rdnkjdi
Legendary

Activity: 1257
Merit: 1009
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 02:38:19 PM |
|
Is there anywhere we can see the current dev fund status / amount?
The view key for the XMR fund is in the OP...we just need to provide tooling for that:) We've received around 25.3 BTC in XMR donations, and 7.80559 BTC in BTC donations, so a total of 33.10559 BTC. Actual expenses / contributor tips / freelancers / mathematicians+cryptographers / hosting have been significantly higher (in the region of 110 BTC excluding the core team's time), which we have been covering out of our pockets. In other words, we're in a perpetually negative balance. For whatever it's worth ... I'll dedicate 5-10% of my holdings towards dev fund. May be a few days & not a lot. I did notice adding up all the XMR donations in the thread rptellia created was quite a bit more than 25 BTC (more like 40?) so I guess you must've exchanged them at lower rates to pay for expenses? I think it would be a great PR move to somehow make how much "in the hole" the project is as far as what the devteam has spent on what more visible. I know it's a labor of love but in my opinion it should be fully funded. Maybe making it visible that the people doing the technical work are also pulling the financial load will help resolve that. Or maybe not too. People are greedy to the point of hurting themselves.
|
|
|
|
|
fluffypony
Donator
Legendary

Activity: 1274
Merit: 1069
GetMonero.org / MyMonero.com
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 02:54:33 PM |
|
I did notice adding up all the XMR donations in the thread rptellia created was quite a bit more than 25 BTC (more like 40?) so I guess you must've exchanged them at lower rates to pay for expenses?
Yes - rates are at-the-time that the expense needs to be paid, so obviously donations took a beating when the exchange rate was quite a bit lower. I think it would be a great PR move to somehow make how much "in the hole" the project is as far as what the devteam has spent on what more visible. I know it's a labor of love but in my opinion it should be fully funded. Maybe making it visible that the people doing the technical work are also pulling the financial load will help resolve that.
Or maybe not too. People are greedy to the point of hurting themselves.
It is kinda frustrating to see other projects raise hundreds and thousands of BTC based on a whim and a promise...but then again, it does change the dynamic as respects the integrity of the project. If we're perpetually in the negative there's nobody's money we can run away with:-P
|
|
|
|
|
halorose
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 03:01:28 PM |
|
the updated version may be being blocked.
|
|
|
|
|
tacotime
Legendary

Activity: 1484
Merit: 1011
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 03:04:47 PM |
|
It's kind of sad... Monero has attracted some of the smartest minds I've seen in cryptocurrencies and cryptography, but we don't have enough money to pay to developed even 1/4 of the things we need to. It costs about $100-150 an hour to contract a decent programmer to hack (and please don't start on the value of third world programmers, if you're talking about that you've probably never used them), or $800-1200 a day. I would estimate that ByteCoin put in about a half million USD to get their project off the ground, which is probably why they've been trolling us so hard. But, the fact of the matter is, we're either paying out of pocket or (like me) working completely for free.
Monero is about a lot more than pumping and dumping -- it uses many of the features that have been desired from core devs over time like privacy and faster/more secure EdDSA (which uses Schnorr signatures). But there are major, major architectural overhauls to the core code that need to be done to give it even a fraction of the usability of BTC, and I fear we won't be able to afford that. I suspect we need at least 0.25-0.50M USD per year to keep things moving along smoothly, and we're not getting close to $21K USD a month in donations.
|
XMR: 44GBHzv6ZyQdJkjqZje6KLZ3xSyN1hBSFAnLP6EAqJtCRVzMzZmeXTC2AHKDS9aEDTRKmo6a6o9r9j86pYfhCWDkKjbtcns
|
|
|
oda.krell
Legendary

