dEBRUYNE
Legendary

Activity: 2268
Merit: 1141
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 10:44:36 PM |
|
I am a (somewhat) large holder of monero, and I promise to dump every single one of the coins I have if there is a post-mine or otherwise dedicated portion of block rewards to the development team.
Ideally, the development team is non-financially motivated, but since they are, they should either back away from the project and allow volunteers to step in,
OR
Purchase Monero, and provide work on the project in an effort to boost the value of their investment.
The coin will never reach mainstream potential if there is a 1% block dedicated to the development team. Imagine if George Washington owned 1% of the USD that did not inflate, he would be a dictator of the economy surrounding the dollar.
-I think this is a misunderstanding, IIRC the dev-team just want to cover their cost and thats it. -IIRC they already hold around 50k together, maybe even more. Who knows?
|
|
|
|
binaryFate
Legendary

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1012
Still wild and free
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 10:48:34 PM |
|
I am a (somewhat) large holder of monero, and I promise to dump every single one of the coins I have if there is a post-mine or otherwise dedicated portion of block rewards to the development team.
Ideally, the development team is non-financially motivated, but since they are, they should either back away from the project and allow volunteers to step in,
OR
Purchase Monero, and provide work on the project in an effort to boost the value of their investment.
The coin will never reach mainstream potential if there is a 1% block dedicated to the development team. Imagine if George Washington owned 1% of the USD that did not inflate, he would be a dictator of the economy surrounding the dollar.
This. And the part in bold in particular. All proposed solutions floating around would be highly detrimental for the coin perception in the public eyes. Starting with the cryptocoin community. I am pretty sure of that, no coin can survive on the long run with such little arrangements that look so crapcoinish done at one point of its history, even with the best intentions. I am also a (somewhat) large holder of monero, and I will also completely get out if there is anything touching what I thought would never be touched, no matter how or what exactly. I will be sad because I have a lot of hope for monero, I love the community around and being a small part of that great project, but still I'll get out.
|
Monero's privacy and therefore fungibility are MUCH stronger than Bitcoin's. This makes Monero a better candidate to deserve the term "digital cash".
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 10:49:00 PM |
|
The coin will never reach mainstream potential if there is a 1% block dedicated to the development team. Imagine if George Washington owned 1% of the USD that did not inflate, he would be a dictator of the economy surrounding the dollar.
Considering the entire purpose of it would be raise money to spend it on development right now, this metaphor of a founder who holds on to the money for 250 years is inaccurate. The coins would be spent, sold, and otherwise dispersed just as they often are through mining. Also, numerically that isn't even true. The widely reported M2 USD money supply is about $10 trillion. 1% of that is approximately Bill Gates's net worth. He is not dictator of the economy.
|
|
|
|
|
binaryFate
Legendary

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1012
Still wild and free
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 10:52:33 PM |
|
The coin will never reach mainstream potential if there is a 1% block dedicated to the development team. Imagine if George Washington owned 1% of the USD that did not inflate, he would be a dictator of the economy surrounding the dollar.
Considering the entire purpose of it would be raise money to spend it on development right now, this metaphor of a founder who holds on to the money for 250 years is inaccurate. The coins would be spent, sold, and otherwise dispersed just as they often are through mining. Also, numerically that isn't even true. The widely reported M2 USD money supply is about $10 trillion. 1% of that is approximately Bill Gates's net worth. He is not dictator of the economy. I think what matters here is not the analogy, but the fact that it's awefull for the coin perception, which penalizes strongly adoption. Maybe there aren't enough people in Monero that were in other altcoins before... because my feeling is that some here don't realize how allergic the crypto community is to some of the changes proposed. We won't get adoption if we don't start first with the current crypto community.
|
Monero's privacy and therefore fungibility are MUCH stronger than Bitcoin's. This makes Monero a better candidate to deserve the term "digital cash".
|
|
|
oda.krell
Legendary

Activity: 1470
Merit: 1007
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 10:54:57 PM |
|
@windjc
Your recent shilling in here is as transparent as it is pathetic.
If feigned outrage ("Oh my! You guys have manipulating whales!", or: "How dare you discussing the emission of a coin I do not even hold!") is really the best you can do, it's probably better if you head back to your amateur hour coin Boolberry.
|
Not sure which Bitcoin wallet you should use? Get Electrum!Electrum is an open-source lightweight client: fast, user friendly, and 100% secure. Download the source or executables for Windows/OSX/Linux/Android from, and only from, the official Electrum homepage.
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 10:59:32 PM |
|
@windjc
Your recent shilling in here is as transparent as it is pathetic.
That's exactly why it is fine if he stays. He's making his level of objectivity and preferred tactics more obvious every time he posts.
|
|
|
|
|
windjc
Legendary

