Zangelbert Bingledack
Legendary

Activity: 1036
Merit: 1000
|
 |
May 02, 2015, 04:04:23 PM |
|
Good post, but the crypto sector (unlike intrinsically monopolistic government) is not zero sum. Canonical Bitcoin doesn't need to be devalued and abolished in order for innovation to occur. Supplementation by forks/altcoins is already well underway, and those processes are functionally (albeit externally) a deviation from Satoshi's magic numbers.
Also, the "Universal Ledger of Civilization" paradigm is flawed by its pretentious Tower of Babel/Third Temple hubris. With rare exception, the phrase 'natural monopoly' is an oxymoron (given time and free market competition/substitution).
There is no problem with alt-protocols. The problem with altcoins is that they are not just alt-protocols, but also alt-ledgers. That's a no-no from the market's perspective. To make an alt-protocol, you fork Bitcoin as it stands, not fork it and start all over with a new ledger. As for Tower of Babel hubris, you'd need to show specifically how a market-chosen standard has any of the ill effects of a monopoly on power. That sounds like arguing that gold is a monopoly so we need silver and platinum as well or something bad will happen. As a backup in case gold becomes counterfeitable, sure, that makes sense, but anything beyond that seems pointless (excepting some niche uses, which may be your point).
|
|
|
|
|
iCEBREAKER
Legendary

Activity: 2156
Merit: 1073
Crypto is the separation of Power and State.
|
 |
May 02, 2015, 04:22:02 PM |
|
There is no problem with alt-protocols. The problem with altcoins is that they are not just alt-protocols, but also alt-ledgers. That's a no-no from the market's perspective. To make an alt-protocol, you fork Bitcoin as it stands, not fork it and start all over with a new ledger. As for Tower of Babel hubris, you'd need to show specifically how a market-chosen standard has any of the ill effects of a monopoly on power. That sounds like arguing that gold is a monopoly so we need silver and platinum as well or something bad will happen. Airdrops patterned on current BTC distribution have been tried, and have been soundly rejected by the market. GavinCoin is still highly controversial vaporware with a rough road ahead of it. New ledgers are valuable for their hot swappable backup utility and as platforms for innovation. The gold standard is inferior to a bimetallic one including silver; that's why the Founding Fathers you quoted in their supreme wisdom choose to specify both as legal tender: The United States Constitution declares, in Article I, Section 10, "No State shall... make any Thing but gold and silver Coin a Tender in Payment of Debts" Your mention of novel, exotic platinum is a straw man, but yes, copper/nickle/zinc are important as 2nd tier monetary metals. They also kill/deactivate pathogens via the oligodynamic effect, just not as effectively as silver. Hence the phrase 'health is wealth.'
|
██████████ ██████████████████ ██████████████████████ ██████████████████████████ ████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████ ████████████████████████████████ ████████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████████ ████████████████████████████████ ██████████████ ██████████████ ████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████ ██████████████████████ ██████████████████ ██████████ Monero
|
| "The difference between bad and well-developed digital cash will determine whether we have a dictatorship or a real democracy." David Chaum 1996 "Fungibility provides privacy as a side effect." Adam Back 2014
|
| | |
|
|
|
sickpig
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1014
|
 |
May 02, 2015, 05:28:32 PM |
|
|
Bitcoin is a participatory system which ought to respect the right of self determinism of all of its users - Gregory Maxwell.
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
May 02, 2015, 06:30:07 PM |
|
Ultimately, I think Justus will be right: no block size limit. The whole above discussion regarding UTXO commitments should convince any skeptics against the future need for outsized storage space. That is a big relief. As far as bandwidth, if the TX throughput grows to a size that pushes the limits, that will be a great problem to have. I'm sure the network and technological improvements will quickly respond to that demand. Furthermore, we NEED that type of TX volume to support the miners and to further hash rate growth. The profit incentive does need to be there.
|
|
|
|
|
Zangelbert Bingledack
Legendary

