|
David Rabahy
|
 |
May 08, 2015, 07:12:09 PM |
|
I thought price would continue to drop as BIT holders began to fear missing out on the arbitrage opportunity. It does not seem like much of an opportunity to me. Although the immediate sell price is great right now, the buying path is encumbered by the delay for the accreditation process (again) besides the additional fees, etc. I'm long-minded; do I really need this hassle? If you are long minded, the delays shouldn't matter? You should be able to double or almost double the shares you sell, right? Are you waiting for an even better arbitrage opportunity? If I could sell and then use the proceeds to quickly and easily purchase more BIT shares at NAV then of course but there's nothing quick and easy about it. It's the timing that hurts the most. The extra work of proving I am accredited again would be worth it I suppose. But if I miss a rise while out of BIT shares messing around with this game isn't worth the risk to me. How much can BIT shares (Bitcoin) rise in the couple of weeks or more that it would take to move my proceeds back in? I don't want to miss the big party trying to grab a fast gain.
|
|
|
|
|
Chef Ramsay
Legendary

Activity: 1568
Merit: 1001
|
 |
May 08, 2015, 07:15:01 PM |
|
Interesting that this GBTC thing is all situated and having a year behind the original shareholders when it appears this market may be turning a new leaf. Coincidence?
|
|
|
|
|
|
gotmilk_
|
 |
May 08, 2015, 07:17:20 PM |
|
I thought price would continue to drop as BIT holders began to fear missing out on the arbitrage opportunity. It does not seem like much of an opportunity to me. Although the immediate sell price is great right now, the buying path is encumbered by the delay for the accreditation process (again) besides the additional fees, etc. I'm long-minded; do I really need this hassle? If you are long minded, the delays shouldn't matter? You should be able to double or almost double the shares you sell, right? Are you waiting for an even better arbitrage opportunity? If I could sell and then use the proceeds to quickly and easily purchase more BIT shares at NAV then of course but there's nothing quick and easy about it. It's the timing that hurts the most. The extra work of proving I am accredited again would be worth it I suppose. But if I miss a rise while out of BIT shares messing around with this game isn't worth the risk to me. How much can BIT shares (Bitcoin) rise in the couple of weeks or more that it would take to move my proceeds back in? I don't want to miss the big party trying to grab a fast gain. GBTC price will probably continue to be 50-70% above BTC price for next month (or more?). So I guess buying first and than selling isn't so risky... Or? Not saying it is safe to buy, just want to hear your opinion 
|
|
|
|
|
|
bad trader
|
 |
May 08, 2015, 07:24:13 PM |
|
If I could sell and then use the proceeds to quickly and easily purchase more BIT shares at NAV then of course but there's nothing quick and easy about it. It's the timing that hurts the most. The extra work of proving I am accredited again would be worth it I suppose. But if I miss a rise while out of BIT shares messing around with this game isn't worth the risk to me. How much can BIT shares (Bitcoin) rise in the couple of weeks or more that it would take to move my proceeds back in? I don't want to miss the big party trying to grab a fast gain. I understand. If I was doing arbitrage on bitcoin, I would try to set it up so I can buy and sell at the same time. (I didn't realize you were talking about delays between selling and buying.)
|
|
|
|
|
|
David Rabahy
|
 |
May 08, 2015, 07:40:39 PM |
|
GBTC price will probably continue to be 50-70% above BTC price for next month (or more?). So I guess buying first and than selling isn't so risky... Or? Not saying it is safe to buy, just want to hear your opinion  I suppose the GBTC price comes at a premium because the source (people like me) is constrained and the demand (people like you) is less so. I'm unlikely to change my mind soon so if that's common then the source will continue to be constrained *but* what will you and yours be thinking? Are your funds retirement or non-retirement funds? Playing GBTC is just like playing BTC or anything else. That GBTC is loosely anchored to BTC is only mildly interesting?
|
|
|
|
|
|
bobabouey2
|
 |
May 08, 2015, 07:42:42 PM |
|
It's in a qualified retirement account, i.e. Roth IRA. I can and have easily obtained Bitcoins from a wide variety of avenues. I have enough non-retirement Bitcoins for now; thank you. To take advantage of the supposed arbitrage opportunity would involve;
1) waiting until my BIT shares actually arrive at my custodian (in-progress; should be soon (next week?)) 2) place sell order (hopefully easy & quick) 3) use proceeds to purchase more BIT shares at NAV via my custodian (pain in the butt, prove I am accredited again, medallion signature guarantee, ...) 4) if I want to do it again then wait 12 months and return to step 1
I didn't know it was so cumbersome. I've rarely seen accredited investor processes needing proof of accredited status (you just make the representation), and I've never seen one requiring medallion signature guarantees. But, those were VC / "friend and family" type investments, so less "public" than BIT. So, maybe they need to be more careful. Still, you'd think it would be more streamlined if you have already purchased from them. Have you checked they'd make you go through the whole process again?
|
|
|
|
|
|
chriswen
|
 |
May 08, 2015, 07:43:21 PM |
|
The premium might even increase as demand increases and we don't see COIN launching.
|
|
|
|
|
|
David Rabahy
|
 |
May 08, 2015, 07:44:20 PM |
|
If I could sell and then use the proceeds to quickly and easily purchase more BIT shares at NAV then of course but there's nothing quick and easy about it. It's the timing that hurts the most. The extra work of proving I am accredited again would be worth it I suppose. But if I miss a rise while out of BIT shares messing around with this game isn't worth the risk to me. How much can BIT shares (Bitcoin) rise in the couple of weeks or more that it would take to move my proceeds back in? I don't want to miss the big party trying to grab a fast gain. I understand. If I was doing arbitrage on bitcoin, I would try to set it up so I can buy and sell at the same time. (I didn't realize you were talking about delays between selling and buying.) If the situation were different, i.e. trivially quick and easy, than I'd arbitrage the hell out of GBTC until it was at parity (taking into account the ~0.1 factor) with BTC.
|
|
|
|
|
|
gotmilk_
|
 |
May 08, 2015, 07:44:35 PM |
|
GBTC price will probably continue to be 50-70% above BTC price for next month (or more?). So I guess buying first and than selling isn't so risky... Or? Not saying it is safe to buy, just want to hear your opinion  I suppose the GBTC price comes at a premium because the source (people like me) is constrained and the demand (people like you) is less so. I'm unlikely to change my mind soon so if that's common then the source will continue to be constrained *but* what will you and yours be thinking? Are your funds retirement or non-retirement funds? Playing GBTC is just like playing BTC or anything else. That GBTC is loosely anchored to BTC is only mildly interesting? Fair enough  Well I'm not from US...
|
|
|
|
|
|
David Rabahy
|
 |
May 08, 2015, 07:46:28 PM |
|
Still, you'd think it would be more streamlined if you have already purchased from them. Have you checked they'd make you go through the whole process again? Yeppers.
|
|
|
|
|
|
bad trader
|
 |
May 08, 2015, 08:31:40 PM |
|
Well, the daily volume was ~1480.7 BTC.  If the volume rises and stays in the thousands and a decent chunk of it goes into arbitrage (maybe not), it should have a noticeable direct effect on BTC prices.
|
|
|
|
|
marcus_of_augustus
Legendary

