|
HeliKopterBen
|
 |
May 04, 2015, 10:19:11 PM |
|
Bitcoin, while its issuance is capped at 21M, the software can be duplicated thousands of times.
The ability to clone/fork the software is a feature, not a bug. Take the Euro for example, which is under a round of QE right now. Imagine if Euro savers could easily clone the entire Euro monetary system, take out the QE, and put the QE_less system into production to compete. Which fork would win? I imagine sound money would win. The only thing that cannot be duplicated is processing power. Processing power is in finite supply, so whichever fork garners the most processing power wins. The ability to clone the software keeps the system honest.
|
Counterfeit: made in imitation of something else with intent to deceive: merriam-webster
|
|
|
tabnloz
Legendary

Activity: 961
Merit: 1000
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 01:09:55 AM |
|
|
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 02:23:55 AM |
|
interesting logarithmic Monte Carlo simulation of tx confirmation delays related to progressive filling of current 1MB block size. bottom line is we need an increase in the block size otherwise confirmation delays will exponentially increase as the fill reaches the max. note in the conclusion who would benefit from NOT increasing the block size; "SC's". no wonder gmax and LukeJr are spamming Reddit in defiance of Gavin's proposal: http://hashingit.com/analysis/34-bitcoin-traffic-bulletin
|
|
|
|
|
sickpig
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1014
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 06:16:53 AM |
|
interesting logarithmic Monte Carlo simulation of tx confirmation delays related to progressive filling of current 1MB block size. bottom line is we need an increase in the block size otherwise confirmation delays will exponentially increase as the fill reaches the max. note in the conclusion who would benefit from NOT increasing the block size; "SC's". no wonder gmax and LukeJr are spamming Reddit in defiance of Gavin's proposal: http://hashingit.com/analysis/34-bitcoin-traffic-bulletin Nice graph! Thanks for sharing. So with a 100% filled block you have a 0.1 probability of having your tx confirmed after 1000/sec. This is nasty. As I already said multiple times I'm a big supporter of Justus proposal to eliminate false block size scarcity and introducing economic incentive in the p2p nodes network. Nonetheless I think that a part of txs will occur out of bitcoin main chain, through payment hub, lightning network, you name it. In fact the very solution Justus proposed to implement a price discovery mechanism in Bitcoin p2p network is based on micropayment channels.
|
Bitcoin is a participatory system which ought to respect the right of self determinism of all of its users - Gregory Maxwell.
|
|
|
solex
Legendary

Activity: 1078
Merit: 1007
100 satoshis -> ISO code
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 06:41:34 AM |
|
no wonder gmax and LukeJr are spamming Reddit in defiance of Gavin's proposal:
I just scanned their recent reddit posts about the proposal and to be fair their position leans more to "open mind but cautious" than "outright rejection". This is good as obviously they contribute a lot to core dev, and hopefully that will continue. Luke mentions increasing the block size in an emergency: Those are all scalability issues that will not be fixed by making the blocks larger. We should fix them, not put them off. Maybe we can increase the max block size just in case of emergency, but we most definitely should not increase the actual block sizes simply to ignore real problems.
http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/34uu02/why_increasing_the_max_block_size_is_urgent_gavin/cqye7m6Well, frankly, passing the point of average blocks being 40% full, where confirmation times start to decay exponentially (as per the hashingit graph) is an emergency, something rightly addressed now because everyone who runs a full node needs to upgrade.
|
|
|
|
|
lunarboy
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 07:03:16 AM |
|
no wonder gmax and LukeJr are spamming Reddit in defiance of Gavin's proposal:
I just scanned their recent reddit posts about the proposal and to be fair their position leans more to "open mind but cautious" than "outright rejection". This is good as obviously they contribute a lot to core dev, and hopefully that will continue. Luke mentions increasing the block size in an emergency: Those are all scalability issues that will not be fixed by making the blocks larger. We should fix them, not put them off. Maybe we can increase the max block size just in case of emergency, but we most definitely should not increase the actual block sizes simply to ignore real problems.
http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/34uu02/why_increasing_the_max_block_size_is_urgent_gavin/cqye7m6Well, frankly, passing the point of average blocks being 40% full, where confirmation times start to decay exponentially (as per the hashingit graph) is an emergency, something rightly addressed now because everyone who runs a full node needs to upgrade. Actually Nullc / Gmax is positive about an increased blocksize WRT sidechains see here: Are 20mb blocks good or bad for Sidechains? https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/34riua/hard_fork_allow_20mb_blocks_after_1_march_2016/cqxhs1o
|
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 10:26:30 AM |
|
Don't forget to vote the poll.
|
|
|
|
|
NewLiberty
Legendary

