xnova
Sr. Member
  

Activity: 390
Merit: 255
Counterparty Developer
|
 |
March 27, 2014, 08:47:43 PM Last edit: March 27, 2014, 09:15:42 PM by xnova |
|
How is this a comment from a bright individual you can reach out to? It's just another Luke Jr. What we are against is extorting other participants of the bitcoin network into processing your transactions which were not in the original social contract of bitcoin, especially when clearly explained alternatives exist. That is frankly evil, although I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and chalk it up to ignorance. This time. The Bitcoin core devs are focused and clearly care about the network. I think a lot of this *may* come from a fundamentally different viewpoint on what Bitcoin is. I.e. is it just a digital currency payment network, or is it a payment network as well as a platform for building higher-level crypto-financial applications, so to say. And if it is the latter, there is a secondary debate on how such data "should" be stored in the block chain. With Mark's view above, it reminds me of Peter Todd's original responses to JR of Mastercoin when that came out. These were, to put it mildly, rather harsh. Since that point Peter's views have changed considerably and he has become a supporter and innovator in this space of "embedded consensus systems". Mark is also an innovator with "2.0"-type systems with his work on Freimarkets, but his views are obviously different than Peter's on multiple levels. My view is that Counterparty is targeting a sector that, by capitalization values, dwarfs that which Bitcoin it targeting by many multiples. Bitcoin is already adding tremendous value to Counterparty, and in return, there is tremendous value that Counterparty can add to Bitcoin, through its building on the Bitcoin "stack", which offers an end-to-end solution for decentralized financial transactions, and is proven, secure, and reliable. In contrast, building our own DHT system, or running a side chain, or whatever else a) adds complexity, b) is not proven to be secure, c) is potentially centralized, or less decentralized than Bitcoin and d) does not add any advantages compared to how we are doing things today. Even if Counterparty was not doing things this way, soon enough someone else will be, and then someone else, and then more people. It will become a game of whack-a-mole to the core devs, as building on Bitcoin entirely just makes sense, at least at this stage, as it is not just the simplest solution, but also the provably most robust one. And those two things are immensely important to a platform looking to carry billions of dollars of market movement on top of it (and on top of Bitcoin, as well). This is not about us being "lazy". It IS about us building on proven solutions, and avoiding potentially costly bugs and issues which can undermine any trust placed in a "Bitcoin-based" platform. We have to remember, this is totally new to the mainstream world. We *have* to make the best first impression possible, and a big part of that is building on top of the most rock-solid technology available and in-use *today*. That all being said, if, in the future, an innovation were to come such as a side chain that was provably as secure as Bitcoin (through being in *actual use*, and not just a whitepaper or a post on the mailing list), possibly had shorter block times (if block based) and was better tuned towards storing this data, then we would strongly consider using that for embedding our transactions. But in that case, the question would arise of not simply just moving to that, if it had as much clout as Bitcoin and was not simply seen as a supplementary data storage side-chain. Bitcoin has a potential here to embrace and "lock in" solutions like Counterparty, and fully integrate them into the BTC economy. We believe this opportunity dwarfs any burden imposed through an extra use of ~10-30 bytes per Counterparty transaction, for instance (i.e. through storing the full transaction in place of a hash). This includes the benefits we would bring both to miners, through paying tx fees on every transaction, as well as full node operators, through hopefully lending extra "future-proofed" market value to the BTC they are likely to hold. Hopefully this response was helpful and constructive towards illustrating our views on this matter. 
