Nekomata
Member


Activity: 99
Merit: 10
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 11:33:26 AM Last edit: April 19, 2015, 05:57:05 AM by Nekomata |
|
XMR is the future.
|
|
|
|
|
aminorex
Legendary

Activity: 1596
Merit: 1031
Sine secretum non libertas
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 12:06:40 PM |
|
Is there an active prioritized bounty list? That's a start.
Apparently the developer group at some point became very opposed to continuing to use bounties (which we did early on). I was not directly part of that decision and have no opinion on it so I can't comment. EDIT: Although, I would add a small opinion. There has been an active bounty for an AMD GPU miner since the very beginning, one to which I pledged (the largest pledge if I'm not mistake). Not only has the bounty not produced such a miner, but no one has pledged anything more toward the bounty since that time either. So based on my limited experience I'd say it suffers from the same failure as other forms of voluntary contributions. It lacked the structure conducive to success. One which has been frequently successful is to capture expressions of interest until the value is sufficient to make successful completion highly probable, then to get the funds committed, and only then to initiate the work. Upon passage of clearly defined success criteria, finally to pay out.
|
Give a man a fish and he eats for a day. Give a man a Poisson distribution and he eats at random times independent of one another, at a constant known rate.
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 12:22:56 PM |
|
Is there an active prioritized bounty list? That's a start.
Apparently the developer group at some point became very opposed to continuing to use bounties (which we did early on). I was not directly part of that decision and have no opinion on it so I can't comment. EDIT: Although, I would add a small opinion. There has been an active bounty for an AMD GPU miner since the very beginning, one to which I pledged (the largest pledge if I'm not mistake). Not only has the bounty not produced such a miner, but no one has pledged anything more toward the bounty since that time either. So based on my limited experience I'd say it suffers from the same failure as other forms of voluntary contributions. It lacked the structure conducive to success. One which has been frequently successful is to capture expressions of interest until the value is sufficient to make successful completion highly probable, then to get the funds committed, and only then to initiate the work. Upon passage of clearly defined success criteria, finally to pay out. That was extremely close to the structure used. It likely failed at the first stage, in that expressions of interest were insufficient, and increases in the expressions of interest have been zero for months. Furthermore, no one has stepped forward to improve the process either. Let someone else pay is approximately the same as let someone else do the work in this context. There is no AMD miner because of both.
|
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 12:25:57 PM |
|
Yes exactly. This is progressive discussion that we can expect if the dev team opens a directed bounty thread as I suggested.
I repeat, anyone can open a thread if the existing one is seen as insufficient. I hope the new thread has more success than the old one. As I said, the dev team has moved away from bounties as a preferred process, but we can't stop others from organizing them, and don't really discourage it either, if it doesn't overlap with work we are already doing or for which we have developed conflicting plans (and AMD miner is not such a work item). This is an open source community project. You are not customers you are participants, if you choose to be.
|
|
|
|
|
wachtwoord
Legendary

Activity: 2478
Merit: 1240
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 12:36:35 PM |
|
I would respectfully request that if you insist on discussing this, that any and all comments or posts discussing ideas around "dev blocks", miner tax, adjusting the emission curve, threats to sell your stash if X happens, calls for the core team to wade through walls of posts and make some comment, and anything of that nature be taken to the MEW thread or anywhere else.
Let's, please, solidify ourselves and retain some degree of unity as we restart our activities and reevaluate our priorities, and we can have these in-depth and controversial discussions once the smoke has cleared.
I concur with my team mate fluffypony. A proposal has been made within MEW on this matter and that is the best place to discuss it. if you think the community will ever accept changes on emission or a dev block you are 100% wrong :p I want to agree with the core team members fluffypony and smooth here: The question of possible slashing of emission rate, with no change in total number of coins, will be addressed in due time in MEW first. It will be thoroughly discussed. Then it will be voted upon. Iff the votes are overwhelmingly in favor of a change, we will expect the change to happen. If not, there will be no change. The most difficult situation would be a close call or a strongly divided community, but we have the resources to handle these cases also. Only after it is clear if the community favors the change, will the devs even need to care about it. This lets them concentrate on their work (which admittedly they have a lot in front of them) and the MEW can concentrate on funding them (we already raised 2,500 XMR for the devs in 2 days). The discussion about the topic is very intriguing, but since it requires community vote instead of a I-yell-louder-with-more-sockpuppets-than-you contest (which btw was the way how the emission was voted upon last time, and the quickmine won over a more moderate curve), I exhort everyone who wants to have a vote, to join MEW.  If you want to change it, why not just hardfork and take the devs that agree with you? I think changing the original is highly unfair to current holders that don't agree. Just fork and let the true economy (not a private organization such as MEW) decide.
|
|
|
|
|
digicoin
Legendary

