Mixin Safe ReviewBitcointalk Username: pakhithebossThanks, Royse777 for giving me the opportunity to review Mixin Safe. This is not my first review as previously I was part of another review campaign. I found Mixin Safe not to be user-friendly as you would need to use multiple apps. I started by downloading Mixin Messenger from the Google Play Store.
Mixin Messenger What I liked about this app is that it is open source and uses End-to-end encryption for communication. What I did not like about it is that you can only log in using a phone number. While reading the privacy policy before setting up the app I found out that this app does access your [https://mixin.one/pages/privacy] phone contact list. Which for me was like an invasion of my privacy.
Setting up the app doesn't require any effort. It is simple to understand. Enter your phone number and wait for the OTP. After receiving the OTP create a username and then followed by a six-digit pin number, which you need to enter four times for you to remember as displayed on the screen. The reason is if you forget your pin you won't be able to access the app. In no time my wallet got created.
Mornin keyIt is nothing but a password manager that is not free unless you download it from the Mixin Safe website. It is available for download on the Google play store for Android users. In my country, the price was showing INR 95 which is approximately $1.15. I did not find any rating for this app on the play store & didn't understand the reason to make it chargeable as its job is to just be a password manager. You can download it for free from the website, but I think the apk file does not work for the old Android version as I was using an old Android mobile with Android version 10. I basically bought it from the play store.
The registration process is again very simple all you need to do is to follow the instructions showing up on the screen. For backup which comes In the end, it will ask you to write down the mnemonic phrases but I found out that you can take a screenshot of that screen. I feel the screen capture facility should be disabled when it displays the phrases for the first time. If not then no need to write the following instructions asking the user to write down the phrases.
Setting up Mixin safeBefore I start I would like to know from the team the reason behind
https://safe.mixin.zone/ not being mobile compatible. In today's age, I expect at least this feature from any platform running a web3 application. After being in service for 6+ years and having 1M+ customers mobile compatibility should be the prime focus of the team.
Now, let's go to the complicated part which I think will not be easy for someone new. I mean someone who is new to this industry. The major discomfort would be using a PC and mobile phone at the same time.
I followed the steps first step by studying the
user guide mentioned on this thread. As I had already downloaded the Mornin key app my owner wallet setup was already done. The next process was to Sign in for which I need to scan a QR code using the Mixin Messenger. After scanning a window will pop up which is basically a request to authorize certain things. You can disallow everything except
Read your profile. It will again ask you to enter your pin and it is done.
After you are signed in on the left side you will see the menu. I clicked on Safe and then clicked on New Safe, then add a name to Safe and select Bitcoin or Liecoin. On the next screen, you would now need your Mornin Key as you need to scan the QR code. Which I did and then followed the screens which for me were simple tasks.
Now, I have to again go back to the website and click on the next button. It asked me how many members I need for confirmation and I selected one and clicked next. On the next screen, I was asked to upgrade. As $2 was the cheapest and it served my requirement I went ahead with it.
Mixin payI think this is a great application and the team should work on creating a mobile application. What made me say wow when I saw there were multiple cryptocurrency payment options available. I selected USDT (TRC20), by default they had Tronlink pay as I did not have it I went for another option which was scanning the QR code. I used my Binance app to scan the QR code and it did not work as the minimum for this transaction is 10 USDT.
The next option for me was to use TRX. I went ahead and transferred the required amount of TRX using a local exchange. What I did not like is that Mixin Pay has a time counter on the payment page.
I feel it is useless as you cannot be sure about confirmation considering they have Bitcoin, Ethereum, and other cryptocurrencies as these cryptos are known for their volatility and uneven transaction fee. I have recently noticed that the Bitcoin transaction fee is more volatile than the market price of Bitcoin.
Next, I clicked on create button, and the owner approval step was done. I was now asked to use the Mornin Key app to scan the QR code, which I did and it took some time. I do not know why? Next, deposited Bitcoin did the transaction as everyone here did.
ConclusionMy experience was neither that bad nor that good. If I assume that I am new to this Bitcoin or Litecoin mixin. I would have been devastated as I need to use 2 mobile apps and then use the desktop application to get my desired outcome. The team needs to come out with a singular interface regardless of whether it is a mobile app or a desktop one.