Bitcoin Forum
November 18, 2026, 08:34:08 PM *
News: Latest Bitcoin Core release: 32.1 [Torrent]
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register More  
Pages: « 1 ... 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 [79] 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 »
  Print  
Author Topic: GBTC Bitcoin Investment Trust Observer  (Read 262607 times)
RoadTrain
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1386
Merit: 1009


View Profile
May 09, 2015, 02:32:21 PM
 #1561

Sorry for being ignorant, but how technically these fund fees are paid?
JorgeStolfi
Hero Member
*****
Offline

Activity: 910
Merit: 1006



View Profile
May 09, 2015, 03:01:59 PM
 #1562

Sorry for being ignorant, but how technically these fund fees are paid?

They are discounted when the shares are redeemed, i.e. returned to Grayscale in exchange for the BTC they are supposed to stand for. 

Academic interest in bitcoin only. Not owner, not trader, very skeptical of its longterm success.
bclcjunkie
Hero Member
*****
Offline

Activity: 833
Merit: 1001



View Profile
May 09, 2015, 03:45:01 PM
 #1563

it's what's designed for: milk the next rich idiot's tits dry... the risk to these so called "bitcoin trust funds", as if we need them, is practically nil, these are the middlemen or parasites who just pass things around and get paid for that, not to mention occasional twitter blabbering...

i for one, would like this silly rally to go on and have more people like cypherdoc around because these are the kind of turn of events that help me stock up more on cheap gold... i can't wait to get rid of my last bitcoin bags and grab as much gold as possible...




@ David Rahaby  ... as you say you are long-minded  (and I believe you) have you considered just how much the management fees will eat into your BTC over the years? IIRC correctly the annual fee is 2% of NAV and it is taken in BTC not USD, so if you start with 100 BTC ...
After 10 years = 81.7 BTC
After 20 years = 66.8 BTC
After 25 years = 60.3 BTC

I am using these time periods as you talk about 'retirement funds'.

So if you hold BTC in this wrapper for 25 years you will pay away 40% in fees, which seems extortionate for something that pays no dividends or coupons, and requires no rebalancing for duration or weighting. It basically sits there in cold-storage.

Put another way, in 10 years, 10 shares of GBTC will not be approximately 1BTC, it will be approximately 0.82 BTC, and at that time the price of the fund should reflect this (ie be based upon it's NAV).

Just wondering if anyone is even looking at or thinking about this ...



 
jl2012 (OP)
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1792
Merit: 1164


View Profile
May 09, 2015, 03:53:40 PM
 #1564

@ David Rahaby  ... as you say you are long-minded  (and I believe you) have you considered just how much the management fees will eat into your BTC over the years? IIRC correctly the annual fee is 2% of NAV and it is taken in BTC not USD, so if you start with 100 BTC ...
After 10 years = 81.7 BTC
After 20 years = 66.8 BTC
After 25 years = 60.3 BTC

I am using these time periods as you talk about 'retirement funds'.

So if you hold BTC in this wrapper for 25 years you will pay away 40% in fees, which seems extortionate for something that pays no dividends or coupons, and requires no rebalancing for duration or weighting. It basically sits there in cold-storage.

Put another way, in 10 years, 10 shares of GBTC will not be approximately 1BTC, it will be approximately 0.82 BTC, and at that time the price of the fund should reflect this (ie be based upon it's NAV).

Just wondering if anyone is even looking at or thinking about this ...



 

The same is true for any retirement fund

Donation address: 374iXxS4BuqFHsEwwxUuH3nvJ69Y7Hqur3 (Bitcoin ONLY)
LRDGENPLYrcTRssGoZrsCT1hngaH3BVkM4 (LTC)
PGP: D3CC 1772 8600 5BB8 FF67 3294 C524 2A1A B393 6517
phoenix1
Hero Member
*****
Offline

Activity: 798
Merit: 1000



View Profile
May 09, 2015, 04:04:14 PM
 #1565


<GBTC fees>


The same is true for any retirement fund

Yes, but the fees are much lower unless you are going for something actively managed, and even then you would struggle to get anywhere near 2% annually unless you are talking decent hegde funds, where a good manager may take 2% p.a. plus a % of any profits (20% is not unusual).