|
|
|
|
|
kdrop22
|
 |
March 27, 2014, 08:52:51 PM |
|
+1 Great post Xnova
|
|
|
|
|
|
porqupine
|
 |
March 27, 2014, 08:57:28 PM |
|
How is this a comment from a bright individual you can reach out to? It's just another Luke Jr. What we are against is extorting other participants of the bitcoin network into processing your transactions which were not in the original social contract of bitcoin, especially when clearly explained alternatives exist. That is frankly evil, although I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and chalk it up to ignorance. This time. The Bitcoin core devs are focused and clearly care about the network. I think a lot of this *may* come from a fundamentally different viewpoint on what Bitcoin is. I.e. is it just a digital currency payment network, or is it a payment network as well as a platform for building higher-level crypto-financial applications, so to say. And if it is the latter, there is a secondary debate on how such data "should" be stored in the block chain. With Mark's view above, it reminds me of Peter Todd's original responses to JR of Mastercoin when that came out. These were, to put it mildly, rather harsh. Since that point Peter's views have changed considerably and he has become a supporter and innovator in this space of "embedded consensus systems". Mark is also an innovator with "2.0"-type systems with his work on Freimarkets, but his views are obviously different than Peter's on multiple levels. My view is that Counterparty is targeting a sector that, by capitalization values, dwarfs that which Bitcoin it targeting by many multiples. Bitcoin is already adding tremendous value to Counterparty, and in return, there is tremendous value that Counterparty can add to Bitcoin, through its building on the Bitcoin "stack", which offers an end-to-end solution for decentralized financial data, and is proven, secure, and reliable. In contrast, building our own DHT system, or running a side chain, or whatever else a) adds complexity, b) is not proven to be secure, c) is potentially centralized, or less decentralized than Bitcoin and d) does not add and advantages towards how we are doing things today. Even if Counterparty was not doing things this way, soon enough someone else will be, and then someone else, and then more people. It will become a game of whack-a-mole to the core devs, as building on Bitcoin entirely just makes sense, at least at this stage, as it is not just the simplest solution, but also the provably most robust one. And those two things are immensely important to a platform looking to carry billions of dollars of market movement on top of it (and on top of Bitcoin, as well). This is not about us being "lazy". That all being said, if, in the future, an innovation were to come such as a side chain that was provably as secure as Bitcoin (through being in *actual use*, and not just a whitepaper or a post on the mailing list), possibly had shorter block times (if block based) and was better tuned towards storing this data, then we would strongly consider using that for embedding our transactions. But in that case, the question would arise of not simply just moving to that, if it had as much clout as Bitcoin (and was not simply seen as a supplementary data storage side-chain). Bitcoin has a potential here to embrace and "lock in" solutions like Counterparty, and fully integrate them into the BTC economy. We believe this opportunity dwarfs any burden imposed through an extra use of ~10-30 bytes per Counterparty transaction, for instance (i.e. through storing a hash instead of storing the full transaction). This includes the benefits we would hopefully bring both to miners (through paying tx fees on every transaction), as well as full node operators (through hopefully lending extra "future-proofed" market value to the BTC they are likely to hold). Hopefully this response was helpful and constructive towards illustrating our views on this matter.  I think you are making great points. Only I still can't find any esteem for the 'implicit' and 'social contract' arguments - if extra data storage is bad - then why not charge extra fees for OP_return proportional to their burden on the network - there is no absolutely no conclusive logic behind 'these types of transactions are part of the social contract' 'these types of transactions are not' - it's just political posturing - it's like if someone came out to tell people that the Internet was designed for X and not for Y: ergo should not be used for Y. If his Freimarkets proposal is better than Counterparty, than he can implement it and market forces will decide which is better.
|
|
|
|
|
BitcoinTangibleTrust
Member


Activity: 111
Merit: 11
Digitizing Valuable Hard Assets with Crypto
|
 |
March 27, 2014, 09:01:15 PM |
|
Product and Service Updates March 27, 2014Introduction:We at BitcoinTangibleTrust are happy that to launch a public, trustless trial of BitcoinTangible Trust's gold asset purchase, custody, and issuance on the Counterparty Platform. The players in this public purchase will be: - Global_trade_repo(Counterparty Forums) also known as led_cd(BitcoinTalk Forums)
- BitcoinTangibleTrust (Counterpart Forums) also known as BitcoinTangibleTrust(BitcoinTalk Forums)
- Agora Commodities
- DiamondState Depository
Objective:Our objective is to open up the BitcoinTangibleTrust process to the community in order to build trust from with our process and to validate that there is a value proposition we can continue to scale with more customers and further sales. Our Process:Walk with led_cd through the purchase of approximately 1 BTC of gold for custody and DEX trading through BitcoinTangible Trust process. led_cd will provide his public feedback on the purchase, custody, and trading process to the community. We welcome a very public exercise. We will not charge any fees to led_cd/Global_Trade_repo outside the fees from either gold sellers or our custodian partners. The first step will be for led_cd to fill out our Order form online and inform us of his desire to make a purchase of 1 BTC of gold here: http://bitcointangibletrust.com/buy-gold/Our Ask:We look to you, the community to share any thoughts on the process and how we might improve by quoting us in the feedback we will share during the entire process. Will you help us? Thank you Counterparty Devs and the Counterparty Community, Bitcoin Tangible Trust Team Cross Posted to Counterparty Forums: https://forums.counterparty.co/index.php/topic,203.0.html
|
|
|
|
xnova
Sr. Member
  

Activity: 390
Merit: 255
Counterparty Developer
|
 |
March 27, 2014, 09:05:36 PM |
|
I think you are making great points. Only I still can't find any esteem for the 'implicit' and 'social contract' arguments - if extra data storage is bad - then why not charge extra fees for OP_return proportional to their burden on the network - there is no absolutely no conclusive logic behind 'these types of transactions are part of the social contract' 'these types of transactions are not' - it's just political posturing - it's like if someone came out to tell people that the Internet was designed for X and not for Y: ergo should not be used for Y. If his Freimarkets proposal is better than Counterparty, than he can implement it and market forces will decide which is better.
