qwizzie
Legendary

Activity: 2548
Merit: 1250
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 12:14:26 AM |
|
"Less likely it can be traced" is anonymous enough for delisting in my eyes. Since coinjoin can be fully traced, we can say bitcoin is not anonymous. Case closed. Thank you for you cooperation.  Lets re-open the case. Bitcoin open blockchain is pseudo-anonymous by default --> fully traced Bitcoin users chosing Bitcoin Mixers to mix their transactions --> anonymous (just lower level then Dash) Only if Bitcoin Mixers get compromised can Bitcoin transactions be fully traced.
|
Learn from the past, set detailed and vivid goals for the future and live in the only moment of time over which you have any control : now
|
|
|
arielbit
Legendary

Activity: 3444
Merit: 1061
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 12:17:04 AM |
|
"Less likely it can be traced" is anonymous enough for delisting in my eyes. Since coinjoin can be fully traced, we can say bitcoin is not anonymous. Case closed. Thank you for you cooperation.  Lets re-open the case. Bitcoin open blockchain is pseudo-anonymous by default --> fully traced Bitcoin users chosing Bitcoin Mixers to mix their transactions --> anonymous Nope, they are not anonymous--those bitcoin mixers. Overruled.
|
|
|
|
|
qwizzie
Legendary

Activity: 2548
Merit: 1250
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 12:18:22 AM |
|
"Less likely it can be traced" is anonymous enough for delisting in my eyes. Since coinjoin can be fully traced, we can say bitcoin is not anonymous. Case closed. Thank you for you cooperation.  Lets re-open the case. Bitcoin open blockchain is pseudo-anonymous by default --> fully traced Bitcoin users chosing Bitcoin Mixers to mix their transactions --> anonymous Nope, they are not anonymous--those bitcoin mixers. Overruled. Tell that to all the Bitcoin users still using those mixers. As long as the Bitcoin mixers don't get compromised, Bitcoin transactions can't be traced very easily. Maybe with a lot of effort by companies specialized in tracing transactions, maybe. But not by you or me.
|
Learn from the past, set detailed and vivid goals for the future and live in the only moment of time over which you have any control : now
|
|
|
arielbit
Legendary

Activity: 3444
Merit: 1061
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 12:29:39 AM |
|
"Less likely it can be traced" is anonymous enough for delisting in my eyes. Since coinjoin can be fully traced, we can say bitcoin is not anonymous. Case closed. Thank you for you cooperation.  Lets re-open the case. Bitcoin open blockchain is pseudo-anonymous by default --> fully traced Bitcoin users chosing Bitcoin Mixers to mix their transactions --> anonymous Nope, they are not anonymous--those bitcoin mixers. Overruled. Tell that to all the Bitcoin users still using those mixers. As long as the Bitcoin mixers don't get compromised, Bitcoin transactions can't be traced very easily. Maybe with a lot of effort by companies specialized in tracing transactions, maybe. But not by you or me. Yup. Told them https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ktkORjPHZvEThe prosecutor of the DEA and FBI agents didn't say how she was able to trace the transactions, but did mention that they were able to follow the coins as it bounced from one address to another until it ended up in the agent's personal exchange accounts, and they kept withdrawing hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Now, that's called something else. They did not do any mixing at all, and they used their own personal exchange accounts, and they were withdrawing hundreds of thousands of dollars every month.
So yeah, they must have missed a brain cell or something. (Maybe a lot more ...)
“the perfect criminals” — being federal agents, “they knew how to cover their tracks,” ---all of them should just ask dabs how to cover their tracks it bounced from one address to another sounds like mixing to me LOL she said "tumblers and mixers were early tech and technically they are not great" and they were able to unscramble. she also said TOR was created by the government BTW so there goes chipmixer signature of yours..hehe  what I pointed out to you are results. companies with tools and government with tools. it is done and proven that bitcoin is not anonymous, whatever mixing toys you use. this is like asking me to prove how uranium can produce so much energy, where i just choose to point out nuclear plant and nuclear bomb to you I'm not gonna get a drawing board and explain technical stuff here. the stuff you need to search was so 2014-2016 LOL can't believe you are still in 2012-2013 era hehe. ever heard of virgin BTC ? https://cointelegraph.com/news/virgin-bitcoin-most-in-demand-crypto-that-is-regulated-differentlyain't touching those mixed coins LOL
|
|
|
|
|
jdmcg
Member