Activity: 1470
Merit: 1007
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 03:06:27 PM |
|
I did notice adding up all the XMR donations in the thread rptellia created was quite a bit more than 25 BTC (more like 40?) so I guess you must've exchanged them at lower rates to pay for expenses?
Yes - rates are at-the-time that the expense needs to be paid, so obviously donations took a beating when the exchange rate was quite a bit lower. I think it would be a great PR move to somehow make how much "in the hole" the project is as far as what the devteam has spent on what more visible. I know it's a labor of love but in my opinion it should be fully funded. Maybe making it visible that the people doing the technical work are also pulling the financial load will help resolve that.
Or maybe not too. People are greedy to the point of hurting themselves.
It is kinda frustrating to see other projects raise hundreds and thousands of BTC based on a whim and a promise...but then again, it does change the dynamic as respects the integrity of the project. If we're perpetually in the negative there's nobody's money we can run away with:-PAmusing as that thought is, it's not a permanently viable solution. I will add my share to the fund in BTC (not exactly now, I'm a bit short for that), but I hope there are some plans to accompany meeting one of the larger goals (official GUI release, for example) with a more concerted fundraiser. Yes?
|
Not sure which Bitcoin wallet you should use? Get Electrum!Electrum is an open-source lightweight client: fast, user friendly, and 100% secure. Download the source or executables for Windows/OSX/Linux/Android from, and only from, the official Electrum homepage.
|
|
|
Anon136
Legendary

Activity: 1722
Merit: 1217
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 03:18:10 PM |
|
I guess ill go ahead and bring up my idea of crowd funding again. Tell us how much it will cost to have the database finished. Tell us when it will be completed if you do raise the funds. Then I will hold peoples funds in escrow until enough is raised. The moment the funding goal is reached i will deliver the funds to the devs as per the arrangement. If the funding goal is not reached than I will refund everyone’s money.
See rep thread in signature if you are concerned about whether I am qualified for this task.
|
Rep Thread: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=381041If one can not confer upon another a right which he does not himself first possess, by what means does the state derive the right to engage in behaviors from which the public is prohibited?
|
|
|
|
OrientA
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 03:18:18 PM |
|
It's kind of sad... Monero has attracted some of the smartest minds I've seen in cryptocurrencies and cryptography, but we don't have enough money to pay to developed even 1/4 of the things we need to. It costs about $100-150 an hour to contract a decent programmer to hack (and please don't start on the value of third world programmers, if you're talking about that you've probably never used them), or $800-1200 a day. I would estimate that ByteCoin put in about a half million USD to get their project off the ground, which is probably why they've been trolling us so hard. But, the fact of the matter is, we're either paying out of pocket or (like me) working completely for free.
Monero is about a lot more than pumping and dumping -- it uses many of the features that have been desired from core devs over time like privacy and faster/more secure EdDSA (which uses Schnorr signatures). But there are major, major architectural overhauls to the core code that need to be done to give it even a fraction of the usability of BTC, and I fear we won't be able to afford that. I suspect we need at least 0.25-0.50M USD per year to keep things moving along smoothly, and we're not getting close to $21K USD a month in donations.
At present, we mine about 20k XMR a day, 1% of that is 200 XMR or about $400. Can we make the the block reward to pay 1% of coins to a wallet controlled by developer? As the value of XMR increases, the reward will also decrease, making the payment almost constant or higher if XMR appreciate faster.
|
|
|
|
|
nioc
Legendary