The problem is that Bitcoin's current fee model is definitely "less-than-ideal". It is both static (i.e. non adaptive) and does not compensate full node operators who store the data. This whole debate, I suspect, is a consequence of that. The model can be adjusted, and there has been copious amounts of talk on doing that, but to the credit of the core devs, it's quite hard to change a flat tire on a five ton dump truck going down the road at 70 miles an hour. 
|
|
|
|
|
porqupine
|
 |
March 27, 2014, 09:17:46 PM |
|
I think you are making great points. Only I still can't find any esteem for the 'implicit' and 'social contract' arguments - if extra data storage is bad - then why not charge extra fees for OP_return proportional to their burden on the network - there is no absolutely no conclusive logic behind 'these types of transactions are part of the social contract' 'these types of transactions are not' - it's just political posturing - it's like if someone came out to tell people that the Internet was designed for X and not for Y: ergo should not be used for Y. If his Freimarkets proposal is better than Counterparty, than he can implement it and market forces will decide which is better.
The problem is that Bitcoin's current fee model is definitely "less-than-ideal". It is both static (i.e. non adaptive) and does not compensate full node operators who store the data. This whole debate, I suspect, is a consequence of that. The model can be adjusted, and there has been copious amounts of talk on doing that, but to the credit of the core devs, it's quite hard to change a flat tire on a 2 ton dump truck going down the road at 70 miles an hour.  Full Nodes have never received any fees - and it's been okay all this time - but then you add .003% more Data and it's abuse? Besides that I think Counterparty users are the straight up largest percent wise group of Full Node operators Take this analogy - you have a highway whose maintenance is paid for by toll fees, and a logging company's trucks cause more wear to the highway surface than your average passenger vehicle - but instead of saying, hey let's do an analysis of how much more wear the logging trucks are causing and charge them higher fees accordingly - they are saying those trucks are evil and hurting all other car owners. Isn't there a problem with this mentality? Sure your average toll paying driver does not need the 'logging trucks', but they are in fact, perhaps essential to the state's economical development in a very important sector. It's economically backward minded - sure that can change with time and I think it will; I just have a problem with libertarians turning free-market economics into 'social ideology that ought to be good enough for everyone' as soon as it violates their favorite order of things.
|
|
|
|
|
samperi649
Member


Activity: 61
Merit: 10
|
 |
March 27, 2014, 10:03:58 PM |
|
I just want to put this out there for those of you who DO believe in Counterparty and XCP that also have Bitcoin to spare etc., Watch the exchanges closely over the next week+, if you're timing is right you're going to get some really cheap XCP  Halfcab, stop this dump plz!!!
|
|
|
|
|
|
led_lcd
|
 |
March 27, 2014, 10:08:40 PM |
|
Our Process:Walk with led_cd through the purchase of approximately 1 BTC of gold for custody and DEX trading through BitcoinTangible Trust process. led_cd will provide his public feedback on the purchase, custody, and trading process to the community. We welcome a very public exercise. We will not charge any fees to led_cd/Global_Trade_repo outside the fees from either gold sellers or our custodian partners. The first step will be for led_cd to fill out our Order form online and inform us of his desire to make a purchase of 1 BTC of gold here: http://bitcointangibletrust.com/buy-gold/ I'm excited to be the person to give this a test run. All my experiences and questions will be posted in the official forums. This way future users of the service can easily refer to a single thread. I'd encourage other people who wish to find out more information to put in that thread too,
|
|
|
|
|
|
freedomfighter
|
 |
March 27, 2014, 10:29:55 PM |
|
+1 Great post Xnova
+1000. Eyeopener.