Activity: 264
Merit: 22
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 12:44:02 AM |
|
The only real difference between Bitcoin's (and LTC's, BCH's, etc) coinjoin and Dash's to my knowledge is a question of trust.
Dash provides a decentralized version of coinjoin where the user doesn't have to hand their coins over and hope they get them back. Dash provides up to 16 rounds of mixing. Since Bitcoin's solutions are centralized, I doubt they really have a mixing limitation. They can pretty much do what they want and they likely have more inputs to mix with.
In practice and if done properly I doubt someone can trace either Bitcoin or Dash transactions once mixed and after the fact.
I've seen many claims that it's been broken but followed by no proof. Perhaps if a transaction (either from Dash or Bitcoin) can be de-anonymyzed and it isn't the result of an obvious user error I'd change my mind.
Now regarding Monero trolling... I'm one of those people who can't seem to pick just one coin. However, it was specifically because of the heavy XMR trolling/hate on multiple threads that I avoided XMR altogether. Of course I regret that, because it's different tech and it does offer something useful to the crypto world. I don't believe a crypto can be true money without privacy. theymos and other BTC maximalists love the XMR crew as they always played buddy-buddy with big brother BTC while praising its superiority all the while attacking all other alts. Charlie Lee and LTC largely played the same game. Dash in contrast went right at BTC and has suffered quite the backlash over the years.
Still though, I can't see any one of these 3, LTC, XMR or DASH just going away. They've all established a decent enough network effect and are all in bull markets vs USD and are all poised for an easy 7x when the time is right. It'll likely be quick, one first, within a 2 week period sometime in the coming months, then the others will follow.
|
|
|
|
|
qwizzie
Legendary

Activity: 2548
Merit: 1250
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 12:44:47 AM |
|
"Less likely it can be traced" is anonymous enough for delisting in my eyes. Since coinjoin can be fully traced, we can say bitcoin is not anonymous. Case closed. Thank you for you cooperation.  Lets re-open the case. Bitcoin open blockchain is pseudo-anonymous by default --> fully traced Bitcoin users chosing Bitcoin Mixers to mix their transactions --> anonymous Nope, they are not anonymous--those bitcoin mixers. Overruled. Tell that to all the Bitcoin users still using those mixers. As long as the Bitcoin mixers don't get compromised, Bitcoin transactions can't be traced very easily. Maybe with a lot of effort by companies specialized in tracing transactions, maybe. But not by you or me. Yup. Told them https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ktkORjPHZvEI am not sure the criminals actually used Bitcoin Mixers there. Looks more like just normal Bitcoin transactions being traced by the Federal Prosecutor, who obviously has a lot of analyzing tools available to her. Analyzing tools you and i don't have. There is also some talk about early tech or something ? Bitcoin Mixers these days are most likely far more secure then those early tech Bitcoin Mixers, if those were Bitcoin mixers in the first place. Stating that Bitcoin Mixed transactions are fully traceable by someone like you or me seems like an overstatement. The only real difference between Bitcoin's (and LTC's, BCH's, etc) coinjoin and Dash's to my knowledge is a question of trust.
Dash provides a decentralized version of coinjoin where the user doesn't have to hand their coins over and hope they get them back. Dash provides up to 16 rounds of mixing. Since Bitcoin's solutions are centralized, I doubt they really have a mixing limitation. They can pretty much do what they want and they likely have more inputs to mix with.
In practice and if done properly I doubt someone can trace either Bitcoin or Dash transactions once mixed and after the fact.
I've seen many claims that it's been broken but followed by no proof. Perhaps if a transaction (either from Dash or Bitcoin) can be de-anonymyzed and it isn't the result of an obvious user error I'd change my mind. I agree with that.
|
Learn from the past, set detailed and vivid goals for the future and live in the only moment of time over which you have any control : now
|
|
|
arielbit
Legendary

