GreekBitcoin
Legendary

Activity: 1428
Merit: 1001
getmonero.org
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 12:12:22 AM |
|
@smooth and others,
Before the BCX episode we had a lengthy exchange on the subject of funding. I suggested (and others agreed) that before more extreme measures are deployed, we will attempt to crowdfund. I agree that donations in this form do not work out. I also agree that riding on transaction fees is a small amount. I have asked for that goddamn spreadsheet that takes little time and effort to make and it seems to me you just don't like the idea but don't want to say so out front.
My point was (and still is) that even regular donations would be more successful if there was some TRANSPARENCY on where the funds went and will go in the future. You countered that exposes you and the recipients to legal risk. Well, given that the community trusts (and has to trust) you already, the spendings do not need to be verifiable. And i can't believe that a simple explanation like amount x to hosting, amount y to developers, amount z to security/crypto experts really exposes you so much.
There are two main ways to crowdfund and both can be employed at the same time. Kickstarter for fiat and larger exposure, Anon's escrow for cryptos. It doesn't even have to be the core who organizes it (after all fundraising is really MEW's cup of tea).
Barring this, you can notice very strong opinions for and against the post-mine, for and against the miner fee, for and against changing the emission curve. I am not debating them, but it should be obvious to all by now they are very controversial and all damage trust in one way or another.
So why not just fucking do the noncontroversial stuff first? It was also semidecided that a month is sufficient time for the fundraise.
Seriously, what am I missing?
I agree with that idea. What is the thinking against crowdfunding?
|
|
|
|
|
TheKoziTwo
Legendary

Activity: 1552
Merit: 1047
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 12:30:53 AM |
|
I suspect the current discussion about emission change is the result of two things.
1. Large holders 2. Price decline / stagnation
I also believe that stagnation and price decline is very healthy, and that emission change is NOT the solution.
The "problem" we have right now is very high inflation, ~20k XMR @ 0.004, we're talking 80 BTC every single day. Price at 0.01 and we're talking 200 BTC daily. Who will absorb all this? Who does so currently? Sure, there is some new adopters consistently coming in, but imo not enough. I believe the vast majority of inflation is absorbed by current large holders. I know many old timers have been buying monero and I think their "bags" are getting heavier and heavier. Who currently own 5k+ XMR and owned more 5-6 months ago (miners excluded)?
At some point, people will reach their limit. Once they reach that % purchasing more can not be justified, perhaps the allocated % ends up being much higher than originally intended too. If the price starts dropping when you really shouldn't buy more, it's not as fun now is it? So perhaps there is some fear that the price will decline until the inflation can absorb it, and that despite being early in the game, they may even end up in the red for a while. The long awaited journey "to the moon" may not come for potentially years. And if it comes right now, it will likely be short lived.
By slowing down emission, large holders will no longer have to worry as much about decline, in fact, that could even trigger a rally. They think. But I fear it may backfire, and have the opposite effect. If the rules of the game is changed midway people will lose confidence. Only the fact that this is even being discussed affect the price, I know some have already sold monero because of this.
Make no mistake about it, changing the fundamental rules may have major impact on trust in the currency. People will start to wonder: What will change in the future? Can we trust the promises? Why did early adopters get this advantage? As binaryFate put it, the community will split in two, those who got in before the emission change, and those who came after. But who will come in after?
Emission change is at it's core a way for early adopters to pre-mine a currency. The slower emission will not allow for accumulation in the same manner.
So I think what is really going on here is large holders / early adopters looking to maximize their short term gains without really considering the impact these choices may have on the future of the coin and the trust in it.
This suggestion seems to be a rather desperate attempt (with inconvenient timing) to keep the price from falling. Well, this may sound harsh but perhaps the price should fall. Monero has been priced very high right from the beginning. If inflation cannot be absorbed by the market naturally, the market will find a new price, naturally. You want the price to stay where it is or go up, get more people involved! We don't need this price fixing attempt to "save" the price (I'm not saying this is the intention of everyone suggesting this change, it just indicates it).
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 12:31:48 AM Last edit: September 26, 2014, 01:05:35 AM by smooth |
|
@smooth and others,
Before the BCX episode we had a lengthy exchange on the subject of funding. I suggested (and others agreed) that before more extreme measures are deployed, we will attempt to crowdfund. I agree that donations in this form do not work out. I also agree that riding on transaction fees is a small amount. I have asked for that goddamn spreadsheet that takes little time and effort to make and it seems to me you just don't like the idea but don't want to say so out front.
My point was (and still is) that even regular donations would be more successful if there was some TRANSPARENCY on where the funds went and will go in the future. You countered that exposes you and the recipients to legal risk. Well, given that the community trusts (and has to trust) you already, the spendings do not need to be verifiable. And i can't believe that a simple explanation like amount x to hosting, amount y to developers, amount z to security/crypto experts really exposes you so much.
There are two main ways to crowdfund and both can be employed at the same time. Kickstarter for fiat and larger exposure, Anon's escrow for cryptos. It doesn't even have to be the core who organizes it (after all fundraising is really MEW's cup of tea).
Barring this, you can notice very strong opinions for and against the post-mine, for and against the miner fee, for and against changing the emission curve. I am not debating them, but it should be obvious to all by now they are very controversial and all damage trust in one way or another.
So why not just fucking do the noncontroversial stuff first? It was also semidecided that a month is sufficient time for the fundraise.
Seriously, what am I missing?
You are missing that someone else raised the issue of the emission curve and I think developer block funding (not 100% sure about the latter) in a rather formal process which means the question won't go away and must be addressed. On the matter of crowd funding I am still in favor of it and will see that it gets done when we get a few minutes to do it. It requires cooperation between numerous parties who are involved with the different work items that have been under way if slowly for some time. Unfortunately this can't stop the discussion of the reward curve for the reason stated above.
|
|
|
|
|
NewLiberty
Legendary