|
|
|
|
|
l4p7
Member


Activity: 70
Merit: 10
|
 |
March 27, 2014, 10:44:56 PM |
|
Product and Service Updates March 27, 2014Introduction:We at BitcoinTangibleTrust are happy that to launch a public, trustless trial of BitcoinTangible Trust's gold asset purchase, custody, and issuance on the Counterparty Platform. The players in this public purchase will be: - Global_trade_repo(Counterparty Forums) also known as led_cd(BitcoinTalk Forums)
- BitcoinTangibleTrust (Counterpart Forums) also known as BitcoinTangibleTrust(BitcoinTalk Forums)
- Agora Commodities
- DiamondState Depository
Objective:Our objective is to open up the BitcoinTangibleTrust process to the community in order to build trust from with our process and to validate that there is a value proposition we can continue to scale with more customers and further sales. Our Process:Walk with led_cd through the purchase of approximately 1 BTC of gold for custody and DEX trading through BitcoinTangible Trust process. led_cd will provide his public feedback on the purchase, custody, and trading process to the community. We welcome a very public exercise. We will not charge any fees to led_cd/Global_Trade_repo outside the fees from either gold sellers or our custodian partners. The first step will be for led_cd to fill out our Order form online and inform us of his desire to make a purchase of 1 BTC of gold here: http://bitcointangibletrust.com/buy-gold/Our Ask:We look to you, the community to share any thoughts on the process and how we might improve by quoting us in the feedback we will share during the entire process. Will you help us? Thank you Counterparty Devs and the Counterparty Community, Bitcoin Tangible Trust Team Cross Posted to Counterparty Forums: https://forums.counterparty.co/index.php/topic,203.0.html In simple word. Does it work in one of these ways: (1) I send you BTC -> you send me Gold via post mail? (2) I send you BTC -> you owe me Gold worth of the amount of BTC i sent you (for ex.: I send you 3.2 BTC which gives me 1 oz of Gold atm. In half a year i will egt a different amount of BTC and UDS compared to now, and I can cash out in BTC or USD at the respective daily rate). And then I can request that you pay me back in BTC (or USD? or Gold?) whenever I choose to?
|
|
|
|
|
|
baddw
|
 |
March 27, 2014, 11:00:55 PM |
|
Product and Service Updates March 27, 2014Introduction:We at BitcoinTangibleTrust are happy that to launch a public, trustless trial of BitcoinTangible Trust's gold asset purchase, custody, and issuance on the Counterparty Platform. The players in this public purchase will be: - Global_trade_repo(Counterparty Forums) also known as led_cd(BitcoinTalk Forums)
- BitcoinTangibleTrust (Counterpart Forums) also known as BitcoinTangibleTrust(BitcoinTalk Forums)
- Agora Commodities
- DiamondState Depository
Objective:Our objective is to open up the BitcoinTangibleTrust process to the community in order to build trust from with our process and to validate that there is a value proposition we can continue to scale with more customers and further sales. Our Process:Walk with led_cd through the purchase of approximately 1 BTC of gold for custody and DEX trading through BitcoinTangible Trust process. led_cd will provide his public feedback on the purchase, custody, and trading process to the community. We welcome a very public exercise. We will not charge any fees to led_cd/Global_Trade_repo outside the fees from either gold sellers or our custodian partners. The first step will be for led_cd to fill out our Order form online and inform us of his desire to make a purchase of 1 BTC of gold here: http://bitcointangibletrust.com/buy-gold/Our Ask:We look to you, the community to share any thoughts on the process and how we might improve by quoting us in the feedback we will share during the entire process. Will you help us? Thank you Counterparty Devs and the Counterparty Community, Bitcoin Tangible Trust Team Cross Posted to Counterparty Forums: https://forums.counterparty.co/index.php/topic,203.0.html In simple word. Does it work in one of these ways: (1) I send you BTC -> you send me Gold via post mail? (2) I send you BTC -> you owe me Gold worth of the amount of BTC i sent you (for ex.: I send you 3.2 BTC which gives me 1 oz of Gold atm. In half a year i will egt a different amount of BTC and UDS compared to now, and I can cash out in BTC or USD at the respective daily rate). And then I can request that you pay me back in BTC (or USD? or Gold?) whenever I choose to? #2. But the cool thing is that you can trade your 1 oz gold IOU on the exchange. So, you buy 1 oz of gold from BTT for 3.2 BTC. You hold it in an XCP asset. Price of gold goes up relative to BTC, I pay you 3.5 BTC for that asset on the exchange. Now you hold 3.5 BTC and I hold the 1 oz of gold asset. Now price of BTC rises or price of gold goes down. You buy back the 1 oz asset from me for 3.0 BTC. Through this trading, you now have an XCP asset holding 1 oz of gold, and 0.5 BTC in profit. EDIT: So nobody ever cashes out through Bitcoin Tangible Trust. (Although I suppose it's possible, they will try to avoid it as it costs a lot of money to ship gold, and they would rather keep the assets in the marketplace.) The assets remain in the market. If you want to cash out, you sell it on the exchange for the going rate in BTC, and then cash out your BTC, and somebody else holds the IOU from Bitcoin Tangible Trust.
