Do you trust Active telegram Groups?

[deathcode]

I don't really understand your criteria for active telegram groups. From what I know xfinance I think B, there is a lack of discussion about the project and some bots that are members of the telegram. For me an active telegram is a telegram that always discusses new developments or new information and members there have an average of 40% active in chat. Instead of that you also have to pay attention to people's responses to a project, so that you can analyze whether many users are satisfied with the developer or not.

projects that can manage their community well will of course get attention from the market. but some projects only fill their community groups with campaign participants who do not like to discuss projects and their progress. all they want to know is campaign updates, payments, and exchange updates. platform development will not be the main focus. those are most of the projects I see currently with group members over 10k.

[1713508237]

1713508237

[1713508237]

1713508237

[1713508237]

1713508237

[1713508237]

1713508237

[TIDOVEE]

Wether a project's telegram group is active or not is not what determines the success of the project, what is it the even makes a telegram group active? We discuss, ask questions and and get reply? Even some failed project telegram after a year is still active, people are there hoping it may still deliver at bull run. It's quite unfortunate that even when some projects have failed most of the telegram manager will never declare that they cannot meet up again. But we cannot because of the unsuccessful ones avoid the effect of the telegram.

[Genemind]

Telegram activity doesn't determine the success of the project. There are telegram bounties and telegram bots that adds participants to a project randomly.  I would believe if the one who is active is the dev team it self, giving the community updates and news about their project and discussing future plans.

[Rikotin]

it doesn't really represent a good project or a yardstick to measure the success of a project, believe me, I've seen some active telegram groups paying their users to shill in the group to stay active and make it appear as though the project has Something going on. beware of this kind of project telegram groups.

[Dr.Osh]

Telegram activity doesn't determine the success of the project. There are telegram bounties and telegram bots that adds participants to a project randomly.  I would believe if the one who is active is the dev team it self, giving the community updates and news about their project and discussing future plans.

agree with this. taking into account the number of bots, and others also determine whether the telegram can be trusted. besides that, not all telegram groups are active because of positive activities, because quite a lot of me joined the crypto telegram group but have a lot of complaints in it.

[lepbagong]

it doesn't really represent a good project or a yardstick to measure the success of a project, believe me, I've seen some active telegram groups paying their users to shill in the group to stay active and make it appear as though the project has Something going on. beware of this kind of project telegram groups.

things that are very possible and understandable because in that way he can see that the number of participants in the telegram can determine how many are involved in the project, even though not all of them are active in asking questions related to the project, sometimes the person is just that.

There are many ways you can do, of course, to always look for loopholes to manipulate people into being interested, but I agree not to believe in telegram groups because it doesn't guarantee that.
the good thing is to return the interaction to the past, of course it will be more effective.

[matchi2011]

Telegram activity doesn't determine the success of the project. There are telegram bounties and telegram bots that adds participants to a project randomly.  I would believe if the one who is active is the dev team it self, giving the community updates and news about their project and discussing future plans.

This can be done and there's no questions about bot and paid chillers, unless the team are more active answering and updating everything inside the group and they are providing detailed information about them and the project itself.
You have to take a much closer look whenever you participate with any telegram group, most of the time when a trader follow or support project they are looking for more information about the developments, so from that point social media channels are mostly used to keep being updated.

[rahmatullah9305]

Each project has a telegram group.This is the normal process.Through this, everyone gets answers to their questions through this group.So I don't think it depends on the success or failure of any project.I think a successful team is needed for the success of any project.

Yes, that's true, but what we always see is that projects that have been successfully developed always provide activity in their telegram groups, and vice versa for projects that fail, so in these two ways we can judge that the activity of the telegram group really reflects the success of the project. built by the team, because they will always notify you about project developments as well as serve questions from members in the group.

[Reatim]

it doesn't really represent a good project or a yardstick to measure the success of a project, believe me, I've seen some active telegram groups paying their users to shill in the group to stay active and make it appear as though the project has Something going on. beware of this kind of project telegram groups.

I believe that this is based on experience?that even Paying to shill in groups are indeed?
I once got involved in close conversation in a
group and sometimes People judged me as a part of the team or even Paid to say good words towards the team and the project but that time this
 is what i see in them But sooner the group collapsed and the Project is now seems to be dying.
This is why i really denied Using and believing telegram groups because even How good they look?still scam or Shit will come majority.

[Fivestar4everMVP]

Having an active telegram group doesnt not tell wether a project is scam or not , there are some projects with active telegram groups but the participants are either scammers or the project itself is a scam, and their are others with active telegram group and are legit.

what i can tell you is that whatever project you want to invest money in , please research very well, if anything looks suspicious, ask about it and if their explanation or reaSON isnt satisfactory, see it as a red flag, there are many scam projects in crypto this days , one have to be very careful where one is putting money in.