Activity: 1106
Merit: 1000
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 12:38:30 PM |
|
I think that trollers are welcomed, even they are making noise only. XMR is under time-based stress test. I want to see how this community can grow up everyday.
|
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 01:04:09 PM |
|
Yes exactly. This is progressive discussion that we can expect if the dev team opens a directed bounty thread as I suggested.
I repeat, anyone can open a thread if the existing one is seen as insufficient. I hope the new thread has more success than the old one. As I said, the dev team has moved away from bounties as a preferred process, but we can't stop others from organizing them, and don't really discourage it either, if it doesn't overlap with work we are already doing or for which we have developed conflicting plans (and AMD miner is not such a work item). This is an open source community project. You are not customers you are participants, if you choose to be. In the context of what I proposed the devs do need to initiate it, at least at the beginning until a suitable volunteer could be found, andthey need to endorse it and be an active part of it. Instead we get "heres an address, give us money" and discussions of taxing the userbase. You keep repeating the same null points so I can only assume you have made up your mind based on those false pretenses and no matter what discussions or propositions, that is what it is. Yes its an open community, but I am talking about an integrative funding model thats closely knit into the development process. Im not talking about a bounty for a damn miner software that was poorly executed. Tell us, what exactly are the developments the dev team is working on? What are the timelines, task lists, expenses? Pony up that info and you have the relevant framework to build a donation/bounty funding model for Xmr development. Or you can keep talking about how poorly the GPU miner bounty was executed and use that as a basis to shut down any discussions about it. All I can say is, we have limited time (100% of us are doing this on a volunteer part time basis in our free time) and have spent most of it at this point fighting fires. You can talk all you want about "integrative funding models" but unless someone steps forward to do the work on that, it won't happen soon if at all. I did say that we will have a spreadsheet as described earlier for crowdfunding of various work items. Even that hasn't been done yet for the above reason. It isn't hard and might not satisfy you but it still takes time to put together. You still aren't getting it. If you want something done around here, you either volunteer to do it, or pay someone to do it. If not, then you get whatever free work you get and that's it.
|
|
|
|
|
|
nakaone
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 01:15:45 PM |
|
what is funny in xmr is that we have a shitload of whales swimming around here compared to other alts and we still have problems financing development.
even from an investors perspective the expected value of financing development will be one of the best deals we could ever make still it somewhat fails.
classical game thoretic single shot prisonners dilemma / tragedy of the commons - there is one proper solution for this kind of shit and that is institutions. maybe mew, even though I still have questions, is the answer.
|
|
|
|
|
|
equipoise
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 01:21:58 PM |
|
blaaa blaaa
Bounty: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=656841.0Unfinished CryptoNight OpenCL (AMD) miner: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=671784.0If you need an open source AMD miner then feel free to add some XMR to the bounty, find/hire someone to code it, code it yourself, cooperate with some other, who need it or whatever you want, but please let the core dev team work on the priorities: ... The constant attacks, both actual and threatened, have left us running around chasing our tails for a month. Now is not the time or create disarray and suck up time in circuitous debates ... Let's, please, solidify ourselves and retain some degree of unity as we restart our activities and reevaluate our priorities, and we can have these in-depth and controversial discussions once the smoke has cleared.
|
|
|
|
Miki
Member


Activity: 68
Merit: 10
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 01:58:55 PM |
|
Moneropool.com needs to stop accepting new miners, its already at 50% net hash rate. Miners please switch to smaller pools for the time being, i myself mine at monero.rs ( https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=791015) . Stable pool with innovative features.
|
|
|
|
|
alloffmyhate
Sr. Member
  

Activity: 280
Merit: 250
It's Never End
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 02:16:56 PM |
|
Moneropool.com needs to stop accepting new miners, its already at 50% net hash rate. Miners please switch to smaller pools for the time being, i myself mine at monero.rs ( https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=791015) . Stable pool with innovative features. yes this pool must be close to accepting new miner
|
|
|
|
|
aerbax
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 03:08:08 PM |
|
Moneropool.com needs to stop accepting new miners, its already at 50% net hash rate. Miners please switch to smaller pools for the time being, i myself mine at monero.rs ( https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=791015) . Stable pool with innovative features. I'm only seeing them at ~30% . But we've seen this before, and the best solution at the time was to increase the pool fees rather than shutting it down to new miners. They could then direct those extra fees to the devs. Two birds...
|
|
|
|
Miki
Member


