Bitcoin Forum
November 20, 2026, 05:14:03 PM *
News: Latest Bitcoin Core release: 32.1 [Torrent]
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register More  
Pages: « 1 ... 687 688 689 690 691 692 693 694 695 696 697 698 699 700 701 702 703 704 705 706 707 708 709 710 711 712 713 714 715 716 717 718 719 720 721 722 723 724 725 726 727 728 729 730 731 732 733 734 735 736 [737] 738 739 740 741 742 743 744 745 746 747 748 749 750 751 752 753 754 755 756 757 758 759 760 761 762 763 764 765 766 767 768 769 770 771 772 773 774 775 776 777 778 779 780 781 782 783 784 785 786 787 ... 2132 »
  Print  
Author Topic: [XMR] Monero - A secure, private, untraceable cryptocurrency  (Read 4678105 times)
Hotmetal
Sr. Member
****
Offline

Activity: 378
Merit: 250


View Profile
September 25, 2014, 12:09:02 PM
 #14721

I was under the impression that when I bought into this coin some things were fixed one of those was the emission curve - if I am wrong that is my own mistake and poor research and I will quietly sell my coins, if I am right then it should remain that way in my opinion.

yeah, believe, there are hundreds of people like you, thats what I'm trying to say to smooth, dont touch the forking emission Grin

There may be but there are thousands or tens of thousands of participants. I have no idea how they all feel. Both views have been represented here.

Isn't that what public votes are for?
oda.krell
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1470
Merit: 1007



View Profile
September 25, 2014, 12:10:09 PM
 #14722

I was under the impression that when I bought into this coin some things were fixed one of those was the emission curve - if I am wrong that is my own mistake and poor research and I will quietly sell my coins, if I am right then it should remain that way in my opinion.

yeah, believe, there are hundreds of people like you, thats what I'm trying to say to smooth, dont touch the forking emission Grin

There may be but there are thousands or tens of thousands of participants. I have no idea how they all feel. Both views have been represented here.

One more remark on this topic:

Big props to you, smooth, for your reactions on the previous pages.

As far as I know you've stated before that you are actually (more or less) against adjusting emission speed. Still, you're giving a very fair representation of both sides (or point out misrepresentation of one by the other). That's not at all to be expected, especially in online discussions, in my experience.

What I'm saying is, if we ever get to the point where the community / devs / stakeholders /miners make a decision on this matter, it's good to know that you're probably going to be in a position to guide that discussion. Even if the result is a resounding 'no change', I'll be happy to know there was a fair discussion and decision.

Not sure which Bitcoin wallet you should use? Get Electrum!
Electrum is an open-source lightweight client: fast, user friendly, and 100% secure.
Download the source or executables for Windows/OSX/Linux/Android from, and only from, the official Electrum homepage.
smooth
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203



View Profile
September 25, 2014, 12:19:55 PM
 #14723

One more remark on this topic:

Big props to you, smooth, for your reactions on the previous pages.

As far as I know you've stated before that you are actually (more or less) against adjusting emission speed.

So there is no misunderstanding, my personal opinion is that it would be better to slow down emission, or couple a longer-term slowdown with some short-term acceleration in the form of "post-mine" funding, such that the two offset each other to some extent.

But that is very different from attempting to impose this view on others. If am convinced that the stakeholders are overwhelmingly opposed, in that case I would be opposed to changing it regardless of my own opinion. In fact I would actively oppose others trying to impose such a change despite my own view on the underlying question. I don't think anyone attempting to impose anything is very likely however.

Thank you for your comments as to style of discussion and perspective.

Quote
Even if the result is a resounding 'no change', I'll be happy to know there was a fair discussion and decision.

Me too.
Ultros
Sr. Member
****
Offline

Activity: 471
Merit: 250



View Profile
September 25, 2014, 12:24:32 PM
 #14724

Beware of people that act like they represent some sort of large group and/or majority, then use it as a pressure tactic, without any strong statistical proof. Forums always gather the most vocal (and sometimes manipulative) individuals.
That statement isn't pointed at anyone in particular in that debate so don't jump on your horse. I just feel it needs to be said, better twice than not.