|
BTC/XCP 11596GYYq5WzVHoHTmYZg4RufxxzAGEGBX DRK XvFhRFQwvBAmFkaii6Kafmu6oXrH4dSkVF Eligius Payouts/CPPSRB Explained I am not associated with Eligius in any way. I just think that it is a good pool with a cool payment system 
|
|
|
BitcoinTangibleTrust
Member


Activity: 111
Merit: 11
Digitizing Valuable Hard Assets with Crypto
|
 |
March 28, 2014, 12:00:00 AM |
|
Product and Service Updates March 27, 2014Introduction:We at BitcoinTangibleTrust are happy that to launch a public, trustless trial of BitcoinTangible Trust's gold asset purchase, custody, and issuance on the Counterparty Platform. The players in this public purchase will be: - Global_trade_repo(Counterparty Forums) also known as led_cd(BitcoinTalk Forums)
- BitcoinTangibleTrust (Counterpart Forums) also known as BitcoinTangibleTrust(BitcoinTalk Forums)
- Agora Commodities
- DiamondState Depository
Objective:Our objective is to open up the BitcoinTangibleTrust process to the community in order to build trust from with our process and to validate that there is a value proposition we can continue to scale with more customers and further sales. Our Process:Walk with led_cd through the purchase of approximately 1 BTC of gold for custody and DEX trading through BitcoinTangible Trust process. led_cd will provide his public feedback on the purchase, custody, and trading process to the community. We welcome a very public exercise. We will not charge any fees to led_cd/Global_Trade_repo outside the fees from either gold sellers or our custodian partners. The first step will be for led_cd to fill out our Order form online and inform us of his desire to make a purchase of 1 BTC of gold here: http://bitcointangibletrust.com/buy-gold/Our Ask:We look to you, the community to share any thoughts on the process and how we might improve by quoting us in the feedback we will share during the entire process. Will you help us? Thank you Counterparty Devs and the Counterparty Community, Bitcoin Tangible Trust Team Cross Posted to Counterparty Forums: https://forums.counterparty.co/index.php/topic,203.0.html In simple word. Does it work in one of these ways: (1) I send you BTC -> you send me Gold via post mail? (2) I send you BTC -> you owe me Gold worth of the amount of BTC i sent you (for ex.: I send you 3.2 BTC which gives me 1 oz of Gold atm. In half a year i will egt a different amount of BTC and UDS compared to now, and I can cash out in BTC or USD at the respective daily rate). And then I can request that you pay me back in BTC (or USD? or Gold?) whenever I choose to? #2. But the cool thing is that you can trade your 1 oz gold IOU on the exchange. So, you buy 1 oz of gold from BTT for 3.2 BTC. You hold it in an XCP asset. Price of gold goes up relative to BTC, I pay you 3.5 BTC for that asset on the exchange. Now you hold 3.5 BTC and I hold the 1 oz of gold asset. Now price of BTC rises or price of gold goes down. You buy back the 1 oz asset from me for 3.0 BTC. Through this trading, you now have an XCP asset holding 1 oz of gold, and 0.5 BTC in profit. EDIT: So nobody ever cashes out through Bitcoin Tangible Trust. (Although I suppose it's possible, they will try to avoid it as it costs a lot of money to ship gold, and they would rather keep the assets in the marketplace.) The assets remain in the market. If you want to cash out, you sell it on the exchange for the going rate in BTC, and then cash out your BTC, and somebody else holds the IOU from Bitcoin Tangible Trust. Thanks for the excellent review baddw! Answering #1: We do not send our customers gold. It's easier to do that directly. We are focused on digitizing the physical gold asset into an XCP IOU. We're a digital custodian for these assets. Adding to #2 answer above: Customers CAN cash out into the physical gold with BitcoinTangible Trust. The unique structure of our custodian agreement allows for our customers to redeem their gold at anytime, less any outstanding custodian fees and subject to private key signature verification. Otherwise, our goal is that you can trade the asset as long as you need and it proves useful to you. I hope that was helpful. Thank you for the excellent questions! BTT
|
|
|
|
halfcab123
Full Member
 

Activity: 224
Merit: 100
CabTrader v2 | crypto-folio.com