Activity: 1204
Merit: 1002
Gresham's Lawyer
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 12:35:14 AM |
|
Ideally, the development team is non-financially motivated, but since they are We are not, but tell me how we'll pay the developers and the consulting and everything? Have you cake and eat it? How much did you donated? How much ALL OF YOU holders donated? Answer: not enough. Now if you have a solution, we are all ears. You are calling us greedy and I take it as a personal insult. Wait, Risto says you are one of the 7 developers. But you pay someone else to develop? :Mind Blown: How is the notion of teamwork so complicated for you? Some programmers have more means than others. Why would it bug you if one buys the lunches for another? Everyone does better if they aren't worried about where the next meal comes from.
|
|
|
|
dEBRUYNE
Legendary

Activity: 2268
Merit: 1141
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 12:38:46 AM |
|
I suspect the current discussion about emission change is the result of two things.
1. Large holders 2. Price decline / stagnation
I also believe that stagnation and price decline is very healthy, and that emission change is NOT the solution.
The "problem" we have right now is very high inflation, ~20k XMR @ 0.004, we're talking 80 BTC every single day. Price at 0.01 and we're talking 200 BTC daily. Who will absorb all this? Who does so currently? Sure, there is some new adopters consistently coming in, but imo not enough. I believe the vast majority of inflation is absorbed by current large holders. I know many old timers have been buying monero and I think their "bags" are getting heavier and heavier. Who currently own 5k+ XMR and owned more 5-6 months ago (miners excluded)?
At some point, people will reach their limit. Once they reach that % purchasing more can not be justified, perhaps the allocated % ends up being much higher than originally intended too. If the price starts dropping when you really shouldn't buy more, it's not as fun now is it? So perhaps there is some fear that the price will decline until the inflation can absorb it, and that despite being early in the game, they may even end up in the red for a while. The long awaited journey "to the moon" may not come for potentially years. And if it comes right now, it will likely be short lived.
By slowing down emission, large holders will no longer have to worry as much about decline, in fact, that could even trigger a rally. They think. But I fear it may backfire, and have the opposite effect. If the rules of the game is changed midway people will lose confidence. Only the fact that this is even being discussed affect the price, I know some have already sold monero because of this.
Make no mistake about it, changing the fundamental rules may have major impact on trust in the currency. People will start to wonder: What will change in the future? Can we trust the promises? Why did early adopters get this advantage? As binaryFate put it, the community will split in two, those who got in before the emission change, and those who came after. But who will come in after?
Emission change is at it's core a way for early adopters to pre-mine a currency. The slower emission will not allow for accumulation in the same manner.
So I think what is really going on here is large holders / early adopters looking to maximize their short term gains without really considering the impact these choices may have on the future of the coin and the trust in it.