If I want to see majority's opinion, I usually watch markets. That's the best indicator I can think of now. If the community, the devs, both, or whoever takes a decision, is confident about the legitimacy of the change, then the market will vote accordingly. Ofc it's healthy to debate but pressure tactics should be avoided. Just my 0.02 xmr.
fluffypony
Donator
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1274
Merit: 1069


GetMonero.org / MyMonero.com


View Profile WWW
September 25, 2014, 12:28:59 PM
 #14725

Guys, it's obviously a contentious topic with proponents on both sides. I think it prudent to table this until we have finalised the minimum subsidy (eternal emission) proposal. This, in itself, is only a proposal, but I believe that the discussion around that will allow us to visit this topic more thoroughly.

Right now we're discussing it in the context of the status quo, whereas I feel we'll be better equipped to do so when we have the bigger picture in view.

smooth
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203



View Profile
September 25, 2014, 12:32:16 PM
 #14726

You need to be able to say these are the things that we can change and these are the things that are core to the coin.

My opinion is the emission curve shouldn't be changed as in my opinion it is core to the coin. Despite the likely economic benefit to me if I were to take the other side.


ad infinitum

just put it to stone, this speculation about emission is not good for the coin, smooth.

That is simply not possible. Even if I were to 100% support calcification, who is to say another developer or stakeholder might push for change a month or a year or a decade from now.

You can't creat absolute unquestionable and unchangable tenets without a religion and even then some will always seek to reform it.

Actually in mathematics you can.

Mathematics does not have tenets, it has axioms. They are two different things.




iourzzz
Member
**
Offline

Activity: 94
Merit: 10


View Profile
September 25, 2014, 12:33:51 PM
 #14727

One more remark on this topic:

Big props to you, smooth, for your reactions on the previous pages.

As far as I know you've stated before that you are actually (more or less) against adjusting emission speed.

So there is no misunderstanding, my personal opinion is that it would be better to slow down emission, or couple a longer-term slowdown with some short-term acceleration in the form of "post-mine" funding, such that the two offset each other to some extent.

But that is very different from attempting to impose this view on others. If am convinced that the stakeholders are overwhelmingly opposed, in that case I would be opposed to changing it regardless of my own opinion. In fact I would actively oppose others trying to impose such a change despite my own view on the underlying question. I don't think anyone attempting to impose anything is very likely however.

Thank you for your comments as to style of discussion and perspective.


Thank you for staying rock solid in the epicenter of typhoon.
smooth
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203



View Profile
September 25, 2014, 12:49:35 PM
 #14728

As far as I know you've stated before that you are actually (more or less) against adjusting emission speed. Still, you're giving a very fair representation of both sides (or point out misrepresentation of one by the other). That's not at all to be expected, especially in online discussions, in my experience.

I guess you were wrong:

So there is no misunderstanding, my personal opinion is that it would be better to slow down emission, or couple a longer-term slowdown with some short-term acceleration in the form of "post-mine" funding, such that the two offset each other to some extent.

I'm glad you are back to your senses smooth, what you are suggesting to like doing would effectively do what BCX couldn't in his wildest dreams Tongue

Maybe you misunderstood his attack. It was actually a mind control ray beamed at smooth.

Nekomata
Member
**
Offline

Activity: 99
Merit: 10


View Profile
September 25, 2014, 12:51:01 PM
Last edit: April 19, 2015, 06:00:32 AM by Nekomata
 #14729

XMR is the future.
nakaone
Hero Member
*****
Offline

Activity: 742
Merit: 500


View Profile
September 25, 2014, 01:05:14 PM
 #14730

Guys, it's obviously a contentious topic with proponents on both sides. I think it prudent to table this until we have finalised the minimum subsidy (eternal emission) proposal. This, in itself, is only a proposal, but I believe that the discussion around that will allow us to visit this topic more thoroughly.

Right now we're discussing it in the context of the status quo, whereas I feel we'll be better equipped to do so when we have the bigger picture in view.

don't you think it would be possible to auction a part of the still undefined emission after 4 years now ?