Activity: 3444
Merit: 1061
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 12:55:37 AM |
|
"Less likely it can be traced" is anonymous enough for delisting in my eyes. Since coinjoin can be fully traced, we can say bitcoin is not anonymous. Case closed. Thank you for you cooperation.  Lets re-open the case. Bitcoin open blockchain is pseudo-anonymous by default --> fully traced Bitcoin users chosing Bitcoin Mixers to mix their transactions --> anonymous Nope, they are not anonymous--those bitcoin mixers. Overruled. Tell that to all the Bitcoin users still using those mixers. As long as the Bitcoin mixers don't get compromised, Bitcoin transactions can't be traced very easily. Maybe with a lot of effort by companies specialized in tracing transactions, maybe. But not by you or me. Yup. Told them https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ktkORjPHZvEI am not sure the criminals actually used Bitcoin Mixers there. Looks more like just normal Bitcoin transactions being traced by the Federal Prosecutor, who obviously has a lot of analyzing tools available to her. Analyzing tools you and i don't have. There is also some talk about early tech or something ? Bitcoin Mixers these days are most likely far more secure then those early tech Bitcoin Mixers, if those were Bitcoin mixers in the first place. Stating that Bitcoin Mixed transactions are fully traceable by someone like you or me seems like an overstatement. Two words, mixing and unscramble--explains everything. Regulators hovering around exchanges demanding transparency and traceability...it is not about you or me. Therefore..delist.
|
|
|
|
|
birdonthewire
Member


Activity: 274
Merit: 10
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 12:59:46 AM |
|
Still though, I can't see any one of these 3, LTC, XMR or DASH just going away. They've all established a decent enough network effect and are all in bull markets vs USD and are all poised for an easy 7x when the time is right. It'll likely be quick, one first, within a 2 week period sometime in the coming months, then the others will follow.
What revaluation do you assume for BTC during that 7x of the altcoins? Thank you.
|
|
|
|
qwizzie
Legendary

Activity: 2548
Merit: 1250
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 01:00:37 AM |
|
Two words, mixing and unscramble--explains everything.
I can manually mix something by splitting my amount and sending them from one address to multiple addresses multiple times and someone else can indeed unscramble that mixing through use of analytical tools. That is not the same as using Bitcoin Mixers though. Provide some specific proof that Bitcoin Mixers can be fully traced these days.
|
Learn from the past, set detailed and vivid goals for the future and live in the only moment of time over which you have any control : now
|
|
|
arielbit
Legendary

Activity: 3444
Merit: 1061
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 01:02:54 AM |
|
Two words, mixing and unscramble--explains everything.
I can manually mix something and then someone else can unscramble my mixing. Provide some specific proof that Bitcoin Mixers can be fully traced these days. Take time to watch the link i gave you...they got caught eventhough they used mixers...the mixings got unscambled btw
|
|
|
|
|
qwizzie
Legendary

Activity: 2548
Merit: 1250
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 01:07:35 AM |
|
Two words, mixing and unscramble--explains everything.
I can manually mix something and then someone else can unscramble my mixing. Provide some specific proof that Bitcoin Mixers can be fully traced these days. Take time to watch the link i gave you...they got caught eventhough they used mixers...the mixings got unscambled btw That is still one case about a Federal Prosecutor on a specific case with the full power of her office. Does not mean all Bitcoin Mixer transactions are fully traced every minute / hour / day. A Federal Prosecutor could maybe do that to a Monero transaction as well these days. So many analytical tools available these days.
|
Learn from the past, set detailed and vivid goals for the future and live in the only moment of time over which you have any control : now
|
|
|
arielbit
Legendary