"Before you embark on a journey of revenge, dig two graves"  - Confucius (China 551BC-479 BC)
JorgeStolfi
Hero Member
*****
Offline

Activity: 910
Merit: 1006



View Profile
May 09, 2015, 04:27:49 PM
 #1566

The same is true for any retirement fund

In my 20's, I and many colleagues here in Brazil contributed for a few years to a retirement fund that was supposed to be solid and traditional etc.  But then it goxxed...

Academic interest in bitcoin only. Not owner, not trader, very skeptical of its longterm success.
oda.krell
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1470
Merit: 1007



View Profile
May 09, 2015, 05:14:43 PM
 #1567

@ David Rahaby  ... as you say you are long-minded  (and I believe you) have you considered just how much the management fees will eat into your BTC over the years? IIRC correctly the annual fee is 2% of NAV and it is taken in BTC not USD, so if you start with 100 BTC ...
After 10 years = 81.7 BTC
After 20 years = 66.8 BTC
After 25 years = 60.3 BTC
[...]

Meh, I'm out of my element here (retirement fund and in the US), but isn't this a bit of a simplistic comparison?

As I understand it, the relevant point here is that GBTC is compatible with a Roth IRA, which is (intended to be) tax free, so depending on how capital gains for "raw" Bitcoin holdings are (and will be) taxed, and whether you are planning to pay those taxes (or, if not, whether you get away with it), those "2% per year" could either turn out to be a lot, or not that much.

Someone more knowledgeable on the topic, please feel free to correct me if the above is factually wrong.

Not sure which Bitcoin wallet you should use? Get Electrum!
Electrum is an open-source lightweight client: fast, user friendly, and 100% secure.
Download the source or executables for Windows/OSX/Linux/Android from, and only from, the official Electrum homepage.
ErisDiscordia
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1133
Merit: 1163


Imposition of ORder = Escalation of Chaos


View Profile
May 09, 2015, 05:23:38 PM
 #1568

The same is true for any retirement fund

In my 20's, I and many colleagues here in Brazil contributed for a few years to a retirement fund that was supposed to be solid and traditional etc.  But then it goxxed...

let me guess, it was government-run? Cheesy

In case it wasn't it was of course the failure of not enough government oversight Wink

It's all bullshit. But bullshit makes the flowers grow and that's beautiful.
phoenix1
Hero Member
*****
Offline

Activity: 798
Merit: 1000



View Profile
May 09, 2015, 06:58:07 PM
Last edit: May 09, 2015, 07:32:42 PM by phoenix1
 #1569

@ David Rahaby  ... as you say you are long-minded  (and I believe you) have you considered just how much the management fees will eat into your BTC over the years? IIRC correctly the annual fee is 2% of NAV and it is taken in BTC not USD, so if you start with 100 BTC ...
After 10 years = 81.7 BTC
After 20 years = 66.8 BTC
After 25 years = 60.3 BTC
[...]

Meh, I'm out of my element here (retirement fund and in the US), but isn't this a bit of a simplistic comparison?

As I understand it, the relevant point here is that GBTC is compatible with a Roth IRA, which is (intended to be) tax free, so depending on how capital gains for "raw" Bitcoin holdings are (and will be) taxed, and whether you are planning to pay those taxes (or, if not, whether you get away with it), those "2% per year" could either turn out to be a lot, or not that much.

Someone more knowledgeable on the topic, please feel free to correct me if the above is factually wrong.