Activity: 1624
Merit: 1008
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 03:18:32 PM |
|
After updating to 8.8.4 and receiving no error messages I woke up to the following. I just checked the log and it started over an hour ago.
Before going to sleep I sent another small donation.
2014-Sep-17 11:08:37.602952 [P2P7]ERROR c:\users\ric_000\desktop\bitmonero\contr ib\epee\include\net\abstract_tcp_server2.inl:307 send que size is more than ABST RACT_SERVER_SEND_QUE_MAX_COUNT(1000), shutting down connection 2014-Sep-17 11:08:37.612959 [P2P7]ERROR c:\users\ric_000\desktop\bitmonero\contr ib\epee\include\net\abstract_tcp_server2.inl:307 send que size is more than ABST RACT_SERVER_SEND_QUE_MAX_COUNT(1000), shutting down connection 2014-Sep-17 11:08:48.546157 [P2P4]ERROR c:\users\ric_000\desktop\bitmonero\contr ib\epee\include\net\abstract_tcp_server2.inl:307 send que size is more than ABST RACT_SERVER_SEND_QUE_MAX_COUNT(1000), shutting down connection 2014-Sep-17 11:08:48.599194 [P2P4]ERROR c:\users\ric_000\desktop\bitmonero\contr ib\epee\include\net\abstract_tcp_server2.inl:307 send que size is more than ABST RACT_SERVER_SEND_QUE_MAX_COUNT(1000), shutting down connection 2014-Sep-17 11:09:07.189484 [P2P5]ERROR c:\users\ric_000\desktop\bitmonero\contr ib\epee\include\net\abstract_tcp_server2.inl:307 send que size is more than ABST RACT_SERVER_SEND_QUE_MAX_COUNT(1000), shutting down connection 2014-Sep-17 11:09:07.199491 [P2P5]ERROR c:\users\ric_000\desktop\bitmonero\contr ib\epee\include\net\abstract_tcp_server2.inl:307 send que size is more than ABST RACT_SERVER_SEND_QUE_MAX_COUNT(1000), shutting down connection 2014-Sep-17 11:09:49.791634 [P2P9]ERROR c:\users\ric_000\desktop\bitmonero\contr ib\epee\include\net\abstract_tcp_server2.inl:307 send que size is more than ABST RACT_SERVER_SEND_QUE_MAX_COUNT(1000), shutting down connection 2014-Sep-17 11:09:49.832649 [P2P9]ERROR c:\users\ric_000\desktop\bitmonero\contr ib\epee\include\net\abstract_tcp_server2.inl:307 send que size is more than ABST RACT_SERVER_SEND_QUE_MAX_COUNT(1000), shutting down connection
|
|
|
|
|
mmortal03
Legendary

Activity: 1762
Merit: 1011
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 03:27:58 PM |
|
It is kinda frustrating to see other projects raise hundreds and thousands of BTC based on a whim and a promise...but then again, it does change the dynamic as respects the integrity of the project. If we're perpetually in the negative there's nobody's money we can run away with:-P
Those other projects usually have prettier websites and make use of other PR techniques. While I personally like the fact that the devs here are focusing on the fundamentals of the backend, I've come to the conclusion that I'm in the minority on that.
|
|
|
|
|
Anon136
Legendary

Activity: 1722
Merit: 1217
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 03:32:19 PM |
|
It's kind of sad... Monero has attracted some of the smartest minds I've seen in cryptocurrencies and cryptography, but we don't have enough money to pay to developed even 1/4 of the things we need to. It costs about $100-150 an hour to contract a decent programmer to hack (and please don't start on the value of third world programmers, if you're talking about that you've probably never used them), or $800-1200 a day. I would estimate that ByteCoin put in about a half million USD to get their project off the ground, which is probably why they've been trolling us so hard. But, the fact of the matter is, we're either paying out of pocket or (like me) working completely for free.
Monero is about a lot more than pumping and dumping -- it uses many of the features that have been desired from core devs over time like privacy and faster/more secure EdDSA (which uses Schnorr signatures). But there are major, major architectural overhauls to the core code that need to be done to give it even a fraction of the usability of BTC, and I fear we won't be able to afford that. I suspect we need at least 0.25-0.50M USD per year to keep things moving along smoothly, and we're not getting close to $21K USD a month in donations.
At present, we mine about 20k XMR a day, 1% of that is 200 XMR or about $400. Can we make the the block reward to pay 1% of coins to a wallet controlled by developer? As the value of XMR increases, the reward will also decrease, making the payment almost constant or higher if XMR appreciate faster. Thats actually a brilliant idea. Release a fork that pays part of the mining rewards automatically to the devs. If people dont like it than they dont have to use that fork. If the network splits into two, one where we have all of the devs being properly compensated and devloping appropriately, and another fork where its just some stubborn guys who dont like the proposal hording and sitting on coins that arnt being developed, than i think we know which would win out in the long run. If they want to fork and get their own devs and follow a more traditional funding model, than great we will have 2 competing cryptos that would both be pretty interesting. I might throw some capital into both. Its not forcing people to pay you either. You provide some code, built in is what you guys want to be compensated for it, and only people who value your code more highly than what you are charging will decide to use it. Its totally fair. Just like a store putting a price tag on a product that they are selling. You either buy it or dont depending on how you feel about the price. I obviously understand the drawbacks. We would be assailed for having an element of centralization. But i really think that when you weigh the costs and the benefits against each other, atleast superficially, we get to a point where we really really really should be atleast talking about this. Also obviously this would have to be temporary. The devs would need to commit to weaning off of such a system after given features are implemented or a given period of time.
|
Rep Thread: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=381041If one can not confer upon another a right which he does not himself first possess, by what means does the state derive the right to engage in behaviors from which the public is prohibited?
|
|
|
aminorex
Legendary