Activity: 3444
Merit: 1061
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 01:17:17 AM |
|
Two words, mixing and unscramble--explains everything.
I can manually mix something and then someone else can unscramble my mixing. Provide some specific proof that Bitcoin Mixers can be fully traced these days. Take time to watch the link i gave you...they got caught eventhough they used mixers...the mixings got unscambled btw That is still one case about a Federal Prosecutor on a specific case with the full power of her office. Does not mean all Bitcoin Mixer transactions are fully traced every minute / hour / day. A Federal Prosecutor could most likely do that to a Monero transaction as well these days. That's 2014...after 7 years they can apply those to exchanges. Mixed can be unscrambled Monero = encrypted, you can't unscramble encrypted, you have to decrypt it.(non transparent blockchain)
|
|
|
|
|
jdmcg
Member


Activity: 264
Merit: 22
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 01:19:58 AM |
|
Still though, I can't see any one of these 3, LTC, XMR or DASH just going away. They've all established a decent enough network effect and are all in bull markets vs USD and are all poised for an easy 7x when the time is right. It'll likely be quick, one first, within a 2 week period sometime in the coming months, then the others will follow.
What revaluation do you assume for BTC during that 7x of the altcoins? Thank you. Any revaluation for BTC I assume will be short-lived (relatively) but it is during this revaluation to at least test the previous high of $20K that I expect major fear and panic which will fuel the alt-season that just about every alt holder is waiting for. But things are different this time... BTC should have done it's 30% dump at $24K or at least $27K to have a healthy correction/pause to allow it to grow organically. I worry how unhealthy this rapid growth might be long term. Maybe all these institutions have stronger hands and aren't so greedy. But ultimately I doubt it, people will want to take profit at some point and like sheep they probably will all try to do it at the same time. I just hope it is only a 30-40% correction and not a major bubble pop that occurs before any alts can recover from the last 2017/2018 bubble pop. That sequence of events perhaps could kill many alts...
|
|
|
|
|
toknormal
Legendary

Activity: 3066
Merit: 1188
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 01:24:49 AM |
|
Two words, mixing and unscramble--explains everything.
I can manually mix something and then someone else can unscramble my mixing. Provide some specific proof that Bitcoin Mixers can be fully traced these days. Take time to watch the link i gave you...they got caught eventhough they used mixers...the mixings got unscambled btw Both of you have lost the plot. Mixing isn't about privacy (at least not primarily). It's about fungibility which is an acknowledged monetary property. A bi-product of hi fungiblity is greater anonymity (ability to decouple a unit of currency from its owner history). But that's just the bi-product. The primary reason is to maintain equivalence of value for each unit. This is one aspect where Dash has got the cash archetype right and coins like Monero have got it wrong IMO. Monero actually went and encrypted the entire transacting platform itself which isn't the same thing as making the currency fungible directly. The transparency of the transacting platform is needed to maximise perceived integrity. ("Math" doesn't cut it because users have no idea whether their particular client is using "math" or not. I doubt bitcoin would have garnered the trust it has without a gazillion forensic trainspotters crawling all over its chain 24 hours a day). Dash's mixing therefore works for high fungility whether a particular user uses it or not because they benefit from all the mixing of coins upstream of their addresses. The delistings if anything demonstrate that it's worked because the regulators are seeing Dash as "cash".....which is actually a design goal. What Dash got wrong was allowing the chain to give up half its supply for nothing, thereby torpedoing its value-storing capacity !
|
|
|
|
|
qwizzie
Legendary

Activity: 2548
Merit: 1250
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 01:32:08 AM Last edit: January 03, 2021, 01:53:49 AM by qwizzie |
|
Two words, mixing and unscramble--explains everything.
I can manually mix something and then someone else can unscramble my mixing. Provide some specific proof that Bitcoin Mixers can be fully traced these days. Take time to watch the link i gave you...they got caught eventhough they used mixers...the mixings got unscambled btw That is still one case about a Federal Prosecutor on a specific case with the full power of her office. Does not mean all Bitcoin Mixer transactions are fully traced every minute / hour / day. A Federal Prosecutor could most likely do that to a Monero transaction as well these days. That's 2014...after 7 years they can apply those to exchanges. Mixed can be unscrambled Looks like there is a move from Bitcoin Mixers to Bitcoin Privacy wallets connected to Tor and making CoinJoin transactions : https://www.cryptopolitan.com/privacy-wallets-their-growing-role-in-bitcoi/I always thought Bitcoin Mixers used CoinJoin, looks like they are actually used differently : Bitcoin Mixers are coin randomizers. They usually make sure that the value of Bitcoin exchanged between a sender and receiver differs greatly. At the end of such transactions, the mixers then make it extremely difficult for the transaction to be traced back to the wallet that initiated the transaction.
However, mixers have a litany of issues and a growing number of regulators have been able to cut their influence. The crypto scammers have seeked an alternative which is the use of privacy wallets.
|
Learn from the past, set detailed and vivid goals for the future and live in the only moment of time over which you have any control : now
|
|
|
jdmcg
Member