Activity: 2156
Merit: 1070
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 11:00:24 PM |
|
@windjc
Your recent shilling in here is as transparent as it is pathetic.
If feigned outrage ("Oh my! You guys have manipulating whales!", or: "How dare you discussing the emission of a coin I do not even hold!") is really the best you can do, it's probably better if you head back to your amateur hour coin Boolberry.
Oda. We've chatted on multiple forums/chat rooms. I've never BSed you. I've been honest with you always. In fact, today we exchanged PMs about where you and I stood as speculators vs. true advocates. I think we were very honest with each other. If you think I'm trolling, I'll leave.
|
|
|
|
|
myagui
Legendary

Activity: 1154
Merit: 1001
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 11:06:39 PM |
|
[...] I honestly don't agree with what Risto is purposing here. If you do, that's cool. But I don't.
I am not making any misdirections about where my long term interests are, hell, I openly tell whoever ask what my book looks like (how many people in the "anon" world do that??). [...]
Did Risto even make an appearance? Pretty cool non-misdirection... Can we perhaps organize a location/time for such discussions to take place, not here? I suppose that reddit or irc would do much better for these interactions.
|
|
|
|
robinwilliams
Member


Activity: 112
Merit: 10
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 11:08:48 PM |
|
I think what matters here is not the analogy, but the fact that it's awefull for the coin perception, which penalizes strongly adoption. Maybe there aren't enough people in Monero that were in other altcoins before... because my feeling is that some here don't realize how allergic the crypto community is to some of the changes proposed. We won't get adoption if we don't start first with the current crypto community.
pffft we r bitcoin holders. stupid altcoin bitches know nothing bro
|
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 11:11:18 PM |
|
[...] I honestly don't agree with what Risto is purposing here. If you do, that's cool. But I don't.
I am not making any misdirections about where my long term interests are, hell, I openly tell whoever ask what my book looks like (how many people in the "anon" world do that??). [...]
Did Risto even make an appearance? Pretty cool non-misdirection... Can we perhaps organize a location/time for such discussions to take place, not here? I suppose that reddit or irc would do much better for these interactions. This is reasonable. As I said earlier, its fine for this thread unless the volume is high, and the volume has gotten fairly high. Creating a new thread is not a good idea given the level of trolling and if the trolls create an unmoderated thread please ignore it. Better venues are suited to further discussion back and forth, unless you have something new to add.
|
|
|
|
|
aminorex
Legendary

Activity: 1596
Merit: 1031
Sine secretum non libertas
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 11:12:09 PM |
|
This thread is now dominated by trolling. None of the stakeholders are discussing these issues here. Anything you read above, in the past day or so, is probably just FUD, supposition, or dissimulation.
|
Give a man a fish and he eats for a day. Give a man a Poisson distribution and he eats at random times independent of one another, at a constant known rate.
|
|
|
|
David Latapie
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 11:19:47 PM |
|
Ideally, the development team is non-financially motivated, but since they are We are not, but tell me how we'll pay the developers and the consulting and everything? Have you cake and eat it? How much did you donated? How much ALL OF YOU holders donated? Answer: not enough. Now if you have a solution, we are all ears. You are calling us greedy and I take it as a personal insult.
|
|
|
|
oda.krell
Legendary