Activity: 1596
Merit: 1031
Sine secretum non libertas
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 03:36:45 PM |
|
I guess ill go ahead and bring up my idea of crowd funding again. Tell us how much it will cost to have the database finished. Tell us when it will be completed if you do raise the funds. Then I will hold peoples funds in escrow until enough is raised. The moment the funding goal is reached i will deliver the funds to the devs as per the arrangement. If the funding goal is not reached than I will refund everyone’s money.
See rep thread in signature if you are concerned about whether I am qualified for this task.
Wouldn't it be better to do it on kickstarter or the like? Wider audience. BTCT is a ghetto.
|
Give a man a fish and he eats for a day. Give a man a Poisson distribution and he eats at random times independent of one another, at a constant known rate.
|
|
|
mmortal03
Legendary

Activity: 1762
Merit: 1011
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 03:37:33 PM |
|
It's kind of sad... Monero has attracted some of the smartest minds I've seen in cryptocurrencies and cryptography, but we don't have enough money to pay to developed even 1/4 of the things we need to. It costs about $100-150 an hour to contract a decent programmer to hack (and please don't start on the value of third world programmers, if you're talking about that you've probably never used them), or $800-1200 a day. I would estimate that ByteCoin put in about a half million USD to get their project off the ground, which is probably why they've been trolling us so hard. But, the fact of the matter is, we're either paying out of pocket or (like me) working completely for free.
Monero is about a lot more than pumping and dumping -- it uses many of the features that have been desired from core devs over time like privacy and faster/more secure EdDSA (which uses Schnorr signatures). But there are major, major architectural overhauls to the core code that need to be done to give it even a fraction of the usability of BTC, and I fear we won't be able to afford that. I suspect we need at least 0.25-0.50M USD per year to keep things moving along smoothly, and we're not getting close to $21K USD a month in donations.
At present, we mine about 20k XMR a day, 1% of that is 200 XMR or about $400. Can we make the the block reward to pay 1% of coins to a wallet controlled by developer? As the value of XMR increases, the reward will also decrease, making the payment almost constant or higher if XMR appreciate faster. Thats actually a brilliant idea. Release a fork that pays part of the mining rewards automatically to the devs. If people dont like it than they dont have to use that fork. If the network splits into two, one where we have all of the devs being properly compensated and devloping appropriately, and another fork where its just some stubborn guys who dont like the proposal hording and sitting on coins that arnt being developed, than i think we know which would win out in the long run. If they want to fork and get their own devs and follow a more traditional funding model, than great we will have 2 competing cryptos that would both be pretty interesting. I might throw some capital into both. I obviously understand the drawbacks. We would be assailed for having an element of centralization. But i really think that when you weigh the costs and the benefits against each other, atleast superficially, we get to a point where we really really really should be atleast talking about this. Also obviously this would have to be temporary. The devs would need to commit to weaning off of such a system after given features are implemented or a given period of time. I would suggest exhausting all possible external options for raising funds before building something into the software. I think going this other route would be more scandalized and trolled than you're considering.
|
|
|
|
|
Anon136
Legendary