This suggestion seems to be a rather desperate attempt (with inconvenient timing) to keep the price from falling. Well, this may sound harsh but perhaps the price should fall. Monero has been priced very high right from the beginning. If inflation cannot be absorbed by the market naturally, the market will find a new price, naturally. You want the price to stay where it is or go up, get more people involved! We don't need this price fixing attempt to "save" the price (I'm not saying this is the intention of everyone suggesting this change, it just indicates it).
You're implying here that every coin that gets mined is directly sold on exchanges. Personally I think only 50% is being sold on exchanges, maybe there are some OTC deals idk. I think holding 0.004 isn't really much of a problem. We've got many great things comming up which will increase adoption. Also IIRC rpietila posted the emission table here somewhere and in the beginning of january 2015 we're already down to 15k a day..
|
|
|
|
TheKoziTwo
Legendary

Activity: 1552
Merit: 1047
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 12:43:55 AM |
|
You're implying here that every coin that gets mined is directly sold on exchanges. Personally I think only 50% is being sold on exchanges, maybe there are some OTC deals idk. I think holding 0.004 isn't really much of a problem. We've got many great things comming up which will increase adoption. Also IIRC rpietila posted the emission table here somewhere and in the beginning of january 2015 we're already down to 15k a day..
It could very well be that we can hold 0.004, but that's just stagnation. People want to see price increase, and when the adoption curve fails to satisfy them they want to modify the fundamentals of the coin and likely destroy the trust in the process. This is the wrong way to go about it, bring in more people instead and the price will raise naturally. If that can't happen it's better that the price falls until it reaches a new stable point.
|
|
|
|
tacotime
Legendary

Activity: 1484
Merit: 1011
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 12:46:51 AM |
|
The only moves that I will commend with regards to emission are that if you don't like the emission, either fork and try to get people to use your fork or to just create a merge mined coin with a longer emission.
|
XMR: 44GBHzv6ZyQdJkjqZje6KLZ3xSyN1hBSFAnLP6EAqJtCRVzMzZmeXTC2AHKDS9aEDTRKmo6a6o9r9j86pYfhCWDkKjbtcns
|
|
|
dEBRUYNE
Legendary

Activity: 2268
Merit: 1141
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 12:49:15 AM |
|
You're implying here that every coin that gets mined is directly sold on exchanges. Personally I think only 50% is being sold on exchanges, maybe there are some OTC deals idk. I think holding 0.004 isn't really much of a problem. We've got many great things comming up which will increase adoption. Also IIRC rpietila posted the emission table here somewhere and in the beginning of january 2015 we're already down to 15k a day..
It could very well be that we can hold 0.004, but that's just stagnation. People want to see price increase, and when the adoption curve fails to satisfy them they want to modify the fundamentals of the coin and likely destroy the trust in the process. This is the wrong way to go about it, bring in more people instead and the price will raise naturally. If that can't happen it's better that the price falls until it reaches a new stable point. Agree with that, the emission curve is choosen and we shouldn't change that. Only thing we can do is to speed up adoption which will drive up the price naturally like you said. Maybe the positive side of the agressive emission curve is that there is more incentive to speed up adoption. Second, with such high inflation there is less pump and dump going on, so people won't get burned as easily as in other pumps. (Have a look at CLOAK for example, which decreased 10 fold..)
|
|
|
|
GreekBitcoin
Legendary