Activity: 1470
Merit: 1007
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 11:23:06 PM |
|
@windjc
Your recent shilling in here is as transparent as it is pathetic.
If feigned outrage ("Oh my! You guys have manipulating whales!", or: "How dare you discussing the emission of a coin I do not even hold!") is really the best you can do, it's probably better if you head back to your amateur hour coin Boolberry.
Oda. We've chatted on multiple forums/chat rooms. I've never BSed you. I've been honest with you always. In fact, today we exchanged PMs about where you and I stood as speculators vs. true advocates. I think we were very honest with each other. I honestly don't agree with what Risto is purposing here. If you do, that's cool. But I don't. I am not making any misdirections about where my long term interests are, hell, I openly tell whoever ask what my book looks like (how many people in the "anon" world do that??). These decisions would hurt XMR and BBR (short term), imo. But I guess, since Im obviously misdirecting, then I must believe these are great ideas and would help XMR tremendously. As I am so transparent in my dishonesty and all. Fair enough. If you don't trust the way this coin is run, divest (you did so already, as I understood). Zero objection to that. If you feel the need to criticize how this coin is run, go ahead and make an argument. No objection to that either. What is transparent (and, frankly, unnecessary) are your latest rhetorics in here: rpietila is known to be a large holder, no revelation there. Also, the dev team has stated multiple times that their decisions are guided by their own compass, plus community input. Finally, there is zero precedence of "the whales" pushing through decisions, it's complete conjecture. But you barge in here anway pretending this coin is about to be taken over by some sinister whale cabal. Same for the emission discussion: the state of the actual discussion so far is "some are for it, some are against, it's probably better to not seriously consider it now anyway". Yet you pretend we're one moment away from changing it on a whim, complete with strawmen arguments why some of us supposedly want to change it ("greedy coin holder and their short sightedness"). There are honest, sometimes blunt discussions. I've seen some of that on the last pages, and I enjoyed it, even if I didn't agree with everything that was said. And then there's inflammatory derailing of a discussions - that's what you've been doing in your last 5 or 6 posts in here. Together with the knowledge that you are a "whale" in a competing coin (oh, the irony), I'm going to assume that's more than just an issue of posting style, but most likely a calculated effort to stir up emotions. I'm up for a serious discussion about whatever you care about at any time. But I'm not going to respond to complete non-issues (whales that might or might not do something at some point) as if it were a relevant topic of debate.
|
Not sure which Bitcoin wallet you should use? Get Electrum!Electrum is an open-source lightweight client: fast, user friendly, and 100% secure. Download the source or executables for Windows/OSX/Linux/Android from, and only from, the official Electrum homepage.
|
|
|
slapper
Legendary

Activity: 2730
Merit: 1258
CCC.io - Crypto Casino & Web3 Betting Platform
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 11:35:10 PM |
|
Ideally, the development team is non-financially motivated, but since they are We are not, but tell me how we'll pay the developers and the consulting and everything? Have you cake and eat it? How much did you donated? How much ALL OF YOU holders donated? Answer: not enough. Now if you have a solution, we are all ears. You are calling us greedy and I take it as a personal insult. Wait, Risto says you are one of the 7 developers. But you pay someone else to develop? :Mind Blown: 
|
|
|
|
windjc
Legendary

Activity: 2156
Merit: 1070
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 11:41:58 PM |
|
@windjc
Your recent shilling in here is as transparent as it is pathetic.
If feigned outrage ("Oh my! You guys have manipulating whales!", or: "How dare you discussing the emission of a coin I do not even hold!") is really the best you can do, it's probably better if you head back to your amateur hour coin Boolberry.
Oda. We've chatted on multiple forums/chat rooms. I've never BSed you. I've been honest with you always. In fact, today we exchanged PMs about where you and I stood as speculators vs. true advocates. I think we were very honest with each other. I honestly don't agree with what Risto is purposing here. If you do, that's cool. But I don't. I am not making any misdirections about where my long term interests are, hell, I openly tell whoever ask what my book looks like (how many people in the "anon" world do that??). These decisions would hurt XMR and BBR (short term), imo. But I guess, since Im obviously misdirecting, then I must believe these are great ideas and would help XMR tremendously. As I am so transparent in my dishonesty and all. Fair enough. If you don't trust the way this coin is run, divest (you did so already, as I understood). Zero objection to that. If you feel the need to criticize how this coin is run, go ahead and make an argument. No objection to that either. What is transparent (and, frankly, unnecessary) are your latest rhetorics in here: rpietila is known to be a large holder, no revelation there. Also, the dev team has stated multiple times that their decisions are guided by their own compass, plus community input. Finally, there is zero precedence of "the whales" pushing through decisions, it's complete conjecture. But you barge in here anway pretending this coin is about to be taken over by some sinister whale cabal. Same for the emission discussion: the state of the actual discussion so far is "some are for it, some are against, it's probably better to not seriously consider it now anyway". Yet you pretend we're one moment away from changing it on a whim, complete with strawmen arguments why some of us supposedly want to change it ("greedy coin holder and their short sightedness"). There are honest, sometimes blunt discussions. I've seen some of that on the last pages, and I enjoyed it, even if I didn't agree with everything that was said. And then there's inflammatory derailing of a discussions - that's what you've been doing in your last 5 or 6 posts in here. Together with the knowledge that you are a "whale" in a competing coin (oh, the irony), I'm going to assume that's more than just an issue of posting style, but most likely a calculated effort to stir up emotions. I'm up for a serious discussion about whatever you care about at any time. But I'm not going to respond to complete non-issues (whales that might or might not do something at some point) as if it were a relevant topic of debate. If emissions are not being serious discussed and Risto isnt a proponent of changing them then I stand corrected. I am not the definitive source and if I was incorrect I apologize.
|
|
|
|
|
steeldog803
Newbie