Let us assume we mine 18,x million coins in the next 4 years; we now auction a part of the following emission rate. these tokens are given to the auctioneer in the time the coins are created, e.g. in 4 years. but you would get the bitcoins for the auction today.

the pros:
1.) we still have no proper idea how to design the emmission after most coins are mined, so we do not destroy the social contract
2.) the investors would have a long term interest in the project and asssuming it succeeds would massively benefit in the future.
3.) you would get the amount of money for development now
4.) short term and mid term effects on distribution and price are almost non-existent

the cons:
1.) some burocratic effort
2.) maybe the network security in 4 years would suffer (not sure on this)
3.) the investors take a high risk and so the coins would very likely be sold with a discount

I think a solution like that would be very beneficial and the economic costs are very low in comparison to the benefits generated. Additionally an incentive structure is generated which has some interesting implications.
binaryFate
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1012


Still wild and free


View Profile
September 25, 2014, 01:13:07 PM
 #14731

You are right now harming the coin with these discussions. "You" being a general address.
(Adding a "we only say it will be debated one day in the future" doesn't change the fact everybody's discussing it right now).   

Cryptocurrencies are nothing tangible and their intrinsic value lies largely in knowing other people attach some value to it, and will keep doing so in the future.
You are putting no less than that at stake for me.
                                       
You're worsening whatever situation you're not happy about by insinuating "something might be fundamentally wrong with the emission curve".
Few likes to be invested in something openly fundamentally unstable. (Note this is different from an alpha-quality of software, that is technically unstable).

Monero's privacy and therefore fungibility are MUCH stronger than Bitcoin's. 
This makes Monero a better candidate to deserve the term "digital cash".
NewLiberty
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1204
Merit: 1002


Gresham's Lawyer


View Profile WWW
September 25, 2014, 01:17:05 PM
 #14732

You need to be able to say these are the things that we can change and these are the things that are core to the coin.

My opinion is the emission curve shouldn't be changed as in my opinion it is core to the coin. Despite the likely economic benefit to me if I were to take the other side.


ad infinitum

just put it to stone, this speculation about emission is not good for the coin, smooth.

Can we then agree that: Discussion is good, uncertainty is bad.

And so: Let me reframe the question.  

Assuming that this can be accomplished with a merged mined side chain.
Whereas XMR will forever keep to the emission it has, can we then discuss what sort of "core covenant" changes might be good to make in a prospective side chain(s).

Doing it that way has the benefit of rewarding the miners who are merge mining both chains.   It further lets the market decide this sort of thing, without any uncertainty regarding changes to that which we already enjoy owning.

Edit: It needs its own thread.

FREE MONEY1 Bitcoin for Silver and Gold NewLibertyDollar.com and now BITCOIN SPECIE (silver 1 ozt) shows value by QR
Bulk premiums as low as .0012 BTC "BETTER, MORE COLLECTIBLE, AND CHEAPER THAN SILVER EAGLES" 1Free of Government
smooth
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203



View Profile
September 25, 2014, 01:31:15 PM
 #14733

You are right now harming the coin with these discussions.

Since the discussion started the price has gone up (not a whole lot, but its measurable). Other factors are always at work of course.

Like you, I believe that stability is important to value, but I see that as future stability. If we were proposing annual redesign meetings for the life of the coin, that would be very different and far worse. How to get there and what helps or hurts are certainly things about which reasonable people can disagree though.

What we are talking about now is something that has been a source of strong disagreement since the very origin of the coin, and has never been properly discussed much less resolved, outside of a single poll that was poisoned by Bytecoin sock-puppets. People are worried about shills sneaking into the MEW, but that was blatant and actually had a direct impact on the design of the coin, something MEW can't do. I see this question as something of a special case, given the peculiar history and origin of this particular coin.

These coins are all speculative assets being priced on the basis of expected future value. We can afford to make a correction or two now with the expectation that makes it more stable (and more valuable) later, not less.


sparky999
Sr. Member
****
Offline

Activity: 473
Merit: 250


View Profile
September 25, 2014, 01:45:15 PM
 #14734



 I see this question as something of a special case, given the peculiar history and origin of this particular coin.




This is certainly an idea that I could get on board with - if a convincing argument can be made that the original emission schedule is somehow 'corrupt' (for want of a better word) then I could potentially get on board with some form of change conducted in some manner. The details of which would need to be debated.

binaryFate
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1012


Still wild and free


View Profile
September 25, 2014, 01:46:39 PM
 #14735

Like you, I believe that stability is important to value


Got your point about seeking future stability.