Activity: 1204
Merit: 1002
Gresham's Lawyer
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 12:02:15 PM |
|
interesting logarithmic Monte Carlo simulation of tx confirmation delays related to progressive filling of current 1MB block size. bottom line is we need an increase in the block size otherwise confirmation delays will exponentially increase as the fill reaches the max. note in the conclusion who would benefit from NOT increasing the block size; "SC's". no wonder gmax and LukeJr are spamming Reddit in defiance of Gavin's proposal: http://hashingit.com/analysis/34-bitcoin-traffic-bulletin Nice graph! Thanks for sharing. So with a 100% filled block you have a 0.1 probability of having your tx confirmed after 1000/sec. This is nasty. As I already said multiple times I'm a big supporter of Justus proposal to eliminate false block size scarcity and introducing economic incentive in the p2p nodes network. Nonetheless I think that a part of txs will occur out of bitcoin main chain, through payment hub, lightning network, you name it. In fact the very solution Justus proposed to implement a price discovery mechanism in Bitcoin p2p network is based on micropayment channels. Justus laid out a structure. There are a great number of missing pieces between what exists today in the consensus code and that structure. There are also undefined and missing elements in the ecosystem. I like the structure too, but we aren't anywhere close to it yet and it won't be soon. The current proposal is Gavin's most reasonable one yet. He dropped the assumptions about the future, took out most of the guesswork, and is implementing the method satoshi offered when the antispam 1mb limit was created in 0.3 or so. More would be great, and future proof would be even better, no limit best.... but... remember, we are still in beta. The pieces to do any of that are not written, tested, integrated, accepted and secured. Bitcoin is still a baby. So as eager as we all are to get there, we will get there by baby steps or end up not getting at all. There are a great many looking for us to fail (check the short interest lately?) we help that failure by over-extending what can be done. 20mb gives us some room to build more of the missing pieces. Its enough for now.
|
|
|
|
sickpig
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1014
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 03:11:58 PM |
|
Justus laid out a structure. There are a great number of missing pieces between what exists today in the consensus code and that structure. There are also undefined and missing elements in the ecosystem. I like the structure too, but we aren't anywhere close to it yet and it won't be soon.
The current proposal is Gavin's most reasonable one yet. He dropped the assumptions about the future, took out most of the guesswork, and is implementing the method satoshi offered when the antispam 1mb limit was created in 0.3 or so.
More would be great, and future proof would be even better, no limit best.... but... remember, we are still in beta. The pieces to do any of that are not written, tested, integrated, accepted and secured.
Bitcoin is still a baby. So as eager as we all are to get there, we will get there by baby steps or end up not getting at all. There are a great many looking for us to fail (check the short interest lately?) we help that failure by over-extending what can be done.
20mb gives us some room to build more of the missing pieces. Its enough for now.
I can't have said it better, really. I'm aware that bitcoin development is quite peculiar and there's little to no margin for errors. And this is the reason why I think it's important to start spreading Justus's idea in advance, because as you rightly said we need a lot of time to get there. So the sooner we start the better. That said I wonder what are the link you see between the price discovering mechanism sketched by Justus and the Bitcoin consensus code? I see them as quite unrelated pieces of the system, but maybe I am missing something obvious.
|
Bitcoin is a participatory system which ought to respect the right of self determinism of all of its users - Gregory Maxwell.
|
|
|
justusranvier
Legendary

Activity: 1400
Merit: 1069
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 03:53:23 PM |
|
Justus laid out a structure. There are a great number of missing pieces between what exists today in the consensus code and that structure. There are also undefined and missing elements in the ecosystem. I like the structure too, but we aren't anywhere close to it yet and it won't be soon.
The current proposal is Gavin's most reasonable one yet. He dropped the assumptions about the future, took out most of the guesswork, and is implementing the method satoshi offered when the antispam 1mb limit was created in 0.3 or so.
More would be great, and future proof would be even better, no limit best.... but... remember, we are still in beta. The pieces to do any of that are not written, tested, integrated, accepted and secured.
Bitcoin is still a baby. So as eager as we all are to get there, we will get there by baby steps or end up not getting at all. There are a great many looking for us to fail (check the short interest lately?) we help that failure by over-extending what can be done.
20mb gives us some room to build more of the missing pieces. Its enough for now.
I can't have said it better, really. I'm aware that bitcoin development is quite peculiar and there's little to no margin for errors. And this is the reason why I think it's important to start spreading Justus's idea in advance, because as you rightly said we need a lot of time to get there. So the sooner we start the better. That said I wonder what are the link you see between the price discovering mechanism sketched by Justus and the Bitcoin consensus code? I see them as quite unrelated pieces of the system, but maybe I am missing something obvious. I'll devote more time to explaining how the price discovery mechanism could be rolled out as an incremental upgrade after I finish with this: https://github.com/justusranvier/wallet-ratings/tree/2015-1/2015-1
|
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 05:12:35 PM |
|
weaker, weaker, and weaker: 
|
|
|
|
|
thezerg
Legendary