Hey, I'm open to being corrected to too  Wink
But as I see it, this is not a simplistic comparison - simplistic compared to what ? This is one 'predetermined' side of the coin that any 'investor' needs to consider before putting funds in. I am no expert on retirement funds either, but what is crystal clear is that 40% of your BTC will have been paid away in fees if you hold for 25 years. Period. You might as well call it 'tax' (meet the new gubinment - same as the old gubinment Smiley)

The tax implications of holding it for less than x years or trading in and out of, I have no idea about, other than I would assume that holding it for less time will give less tax relief, if any. Just pointing out that if the motivation is solely 'reduced taxes' and holding period is 'until retirement', you are paying a very high 'tax' for the privelege, one that can only be weighed up against individual circumstances. That's the other side of the coin ... ok ... yeah, that side is not so simple  Cheesy

EDIT: If you are unlucky enough to buy at a price that gives you NO capital gains, you will have an extra 40% loss that you would not have incurred otherwise (in the 25 yr scenario)





"Before you embark on a journey of revenge, dig two graves"  - Confucius (China 551BC-479 BC)
bobabouey2
Sr. Member
****
Offline

Activity: 248
Merit: 250


View Profile
May 09, 2015, 07:35:22 PM
 #1570

@ David Rahaby  ... as you say you are long-minded  (and I believe you) have you considered just how much the management fees will eat into your BTC over the years? IIRC correctly the annual fee is 2% of NAV and it is taken in BTC not USD, so if you start with 100 BTC ...
After 10 years = 81.7 BTC
After 20 years = 66.8 BTC
After 25 years = 60.3 BTC

I am using these time periods as you talk about 'retirement funds'.

So if you hold BTC in this wrapper for 25 years you will pay away 40% in fees, which seems extortionate for something that pays no dividends or coupons, and requires no rebalancing for duration or weighting. It basically sits there in cold-storage.

Put another way, in 10 years, 10 shares of GBTC will not be approximately 1BTC, it will be approximately 0.82 BTC, and at that time the price of the fund should reflect this (ie be based upon it's NAV).

Just wondering if anyone is even looking at or thinking about this ...

 

In the short term, since it was easier to get the BIT into a tax deferred retirement account, the fees are probably worth it.

Long term, if bitcoin takes off, there will no doubt be competition, and COIN / other investment vehicles will pop up with lower fees.  And since it is in a tax-deferred account, David will be able to roll into one of those investments without taking a capital gain hit.
phoenix1
Hero Member
*****
Offline

Activity: 798
Merit: 1000



View Profile
May 09, 2015, 08:20:01 PM
 #1571


In the short term, since it was easier to get the BIT into a tax deferred retirement account, the fees are probably worth it.

Long term, if bitcoin takes off, there will no doubt be competition, and COIN / other investment vehicles will pop up with lower fees.  And since it is in a tax-deferred account, David will be able to roll into one of those investments without taking a capital gain hit.

I hear you. Over time if more of these vehicles are created, fees will drop. I read somewhere that fees on some ETF's are as low as 0.04%. Makes this one seem even more extortionate. And I would imagine COIN will not be in a hurry to undercut GBIT by very much, if at all, given they will be a genuine ETF.
We will need a lot more competition than that to see fees drop significantly IMO.

Interesting to hear that he could 'roll' between them without penalties. I have no knowledge of any of these rules.
How does the tax deferral of a retirement account work? If it is just a deferral, is any CGT paid at the same rate at the end of the day? Or is there some tax relief too?

"Before you embark on a journey of revenge, dig two graves"  - Confucius (China 551BC-479 BC)
JorgeStolfi
Hero Member
*****
Offline

Activity: 910
Merit: 1006



View Profile
May 09, 2015, 08:26:15 PM
 #1572

let me guess, it was government-run? Cheesy

In case it wasn't it was of course the failure of not enough government oversight Wink

No, it was a private plan (sorry to disappoint you).  Government pensions have been "adjusted" at times,  but they have been surprisingly dependable over half a century or more, even through bouts of hyperinflation and currency changes, military dictatorships, neocon governments, keynesian-socialist governments, just plain corrupt governments...

Of course, that collapse was indeed a failure of government oversight.  (The military were in power at the time, so the only license that a business really needed was the support of some general, and the only finacial reports that had to be filed were those printed on 2" x 5" pieces of paper.  Not that things have improved much since then.)

Academic interest in bitcoin only. Not owner, not trader, very skeptical of its longterm success.
bobabouey2
Sr. Member
****
Offline

Activity: 248
Merit: 250


View Profile
May 09, 2015, 09:57:23 PM
 #1573


In the short term, since it was easier to get the BIT into a tax deferred retirement account, the fees are probably worth it.

