[PrimeDice] (Staff Only) Earn Bitcoins Simply By Posting

[johnwest]

Pretty surprised that I was cut from the campaign to be honest.

I wonder what criteria the 3rd party was using to determine "quality posts".

I'm not going to PM Stunna about it of course, as he said in the PM that it's non-negotiable. But thought I would at least register my skepticism here with whatever methods were used.

Third party?  What third party?

I thought primedice and stunna decided who got cut and who didn't. 

I'll tell you why you probably got cut.  Half of your posts are in off-topic, as compared to over 90% of mine being in alt-coins where the miners and speculative investors are [people with coins to spend and an appetite for risk].

That's just my guess but I bet I'm right on the money.  I'd be curious to know how many other guys made it and if they have a very high post % in the alt-coin section. 

Cheers!

Micro making list of cut, who will stay on PD and who will out.
So I think he is only deciding cut, Stunna is very busy so can't decide alone.

[1714696518]

1714696518

[1714696518]

1714696518

[1714696518]

1714696518

[1714696518]

1714696518

[1714696518]

1714696518

[Cranky4u]

Pretty surprised that I was cut from the campaign to be honest.

I wonder what criteria the 3rd party was using to determine "quality posts".

I'm not going to PM Stunna about it of course, as he said in the PM that it's non-negotiable. But thought I would at least register my skepticism here with whatever methods were used.

Third party?  What third party?

I thought primedice and stunna decided who got cut and who didn't.  

I'll tell you why you probably got cut.  Half of your posts are in off-topic, as compared to over 95% of mine being in alt-coins where the miners and speculative investors are [people with coins to spend and an appetite for risk].

That's just my guess but I bet I'm right on the money.  I'd be curious to know how many other guys made it and if they have a very high post % in the alt-coin section.  

Cheers!

Don't forget that off-topic posts don't count so if they were claimed, it is a likely reason for the booting..*shurgs*

[Vlad2Vlad]

Micro making list of cut, who will stay on PD and who will out.
So I think he is only deciding cut, Stunna is very busy so can't decide alone.

And Micro is third party to whom?  I would imagine Micro is either a trusted person working for Primedice or an outright PD employee.

Really no third party.  A 3rd party doesn't make any sense since Primedice is the beneficiary and the employer.

[johnwest]

Micro making list of cut, who will stay on PD and who will out.
So I think he is only deciding cut, Stunna is very busy so can't decide alone.

And Micro is third party to whom?  I would imagine Micro is either a trusted person working for Primedice or an outright PD employee.

Really no third party.  A 3rd party doesn't make any sense since Primedice is the beneficiary and the employer.

I know Micro is mod on PD chat, and very helpful for Stunna.
This is the reason Stunna trust him so much on his decision.

[MICRO]

Pretty surprised that I was cut from the campaign to be honest.

I wonder what criteria the 3rd party was using to determine "quality posts".

I'm not going to PM Stunna about it of course, as he said in the PM that it's non-negotiable. But thought I would at least register my skepticism here with whatever methods were used.

Its not like that u are spaming its just that goal was to cut 50% , so criteria was rly strict .
Lots of ur posts are in other section short and not fully constructive.

50% is huge cut so u need to understand that even some pretty good posters needed to be cut off .
Im sorry for that.

Also if quality of ur posts improve and there will be some free spots for the taking u are more than welcome to apply for this campaign again.

And btw i wasn't deciding who will be cut off, i just put a marks on users that are so/so in my opinion and everybody of them are later checked by Stunna.

[Balls]

Micro making list of cut, who will stay on PD and who will out.
So I think he is only deciding cut, Stunna is very busy so can't decide alone.

And Micro is third party to whom?  I would imagine Micro is either a trusted person working for Primedice or an outright PD employee.

Really no third party.  A 3rd party doesn't make any sense since Primedice is the beneficiary and the employer.

He's trusted somewhat, but isn't an employee as far as I'm aware. He's a volunteer mod but not a paid employee and just helps stunna out occasionally when he can.

[Este Nuno]

A decent amount of my posts in off-topic were made a couple of years ago, or on a campaign that I was on previous to Primedice that allowed posting in off-topic. The off-topic forum wasn't always a complete waste of space like it is now.

For what it's worth I don't even think I posted in off-topic while I was with the Primedice campaign, and if I did I definitely didn't claim it.

[Gervais]

Pretty surprised that I was cut from the campaign to be honest.