Activity: 1036
Merit: 1000
|
 |
May 02, 2015, 07:11:39 PM |
|
Airdrops patterned on current BTC distribution have been tried, and have been soundly rejected by the market. I'm not aware of any major altcoin (of those deemed useful/promising even by some bitcoiners) that has tried bootstrapping off Bitcoin's ledger. I hear Stellar did a partial, but I wouldn't consider that major since its market cap is grossly inflated. It will have to be tried on a popular altcoin and executed effectively, which by the way is not a trivial problem, before we can know what the market will think of it. As for gold and silver, sure it's in the Constitution, but why? Presumably because of limitations in sizing, like you don't want to use teensy gold dots to pay for a loaf of bread, and you don't want to lug around a kilo of silver to pay for a business suit. It's a hard trade-off: gold was too valuable for small transactions, while silver was too heavy for large transactions. Similarly, in Bitcoin there will only be a persistent fork if there is a hard trade-off that must be made. For example in the blocksize limits. Whether or not this requires a protocol fork, it doesn't require starting a bran new ledger. At the time of the fork, every BTC holder will have their coins in both ledgers. They can sell one for the other if they way to take sides, but they can simply sit tight and have the value of their money fully retained whichever fork wins, or however their market shares split.
|
|
|
|
|
Jungian
Legendary

Activity: 930
Merit: 1010
|
 |
May 02, 2015, 10:27:17 PM |
|
Airdrops patterned on current BTC distribution have been tried, and have been soundly rejected by the market. I'm not aware of any major altcoin (of those deemed useful/promising even by some bitcoiners) that has tried bootstrapping off Bitcoin's ledger. I hear Stellar did a partial, but I wouldn't consider that major since its market cap is grossly inflated. It will have to be tried on a popular altcoin and executed effectively, which by the way is not a trivial problem, before we can know what the market will think of it. As for gold and silver, sure it's in the Constitution, but why? Presumably because of limitations in sizing, like you don't want to use teensy gold dots to pay for a loaf of bread, and you don't want to lug around a kilo of silver to pay for a business suit. It's a hard trade-off: gold was too valuable for small transactions, while silver was too heavy for large transactions. Similarly, in Bitcoin there will only be a persistent fork if there is a hard trade-off that must be made. For example in the blocksize limits. Whether or not this requires a protocol fork, it doesn't require starting a bran new ledger. At the time of the fork, every BTC holder will have their coins in both ledgers. They can sell one for the other if they way to take sides, but they can simply sit tight and have the value of their money fully retained whichever fork wins, or however their market shares split. Clams bootstrapped using BTC, LTC and DOGE I think.
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
May 02, 2015, 11:39:06 PM |
|
|
|
|
|
|
shmadz
Legendary

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1000
@theshmadz
|
 |
May 02, 2015, 11:50:49 PM |
|
Ultimately, I think Justus will be right: no block size limit. The whole above discussion regarding UTXO commitments should convince any skeptics against the future need for outsized storage space. That is a big relief. As far as bandwidth, if the TX throughput grows to a size that pushes the limits, that will be a great problem to have. I'm sure the network and technological improvements will quickly respond to that demand. Furthermore, we NEED that type of TX volume to support the miners and to further hash rate growth. The profit incentive does need to be there. As long as the price continues to increase ten fold every other year , then the block reward will be sufficient for at least the immediate future (next 5-10 years) Long term, I think justus' proposed payment structure, or something like it, will be necessary for miners and full nodes to continue to be viable. Might as well give it a try now while the network is *only* worth a few billion... (if this is gonna fail, sooner is better than later)
|
"You have no moral right to rule us, nor do you possess any methods of enforcement that we have reason to fear." - John Perry Barlow, 1996
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
May 03, 2015, 06:01:57 AM |
|
Grinding higher
|
|
|
|
|
solex
Legendary