Long term, if bitcoin takes off, there will no doubt be competition, and COIN / other investment vehicles will pop up with lower fees.  And since it is in a tax-deferred account, David will be able to roll into one of those investments without taking a capital gain hit.

I hear you. Over time if more of these vehicles are created, fees will drop. I read somewhere that fees on some ETF's are as low as 0.04%. Makes this one seem even more extortionate. And I would imagine COIN will not be in a hurry to undercut GBIT by very much, if at all, given they will be a genuine ETF.
We will need a lot more competition than that to see fees drop significantly IMO.

Interesting to hear that he could 'roll' between them without penalties. I have no knowledge of any of these rules.
How does the tax deferral of a retirement account work? If it is just a deferral, is any CGT paid at the same rate at the end of the day? Or is there some tax relief too?

There are two general types.  One a 401k or simple IRA, allows you to invest a certain amount of income, and that investment is not considered earnings or otherwise taxed (meaning you can invest more upfront).  The investment then grows without taxes, capital gains or dividends.  When you reach the qualifying age and withdraw the money, it is taxed as ordinary income.  But, ideally you are in a lower tax bracket as you are retired.

Roth IRAs let you invest after tax income, but then distributions are not taxed.

Lots of other details.
phoenix1
Hero Member
*****
Offline

Activity: 798
Merit: 1000



View Profile
May 09, 2015, 10:17:52 PM
 #1574


In the short term, since it was easier to get the BIT into a tax deferred retirement account, the fees are probably worth it.

Long term, if bitcoin takes off, there will no doubt be competition, and COIN / other investment vehicles will pop up with lower fees.  And since it is in a tax-deferred account, David will be able to roll into one of those investments without taking a capital gain hit.

I hear you. Over time if more of these vehicles are created, fees will drop. I read somewhere that fees on some ETF's are as low as 0.04%. Makes this one seem even more extortionate. And I would imagine COIN will not be in a hurry to undercut GBIT by very much, if at all, given they will be a genuine ETF.
We will need a lot more competition than that to see fees drop significantly IMO.

Interesting to hear that he could 'roll' between them without penalties. I have no knowledge of any of these rules.
How does the tax deferral of a retirement account work? If it is just a deferral, is any CGT paid at the same rate at the end of the day? Or is there some tax relief too?

There are two general types.  One a 401k or simple IRA, allows you to invest a certain amount of income, and that investment is not considered earnings or otherwise taxed (meaning you can invest more upfront).  The investment then grows without taxes, capital gains or dividends.  When you reach the qualifying age and withdraw the money, it is taxed as ordinary income.  But, ideally you are in a lower tax bracket as you are retired.

Roth IRAs let you invest after tax income, but then distributions are not taxed.

Lots of other details.

Thanks for the reply - yeh, I am sure there are loads of other details lol , but I think I understand the basic differences now

Can a BTC 'ETF' be part of either or just the Roth?

"Before you embark on a journey of revenge, dig two graves"  - Confucius (China 551BC-479 BC)
Chef Ramsay
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1568
Merit: 1001



View Profile
May 09, 2015, 10:56:15 PM
 #1575


In the short term, since it was easier to get the BIT into a tax deferred retirement account, the fees are probably worth it.

Long term, if bitcoin takes off, there will no doubt be competition, and COIN / other investment vehicles will pop up with lower fees.  And since it is in a tax-deferred account, David will be able to roll into one of those investments without taking a capital gain hit.

I hear you. Over time if more of these vehicles are created, fees will drop. I read somewhere that fees on some ETF's are as low as 0.04%. Makes this one seem even more extortionate. And I would imagine COIN will not be in a hurry to undercut GBIT by very much, if at all, given they will be a genuine ETF.
We will need a lot more competition than that to see fees drop significantly IMO.

Interesting to hear that he could 'roll' between them without penalties. I have no knowledge of any of these rules.
How does the tax deferral of a retirement account work? If it is just a deferral, is any CGT paid at the same rate at the end of the day? Or is there some tax relief too?