|
 |
March 28, 2014, 12:03:21 AM |
|
The drop in btc is aggravating
|
DayTrade with less exposure to risk, by setting buy and sell spreads with CabTrader v2, buy now @ crypto-folio.com
|
|
|
l4p7
Member


Activity: 70
Merit: 10
|
 |
March 28, 2014, 12:24:31 AM |
|
Product and Service Updates March 27, 2014Introduction:We at BitcoinTangibleTrust are happy that to launch a public, trustless trial of BitcoinTangible Trust's gold asset purchase, custody, and issuance on the Counterparty Platform. The players in this public purchase will be: - Global_trade_repo(Counterparty Forums) also known as led_cd(BitcoinTalk Forums)
- BitcoinTangibleTrust (Counterpart Forums) also known as BitcoinTangibleTrust(BitcoinTalk Forums)
- Agora Commodities
- DiamondState Depository
Objective:Our objective is to open up the BitcoinTangibleTrust process to the community in order to build trust from with our process and to validate that there is a value proposition we can continue to scale with more customers and further sales. Our Process:Walk with led_cd through the purchase of approximately 1 BTC of gold for custody and DEX trading through BitcoinTangible Trust process. led_cd will provide his public feedback on the purchase, custody, and trading process to the community. We welcome a very public exercise. We will not charge any fees to led_cd/Global_Trade_repo outside the fees from either gold sellers or our custodian partners. The first step will be for led_cd to fill out our Order form online and inform us of his desire to make a purchase of 1 BTC of gold here: http://bitcointangibletrust.com/buy-gold/Our Ask:We look to you, the community to share any thoughts on the process and how we might improve by quoting us in the feedback we will share during the entire process. Will you help us? Thank you Counterparty Devs and the Counterparty Community, Bitcoin Tangible Trust Team Cross Posted to Counterparty Forums: https://forums.counterparty.co/index.php/topic,203.0.html In simple word. Does it work in one of these ways: (1) I send you BTC -> you send me Gold via post mail? (2) I send you BTC -> you owe me Gold worth of the amount of BTC i sent you (for ex.: I send you 3.2 BTC which gives me 1 oz of Gold atm. In half a year i will egt a different amount of BTC and UDS compared to now, and I can cash out in BTC or USD at the respective daily rate). And then I can request that you pay me back in BTC (or USD? or Gold?) whenever I choose to? #2. But the cool thing is that you can trade your 1 oz gold IOU on the exchange. So, you buy 1 oz of gold from BTT for 3.2 BTC. You hold it in an XCP asset. Price of gold goes up relative to BTC, I pay you 3.5 BTC for that asset on the exchange. Now you hold 3.5 BTC and I hold the 1 oz of gold asset. Now price of BTC rises or price of gold goes down. You buy back the 1 oz asset from me for 3.0 BTC. Through this trading, you now have an XCP asset holding 1 oz of gold, and 0.5 BTC in profit. EDIT: So nobody ever cashes out through Bitcoin Tangible Trust. (Although I suppose it's possible, they will try to avoid it as it costs a lot of money to ship gold, and they would rather keep the assets in the marketplace.) The assets remain in the market. If you want to cash out, you sell it on the exchange for the going rate in BTC, and then cash out your BTC, and somebody else holds the IOU from Bitcoin Tangible Trust. Thanks for the excellent review baddw! Answering #1: We do not send our customers gold. It's easier to do that directly. We are focused on digitizing the physical gold asset into an XCP IOU. We're a digital custodian for these assets. Adding to #2 answer above: Customers CAN cash out into the physical gold with BitcoinTangible Trust. The unique structure of our custodian agreement allows for our customers to redeem their gold at anytime, less any outstanding custodian fees and subject to private key signature verification. Otherwise, our goal is that you can trade the asset as long as you need and it proves useful to you. I hope that was helpful. Thank you for the excellent questions! BTT So you would send me the Gold via post mail. Did I get that right? How do I know that you have the gold? And you also provide a BTC/1ozGold price feed? What data is that feed based on exactly?