Activity: 1246
Merit: 1018
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 07:48:29 PM |
|
I'm for Gavin's 20MB increase. But if I was doing it, I'd propose actually building a real supply/demand curve so economic analysis actually works. The reason it doesn't work today is because additional demand (price) cannot ever create new supply (space in the block).
So I'd do it by allowing txn fee paying blocks to be located beyond the limit (its now a "soft" limit). In other words, if your txn pays 0uBTC fee it can be located in the block at 0-20MB, if 1uBtc located at 0-21MB, if 2uBTC located at 0-22MB, 3uBTC located at 0-23MB, etc (or some other pricing curve). So supply (space in a block) can actually increase as demand increases.
You might be able to look at historical block size vs price information to actually price this... it does not need to be perfect since an error will just move the graph a bit. The biggest concern would be if exponential BTC price increases (vs fiat) makes the minimum fee way too high. In that case, we are no worse than today's proposal.
|
|
|
|
|
Zangelbert Bingledack
Legendary

Activity: 1036
Merit: 1000
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 07:52:18 PM |
|
I don't think we need the same security model for buying loaves of bread that we use for buying homes,. Of course you do, once you understand what the security problem is. The entire job of the Bitcoin network is to make sure that the number of currency units is exactly correct at all times. There's probably a hundred million loaves of bread sold every day, which represents a hundred million opportunities to improperly expand the currency supply. I don't know if there's much hope of avoiding every possible improper expansion. I'm undecided on whether it really matters to have everything be on blockchain (or otherwise completely un-finagle-able like through OT).
|
|
|
|
|
Zangelbert Bingledack
Legendary

Activity: 1036
Merit: 1000
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 08:03:13 PM |
|
I'm for Gavin's 20MB increase. But if I was doing it, I'd propose actually building a real supply/demand curve so economic analysis actually works. The reason it doesn't work today is because additional demand (price) cannot ever create new supply (space in the block).
So I'd do it by allowing txn fee paying blocks to be located beyond the limit (its now a "soft" limit). In other words, if your txn pays 0uBTC fee it can be located in the block at 0-20MB, if 1uBtc located at 0-21MB, if 2uBTC located at 0-22MB, 3uBTC located at 0-23MB, etc (or some other pricing curve). So supply (space in a block) can actually increase as demand increases.
You might be able to look at historical block size vs price information to actually price this... it does not need to be perfect since an error will just move the graph a bit. The biggest concern would be if exponential BTC price increases (vs fiat) makes the minimum fee way too high. In that case, we are no worse than today's proposal. I assume a fee market will be ready by then, or by whenever block scarcity becomes an issue.
|
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 08:08:23 PM |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Zangelbert Bingledack
Legendary

Activity: 1036
Merit: 1000
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 08:11:32 PM |
|
Blocksize debate blowing up all over /r/Bitcoin right now, though it's mostly pro-increase.
|
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 08:48:32 PM |
|
Blocksize debate blowing up all over /r/Bitcoin right now, though it's mostly pro-increase. what strikes me most about /nullc and LukeJr objections are that they revolve around incorrect perceptions of what the Bitcoin market looks like today. for instance, /nullc believes that mining is centralizing. i don't; look at the pie charts from mempool:  the distribution of miners has improved (decentralized) markedly since the ghash event. i've regularly documented that improvement over the years and believe we may have in fact witnessed the very last time any pool gets anywhere near 50%. i've argued using game theory and it appears to have been prescient. also, he believes that the decrease in full nodes "creates huge systemic risk and undermines Bitcoin's value proposition". give me a break; the decrease in nodes yes might be due partly to node dropout but i think it is mainly due to the proliferation of SPV clients. furthermore, i was initially a part of the Bitnodes Incentive Program and was one of it's first payment recipients, however, due to the fact they require re-registration every month, i've dropped out. it's too much of a hassle and involves relatively complex code to re-register while the payout is trivial. but i still run my nodes and as i've said before, i'm actually looking forward to learning how to prune so i can run a dozen more nodes or so. and what does he mean by this? "This is especially concerning as we've seen the deployment of full nodes fade out and even large commercial operations become dependant on third party hosted node services." what's he talking about and where's the evidence? and then he points to Kaminsky as some kind of prophet?: "it should be noted that this outcome was already predicted years ago (e.g. by Dan Kaminsky's comments that I was writing about above), but we've still slid into it." what sticks in my mind is the lost bet btwn Garzik and Kaminsky when DK predicted Bitcoin's underlying Proof-of-Work hash function (Sha-2) would be replaced within 12 months: https://storify.com/socrates1024/bitcoin-pow-bet-10btc-jgarzik-vs-dakami-may-2014. There haven't been any more famous tech experts who have been more wrong about Bitcoin. even DK admits it now. and then he points to Todd and MPOE as worthy colleagues against increased block sizes: "Rather, the only push you see against larger blocks come from strong advocates of personal autonomy and decenteralization, like Peter Todd; or the MPOE crowd". aligning one's self with these 2 is even more dangerous than Kaminsky. he's always been almost bearish on Bitcoin; for years. he's always said mining is centralizing despite the facts. he's been a fan of Ripple in the past here: https://en.bitcoin.it/w/index.php?title=Scalability&action=historysubmit&diff=14273&oldid=14112you'll notice in the link below he admits to going back and deleting his posts of support for Ripple in the past. who does that? own up to it, don't try to cover it up. here's all his concerns highlighted in gory detail  : https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/34uu02/why_increasing_the_max_block_size_is_urgent_gavin/cqycy4h
|
|
|
|
|
rocks
Legendary