There are two general types.  One a 401k or simple IRA, allows you to invest a certain amount of income, and that investment is not considered earnings or otherwise taxed (meaning you can invest more upfront).  The investment then grows without taxes, capital gains or dividends.  When you reach the qualifying age and withdraw the money, it is taxed as ordinary income.  But, ideally you are in a lower tax bracket as you are retired.

Roth IRAs let you invest after tax income, but then distributions are not taxed.

Lots of other details.
Which is subject to change when they run out of money to tap into and subsequently come for pensions and 401Ks to nationalize. Or, the market just collapses and you're wiped out either way.
phoenix1
Hero Member
*****
Offline

Activity: 798
Merit: 1000



View Profile
May 09, 2015, 11:10:40 PM
 #1576


Which is subject to change when they run out of money to tap into and subsequently come for pensions and 401Ks to nationalize. Or, the market just collapses and you're wiped out either way.

Lol !! You cynic you !!
But you're probably right - pension fund raids have been done before and they will be done again ...  Undecided
Which makes someone else holding BTC in a fund for you seem even more risky, and all the while you pay them a nice chunk for their efforts ...

"Before you embark on a journey of revenge, dig two graves"  - Confucius (China 551BC-479 BC)
Mayer Amschel
Full Member
***
Offline

Activity: 140
Merit: 100


View Profile
May 10, 2015, 08:12:04 AM
 #1577

The prices should go over 300 soon.

- Mayer Amschel

Hours
BitcoinIsLiberty
Newbie
*
Offline

Activity: 55
Merit: 0


View Profile
May 10, 2015, 02:50:40 PM
 #1578

http://insidebitcoins.com/news/barry-silbert-plans-to-have-bitcoin-fund-traded-on-nasdaq-or-nyse/32161
“Our plan is to have [the Bitcoin Investment Trust] listed on either NASDAQ or New York Stock Exchange as fast as possible. We have selected a law firm to go through the registration process with us, and we intend to file with the SEC . . . as soon as possible. We will then be in the same boat as the Winklevoss brothers.”

Assuming they file right now would there be a chance they can beat COIN out the gates or would their filing have to go through the same long process?
coinableS
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1484
Merit: 1191



View Profile
May 10, 2015, 03:07:10 PM
 #1579

http://insidebitcoins.com/news/barry-silbert-plans-to-have-bitcoin-fund-traded-on-nasdaq-or-nyse/32161
“Our plan is to have [the Bitcoin Investment Trust] listed on either NASDAQ or New York Stock Exchange as fast as possible. We have selected a law firm to go through the registration process with us, and we intend to file with the SEC . . . as soon as possible. We will then be in the same boat as the Winklevoss brothers.”

Assuming they file right now would there be a chance they can beat COIN out the gates or would their filing have to go through the same long process?

Except COIN would be way more liquid as a true ETF instead of the trust that Barry hacked together to squeeze into the markets. Once both are available through major markets I'm pretty certain that most people would choose to trade COIN over GBTC. Time will tell!
JorgeStolfi
Hero Member
*****
Offline

Activity: 910
Merit: 1006



View Profile
May 10, 2015, 05:44:19 PM
 #1580

http://insidebitcoins.com/news/barry-silbert-plans-to-have-bitcoin-fund-traded-on-nasdaq-or-nyse/32161
“Our plan is to have [the Bitcoin Investment Trust] listed on either NASDAQ or New York Stock Exchange as fast as possible. We have selected a law firm to go through the registration process with us, and we intend to file with the SEC . . . as soon as possible. We will then be in the same boat as the Winklevoss brothers.”

Assuming they file right now would there be a chance they can beat COIN out the gates or would their filing have to go through the same long process?

It is not just a bureaucratic process. The SEC has to decide whether they will allow the fund to be traded or not.  It is not surprising that the SEC is still undecided, because it is the first fund whose only backing asset is a virtual currency with no backing asset.

If BIT can convince the SEC that they are better than COIN in some relevant sense, I suppose that they could be approved before COIN.  Or, even, BIT may be approved and COIN denied, or vice-versa.

Academic interest in bitcoin only. Not owner, not trader, very skeptical of its longterm success.
Pages: « 1 ... 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 [79] 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 »
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.19 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!