If you value this wallet please consider helping to beta-test (I'm occupied at the moment and likely to miss finer points). Based on where it is today I would assume it will hit the Google Play Store soon. Hash should be watching this thread, feedback is welcome here, PM to Hash, or on the HashEngineering thread.
Perfect, thank you. Will test tomorrow afternoon and provide feedback. Ta!
Samsung Galaxy Note 3 4G (Model SM-N9007)
Android Version: 4.4.2
Baseband Version: N9007DIUDNK1
Kernel Version: 3.4.0-3408217 (Thu Jan 8 17:24:09 KST 2015)
Downloaded file: unobtanium-wallet-0.21.apk (
github location)
--
Installation required allowing unknown sources, as expected. Installation successful.
Icon looks good on phone:
-
App looks great when first opened, too!
SUGGESTION: Upon opening, the application's title at top of page simply says 'Unobtanium' and has the logo. Might be better for it to say what it actually is: Unobtanium Wallet (gives assurance to new users that they've got the app they think they've got - particularly if they're unfamiliar with any digital wallet interface).
SUGGESTION: Also, the two links at bottom of page are too small and close together to accurately press. The 'safety notes' link in particular is too close to the back button on my device and so far
I have been 100% unable to press it. Every time I do, even at the very edge of the screen, the BACK UP WALLET option pops up instead. Minor annoyance but for an important thing like this, it'd be ideal to improve the link placement if possible.
SUGGESTION: Lastly, the default denomination for the currency should be Kg (or just 'UNO'), in my opinion. If I send myself 0.01kg it tells me I've received
+10.00, which I expect may be quite confusing to newcomers:
-
PROBLEM:
Exchange Rates option doesn't currently work:
-
LOVE the Sweep Paper Wallet option, well done!
SUGGESTION: The current wording is a bit confusing though, particularly for non-IT users whose phones may actually have a physical camera button. I suggest a change in wording to the
bolded text for clarity; something like this:
Start by tapping the camera button to turn your camera on, allowing you to scan the private key of a paper wallet or coupon.-
Receiving coins:SUGGESTION:
Request Unobtanium works, but it would be good if the wallet address could appear underneath the QR code when you press it in the Request window. It does this currently if you press the QR code in the main window, so consistency here would also improve usability:
SUGGESTION: I tested a transfer to the phone wallet, worked perfectly. However, there's
no option to turn sounds off and the 'ca-chink' noise it makes when receiving is quite loud. Please include option to turn sounds off!
Sending coins:After you press SEND COINS, there should be a button to access the Address book, which is currently only accessible via the unlabeled dog tags at top-right of home screen (and is not labelled, you have to guess and press it):
Indeed, if you want to send coins, this is the window you see below. Pretend you want to send me some coins right now and this is what's in front of you:
My confusion/questions as an
experienced UNO user: How do I access my address book? What's my current wallet balance? Why are there two text fields here? Once I type a number into the first field, what do I do? Press Enter on my keyboard? Select the second field? Taking a guess, I entered the amount I wanted to send (which was 10.00 mUNO, only because I knew how much that was from when I sent myself 0.01kg earlier) and pressed Send. I didn't know how much was in my wallet, what the Tx fee might be or if I'd even have enough. There was no summary screen, I just had to guess. Not ideal.
SUGGESTION: I was actually trying to send coins here and I couldn't use the camera because the address failed (see next item) and there was no link to the address book! Placing the dog tags next to the camera button would be a good start.
PROBLEM: Importantly, I tried to scan the address of my computer wallet to add as the recipient (both in the Address book and at the SEND COINS screen) and it failed! Tried several physical camera orientations, failed every time:
SUGGESTION: After manually typing in the sending address, the
Amount to pay is also in 'mUno'. It would be hugely helpful if the total available amount in the wallet was shown on this screen, too. Once the amount is entered, the Network fee doesn't show until after you press Send. Would be better if this showed after you pressed Enter or left the Amount to pay field, so you can see the updated totals. Pressing Send, it went instantly.
SUGGESTION: When pressing send, it would be good for a summary window/pop-up that says something like:
You're about to send X kg UNO to Y address with a network transaction fee of Z. Your remaining wallet total will be n. Please confirm: Y/N.SUGGESTION: Sending was instant and it appeared in my PC wallet nearly immediately. The address I sent to was not saved in the Address book under Sending addresses, this should also be fixed so that used addressed are automatically added here to save me re-typing them (or giving me this option in the Settings).
-
Overall, it's very good. With a few changes to help usability, it'll be ready to rock! Cheers.