I wonder what criteria the 3rd party was using to determine "quality posts".

I'm not going to PM Stunna about it of course, as he said in the PM that it's non-negotiable. But thought I would at least register my skepticism here with whatever methods were used.

Third party?  What third party?

I thought primedice and stunna decided who got cut and who didn't.  

I'll tell you why you probably got cut.  Half of your posts are in off-topic, as compared to over 95% of mine being in alt-coins where the miners and speculative investors are [people with coins to spend and an appetite for risk].

That's just my guess but I bet I'm right on the money.  I'd be curious to know how many other guys made it and if they have a very high post % in the alt-coin section.  

Cheers!

Don't forget that off-topic posts don't count so if they were claimed, it is a likely reason for the booting..*shurgs*

Posts in the off-topic subforum count, but not posts that are off topic or irrelevant to the discussion. I also don't think posting in off-topic will get you any more or less hits than anywhere else, though who clicks on your links is compeletly random and there's obviously no stats to prove where the most popular forums are.

[Malin Keshar]

Pretty surprised that I was cut from the campaign to be honest.

I wonder what criteria the 3rd party was using to determine "quality posts".

I'm not going to PM Stunna about it of course, as he said in the PM that it's non-negotiable. But thought I would at least register my skepticism here with whatever methods were used.

Third party?  What third party?

I thought primedice and stunna decided who got cut and who didn't.  

I'll tell you why you probably got cut.  Half of your posts are in off-topic, as compared to over 95% of mine being in alt-coins where the miners and speculative investors are [people with coins to spend and an appetite for risk].

That's just my guess but I bet I'm right on the money.  I'd be curious to know how many other guys made it and if they have a very high post % in the alt-coin section.  

Cheers!

Don't forget that off-topic posts don't count so if they were claimed, it is a likely reason for the booting..*shurgs*

Off topics in the sense they are not related to the thread's topic. Posts in the off topic section are valid, if they are constructive and not in one of the activity farm topics(count to 21M with images, ban the person above you, what drink you drank, etc...).

And maybe wether you tried to promote Prime Dice and other gambling related posts might have been taken into account too.

[Este Nuno]

Pretty surprised that I was cut from the campaign to be honest.

I wonder what criteria the 3rd party was using to determine "quality posts".

I'm not going to PM Stunna about it of course, as he said in the PM that it's non-negotiable. But thought I would at least register my skepticism here with whatever methods were used.

Third party?  What third party?

I thought primedice and stunna decided who got cut and who didn't.  

I'll tell you why you probably got cut.  Half of your posts are in off-topic and only 25% are in the alt-coins sections, as compared to over 95% of mine being in alt-coins where the miners and speculative investors are [people with coins to spend and an appetite for risk].

That's just my guess but I bet I'm right on the money.  I'd be curious to know how many other guys made it and if they have a very high post % in the alt-coin section.  

Cheers!

The "third party" was claimed by Stunna in the PM he sent out to cut memebers:

Hey all,

Unfortunately you were determined to be in the bottom half of currently enrolled members in terms of post quality, as discussed on the thread I was going to be making cuts today.

This decision is not negotiable, I had a third party determine this to remain unbiased and you are not elgible for the August to September term. You are however still eligible for the affiliate program: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=745779.0

I appreciate your support thus far and wish you all the best, sorry to have to boot you out after many of you had been involved so long. As mentioned before this isn't negotiable unfortunately, so please do not PM me with arguments.

Thank You

[Este Nuno]

Pretty surprised that I was cut from the campaign to be honest.

I wonder what criteria the 3rd party was using to determine "quality posts".

I'm not going to PM Stunna about it of course, as he said in the PM that it's non-negotiable. But thought I would at least register my skepticism here with whatever methods were used.

Its not like that u are spaming its just that goal was to cut 50% , so criteria was rly strict .
Lots of ur posts are in other section short and not fully constructive.

50% is huge cut so u need to understand that even some pretty good posters needed to be cut off .
Im sorry for that.

Also if quality of ur posts improve and there will be some free spots for the taking u are more than welcome to apply for this campaign again.

And btw i wasn't deciding who will be cut off, i just put a marks on users that are so/so in my opinion and everybody of them are later checked by Stunna.

Thanks for the reply. I tend to answer or ask a lot of questions, and I'm often concise. So if your were scanning through thousands of different peoples posts and looking for length I can see how you might have gotten that impression. And yes, it must have been difficult having to choose 50% of all senior and hero members.