Activity: 1078
Merit: 1007
100 satoshis -> ISO code
|
 |
May 03, 2015, 06:13:24 AM |
|
Ultimately, I think Justus will be right: no block size limit. The whole above discussion regarding UTXO commitments should convince any skeptics against the future need for outsized storage space. That is a big relief. As far as bandwidth, if the TX throughput grows to a size that pushes the limits, that will be a great problem to have. I'm sure the network and technological improvements will quickly respond to that demand. Furthermore, we NEED that type of TX volume to support the miners and to further hash rate growth. The profit incentive does need to be there. As long as the price continues to increase ten fold every other year , then the block reward will be sufficient for at least the immediate future (next 5-10 years) Long term, I think justus' proposed payment structure, or something like it, will be necessary for miners and full nodes to continue to be viable. Might as well give it a try now while the network is *only* worth a few billion... (if this is gonna fail, sooner is better than later) Agreed. And perhaps JR's node services payment structure could be progressed via a Lighthouse funding process. It might get traction if it was divided into broad phases, such as: detailed technical specification, alpha/test version, beta/production-ready version The last of which would eventually need integrating with Bitcoin Core.
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
May 03, 2015, 08:13:28 AM |
|
Rally rally
|
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
May 03, 2015, 08:42:49 AM |
|
Oh it feels so good... moar, mosr!
|
|
|
|
|
BlindMayorBitcorn
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1116
|
 |
May 03, 2015, 08:45:21 AM |
|
Oh it feels so good... moar, mosr!
Don't freak your calm, bro. We've only just now stopped collapsing. 
|
Forgive my petulance and oft-times, I fear, ill-founded criticisms, and forgive me that I have, by this time, made your eyes and head ache with my long letter. But I cannot forgo hastily the pleasure and pride of thus conversing with you.
|
|
|
|
zanzibar
|
 |
May 03, 2015, 09:23:35 AM |
|
Really doesn't matter the price, BTC cannot be stopped at this point.
|
|
|
|
|
|
fox19891989
|
 |
May 03, 2015, 09:48:22 AM |
|
Bitcoin doesn't care about our human concepts of possession and ownership and control. Bitcoin is a self-contained system of rules. Those rules say that we have a blockchain containing a list of precise, cryptographic conditions which are necessary and sufficient to transform the blockchain in particular ways. If we want Bitcoin to behave in in a manner that matches our preconceived notions of property and ownership, the onus is on us to use Bitcoin's rules in a way that achieves what we want. Bitcoin is in no way limited to only behaving in ways that match our expectations. Bitcoin can do anything which is allowed by its rules, including operations that have no equivalent in our existing property and ownership paradigms. Gold collapsing. Bitcoin DOWN, too. 
|
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
May 03, 2015, 11:20:07 AM |
|
Airdrops patterned on current BTC distribution have been tried, and have been soundly rejected by the market. I'm not aware of any major altcoin (of those deemed useful/promising even by some bitcoiners) that has tried bootstrapping off Bitcoin's ledger. I hear Stellar did a partial, but I wouldn't consider that major since its market cap is grossly inflated. It will have to be tried on a popular altcoin and executed effectively, which by the way is not a trivial problem, before we can know what the market will think of it. As for gold and silver, sure it's in the Constitution, but why? Presumably because of limitations in sizing, like you don't want to use teensy gold dots to pay for a loaf of bread, and you don't want to lug around a kilo of silver to pay for a business suit. It's a hard trade-off: gold was too valuable for small transactions, while silver was too heavy for large transactions. Similarly, in Bitcoin there will only be a persistent fork if there is a hard trade-off that must be made. For example in the blocksize limits. Whether or not this requires a protocol fork, it doesn't require starting a bran new ledger. At the time of the fork, every BTC holder will have their coins in both ledgers. They can sell one for the other if they way to take sides, but they can simply sit tight and have the value of their money fully retained whichever fork wins, or however their market shares split. Clams bootstrapped using BTC, LTC and DOGE I think. No it didn't. They paid an equal amount per-output not based on output value which has some "interesting" properties. In any case it wasn't a spin off.
|
|
|
|
|
Zangelbert Bingledack
Legendary