Activity: 1722
Merit: 1217
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 03:39:31 PM |
|
It's kind of sad... Monero has attracted some of the smartest minds I've seen in cryptocurrencies and cryptography, but we don't have enough money to pay to developed even 1/4 of the things we need to. It costs about $100-150 an hour to contract a decent programmer to hack (and please don't start on the value of third world programmers, if you're talking about that you've probably never used them), or $800-1200 a day. I would estimate that ByteCoin put in about a half million USD to get their project off the ground, which is probably why they've been trolling us so hard. But, the fact of the matter is, we're either paying out of pocket or (like me) working completely for free.
Monero is about a lot more than pumping and dumping -- it uses many of the features that have been desired from core devs over time like privacy and faster/more secure EdDSA (which uses Schnorr signatures). But there are major, major architectural overhauls to the core code that need to be done to give it even a fraction of the usability of BTC, and I fear we won't be able to afford that. I suspect we need at least 0.25-0.50M USD per year to keep things moving along smoothly, and we're not getting close to $21K USD a month in donations.
At present, we mine about 20k XMR a day, 1% of that is 200 XMR or about $400. Can we make the the block reward to pay 1% of coins to a wallet controlled by developer? As the value of XMR increases, the reward will also decrease, making the payment almost constant or higher if XMR appreciate faster. Thats actually a brilliant idea. Release a fork that pays part of the mining rewards automatically to the devs. If people dont like it than they dont have to use that fork. If the network splits into two, one where we have all of the devs being properly compensated and devloping appropriately, and another fork where its just some stubborn guys who dont like the proposal hording and sitting on coins that arnt being developed, than i think we know which would win out in the long run. If they want to fork and get their own devs and follow a more traditional funding model, than great we will have 2 competing cryptos that would both be pretty interesting. I might throw some capital into both. I obviously understand the drawbacks. We would be assailed for having an element of centralization. But i really think that when you weigh the costs and the benefits against each other, atleast superficially, we get to a point where we really really really should be atleast talking about this. Also obviously this would have to be temporary. The devs would need to commit to weaning off of such a system after given features are implemented or a given period of time. I would suggest exhausting all possible external options for raising funds before building something into the software. I think going this other route would be more scandalized and trolled than you're considering. well there is the crowd funding idea that i mentioned a few posts back. we could always try that first.
|
Rep Thread: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=381041If one can not confer upon another a right which he does not himself first possess, by what means does the state derive the right to engage in behaviors from which the public is prohibited?
|
|
|
oda.krell
Legendary

Activity: 1470
Merit: 1007
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 03:41:31 PM |
|
plus 1 for classical fundraising, minus... a lot for a forkraiser. As if we don't have enough detractors, just imagine what will happen if we build a payout into the protocol.
That said, I'm kinda out of the loop here: is there a Bitcoin accepting Kickstarter-like site in the wild?
What about the Mike Hearn 'alternative to the BTC foundation' project, that is supposed to combine community decision making with fundraising? Any ETA on that, and whether it'll be usable by alts?
|
Not sure which Bitcoin wallet you should use? Get Electrum!Electrum is an open-source lightweight client: fast, user friendly, and 100% secure. Download the source or executables for Windows/OSX/Linux/Android from, and only from, the official Electrum homepage.
|
|
|
aminorex
Legendary

Activity: 1596
Merit: 1031
Sine secretum non libertas
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 03:44:42 PM |
|
[...consensus enforced reward share...]
When considering such options, please be careful not to poison XMR's image. I would rather pay 50% out of pocket voluntarily than 1% involuntarily - because I think an involuntary payment will degrade the value of the currency by more than 50%. It would be a value-destroying option. [Note that no one is proposing a brute tax here - just brainstorming.] BBR's method is less damaging to the currency than a brute tax: It is default opt-in, IIRC, which is not so bad. It doesn't press a one-sided change in contract.
|
Give a man a fish and he eats for a day. Give a man a Poisson distribution and he eats at random times independent of one another, at a constant known rate.
|
|
|
aminorex
Legendary

