|
Cconvert2G36
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 12:05:50 AM |
|
A large miner only needs a hash of the transactions in order to mine remotely, so it could delegate the censorship of transactions to some other entity (e.g. IBLT), thus effectively censorship of transactions is under control of an entity that is aggregating hashrate (nodes).
You're describing a mining pool, and disparate miners connect via stratum to the pool, which administers the mining node. Nothing new here with larger maxblocksize. Whereas, a smaller independent miner that refuses to delegate and be permanently sited so that it can't be easily regulated by TPTB, will need to have enough ephemeral bandwidth to see every transaction across the P2P network. For example, I can still obtain an unregistered, wireless connection to the internet here in my location with a prepaid 3G USB dongle, but if I site any where but a few special locations then I will often see the bandwidth drop down to 28.8K baud.
I throw 'baud' in there to remind youngsters that maybe somebody in this world still uses an analog audible spectrum telephone (or HAM radio?) modem.
Small time miners solo mining via 3G dongle, 28.8k baud modems, and HAM radios? Are you serious? Are you describing your, as yet unreleased, superproject? You're not describing post 2011 Bitcoin. Hand waving about TPTB shutting down/censoring bitcoin on a global scale because of bigger blocks is hyperbolic.
|
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 01:12:48 AM |
|
A large miner only needs a hash of the transactions in order to mine remotely, so it could delegate the censorship of transactions to some other entity (e.g. IBLT), thus effectively censorship of transactions is under control of an entity that is aggregating hashrate (nodes).
You're describing a mining pool, and disparate miners connect via stratum to the pool, which administers the mining node. Nothing new here with larger maxblocksize. Nothing new by forcing more miners to pools with sufficient connectivity  Nothing new by enabling those with more connectivity to harness higher revenue per block and to block propagation (orphan rate) attacks on the less well connected nodes  Whereas, a smaller independent miner that refuses to delegate and be permanently sited so that it can't be easily regulated by TPTB, will need to have enough ephemeral bandwidth to see every transaction across the P2P network. For example, I can still obtain an unregistered, wireless connection to the internet here in my location with a prepaid 3G USB dongle, but if I site any where but a few special locations then I will often see the bandwidth drop down to 28.8K baud.
I throw 'baud' in there to remind youngsters that maybe somebody in this world still uses an analog audible spectrum telephone (or HAM radio?) modem.
Small time miners solo mining via 3G dongle, 28.8k baud modems, and HAM radios? Are you serious? Are you describing your, as yet unreleased, superproject? You're not describing post 2011 Bitcoin. Hand waving about TPTB shutting down/censoring bitcoin on a global scale because of bigger blocks is hyperbolic. Go ahead. I am quite happy if you centralize Bitcoin Core. PLEASE MAKE MY DAY (and fatten my wallet by a few $million at least).
|
|
|
|
shmadz
Legendary

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1000
@theshmadz
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 01:18:03 AM |
|
To any mining pool operators out there reading,
next year July your mining pool income will be cut in half by the block halving.
Are you doing ok cypher? You seem to be increasingly hyperbolic and desperate in your comments. This one in particular is exceedingly misleading and smells like a blatant attempt to use unfounded fear, uncertainty, and doubt to make your case and influence others. You do of course realize that if the price were to rise to 500 by next July their income will remain precisely the same as it is today? Luckily, I'm sure the miners understand the economics of mining well enough that they will not be taking your misguided advice. And if it doesn't rise, what's your long term plan for miners to supplement the lost block reward income? If the price does not rise, there's no extra security needed to protect the system... Why pay more to defend a system that's not increasing in value? We see this market force in action right now as the low prices have caused the global hash rate to stagnate. My long term plan is that users will be willing to pay increasing fees due to scarcity of embedding information in the most secure ledger on the planet. When you propose changes to a system that may have an effect on the security profile of such a system, you should expect serious opposition.
|
"You have no moral right to rule us, nor do you possess any methods of enforcement that we have reason to fear." - John Perry Barlow, 1996
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 01:19:53 AM |
|
ooh, looky here, Dow futures: 
|
|
|
|
|
shmadz
Legendary

