|
fonsie
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 08:08:22 AM |
|
It would be useful to know what percentage of requests for ETFs are denied by the SEC.
Why don't you suck on your thumb real hard, I'm sure you can come up with some numbers. Put those numbers on a pretty drawing and go tell people you see no economic sense in the SEC and ETF's. After you are done with that you can go to a candy shop and tell little children everything there is to know about dental hygiene, go to mc donalds with a sign that says it's bad for your health, go to the beach to talk about how bad the sun is for your skin, etc.. I'm sure you can come up with plenty more examples about things that lots of people like doing, except for you the grumpy old man that shouts behind closed doors to people walking on his lawn.
|
I decided to no longer use a signature, because people were trolling me about it.
|
|
|
|
Bitcoiner2015
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 10:23:49 AM |
|
Are there not massive Arbing opportunities for people here who trade 2nd market and normal exchanges? 50% for a quick in and out trade!?
|
|
|
|
|
NUFCrichard
Legendary

Activity: 1218
Merit: 1003
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 10:29:29 AM |
|
Updated(!) Puma Capital, LLC 100 38.00 Canaccord Genuity Inc 100 37.50 Citadel Securities 100 36.00 KCG Americas LLC 100 35.55 Maxim Group LLC 50000 35.00 Wedbush Securities Inc 100 31.50 Cantor Fitzgerald & Co 100 25.00 Merriman Curhan Ford & Co 100 20.00
Wow! So people outbid Maxim, already? Unfortunately 'only' with bids of 100 shares. Still, this is really impressive... I still can't really wrap my head around why they would pay this much of a premium. It can't solely be the convenience of buying using an ETF, can it? I mean, if they really wanted to get their hand on some BTCs, they surely would jump through the hoops of a regular BTC exchange. They are only trying to buy 100 shares, yes, but the yare bidding quite a lot more than Maxim! That market looks crazy to me, I haven't seen a market that out of line with the actual price for some time! Who knew everyone eanted to invest their pensions in Bitcoin
|
|
|
|
|
|
greenlion
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 10:31:14 AM |
|
I don't think the SEC would approve a bitcoin etf
I'm almost sure they will as I don't think that heavyweight attorney that specializes in this kind of thing has no influence/colleagues in the SEC nor would she take on a knowingly failed case just for extra money because she has a reputation to upkeep. We're not talking defense attorneys here. It would be useful to know what percentage of requests for ETFs are denied by the SEC. Their approval is not a mere formality, and COIN surely is not the only wannabe ETF with heavyweight attorneys. I gather that it is not a good sign that COIN has been sitting on SEC's desks for ~2 years, and already went through 5 amended re-filings. Wall Street hedge funds have invested in lots of garbage like mortgage-backed securities, derivatives and other worthless junk so they need something like Bitcoin in their portfolio to provide an upside to their valuations as well as something more to sell to their clients who don't want direct exposure to Bitcoin itself. I doubt that loading up in bitcoin would improve the image of any investment fund. Wall Street is not very fond of instruments that lose value every quarter for five consecutive quarters, and whose Captains of Industry cannot even explain why the price is now 220, much less why it should rise again in the future. "Because Wall Street will buy lots of it" is not a convincing argument to Wall Street, I suspect. What other "wannabe ETF"'s have "heavy weight attorneys? What evidence do you have that "COIN has been sitting on SEC's desks"? I.e. what factual basis do you have to characterize the SEC as just ignoring the filing? What information/background do you have on the goals and operations of "any investment fund"? Please explain in your own words what an investment fund even does. What information/background do you have to comment on what kinds of instruments that "Wall Street" might be interested in and why? What evidence do you have that justifies asserting that nobody in Wall Street has any tools or methodology to begin to analyze bitcoin valuation? What is the purpose of using the phrase "Captains of industry" other than as a pejorative to advance nothing but innuendo? What basis do you have to poison the well by insinuating that FOMO is the front-line argument in favor of a possible future bitcoin appreciation? What is the redeeming value in anything whatsoever in your post when the entire thing is toxic innuendo substantiated by absolutely nothing other than completely baseless conjecture?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