Activity: 68
Merit: 10
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 03:10:07 PM |
|
Moneropool.com needs to stop accepting new miners, its already at 50% net hash rate. Miners please switch to smaller pools for the time being, i myself mine at monero.rs ( https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=791015) . Stable pool with innovative features. I'm only seeing them at ~30% . But we've seen this before, and the best solution at the time was to increase the pool fees rather than shutting it down to new miners. They could then direct those extra fees to the devs. Two birds... Their hash has dropped from 8.8MH/s to 7.8MH/s since my post. Network hash is also higher than it was 1h ago.
|
|
|
|
|
rdnkjdi
Legendary

Activity: 1257
Merit: 1009
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 03:22:17 PM Last edit: September 26, 2014, 03:53:42 PM by rdnkjdi |
|
even from an investors perspective the expected value of financing development will be one of the best deals we could ever make still it somewhat fails. I agree with this. I've shot off 5% of my holdings and may go up to 10% to the devteam (I'm a minnow). If Monero isn't properly funded it will lose it's value. I'm not sure who needs to organize the whales (is Risto doing this) but IMO 1% of holdings isn't enough. In the beginning I was ok with the 1% forced dev fee. I still am if absolutely everything else fails. I will probably sell half of my XMR if that happens judging by how the community is threatening to react - but by the time XMR dies it will have an improved code base because it was funded. We won't even get this far if it dies due to lack of developer interest / effort.
|
|
|
|
|
|
xulescu
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 03:23:09 PM |
|
Some error messages need to be sanitized because they leak information:  EDIT: Actually the errors are triggered by my actions (i.e. failed send, also got similar errors for get_blocks() or similar). For some reason the wallet could not talk to the daemon anymore. That path does not exist on my computer. Any clues?
|
|
|
|
|
|
richwang
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 03:40:35 PM |
|
a stable coin
|
|
|
|
|
equipoise
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 04:09:22 PM |
|
Some error messages need to be sanitized because they leak information:  EDIT: Actually the errors are triggered by my actions (i.e. failed send, also got similar errors for get_blocks() or similar). For some reason the wallet could not talk to the daemon anymore. That path does not exist on my computer. Any clues? Much mystery...
...such Scooby Doo: tewinget (Tom) built the Windows binaries, and I (Riccardo) built the OS X binaries. Obviously when you execute compiled code you don't have the source code *on your system*, but it has to still be able to reference where the error is occurring. You can safely ignore both those "ABSTRACT_SERVER_SEND_QUE_MAX_COUNT " errors as well as the path it refers to, as that just happened to be the build path at the time:)
|
|
|
|
|
xulescu
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 04:25:56 PM |
|
whoops, FAIL
Thanks equipoise
|
|
|
|
|
TrueCryptonaire
Legendary

Activity: 1092
Merit: 1000
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 04:44:28 PM |
|
The fact is, the emission rate is too high now - this can be seen 1) Price is dropping, more supply than demand 2) blocks that do not have transactions.
To solve this I suggest to increase the block time without touching the block reward. This gives also more life expectancy for the coin. The other alternative is to tax mining and put the taxes into escrowed account for development. However I assume the miners do not like the latter so we basically are left with increasing the block time without touching in any other parameters. The economy is not simply ready just yet for the current emission rate. I see it not a problem to change later back if there is demand enough for the coins.
Ideally coin should be in overall bull trend on macro level. It kind of forces adoption since people do not get coins for lower price so they have to buy it right now. If the coins are flooding to the markets but there is only little demand (supply > demand), the price goes down which will create a vicious cycle: when price goes down, people postpone their buy orders in hope of lower price (like if there is deflation in economy, people do not consume but they hold their cash and it kills the economy - even the real non-inflationary economic growth).
|
|
|
|
|
|
xulescu
|
 |
September 26, 2014, 04:59:04 PM |
|
The fact is, the emission rate is too high now - this can be seen 1) Price is dropping, more supply than demand 2) blocks that do not have transactions.
To solve this I suggest to increase the block time without touching the block reward. This gives also more life expectancy for the coin. The other alternative is to tax mining and put the taxes into escrowed account for development. However I assume the miners do not like the latter so we basically are left with increasing the block time without touching in any other parameters. The economy is not simply ready just yet for the current emission rate. I see it not a problem to change later back if there is demand enough for the coins.
Ideally coin should be in overall bull trend on macro level. It kind of forces adoption since people do not get coins for lower price so they have to buy it right now. If the coins are flooding to the markets but there is only little demand (supply > demand), the price goes down which will create a vicious cycle: when price goes down, people postpone their buy orders in hope of lower price (like if there is deflation in economy, people do not consume but they hold their cash and it kills the economy - even the real non-inflationary economic growth).
Spoken like a true student of Bernanke. Macroprudential, right? You're not describing adoption, you're describing a Ponzi.
|
|
|
|
|
|