it could be beneficial to have certain elements of an exchange centralised, from both a technical (speed) and a regulatory and management/security point of view..... and certain aspect of the exchange decentralised/distributed, for example custody// withdrawals and deposit functions
Then if the custody solution is either very transparent, or you maintain your keys until you enter a trade, then yearly proof of keys would not be needed... and indeed we can keep an even closer eye on the status of our assets..
This would greatly reduce the worry of an exchange rehypothecating our tokens, or of any fractional reserve practice or a straight up exit scam with everyone's denero
Nice and safu, more practical, technically feasible.