Activity: 3920
Merit: 2352
Eadem mutata resurgo
|
 |
May 08, 2015, 09:10:12 PM |
|
If I could sell and then use the proceeds to quickly and easily purchase more BIT shares at NAV then of course but there's nothing quick and easy about it. It's the timing that hurts the most. The extra work of proving I am accredited again would be worth it I suppose. But if I miss a rise while out of BIT shares messing around with this game isn't worth the risk to me. How much can BIT shares (Bitcoin) rise in the couple of weeks or more that it would take to move my proceeds back in? I don't want to miss the big party trying to grab a fast gain. I understand. If I was doing arbitrage on bitcoin, I would try to set it up so I can buy and sell at the same time. (I didn't realize you were talking about delays between selling and buying.) If the situation were different, i.e. trivially quick and easy, than I'd arbitrage the hell out of GBTC until it was at parity (taking into account the ~0.1 factor) with BTC. Thanks for your view-from-the-cockpit accounts on this ... makes the seemingly mysterious GBTC pricing more understandable hearing incentives, practicalities, etc for trading this instrument. Now I'm wondering if GBTC is actually closer to the true price of bitcoin, i.e. on a fully regulated exchange without all the quote stuffing, order spoofing and crazy manipulation rampant on stamp, finex, OKCoin, etc. Sometimes those prices on existing exchanges look totally fabricated, all moving exactly in lockstep, $10 step changes up or down ...
|
|
|
|
coinableS
Legendary

Activity: 1484
Merit: 1191
|
 |
May 09, 2015, 12:53:27 AM |
|
The #1 in USD volume on OTCQX today was RHHBY (Roche Holding Ltd) that did $21 million. GBTC did $750,020 in USD volume today. That's 3.5% of the #1 traded symbol of the QX market, not a bad figure IMO. Today there was a total $125 million in volume for all of OTCQX market. If you calculate it GBTC was 0.5% of that. Not a bad slice of the pie if you ask me. 
|
|
|
|
|
ImI
Legendary