Activity: 18
Merit: 0
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 11:44:28 PM |
|
I hold a lot of monero and I do not support this.
I believe such a distribution is a betrayal of ideology that will divorce this coin from all seriousness.
|
|
|
|
|
|
canonsburg
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 11:47:24 PM |
|
Can't some type of token be created to help fund the development of Monero? Since pre-mine, insta-mine, fast-mine, whatever-mine are off the table, how about creating a separate "token", from which a substantial amount is awarded to the development of Monero. Since the MEW is "independent" from the core Monero, they can issue a "MEW Token", maybe some type of PoS fork (NXT, NODE, etc  --- why another type of crypto, because you don't want to be a competing type) from which an acceptable percentage is awarded to the development of Monero. The MEW can also distribute the remaining Tokens as some type of promotion (free for all?), and establish some type of market which allows it to trade for XMR. The funds will then allow for the development of XMR but without the nastiness that goes with it and this way, the XMR emission and "social contract" remains untouched.
|
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 11:54:27 PM |
|
Can't some type of token be created to help fund the development of Monero?
Possibly Since pre-mine, insta-mine, fast-mine, whatever-mine are off the table Nothing is off the table. Since the MEW is "independent" from the core Monero, they can issue a "MEW Token", maybe some type of PoS fork (NXT, NODE, etc  --- why another type of crypto, because you don't want to be a competing type) from which an acceptable percentage is awarded to the development of Monero. The MEW can also distribute the remaining Tokens as some type of promotion (free for all?), and establish some type of market which allows it to trade for XMR. The funds will then allow for the development of XMR but without the nastiness that goes with it and this way, the XMR emission and "social contract" remains untouched. Why would these have any value at all?
|
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
September 25, 2014, 11:59:35 PM |
|
I hold a lot of monero and I do not support this.
I believe such a distribution is a betrayal of ideology that will divorce this coin from all seriousness.
Please do not take this as a personal insult because it is not intended that way, but merely as a statement of facts. When a Newbie account that no one has ever heard of before shows up and claims to own "a lot of monero" and states a position on something, it suggests that some external party of some potential significance is sufficiently threatened by something as to use use shills (likely paid) to attempt to derail something. In a competitive environment it is highly likely that whatever it is that party opposes would be good for us. Obviously it can't be known if you individually are a shill (nor can you disprove it so please don't bother replying to try), but after a while a pattern emerges.
|
|
|
|
|
|
xulescu
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 12:06:35 AM |
|
@smooth and others,
Before the BCX episode we had a lengthy exchange on the subject of funding. I suggested (and others agreed) that before more extreme measures are deployed, we will attempt to crowdfund. I agree that donations in this form do not work out. I also agree that riding on transaction fees is a small amount. I have asked for that goddamn spreadsheet that takes little time and effort to make and it seems to me you just don't like the idea but don't want to say so out front.
My point was (and still is) that even regular donations would be more successful if there was some TRANSPARENCY on where the funds went and will go in the future. You countered that exposes you and the recipients to legal risk. Well, given that the community trusts (and has to trust) you already, the spendings do not need to be verifiable. And i can't believe that a simple explanation like amount x to hosting, amount y to developers, amount z to security/crypto experts really exposes you so much.
There are two main ways to crowdfund and both can be employed at the same time. Kickstarter for fiat and larger exposure, Anon's escrow for cryptos. It doesn't even have to be the core who organizes it (after all fundraising is really MEW's cup of tea).
Barring this, you can notice very strong opinions for and against the post-mine, for and against the miner fee, for and against changing the emission curve. I am not debating them, but it should be obvious to all by now they are very controversial and all damage trust in one way or another.
So why not just fucking do the noncontroversial stuff first? It was also semidecided that a month is sufficient time for the fundraise.
Seriously, what am I missing?
|
|
|
|
|
|