However there is another aspect in danger here: fairness between holders across time. Any change would split monero holders forever into the before-change holders and the after-change newcomers. The latters criticizing the formers for the advantage they got over them. Serious drawback for adoption to be carried forever.                 
                         

Monero's privacy and therefore fungibility are MUCH stronger than Bitcoin's. 
This makes Monero a better candidate to deserve the term "digital cash".
smooth
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203



View Profile
September 25, 2014, 01:53:29 PM
 #14736

However there is another aspect in danger here: fairness between holders across time. Any change would split monero holders forever into the before-change holders and the after-change newcomers. The latters criticizing the formers for the advantage they got over them. Serious drawback for adoption to be carried forever.                  

Definitely a valid point. If it were not addressed adequately could very well spell the undoing of any change, and I'm not sure whether or not it can be.

Likewise about there being a possible silent majority that would be strongly against it. Again I'm not sure how we could know whether there is or not.

I have some ideas to handle this in a way that I believe is absolutely 100% fair to everyone, but hard to implement. Perhaps we consider that at a later time when there are less pressing issues.




sparky999
Sr. Member
****
Offline

Activity: 473
Merit: 250


View Profile
September 25, 2014, 01:56:49 PM
 #14737







That's the thing, the practicality of verifying that  a change is a majority decision is hard enough. Let alone even fairly defining a majority of what.
There are a multitude of systems that are all arguably fair but could provide drastically different results in a vote.
aerbax
Full Member
***
Offline

Activity: 201
Merit: 100


View Profile WWW
September 25, 2014, 02:19:21 PM
 #14738

...

Please make a new clone from github one more time. There was a bad commit that got removed but then got reapplied later. Some people ended up with the wrong one. Everything is fixed now afaik.

I cloned again this morning and everything appears to syncing perfectly.  Thanks again!

iourzzz
Member
**
Offline

Activity: 94
Merit: 10


View Profile
September 25, 2014, 02:20:57 PM
 #14739

Like you, I believe that stability is important to value


Got your point about seeking future stability.

However there is another aspect in danger here: fairness between holders across time. Any change would split monero holders forever into the before-change holders and the after-change newcomers. The latters criticizing the formers for the advantage they got over them. Serious drawback for adoption to be carried forever.                 
                         

Totally agree. It's the real risk for future adoption and possible criticism. But this risk is comparable with the one regarding the lack of funds in the hands of developers for solid progress in development.

But there are definitely other ways to solve it. Not only the abrupt change of rules during the crisis.
rdnkjdi
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1257
Merit: 1009


View Profile
September 25, 2014, 02:24:26 PM
Last edit: September 25, 2014, 02:34:28 PM by rdnkjdi
 #14740

However there is another aspect in danger here: fairness between holders across time. Any change would split monero holders forever into the before-change holders and the after-change newcomers. The latters criticizing the formers for the advantage they got over them. Serious drawback for adoption to be carried forever.                  

Definitely a valid point. If it were not addressed adequately could very well spell the undoing of any change, and I'm not sure whether or not it can be.

Likewise about there being a possible silent majority that would be strongly against it. Again I'm not sure how we could know whether there is or not.

I have some ideas to handle this in a way that I believe is absolutely 100% fair to everyone, but hard to implement. Perhaps we consider that at a later time when there are less pressing issues.


I agree 100% to flattening the emission curve to benefit later adopters.  Sadly it also benefits early adopters before the curve by slowing things down early.  So maybe it benefits late & early adopters at the expense of middle adopters?

But more than that on a fundamental discussion like this would be figuring out how to "vote" with real monero supporters.

On idea is to have people spend Monero for a vote that goes into the dev fund.  Since we are massively underfunded I like the idea of pitting two groups against each other in a fundamental vote and throwing the proceeds at the dev fund.

(I do think what money has been spent by the devs needs to be documented - and the dev fund needs to be transparent)

Another is to have a 3 month (or even 1 month) escrow.  This should get rid of a lot of the bytecoin shills.  Instead of proving they just have the coins (buy from market, vote, sell) they have to send to a pre-determined escrow and the coins are released after 1 - 3 months.
Pages: « 1 ... 687 688 689 690 691 692 693 694 695 696 697 698 699 700 701 702 703 704 705 706 707 708 709 710 711 712 713 714 715 716 717 718 719 720 721 722 723 724 725 726 727 728 729 730 731 732 733 734 735 736 [737] 738 739 740 741 742 743 744 745 746 747 748 749 750 751 752 753 754 755 756 757 758 759 760 761 762 763 764 765 766 767 768 769 770 771 772 773 774 775 776 777 778 779 780 781 782 783 784 785 786 787 ... 2132 »
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.19 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!