Activity: 264
Merit: 22
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 01:59:00 AM |
|
Mixed can be unscrambled
Monero = encrypted, you can't unscramble encrypted, you have to decrypt it.(non transparent blockchain)
Sounds like you're arguing that Dash is like Bitcoin then and perhaps should be treated the same. But tell me, once you deposit/trade/withdraw your XMR on an exchange which forced you to KYC how does Monero's encryption hide this activity from the relevant authorities? Seems to me, banning privacy coins from exchanges is a misinterpretation of the new laws being put in place. In fact I would think it's better to direct XMR traffic to exchanges to be better monitored for possible money laundering and other misbehaviors. Mixing isn't about privacy (at least not primarily). It's about fungibility which is an acknowledged monetary property. A bi-product of hi fungiblity is greater anonymity (ability to decouple a unit of currency from its owner history). But that's just the bi-product. The primary reason is to maintain equivalence of value for each unit.
This is one aspect where Dash has got the cash archetype right and coins like Monero have got it wrong IMO. Monero actually went and encrypted the entire transacting platform itself which isn't the same thing as making the currency fungible directly. The transparency of the transacting platform is needed to maximise perceived integrity. ("Math" doesn't cut it because users have no idea whether their particular client is using "math" or not. I doubt bitcoin would have garnered the trust it has without a gazillion forensic trainspotters crawling all over its chain 24 hours a day).
Good, we can still agree on something... fungibility is definitely required for sound money. As is transparency/auditability and the ability to verify the integrity of the system. Privacy is more about human rights.
|
|
|
|
|
|
bitwolf
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 07:42:46 AM |
|
Darkcoin to the world : we are super private and super secure and super fast and super unique crypto. Darkcoin when it gets delisted: Pls , pls we are useless simple btc cloning shitcoin like the thousands other useless btc clonings.
|
|
|
|
|
arielbit
Legendary