phoenix1
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 11:00:37 AM Last edit: April 29, 2015, 11:13:57 AM by phoenix1 |
|
Updated(!) Puma Capital, LLC 100 38.00 Canaccord Genuity Inc 100 37.50 Citadel Securities 100 36.00 KCG Americas LLC 100 35.55 Maxim Group LLC 50000 35.00 Wedbush Securities Inc 100 31.50 Cantor Fitzgerald & Co 100 25.00 Merriman Curhan Ford & Co 100 20.00
Wow! So people outbid Maxim, already? Unfortunately 'only' with bids of 100 shares. Still, this is really impressive... I still can't really wrap my head around why they would pay this much of a premium. It can't solely be the convenience of buying using an ETF, can it? I mean, if they really wanted to get their hand on some BTCs, they surely would jump through the hoops of a regular BTC exchange. They are only trying to buy 100 shares, yes, but the yare bidding quite a lot more than Maxim! That market looks crazy to me, I haven't seen a market that out of line with the actual price for some time! Who knew everyone eanted to invest their pensions in Bitcoin No, they were not and have not been outbid as the Maxim bid of $35 for 50k was never the highest one. Previously they were bidding $40 for 100 share, now they lowered the bid and increased quantity( possibly hiding behind the higher bids to be quickly removed - we will see ) Look at the free publicity it is getting them already  Would not be surprised to see one of the silly high bids actually trade 100 shares, just for those bragging rights and the free press. This change of their bid appears to be the only change in the orderbook in the last 24 hours ... Updated. Maxim Group LLC 100 40.00 Puma Capital, LLC 100 38.00 Canaccord Genuity Inc 100 37.50 Citadel Securities 100 36.00 KCG Americas LLC 100 35.55 Wedbush Securities Inc 100 31.50 Cantor Fitzgerald & Co 100 25.00 Merriman Curhan Ford & Co 100 20.00
|
"Before you embark on a journey of revenge, dig two graves" - Confucius (China 551BC-479 BC)
|
|
|
|
JorgeStolfi
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 11:14:54 AM |
|
It would be useful to know what percentage of requests for ETFs are denied by the SEC. Their approval is not a mere formality, and COIN surely is not the only wannabe ETF with heavyweight attorneys. I gather that it is not a good sign that COIN has been sitting on SEC's desks for ~2 years, and already went through 5 amended re-filings.
I doubt that loading up in bitcoin would improve the image of any investment fund. Wall Street is not very fond of instruments that lose value every quarter for five consecutive quarters, and whose Captains of Industry cannot even explain why the price is now 220, much less why it should rise again in the future. "Because Wall Street will buy lots of it" is not a convincing argument to Wall Street, I suspect.
What What What What What evidence do you have What What Like, for example, actually reading the 5th amended COIN filing? What is the purpose of using the phrase "Captains of industry" other than as a pejorative to advance nothing but innuendo?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VzmzQja7a2M
|
Academic interest in bitcoin only. Not owner, not trader, very skeptical of its longterm success.
|
|
|
jl2012 (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1792
Merit: 1164
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 11:30:42 AM |
|
It would be useful to know what percentage of requests for ETFs are denied by the SEC. Their approval is not a mere formality, and COIN surely is not the only wannabe ETF with heavyweight attorneys. I gather that it is not a good sign that COIN has been sitting on SEC's desks for ~2 years, and already went through 5 amended re-filings.
I doubt that loading up in bitcoin would improve the image of any investment fund. Wall Street is not very fond of instruments that lose value every quarter for five consecutive quarters, and whose Captains of Industry cannot even explain why the price is now 220, much less why it should rise again in the future. "Because Wall Street will buy lots of it" is not a convincing argument to Wall Street, I suspect.
What What What What What evidence do you have What What Like, for example, actually reading the 5th amended COIN filing? What is the purpose of using the phrase "Captains of industry" other than as a pejorative to advance nothing but innuendo?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VzmzQja7a2MStop spreading unfounded FUD. You can see the early history of the GLD ETF here: http://www.sec.gov/cgi-bin/browse-edgar?action=getcompany&CIK=0001222333&type=&dateb=20050101&owner=include&count=100The application was submitted on 2003-05-13, after 5 amendments, it was approved on 2004-11-17. I'm not sure if COIN will be approved, but for something as innovative as bitcoin, I don't think it is significantly slower than GLD.