[ArIMy11]

My analysis Results are here
A)  9%      successful projects with an Active telegram group
B)  6%      unsuccessful projects with an Active telegram group
C)  25%    unsuccessful projects
D)  60%    scam projects

I think project success is not measured through its telegram group or channel. I believe telegram group is created for easier dissimination of updates or announcement of important things about the project from the manager or the team who have created the campaign to the participants. Telegram is also a big help for members who have questions or concerns about unclear rules. I also make telegram group as a tool to become updated how the campaign is going. Yes some active telegram groups are non-sense but I think it is only because admins are not strict or maybe very busy so they have no time to monitor the telegram group.

[Wildwest]

If you want to join a project then do not see from telegram active only but you also have to see the team working on the project how they work if it fits the path they set then can only see the activeness of telegram, and you have already joined the Xfinane project then try to check the development of the project first if the team is always active then you will be lucky.

[Falconer]

Telegram is only a supporting factor to get to know the team and project development more closely, discussions about project development are the main reason telegrams are made for the public so you can find out the latest information updates quickly. Take advantage of telegrams to find project information that you need for investment considerations and don't be fooled by tens of thousands of members because they are fake members and members of the campaign. I haven't checked the xFinance telegram and hope you have a more detailed analysis before buying the coin.

[sallasvve]

Having an active telegram group doesnt not tell wether a project is scam or not , there are some projects with active telegram groups but the participants are either scammers or the project itself is a scam, and their are others with active telegram group and are legit.

what i can tell you is that whatever project you want to invest money in , please research very well, if anything looks suspicious, ask about it and if their explanation or reaSON isnt satisfactory, see it as a red flag, there are many scam projects in crypto this days , one have to be very careful where one is putting money in.

I agree. The mere fact of the presence or absence of an active telegram group cannot be an indicator of a Scam project or not. You need to carefully study all available information about the project.
However, in some cases, you can see from the first glance at the telegram group that the same people write paid posts there to create the appearance of activity.

[btc-facebook]

A project with an active telegram group activity is not a guarantee that the project will be successful in the future and have a bright future.
although indeed the success of a project depends on how much the project has an active community or supporting investors, but of course it must be by looking at the development of the team and also the project's marketing,
because without the right marketing, it will be difficult for the project to be known by many people.

[jdnthny]

Hi all , I'm a newbie in bitcointalk but not in Crypto field. I have about 6 Years of experience about this field.

As an Investor , Still i have a doubt with some active telegram groups. I have analysed so many projects and Most successful projects had an Active telegram Group.

So far I have analyzed 500+ projects before investment 

My analysis Results are here

A)  9%      successful projects with an Active telegram group
B)  6%      unsuccessful projects with an Active telegram group
C)  25%    unsuccessful projects
D)  60%    scam projects

But Now I have decided to invest for a projects having an Active Telegram group , But tell me your openion about these type of projects.
Project name --  Xfinance

Is it belongs to Which one ?[ A or B  ?]

I would agree to you especially nowadays that there are several telegram groups/channel that is just looking for catch newbies in the cryptoworld that they can take advantage. It is a very well said and a very nice statistics that will help especially newbies to be more vigilant in joining and participating telegram groups/channels.

[plr]

Sometimes it gives us more details how the project really works, ever since I promote and support projects thru telegram even they end up mostly a scam. Nothing to lose if I trust telegram I continue works here as one member or supporters.

Yes you can trust them but do not believe in all that they are saying you need to check the people behind the project what are their intention and the platform they are putting is it worth investing or they are just copying other platform, even if the telegram has 20 k or more members I don't just jump in easily.

[Swordsoffreedom]

It is true that the social media of a good project have to be active. But the success of a project cannot be verified based only on the telegram group, in most cases the members of the telegram group are hired. If you wanted to determine any good project then you have to look for that project's roadmap and their Activity on the base of their word. you have to see on the team members, if they are promising or not? Check to see if they have a whitepaper. you have to look about their security system and smart contact code. If everything is neat and clean then the project can be called good.

[Surrapatt]

Sometimes it gives us more details how the project really works, ever since I promote and support projects thru telegram even they end up mostly a scam. Nothing to lose if I trust telegram I continue works here as one member or supporters.

Yes, there is nothing to lose if we trust the telegram and the projects we support to be successful, but when the projects we support are delayed or not successful, then indirectly we will lose the time we have spent promoting them.

[sallasvve]

It is true that the social media of a good project have to be active. But the success of a project cannot be verified based only on the telegram group, in most cases the members of the telegram group are hired. If you wanted to determine any good project then you have to look for that project's roadmap and their Activity on the base of their word. you have to see on the team members, if they are promising or not? Check to see if they have a whitepaper. you have to look about their security system and smart contact code. If everything is neat and clean then the project can be called good.

All you need to know about the project is whether the team is going to implement it or is planning a Scam. And this, unfortunately, can not be found out not from social networks, nor from a white paper. You need to have experience and flair.