Activity: 3444
Merit: 1061
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 07:45:23 AM Last edit: November 26, 2021, 12:48:31 PM by mprep |
|
Two words, mixing and unscramble--explains everything.
I can manually mix something and then someone else can unscramble my mixing. Provide some specific proof that Bitcoin Mixers can be fully traced these days. Take time to watch the link i gave you...they got caught eventhough they used mixers...the mixings got unscambled btw That is still one case about a Federal Prosecutor on a specific case with the full power of her office. Does not mean all Bitcoin Mixer transactions are fully traced every minute / hour / day. A Federal Prosecutor could most likely do that to a Monero transaction as well these days. That's 2014...after 7 years they can apply those to exchanges. Mixed can be unscrambled Looks like there is a move from Bitcoin Mixers to Bitcoin Privacy wallets connected to Tor and making CoinJoin transactions : https://www.cryptopolitan.com/privacy-wallets-their-growing-role-in-bitcoi/I always thought Bitcoin Mixers used CoinJoin, looks like they are actually used differently : Bitcoin Mixers are coin randomizers. They usually make sure that the value of Bitcoin exchanged between a sender and receiver differs greatly. At the end of such transactions, the mixers then make it extremely difficult for the transaction to be traced back to the wallet that initiated the transaction.
However, mixers have a litany of issues and a growing number of regulators have been able to cut their influence. The crypto scammers have seeked an alternative which is the use of privacy wallets. Tor is also not anonymous.. We think it was back then. So mixing tor and coinjoin is not anonymous.
Mixed can be unscrambled
Monero = encrypted, you can't unscramble encrypted, you have to decrypt it.(non transparent blockchain)
Sounds like you're arguing that Dash is like Bitcoin then and perhaps should be treated the same. But tell me, once you deposit/trade/withdraw your XMR on an exchange which forced you to KYC how does Monero's encryption hide this activity from the relevant authorities? Seems to me, banning privacy coins from exchanges is a misinterpretation of the new laws being put in place. In fact I would think it's better to direct XMR traffic to exchanges to be better monitored for possible money laundering and other misbehaviors. They know you have an X amount of xmr in your exchange account but they cannot trace where it came from and cannot trace where you will send it. Dash is just like bitcoin in terms of privacy, but marketed to be good enough as a privacy/anonymous coin which dash will be treated as such LOL
Two words, mixing and unscramble--explains everything.
I can manually mix something and then someone else can unscramble my mixing. Provide some specific proof that Bitcoin Mixers can be fully traced these days. Take time to watch the link i gave you...they got caught eventhough they used mixers...the mixings got unscambled btw Both of you have lost the plot. Mixing isn't about privacy (at least not primarily). It's about fungibility which is an acknowledged monetary property. A bi-product of hi fungiblity is greater anonymity (ability to decouple a unit of currency from its owner history). But that's just the bi-product. The primary reason is to maintain equivalence of value for each unit. This is one aspect where Dash has got the cash archetype right and coins like Monero have got it wrong IMO. Monero actually went and encrypted the entire transacting platform itself which isn't the same thing as making the currency fungible directly. The transparency of the transacting platform is needed to maximise perceived integrity. ("Math" doesn't cut it because users have no idea whether their particular client is using "math" or not. I doubt bitcoin would have garnered the trust it has without a gazillion forensic trainspotters crawling all over its chain 24 hours a day). Dash's mixing therefore works for high fungility whether a particular user uses it or not because they benefit from all the mixing of coins upstream of their addresses. The delistings if anything demonstrate that it's worked because the regulators are seeing Dash as "cash".....which is actually a design goal. What Dash got wrong was allowing the chain to give up half its supply for nothing, thereby torpedoing its value-storing capacity !Monero got it right and go 100% full privacy, the aim is privacy and doing 50-50 on the design will compromise the goal which is privacy. That's why monero is not trying to be bitcoin, it complements bitcoin. That's why dash got it wrong, first trying to be anonymous coin and now trying to be ethereum too just to keep the ball rolling. Actually dash is trying to be bitcoin in the first place, plagiarized bitcoin and coinjoin to market anonymity. Fungibility, privacy, anonymous...we mean the same thing, not everytime we say anonymous we have to say privacy and fungible too all the time. They all go together. [moderator's note: consecutive posts merged]
|
|
|
|
|
toknormal
Legendary

Activity: 3066
Merit: 1188
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 08:38:50 AM |
|
the aim is privacy...
If you're part of the cult that you appear to subscribe to. Then I suppose it is. But it's a cult. Not a monetary property  Ordinary cash, whether its gold, paper or whatever is not "private". The transacting platform can never be "private" because that requires it to be hidden. It's fungible. What you call "50-50" is actually a decoupling of 2 separate objective. One is to make the "cash" fungible and the other is to make the transacting platform (as distinct from the cash) transparent.
|
|
|
|
|
arielbit
Legendary

Activity: 3444
Merit: 1061
|
 |
January 03, 2021, 08:48:18 AM |
|
the aim is privacy...
If you're part of the cult that you appear to subscribe to. Then I suppose it is. But it's a cult. Not a monetary property  Ordinary cash, whether its gold, paper or whatever is not "private". The transacting platform can never be "private" because that requires it to be hidden. It's fungible. What you call "50-50" is actually a decoupling of 2 separate objective. One is to make the "cash" fungible and the other is to make the transacting platform (as distinct from the cash) transparent. The aim is to become better than cash...not as good as cash, that's innovation and moving forward..a true fungible, private, and anonymous transaction. Dash aims just as to be as good as cash..just like USDT and other stablecoins LOL
|
|
|
|
|
|