[BRE]

somebody answer this ?

i just join this PD sig 24 july 2014 and only made 30 post till 17 august 2014 maybe only 25 post can be count
so do my 25 post will be paid or not ?
i already filled form for payment.
i ask yesterday here and still no answer.
i PM somebody who in charge about payment and still no answer

if im not eligible for payment its ok , i just want to know and im sure im not alone in this matter.

thanks

[Lauda]

somebody answer this ?

i just join this PD sig 24 july 2014 and only made 30 post till 17 august 2014 maybe only 25 post can be count
so do my 25 post will be paid or not ?
i already filled form for payment.
i ask yesterday here and still no answer.
i PM somebody who in charge about payment and still no answer

if im not eligible for payment its ok , i just want to know and im sure im not alone in this matter.

thanks

Why didn't you read the topic itself?

50 Posts minimum to claim, must have 50+ activity. Rates can change at any given time.

So that should answer it. You're not going to be paid.

[monbux]

Hi Stunna!  I didn't receive my signature payment
1Q2CupiU5DfWupRGBQ66QYRqvxoNxGZCcn

Could you please help? :O

Bumping this... Still received no payment.  I believe it was either 93 or 97 posts, 97 more like.  I've also recieved no response to my PM

[MICRO]

Pretty surprised that I was cut from the campaign to be honest.

I wonder what criteria the 3rd party was using to determine "quality posts".

I'm not going to PM Stunna about it of course, as he said in the PM that it's non-negotiable. But thought I would at least register my skepticism here with whatever methods were used.

Its not like that u are spaming its just that goal was to cut 50% , so criteria was rly strict .
Lots of ur posts are in other section short and not fully constructive.

50% is huge cut so u need to understand that even some pretty good posters needed to be cut off .
Im sorry for that.

Also if quality of ur posts improve and there will be some free spots for the taking u are more than welcome to apply for this campaign again.

And btw i wasn't deciding who will be cut off, i just put a marks on users that are so/so in my opinion and everybody of them are later checked by Stunna.

Thanks for the reply. I tend to answer or ask a lot of questions, and I'm often concise. So if your were scanning through thousands of different peoples posts and looking for length I can see how you might have gotten that impression. And yes, it must have been difficult having to choose 50% of all senior and hero members.

Yeah , but again my decision was not final im not sure if Stunna had somebody , like some mod or somebody to check people that i marked and make final decision .

It was rly hard for me to mark 50% of seniors to be out , coz most of seniors are solid posters , but now i did get final list of members , and added theirs payments for last month and it was 18btc .

18 BTC and that is without all members and full members and without all people that been cut off . That is still HUGE amount , and idk if there will be more cuts , and it will be so hard to decide who else need to go :S .

Tnx for understanding, this rly needed to be done coz it rly got out of control 220+ members and 30+ btc per month for this campaign is just way to much.


List will be posted later when Stunna checks it and he will post it here.

[MICRO]

Hi Stunna!  I didn't receive my signature payment
1Q2CupiU5DfWupRGBQ66QYRqvxoNxGZCcn

Could you please help? :O

Bumping this... Still received no payment.  I believe it was either 93 or 97 posts, 97 more like.  I've also recieved no response to my PM

Im sorry, he is just so much tied up atm. U aren't on the google doc list, so u probably did not submit request properly , it will be sorted out, but u just need to be patient .

Tnx.

[monbux]

Hi Stunna!  I didn't receive my signature payment
1Q2CupiU5DfWupRGBQ66QYRqvxoNxGZCcn

Could you please help? :O

Bumping this... Still received no payment.  I believe it was either 93 or 97 posts, 97 more like.  I've also recieved no response to my PM

Im sorry, he is just so much tied up atm. U did not show on the google doc list, so u probably did not submit request properly , it will be sorted out, but u just need to be patient .

Tnx.

Weirdly I remember submitting it correctly and double checking.  Only thing was, I submitted on the 18th so that may be a problem?  Could you help me forward this to stunna when he has more time?  Cheers!

[zolace]

Pretty surprised that I was cut from the campaign to be honest.

I wonder what criteria the 3rd party was using to determine "quality posts".

I'm not going to PM Stunna about it of course, as he said in the PM that it's non-negotiable. But thought I would at least register my skepticism here with whatever methods were used.

Its not like that u are spaming its just that goal was to cut 50% , so criteria was rly strict .
Lots of ur posts are in other section short and not fully constructive.