|
|
|
|
|
Bellebite2014
Newbie

Activity: 56
Merit: 0
|
 |
March 28, 2014, 12:33:53 AM |
|
The drop in btc is aggravating
As Pavarotti was singing, *time to say goodbye*
|
|
|
|
|
BitcoinTangibleTrust
Member


Activity: 111
Merit: 11
Digitizing Valuable Hard Assets with Crypto
|
 |
March 28, 2014, 12:37:59 AM |
|
So you would send me the Gold via post mail. Did I get that right? How do I know that you have the gold? And you also provide a BTC/1ozGold price feed? What data is that feed based on exactly?
Answer1: We don't send you the gold. Our system is setup that gold goes directly from the gold seller to the custodian. We never touch your gold. Answer 2:With our special custody agreement, you can conduct an independent audit on the gold in custody. Again, we never touch your gold. It's in professional, bonded, insured, guarded custody. Answer 3:We will provide a feed on spot gold. I just need to figure out how to do that on Counterparty, but it's not a blocker to trading your gold coin on the DEX. EDIT: Super Thanks for these questions, l4p7. I will add them to our FAQ right now.
|
|
|
|
kkangjji22
Member


Activity: 67
Merit: 10
|
 |
March 28, 2014, 03:58:01 AM |
|
The drop in btc is aggravating
BTC decline of the market will have a significant impact, But I believe BTC will rise up in a day! 
|
|
|
|
|
|
lonsharim
|
 |
March 28, 2014, 05:55:28 AM |
|
I think you are making great points. Only I still can't find any esteem for the 'implicit' and 'social contract' arguments - if extra data storage is bad - then why not charge extra fees for OP_return proportional to their burden on the network - there is no absolutely no conclusive logic behind 'these types of transactions are part of the social contract' 'these types of transactions are not' - it's just political posturing - it's like if someone came out to tell people that the Internet was designed for X and not for Y: ergo should not be used for Y. If his Freimarkets proposal is better than Counterparty, than he can implement it and market forces will decide which is better.
The problem is that Bitcoin's current fee model is definitely "less-than-ideal". It is both static (i.e. non adaptive) and does not compensate full node operators who store the data. This whole debate, I suspect, is a consequence of that. The model can be adjusted, and there has been copious amounts of talk on doing that, but to the credit of the core devs, it's quite hard to change a flat tire on a 2 ton dump truck going down the road at 70 miles an hour.  Full Nodes have never received any fees - and it's been okay all this time - but then you add .003% more Data and it's abuse? Besides that I think Counterparty users are the straight up largest percent wise group of Full Node operators Take this analogy - you have a highway whose maintenance is paid for by toll fees, and a logging company's trucks cause more wear to the highway surface than your average passenger vehicle - but instead of saying, hey let's do an analysis of how much more wear the logging trucks are causing and charge them higher fees accordingly - they are saying those trucks are evil and hurting all other car owners. Isn't there a problem with this mentality? Sure your average toll paying driver does not need the 'logging trucks', but they are in fact, perhaps essential to the state's economical development in a very important sector. It's economically backward minded - sure that can change with time and I think it will; I just have a problem with libertarians turning free-market economics into 'social ideology that ought to be good enough for everyone' as soon as it violates their favorite order of things. That's a very good analogy porqupine and accurately reflects our predicament.
|
|
|
|
|
utuxia
Member


Activity: 69
Merit: 10
|
 |
March 28, 2014, 06:01:36 AM |
|
how do i fund the wallet on testnet?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|