Activity: 1946
Merit: 1019
|
 |
May 09, 2015, 12:55:35 AM |
|
Definitely a good start!
|
|
|
|
|
|
hodlmybtc
|
 |
May 09, 2015, 01:01:43 AM |
|
Exciting times ahead 
|
|
|
|
|
Chef Ramsay
Legendary

Activity: 1568
Merit: 1001
|
 |
May 09, 2015, 03:30:03 AM |
|
Very positive day for GBTC, kindly and aggressively building upon itself day by day during the first week of active service. I wonder if this is the premonition that Barry was alluding to in his ''promising another bubble'' tweet.. Nutcase sure was active today so I'm puzzled who set that creep in motion on such a day.
|
|
|
|
|
mmortal03
Legendary

Activity: 1762
Merit: 1011
|
 |
May 09, 2015, 04:34:52 AM |
|
Interesting that this GBTC thing is all situated and having a year behind the original shareholders when it appears this market may be turning a new leaf. Coincidence?
Is it, though? I keep tabs on the 365-day price difference (with the following chart), and a bitcoin investment held for a year continues to be under water right now. Also, note the red line, which is where it will be if the price stays the same. 
|
|
|
|
|
Chef Ramsay
Legendary

Activity: 1568
Merit: 1001
|
 |
May 09, 2015, 04:41:21 AM |
|
Interesting that this GBTC thing is all situated and having a year behind the original shareholders when it appears this market may be turning a new leaf. Coincidence?
Is it, though? I keep tabs on the 365-day price difference (with the following chart), and a bitcoin investment held for a year continues to be under water right now. Also, note the red line, which is where it will be if the price stays the same. I see your point but I believe that I posted here or on another site (RPF) in regards to the shareholders' holdings that I believed them to have bought in the 6-700+ range in full, so this could mean they're slightly under water. Yet, the arb opportunity seems worthwhile or the selling and rebuying to check out the market next year to see some gains. Today was good for PR purposes going forward and the entire market.
|
|
|
|
|
mmortal03
Legendary

Activity: 1762
Merit: 1011
|
 |
May 09, 2015, 05:05:39 AM Last edit: May 09, 2015, 05:31:11 AM by mmortal03 |
|
Interesting that this GBTC thing is all situated and having a year behind the original shareholders when it appears this market may be turning a new leaf. Coincidence?
Is it, though? I keep tabs on the 365-day price difference (with the following chart), and a bitcoin investment held for a year continues to be under water right now. Also, note the red line, which is where it will be if the price stays the same. I see your point but I believe that I posted here or on another site (RPF) in regards to the shareholders' holdings that I believed them to have bought in the 6-700+ range in full, so this could mean they're slightly under water. Yet, the arb opportunity seems worthwhile or the selling and rebuying to check out the market next year to see some gains. Today was good for PR purposes going forward and the entire market. Yeah, I like the good PR going forward, and I'm cautiously optimistic. The worst case scenario recently for a buyer who held for a year was if they bought on January 15th, 2014, and sold on January 15th, 2015 (-76.16%), and that doesn't apply here. We're off that low. Wouldn't it be great to know the percentage of these guys that are selling on GBTC *and* buying back real bitcoins at the lower levels? I guess we'll be able to infer on this if the price difference closes. Sounds like a new sort of diff chart could be in order.
|
|
|
|
|
|
phoenix1
|
 |
May 09, 2015, 11:28:28 AM Last edit: May 09, 2015, 11:43:23 AM by phoenix1 |
|
@ David Rahaby ... as you say you are long-minded (and I believe you) have you considered just how much the management fees will eat into your BTC over the years? IIRC correctly the annual fee is 2% of NAV and it is taken in BTC not USD, so if you start with 100 BTC ... After 10 years = 81.7 BTC After 20 years = 66.8 BTC After 25 years = 60.3 BTC
I am using these time periods as you talk about 'retirement funds'.
So if you hold BTC in this wrapper for 25 years you will pay away 40% in fees, which seems extortionate for something that pays no dividends or coupons, and requires no rebalancing for duration or weighting. It basically sits there in cold-storage.
Put another way, in 10 years, 10 shares of GBTC will not be approximately 1BTC, it will be approximately 0.82 BTC, and at that time the price of the fund should reflect this (ie be based upon it's NAV).
Just wondering if anyone is even looking at or thinking about this ...
|
"Before you embark on a journey of revenge, dig two graves" - Confucius (China 551BC-479 BC)
|
|
|
|