Activity: 1596
Merit: 1031
Sine secretum non libertas
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 03:48:40 PM |
|
What about the Mike Hearn 'alternative to the BTC foundation' project, that is supposed to combine community decision making with fundraising? Any ETA on that, and whether it'll be usable by alts?
MEW does this for XMR. An open cross-currency foundation would command a pathetically limited kingdom, because they are so often at each other's throats (often irrationally).
|
Give a man a fish and he eats for a day. Give a man a Poisson distribution and he eats at random times independent of one another, at a constant known rate.
|
|
|
|
pinky
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 04:02:21 PM |
|
I guess ill go ahead and bring up my idea of crowd funding again. Tell us how much it will cost to have the database finished. Tell us when it will be completed if you do raise the funds. Then I will hold peoples funds in escrow until enough is raised. The moment the funding goal is reached i will deliver the funds to the devs as per the arrangement. If the funding goal is not reached than I will refund everyone’s money.
See rep thread in signature if you are concerned about whether I am qualified for this task.
Wouldn't it be better to do it on kickstarter or the like? Wider audience. BTCT is a ghetto. Yes, this is the way to go. Anon136 idea of forking in order to give 1% of mining reward to dev team is bad and will only bring confusion. If that would to occur xmr would become worthless. Forking is violent way of doing things. Kickstarter idea works in real world. Devs (or maybe MEW?) only need to create page where they or any other interested party could publish ideas for xmr changes/projects. Of course they will have to make a good arguments in layman terms why this changes would be beneficial and how much would it cost. Distinguished members or multisig wallet or donators vote will decide if job is finished.
|
|
|
|
|
Ultros
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 04:28:36 PM |
|
Did you see this? https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=786201.0 [...]
* I have found very specific exploits in CN that have not been fixed that would be successful on XMR. Most are what I call annoyance attacks, that would be fixed and the coin would probably survive, but one is a coin killer. In XMR there exist a flaw involving the keyrings that under the right conditions will allow an attacker to steal your wallets and hijack your addresses. To fix this, anonymity will need to be sacrificed. These exploits are why two top exchanges who have asked for my opinion have not added XMR.
[...]
|
|
|
|
|
fluffypony
Donator
Legendary

Activity: 1274
Merit: 1069
GetMonero.org / MyMonero.com
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 04:37:26 PM |
|
Also obviously this would have to be temporary. The devs would need to commit to weaning off of such a system after given features are implemented or a given period of time.
I would suggest exhausting all possible external options for raising funds before building something into the software. I think going this other route would be more scandalized and trolled than you're considering. I don't think that it's fundamentally bad to build something into the software. Not sure if you saw the Missive, but in the last wizard screenshot there's an idea for an auto-donation system we want to implement: https://i.imgur.com/ACDmOFJ.jpgThe basic idea is that it's completely user-selectable, based on a % of your tx fee (cumulative to avoid adding dust outputs) that is added on top of the tx fee, so it'll never have a major impact. In the GUI we'd most likely have it on at 50% by default.
|
|
|
|
rpietila
Donator
Legendary

Activity: 1722
Merit: 1037
|
 |
September 17, 2014, 04:48:53 PM |
|
Regarding donations - we already have about 20% of the Monero owners joining MEW. If we get this number to about 50%, then it will be easier to fund development as a community effort because there is no free riding.
|
HIM TVA Dragon, AOK-GM, Emperor of the Earth, Creator of the World, King of Crypto Kingdom, Lord of Malla, AOD-GEN, SA-GEN5, Ministry of Plenty (Join NOW!), Professor of Economics and Theology, Ph.D, AM, Chairman, Treasurer, Founder, CEO, 3*MG-2, 82*OHK, NKP, WTF, FFF, etc(x3)
|
|
|
|