|
Donation address: 374iXxS4BuqFHsEwwxUuH3nvJ69Y7Hqur3 (Bitcoin ONLY) LRDGENPLYrcTRssGoZrsCT1hngaH3BVkM4 (LTC) PGP: D3CC 1772 8600 5BB8 FF67 3294 C524 2A1A B393 6517
|
|
|
|
JorgeStolfi
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 12:17:37 PM |
|
Why is doubting the approval and asking for data on SEC performance "spreading FUD"? I am not sure COIN will be approved either. It has certainly the same problem as GLD, namely being based on an asset whose price is almost entirely speculative, not grounded on concrete fundamentals. Actually, gold does have some fundamentals, only that they account for only a small fraction of the current market price. And GLD (like gold) lost 1/3 of its value after it was approved by the SEC. Would that fact influence SEC's decision about COIN?
|
Academic interest in bitcoin only. Not owner, not trader, very skeptical of its longterm success.
|
|
|
Alley
Legendary

Activity: 910
Merit: 1000
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 12:36:42 PM |
|
Looks like maxims bid is back to 100 shares. Maybe they got some bad info that asks were going to be up yesterday?
|
|
|
|
|
|
ensurance982
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 01:07:44 PM |
|
Why is doubting the approval and asking for data on SEC performance "spreading FUD"? I am not sure COIN will be approved either. It has certainly the same problem as GLD, namely being based on an asset whose price is almost entirely speculative, not grounded on concrete fundamentals. Actually, gold does have some fundamentals, only that they account for only a small fraction of the current market price. And GLD (like gold) lost 1/3 of its value after it was approved by the SEC. Would that fact influence SEC's decision about COIN? Well, you said it yourself - the intrinsic value of Gold is much lower than its market value - therefore its price is also mostly based on speculation (as per definition!). Losing 1/3 of its price doesn't really make all funds based on similar assets as failure, as well, does it?
|
We Support Currencies: BTC, LTC, USD, EUR, GBP
|
|
|
|
HeliKopterBen
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 01:30:53 PM |
|
And GLD (like gold) lost 1/3 of its value after it was approved by the SEC. Would that fact influence SEC's decision about COIN?
You have eaten too many FUD sandwiches. GLD gained over 400% after approval and trading began, and this is after gold had already traded for centuries.
|
Counterfeit: made in imitation of something else with intent to deceive: merriam-webster
|
|
|
|
JorgeStolfi
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 01:34:36 PM |
|
Well, you said it yourself - the intrinsic value of Gold is much lower than its market value - therefore its price is also mostly based on speculation (as per definition!). Losing 1/3 of its price doesn't really make all funds based on similar assets as failure, as well, does it?
It makes investing in such assets a gamble with unknown and unknowable odds and prizes. Gold at least has a hard price floor, based on its industrial and decorative uses. Bitcoin doesn't. I understand that the SEC will not block risky instruments, as long as the potential investors are clearly informed about the risks. The question is, can one really do that with bitcoin, without scaring the investors away? I think that it is totally immoral, if not worse, to try to sell bitcoin -- whether bare or wrapped in fund shares -- to people who do not have the necessary knowledge to really understand the risks, and may be taken in by the glowing predictions of Anotonopoulos, the Winkles, and other "bitcoin evangelists". But, unfortunately, the expected market for those funds is precisely that kind of investor...
|
Academic interest in bitcoin only. Not owner, not trader, very skeptical of its longterm success.
|
|
|
|
JorgeStolfi
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 01:43:40 PM |
|
GLD gained over 400% after approval and trading began, and this is after gold had already traded for centuries. Yes, gold had a speculative bubble after GLD was approved -- thanks in part, it seems, to an intensive FUD-based marketing campaign about the impending collapse of everything else, a la Max Keyser and Zerohedge. But the bubble has already deflated 30%, which must have ruined many people who believed those "specialists" and did not realize that the price was holding itself by its own bootstraps. I understand that, in the moral value system of the financial industry, anything that may result in fat profits for smart and/or lucky speculators is by definition "good". Well, sorry, I am not of that religion myself.
|
Academic interest in bitcoin only. Not owner, not trader, very skeptical of its longterm success.
|
|
|
NUFCrichard
Legendary

Activity: 1218
Merit: 1003
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 01:50:58 PM |
|
And GLD (like gold) lost 1/3 of its value after it was approved by the SEC. Would that fact influence SEC's decision about COIN?