Activity: 1428
Merit: 1001
getmonero.org
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 12:51:11 AM |
|
The only moves that I will commend with regards to emission are that if you don't like the emission, either fork and try to get people to use your fork or to just create a merge mined coin with a longer emission.
Just to be clear, that means that emission will remain like it is except obviously for what to decide for the final years OR that in case emission is changed we can always fork it and do whatever we want?
|
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 01:06:17 AM |
|
Ideally, the development team is non-financially motivated, but since they are We are not, but tell me how we'll pay the developers and the consulting and everything? Have you cake and eat it? How much did you donated? How much ALL OF YOU holders donated? Answer: not enough. Now if you have a solution, we are all ears. You are calling us greedy and I take it as a personal insult. Wait, Risto says you are one of the 7 developers. But you pay someone else to develop? :Mind Blown: How is the notion of teamwork so complicated for you? Some programmers have more means than others. Why would it bug you if one buys the lunches for another? Everyone does better if they aren't worried about where the next meal comes from. Multiple choice 1. Because he is a troll 2. Because he is a troll 3. Because he is a troll 4. All of the above
|
|
|
|
|
tacotime
Legendary

Activity: 1484
Merit: 1011
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 01:08:18 AM |
|
The only moves that I will commend with regards to emission are that if you don't like the emission, either fork and try to get people to use your fork or to just create a merge mined coin with a longer emission.
Just to be clear, that means that emission will remain like it is except obviously for what to decide for the final years OR that in case emission is changed we can always fork it and do whatever we want? Oh, sorry, I meant with regard to increasing inflation dramatically at the current time, not the perpetual inflation at year 10 as discussed a long, long time ago and which was generally well received by the community. This I am strongly in support of, but a lot of my support for this is in the anticipation that it will secure the network perpetually.
|
XMR: 44GBHzv6ZyQdJkjqZje6KLZ3xSyN1hBSFAnLP6EAqJtCRVzMzZmeXTC2AHKDS9aEDTRKmo6a6o9r9j86pYfhCWDkKjbtcns
|
|
|
cAPSLOCK
Legendary

Activity: 4522
Merit: 8318
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 01:12:50 AM |
|
The only moves that I will commend with regards to emission are that if you don't like the emission, either fork and try to get people to use your fork or to just create a merge mined coin with a longer emission.
Thank you.
|
|
|
|
|
BitcoinDN.com
Member


Activity: 97
Merit: 10
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 01:13:30 AM |
|
The only moves that I will commend with regards to emission are that if you don't like the emission, either fork and try to get people to use your fork or to just create a merge mined coin with a longer emission.
Just to be clear, that means that emission will remain like it is except obviously for what to decide for the final years OR that in case emission is changed we can always fork it and do whatever we want? Oh, sorry, I meant with regard to increasing inflation dramatically at the current time, not the perpetual inflation at year 10 as discussed a long, long time ago and which was generally well received by the community. This I am strongly in support of, but a lot of my support for this is in the anticipation that it will secure the network perpetually. That is a great solution. If I understand correctly, the goal is to allow Monero to penetrate general acceptance in it's current emission, and then tail off to an inflationary cycle for perpetuity during the general use everyday stage? I would just like to revoice my concern that in the case of a 1% post-mine or block reward subsidy to devs, this general acceptance is less likely to occur due to the attitude of the general crypto community. They will all (rightfully) bash Monero as a scam if there is any sort of atonement to the developers, even if it is only to repay costs. While it isn't fair for developers to subside gains for whales, it is also not fair to jeopardize the entire project for the sake of the few (but important).
|
|
|
|
|
GreekBitcoin
Legendary