50% is huge cut so u need to understand that even some pretty good posters needed to be cut off .
Im sorry for that.

Also if quality of ur posts improve and there will be some free spots for the taking u are more than welcome to apply for this campaign again.

And btw i wasn't deciding who will be cut off, i just put a marks on users that are so/so in my opinion and everybody of them are later checked by Stunna.

Thanks for the reply. I tend to answer or ask a lot of questions, and I'm often concise. So if your were scanning through thousands of different peoples posts and looking for length I can see how you might have gotten that impression. And yes, it must have been difficult having to choose 50% of all senior and hero members.

Yeah , but again my decision was not final im not sure if Stunna had somebody , like some mod or somebody to check people that i marked and make final decision .

It was rly hard for me to mark 50% of seniors to be out , coz most of seniors are solid posters , but now i did get final list of members , and added theirs payments for last month and it was 18btc .

18 BTC and that is without all members and full members and without all people that been cut off . That is still HUGE amount , and idk if there will be more cuts , and it will be so hard to decide who else need to go :S .

Tnx for understanding, this rly needed to be done coz it rly got out of control 220+ members and 30+ btc per month for this campaign is just way to much.


List will be posted later when Stunna checks it and he will post it here.

Honestly I had mentioned long ago that the doors should have been closed, cause I knew this was going out of control but to be honest.  Also I hardly see any PD sigs anymore and seeing alot more other sigs, meaning if he cutting this much then why dont he he just lower the rate for senior members to 0.009 per post?  or just go the fixed rate?

[BRE]

(...)
Please Read
For next month it looks like we are going to cut anyone below Sr member from the campaign and then further limit the campaign down to the highest quality posters if needed. I will begin reviewing the quality of our higher ranked posters tomorrow and notify you if I've decided to cut you from the campaign.
(...)
Ever since we started this campaign the quality of posts on bitcointalk has plummeted and it is becoming more and more difficult to regulate things. I think this is the best move for the health of this community.

Hi, Stunna, thanks for the info. I've got some questions:

(...)
First payments are starting to go out, there is a record amount of people participating from the looks of it so please allow up to 48 hours for a payment.
and kindly leave feedback after receiving.
(...)

I have only had time for about 20 constructive posts during this period. I believe others are in the same situation. In this case, will I receive some proportional payment?

(...)
If you are below senior member you will be able to keep your signature and put a referral link in at a boosted rate which will net you 15-20% of the house edge on any bets made on your url. I'm not sure how profitable this will be for users but it will likely be decent profit until you can potentially participate at the pay per post level. This program is also 100% automatic with profits available instantly to cash out from your primedice account. If you are below a senior member I suggest creating a primedice account and adding your affiliate link now (this is available under profile). To get your rate boosted please send me a PM in over 24 hours from now.

In case the user decides to continue with the referral link, can he also promote that referral elsewhere (if the user has got some other website or blog) keeping the same boosted rate?

Thank you again.

Success!

If you didn't make it to 50 posts and are being pushed out I'll handle it on a case by case basis. Just wait 2 days and PM me about that or request payment on 20 posts. Also the ref links will be usable anywhere at that rate.

somebody answer this ?

i just join this PD sig 24 july 2014 and only made 30 post till 17 august 2014 maybe only 25 post can be count
so do my 25 post will be paid or not ?
i already filled form for payment.
i ask yesterday here and still no answer.
i PM somebody who in charge about payment and still no answer

if im not eligible for payment its ok , i just want to know and im sure im not alone in this matter.

thanks

Why didn't you read the topic itself?

50 Posts minimum to claim, must have 50+ activity. Rates can change at any given time.

So that should answer it. You're not going to be paid.

ok thanks  

[Balls]

Honestly I had mentioned long ago that the doors should have been closed, cause I knew this was going out of control but to be honest,  because I hardly see any PD sigs anymore and seeing alot more other sigs, meaning if he cutting this much then why dont he he just lower the rate for senior members to 0.009 per post?  or just go the fixed rate?

I'm sure this is stunna's attempt at cutting costs by half and also cutting down the bad quality posts. He probably has a budget in mind and wants to stick with it. If it still goes overboard then maybe further cuts or price reductions or a change of deal will have to be done, but only time will reveal on that front. Chnaging to a fixed deal might not have a good effect because you pay more and for less posts. Sure some people may do a lot more than 50 posts but most will just do the minimum 50 posts and collect double the amount of money they would if this was still a pay per post campaign.