About the best thing I can think of is it's a layout issue.
Sidehack:
Did you get this figured out? I had a similar problem on one of those TI TPS chips and I never really figured it out. I had to rev the board to fix another problem and on the new rev I did a better job of making the layout match the "suggested layout" in the datasheet. Worked just fine on the new layout... so take that as a my
BTC0.02
Good luck!
-a[g