Activity: 1036
Merit: 1000
|
 |
May 03, 2015, 12:26:29 PM Last edit: May 03, 2015, 12:41:11 PM by Zangelbert Bingledack |
|
Justus's seminal work on incentivizing full nodes will take some time to be assimilated into the mainstream of the community, but I think it will have to be. Either through some high-powered explanatory tool or by the market forcing it on everyone when rubber meets road, which will be unsettling for many. Speaking of high-powered explanatory tools, it would be great if there were a sort of "hard money wiki/FAQ," for lack of a better term, that explains the economic points often raised in this thread for a general (Bitcoin-conversant) audience. Not just why Bitcoin is replacing gold, though that's a core part of it, but all the points about incentives and economics that are are typically misunderstood in the wider community. Things like Money as Memory, the role of investors ("who controls Bitcoin?"), why Bitcoin is more valuable as a store of value than as a digital currency, how and why to introduce market economics to fee payment, node incentivization, etc. etc. Instead of a traditional wiki format, I'm a big fan of prezi.com's platform for visual explanations. In that format it could serve as a visual background for hundreds of easy-to-produce videos where someone is simply explaining a bite-sized point while using one small aspect of the larger Prezi wiki, effectively narrating it. Without such a visual communication medium and readily-producible videos, I think the explanatory load to actually educate the larger community about economics and such is just too much. The Nakamoto Institute is doing pretty well, but relying solely on essays is too slow in Bitcoin time for the permeation of understanding that it would be ideal to have.
|
|
|
|
|
sickpig
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1014
|
 |
May 03, 2015, 05:39:27 PM |
|
Justus's seminal work on incentivizing full nodes will take some time to be assimilated into the mainstream of the community, but I think it will have to be. Either through some high-powered explanatory tool or by the market forcing it on everyone when rubber meets road, which will be unsettling for many. Speaking of high-powered explanatory tools, it would be great if there were a sort of "hard money wiki/FAQ," for lack of a better term, that explains the economic points often raised in this thread for a general (Bitcoin-conversant) audience. Not just why Bitcoin is replacing gold, though that's a core part of it, but all the points about incentives and economics that are are typically misunderstood in the wider community. Things like Money as Memory, the role of investors ("who controls Bitcoin?"), why Bitcoin is more valuable as a store of value than as a digital currency, how and why to introduce market economics to fee payment, node incentivization, etc. etc. Instead of a traditional wiki format, I'm a big fan of prezi.com's platform for visual explanations. In that format it could serve as a visual background for hundreds of easy-to-produce videos where someone is simply explaining a bite-sized point while using one small aspect of the larger Prezi wiki, effectively narrating it. I don't even know if core the developers and other "inner" influential community members have the right level of awareness, I've even asked Justus if he had the chance to talk with some of the aforementioned people about is proposal, this is Justus' answer: Secondly, as of your knowledge, are the core devs aware of this issue? Do they agree with the given definition of the problem? And more to the point, is there a plan to develop something along the line of your proposed solution? To the best of my knowledge, they are aware of it. None of them have commented, however. I don't know of any immediate, specific plans to implement this. Without such a visual communication medium and readily-producible videos, I think the explanatory load to actually educate the larger community about economics and such is just too much. The Nakamoto Institute is doing pretty well, but relying solely on essays is too slow in Bitcoin time for the permeation of understanding that it would be ideal to have.
I agree we need to accelerate the assimilation and the understanding of those concepts at least among those people that can influence bitcoin development trajectory.
|
Bitcoin is a participatory system which ought to respect the right of self determinism of all of its users - Gregory Maxwell.
|
|
|
sickpig
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1014
|
 |
May 03, 2015, 05:46:02 PM |
|
Speaking about recent Justus' activity I forgot to mention "Reusable payment codes": https://github.com/justusranvier/rfc/blob/payment_code/bips/bip-pc01.mediawikiThis link contains an RFC for a new type of Bitcoin address called a "payment code"
Payment codes are SPV-friendly alternatives to DarkWallet-style stealth addresses which provide useful features such as positively identifying senders to recipients and automatically providing for transaction refunds.
Payment codes can be publicly advertised and associated with a real-life identity without causing a loss of financial privacy.
Compared to stealth addresses, payment codes require less blockchain data storage.
Payment codes require 65 bytes of OP_RETURN data per sender-recipient pair, while stealth addresses require 40 bytes per transaction.
|
Bitcoin is a participatory system which ought to respect the right of self determinism of all of its users - Gregory Maxwell.
|
|
|
Zangelbert Bingledack
Legendary

Activity: 1036
Merit: 1000
|
 |
May 03, 2015, 06:33:28 PM |
|
I believe the core devs, at least from what I have seen, are not especially astute as far as the economics. They are a lot better than average, don't get me wrong, but not to the level I personally would be comfortable with. I suppose it falls on those who do understand to convey that understanding in debate.
Therefore I wouldn't expect them to take to Justus's proposal at first, as it's quite a big jump conceptually toward a free market approach, but on the other hand I think things become clearer when scarcity actually presents itself. It would be nice, of course, to have that level of clarity in place well before things reach a critical stage.
|
|
|
|
|
|