Activity: 1428
Merit: 1001
getmonero.org
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 01:16:06 AM |
|
The only moves that I will commend with regards to emission are that if you don't like the emission, either fork and try to get people to use your fork or to just create a merge mined coin with a longer emission.
Just to be clear, that means that emission will remain like it is except obviously for what to decide for the final years OR that in case emission is changed we can always fork it and do whatever we want? Oh, sorry, I meant with regard to increasing inflation dramatically at the current time, not the perpetual inflation at year 10 as discussed a long, long time ago and which was generally well received by the community. This I am strongly in support of, but a lot of my support for this is in the anticipation that it will secure the network perpetually. Nice!  Now can we all discuss how to fund the team? 
|
|
|
|
|
NewLiberty
Legendary

Activity: 1204
Merit: 1002
Gresham's Lawyer
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 01:17:01 AM |
|
The only moves that I will commend with regards to emission are that if you don't like the emission, either fork and try to get people to use your fork or to just create a merge mined coin with a longer emission.
A merge mined fork with a very low, very long (perpetual?) emission would also reward mining, and provide for new entrants into many future generations. It is something to consider. It would preserve the currency XMR scarcity. If it uses the same codebase, with only the emission parameters changed, it could solve the problems for everyone without a huge new burden. Something to think about anyway. There would be a lot of details to consider first.
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 01:17:49 AM |
|
Barring this, you can notice very strong opinions for and against the post-mine, for and against the miner fee, for and against changing the emission curve. I am not debating them, but it should be obvious to all by now they are very controversial and all damage trust in one way or another.
I don't necessarily agree. In such matters of practice, you must always ask the question, compared to what. A decision not to act is still a decision. The community trusts us to be good custodians and do the right thing with respect to ongoing development of the project. Failing to act when a strong case has been made in favor of acting, even if some controversy remains, could equally damage trust. What is "the right thing" is certainly contentious and on that I agree entirely with your comments above. I do not give the status quo any inherent advantage when considering a proposed change in its merits. There may be considerations that weigh in favor of the status quo, but they must still be weighed, not assumed. Regarding the later question of subsidizing whales. All can rest assured that our decisions are most certainly not influenced by that consideration, at least not positively. If you want to be cynical about it, consider that we are not whales so we would be acting against our direct interests to do that. In any case, it is not going to happen. Reasonable opinions may differ about the effect of various changes of course. I don't happen to think that inflation affects the price of the coin much at all within a reasonable range and assuming no change in the long term supply.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 01:20:06 AM |
|
Now can we all discuss how to fund the team?  Certainly yes. I remind that there is no immediate funding crisis. The work is getting done and the team remains, for the time being, comfortable with subsidizing the project with our own time and money. So fix it yes, but don't panic.
|
|
|
|
|
tacotime
Legendary

Activity: 1484
Merit: 1011
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 01:21:46 AM |
|
That is a great solution. If I understand correctly, the goal is to allow Monero to penetrate general acceptance in it's current emission, and then tail off to an inflationary cycle for perpetuity during the general use everyday stage?
I would just like to revoice my concern that in the case of a 1% post-mine or block reward subsidy to devs, this general acceptance is less likely to occur due to the attitude of the general crypto community. They will all (rightfully) bash Monero as a scam if there is any sort of atonement to the developers, even if it is only to repay costs. While it isn't fair for developers to subside gains for whales, it is also not fair to jeopardize the entire project for the sake of the few (but important).
Yeah. Currently with XMR we won't see single digit inflation until well into year 4, so between now and then users will be able to buy in cheaply.
|
XMR: 44GBHzv6ZyQdJkjqZje6KLZ3xSyN1hBSFAnLP6EAqJtCRVzMzZmeXTC2AHKDS9aEDTRKmo6a6o9r9j86pYfhCWDkKjbtcns
|
|
|
GreekBitcoin
Legendary

Activity: 1428
Merit: 1001
getmonero.org
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 01:22:48 AM |
|
I will soon  Certainly yes. I remind that there is no immediate funding crisis. The work is getting done and the team remains, for the time being, comfortable with subsidizing the project with our own time and money.
So fix it yes, but don't panic.
Good to know because it felt for a moment that we were panicking indeed 
|
|
|
|
|
|