You have eaten too many FUD sandwiches. GLD gained over 400% after approval and trading began, and this is after gold had already traded for centuries. It is amazing that a new way to invest in Gold would make a 400% change in either direction. I have been quite agnostic about the ETF coming online, I thought that it would make little difference that people have yet another way to invest in Bitcoin. I now see that may well be wrong, it will be interesting with 401ks, as that is a lot of money sloshing around in an ATH stock market with bonds yielding almost nothing, it could really flood in. Interesting times ahead.
|
|
|
|
|
|
HeliKopterBen
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 02:10:13 PM |
|
GLD gained over 400% after approval and trading began, and this is after gold had already traded for centuries. Yes, gold had a speculative bubble after GLD was approved -- thanks in part, it seems, to an intensive FUD-based marketing campaign about the impending collapse of everything else, a la Max Keyser and Zerohedge. But the bubble has already deflated 30%, which must have ruined many people who believed those "specialists" and did not realize that the price was holding itself by its own bootstraps. I understand that, in the moral value system of the financial industry, anything that may result in fat profits for smart and/or lucky speculators is by definition "good". Well, sorry, I am not of that religion myself. So GLD has fallen 30% from its all time high, NOT from the time it was approved and began trading. Those are two completely different points in time. Anyway, gold gained over 400% after GLD began trading because it could finally work somewhat as a store of value in a digital world, but it doesn't solve the problem of third party risk and GLD can't be used as a currency, so it still doesn't work very well. But the bubble has already deflated 30%, which must have ruined many people
The Euro has lost over 20% of its value in just the past year. Has that ruined many people?
|
Counterfeit: made in imitation of something else with intent to deceive: merriam-webster
|
|
|
|
jehst
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 02:17:44 PM |
|
Before gold's 10 year bull market, it had a 20+ year bear market. I don't think the ETF caused the bull market. It triggered what was primed to happen. Gold was severely undervalued since the 1980s.
The same thing may happen with bitcoin and the Winklevoss ETF (which has a tighter, less-limited relationship with other exchanges).
|
Year 2021 Bitcoin Supply: ~90% mined Supply Inflation: <1.8%
|
|
|
|
JorgeStolfi
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 03:02:36 PM |
|
So GLD has fallen 30% from its all time high, NOT from the time it was approved and began trading. Those are two completely different points in time.
I did not mean to say that it devalued 30% from the value it had at the time of approval, athough my use of "after it was approved" could be read that way. Sorry for that. Anyway, gold gained over 400% after GLD began trading because it could finally work somewhat as a store of value in a digital world, but it doesn't solve the problem of third party risk and GLD can't be used as a currency, so it still doesn't work very well. And it did not work well as a store of value, either. That was my point. But the [ gold ] bubble has already deflated 30%, which must have ruined many people
The Euro has lost over 20% of its value in just the past year. Has that ruined many people? It would have been a severe hit to anyone who invested in euros; but no sane investor should invest in a currency. The drop may cause hardship to those who have pensions or salaries fixed in euros; but it will take some time for the exchange rate drop to be translated into a drop of local purchasing power. While the price is above the hard floor, GLD and COIN will be ultimately zero-sum games. The losses suffered by those who bought too high are not just "acceptable collateral damage", but the very reason for the existence of those funds: because the profits of lucky speculators can only come from those losses.
|
Academic interest in bitcoin only. Not owner, not trader, very skeptical of its longterm success.
|
|
|
criptix
Legendary

Activity: 2464
Merit: 1145
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 03:24:48 PM |
|
[...] The losses suffered by those who bought too high are not just "acceptable collateral damage", but the very reason for the existence of those funds: because the profits of lucky speculators can only come from those losses.
Not nessecary, assuming that bitcoin will be a true competition or successor for the traditional banking system the profit will arise from a much lower transaction cost. Also i dont believe Bitcoin will stay static like now - i'm pretty sure it can/will evolve to a plattform which enables you to do a lot more things than just sending money (i.e. smart contracts etc.).
|
|
|
|
|
gotmilk_
|
 |
April 29, 2015, 06:57:56 PM |
|
Looks like Barry talked about it at InsideBitcoins.
@barrysilbert says trading of $GBTC should start today or tomorrow at @InsideBitcoins #BitcoinConf #bitcoin
|
|
|
|
|
|