Activity: 1153
Merit: 1000
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 09:36:15 PM |
|
I'm for Gavin's 20MB increase. But if I was doing it, I'd propose actually building a real supply/demand curve so economic analysis actually works. The reason it doesn't work today is because additional demand (price) cannot ever create new supply (space in the block).
So I'd do it by allowing txn fee paying blocks to be located beyond the limit (its now a "soft" limit). In other words, if your txn pays 0uBTC fee it can be located in the block at 0-20MB, if 1uBtc located at 0-21MB, if 2uBTC located at 0-22MB, 3uBTC located at 0-23MB, etc (or some other pricing curve). So supply (space in a block) can actually increase as demand increases.
You might be able to look at historical block size vs price information to actually price this... it does not need to be perfect since an error will just move the graph a bit. The biggest concern would be if exponential BTC price increases (vs fiat) makes the minimum fee way too high. In that case, we are no worse than today's proposal.
I like this proposal a lot. High-priority non-fee transactions that consume older coins are suppose to be just that, free and gain priority access to a block. Today's situation is even if your transaction has enough priority to qualify for free processing, they often take hours to confirm since most minors do not pick high priority transactions without a fee. This completely defeats the purpose of having the priority system at all. Reserving a front space in each block for high-priority non-fee transactions does two things: 1) It would ensure that high-priority transactions are processed in a timely fashion 2) It would encourage more competition from low-priority transactions and possibly increase the fees they need to offer to be processed quickly This would shift transaction fees more towards for profit services that are built on top of bitcoin and away from individual wallet users. I would consider this to be a good thing. Anyone on this thread have contact with any of the core developers? Have they considered it? If not how could zerg propose it (provide people here also think it makes sense...)
|
|
|
|
|
Adrian-x
Legendary

Activity: 1372
Merit: 1000
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 09:39:35 PM Last edit: May 05, 2015, 10:18:32 PM by Adrian-x |
|
You've repeatedly made this accusation regarding me specifically- LOL, bribing up that history is his response to this comment, for pointing out sidechains stand to benefit from a small transaction size. I was not picking on him or even challenging his position merely pointing out why there was a debate at all. I originally stopped reading after the word specifically. but if it's any consolation ripple has always been a centralized system, and I have taken a lot of flack for pointing out that's its Achilles' heel and not supporting it, why not take some heat on the other side for not recognizing that fact at the start. I think nullc relates to sidechains on a very personal level and is feeling very threatened at the moment, my comment was an observation not an accusation for the record.
|
Thank me in Bits 12MwnzxtprG2mHm3rKdgi7NmJKCypsMMQw
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
May 05, 2015, 09:47:21 PM |
|
You've repeatedly made this accusation regarding me specifically- LOL, that is his response to this comment, for pointing out sidechains stand to benefit from a small transaction size. I think nullc feels very defensive at the moment, I was not picking on him or even challenging his position merely pointing out why there was a debate at all. ppl get defensive when they know there's some truth to the allegation. in fact, they start seeing things that aren't there, like in your comment. problem is, though, Blockstream for profit does indeed represent a conflict of interest to expanding tx throughput on the MC. it's clear they stand to profit the more this tx volume gets pushed off to SC's. plus, given all his Bitcoin skepticism and behavior over the years, it all fits.
|
|
|
|
|
|