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1000
@theshmadz
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 01:20:28 AM |
|
Although I'm opposed to the current proposals for block size increase, I'm not opposed to the idea entirely, and I'm optimistic that a compromise can be reached. Supply is halving every 4 years. And I think that doubling block size every 4 years is enough to compensate.
Thanks Odalv, this is perhaps the simplest and most reasonable proposal I've heard on the subject, though I disagree with the following: And maybe it would be fine to double block size in the middle of halving period.
It may be only semantic, but I think the doubling of the block size should happen in tandem with the halving of the reward. It makes for a kind of trade off, trade half the disbursement awards for potentially double the transaction rewards. The important thing here is that the much slower rate of increase should keep the security profile of the network intact, and increasing to 2mb in 2016 and 4mb in 2020 etc. should enforce an acceptable level of scarcity while allowing the network to grow.
|
"You have no moral right to rule us, nor do you possess any methods of enforcement that we have reason to fear." - John Perry Barlow, 1996
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 01:21:23 AM |
|
above chart 1min. here's the daily Dow futures. note the breakdown. they were lying to you: 
|
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 01:23:52 AM |
|
To any mining pool operators out there reading,
next year July your mining pool income will be cut in half by the block halving.
Are you doing ok cypher? You seem to be increasingly hyperbolic and desperate in your comments. This one in particular is exceedingly misleading and smells like a blatant attempt to use unfounded fear, uncertainty, and doubt to make your case and influence others. You do of course realize that if the price were to rise to 500 by next July their income will remain precisely the same as it is today? Luckily, I'm sure the miners understand the economics of mining well enough that they will not be taking your misguided advice. And if it doesn't rise, what's your long term plan for miners to supplement the lost block reward income? If the price does not rise, there's no extra security needed to protect the system... Why pay more to defend a system that's not increasing in value? We see this market force in action right now as the low prices have caused the global hash rate to stagnate. My long term plan is that users will be willing to pay increasing fees due to scarcity of embedding information in the most secure ledger on the planet. When you propose changes to a system that may have an effect on the security profile of such a system, you should expect serious opposition. a goal of increasing fees is a worthy goal. but when you propose to maintain a 1MB choke that was always meant to be a DoS protection mechanism to be removed when Bitcoin is ready, then YOU should expect serious opposition.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Cconvert2G36
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 01:25:45 AM |
|
A large miner only needs a hash of the transactions in order to mine remotely, so it could delegate the censorship of transactions to some other entity (e.g. IBLT), thus effectively censorship of transactions is under control of an entity that is aggregating hashrate (nodes).
You're describing a mining pool, and disparate miners connect via stratum to the pool, which administers the mining node. Nothing new here with larger maxblocksize. Nothing new by forcing more miners to pools with sufficient connectivity  Nothing new by enabling those with more connectivity to harness higher revenue per block and to block propagation (orphan rate) attacks on the less well connected nodes  This already happened, several years ago in fact. Sorry to be the bearer of bad tidings. The former already happening substantially negates your second point. Additionally, we are talking about graduated increases here, not 1 to 256MB overnight.
|
|
|
|
|
shmadz
Legendary

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1000
@theshmadz
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 01:44:48 AM |
|
To any mining pool operators out there reading,
next year July your mining pool income will be cut in half by the block halving.
Are you doing ok cypher? You seem to be increasingly hyperbolic and desperate in your comments. This one in particular is exceedingly misleading and smells like a blatant attempt to use unfounded fear, uncertainty, and doubt to make your case and influence others. You do of course realize that if the price were to rise to 500 by next July their income will remain precisely the same as it is today? Luckily, I'm sure the miners understand the economics of mining well enough that they will not be taking your misguided advice. And if it doesn't rise, what's your long term plan for miners to supplement the lost block reward income? If the price does not rise, there's no extra security needed to protect the system... Why pay more to defend a system that's not increasing in value? We see this market force in action right now as the low prices have caused the global hash rate to stagnate. My long term plan is that users will be willing to pay increasing fees due to scarcity of embedding information in the most secure ledger on the planet. When you propose changes to a system that may have an effect on the security profile of such a system, you should expect serious opposition. a goal of increasing fees is a worthy goal. but when you propose to maintain a 1MB choke that was always meant to be a DoS protection mechanism to be removed when Bitcoin is ready, then YOU should expect serious opposition. Aha thank you. Now I understand the vehemence and panic that I sense from most of the people that are trying to push for bigger blocks. The problem here is that you cannot force me to accept your fork; you can't force me to accept your blocks; you can't force me to accept your unspent transactions. You. can't. force. me. You must convince me, but since you lack sufficient logical argument to convince, you resort to coercion, or as in your original post that ruffled my feathers , down right threats. As I posted earlier I am open to compromise or negotiation, and I think that eventually a rational solution will find consensus and bitcoin will move on. I just find the aggressive posturing and fear-mongering methods of many of the people pushing for bigger blocks to be tiresome, and frankly, childish.
|
"You have no moral right to rule us, nor do you possess any methods of enforcement that we have reason to fear." - John Perry Barlow, 1996
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 02:24:21 AM |
|
A large miner only needs a hash of the transactions in order to mine remotely, so it could delegate the censorship of transactions to some other entity (e.g. IBLT), thus effectively censorship of transactions is under control of an entity that is aggregating hashrate (nodes).
You're describing a mining pool, and disparate miners connect via stratum to the pool, which administers the mining node. Nothing new here with larger maxblocksize. Nothing new by forcing more miners to pools with sufficient connectivity  Nothing new by enabling those with more connectivity to harness higher revenue per block and to block propagation (orphan rate) attacks on the less well connected nodes  This already happened, several years ago in fact. Sorry to be the bearer of bad tidings. The former already happening substantially negates your second point. Additionally, we are talking about graduated increases here, not 1 to 256MB overnight. No it doesn't negate the second point unless you think winner-take-all (or at least greater centralization) of the pools is a desired next step. Also the former did not already happen for those with sufficient hashrate (or perhaps hardware NAV economics) such that mining on a pool has undesirable tradeoffs, such as paying fees (or perhaps anonymity timing correlation attacks on onion routing to the known termination node the pool). I don't claim to be omniscient on all the reasons why nodes don't all mine on pools. Also keep in mind P2Pool which has some of the economic benefits of a pool yet requires miners to have the bandwidth to handle the block size.
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 02:36:34 AM |
|
To any mining pool operators out there reading,
next year July your mining pool income will be cut in half by the block halving.
Are you doing ok cypher? You seem to be increasingly hyperbolic and desperate in your comments. This one in particular is exceedingly misleading and smells like a blatant attempt to use unfounded fear, uncertainty, and doubt to make your case and influence others. You do of course realize that if the price were to rise to 500 by next July their income will remain precisely the same as it is today? Luckily, I'm sure the miners understand the economics of mining well enough that they will not be taking your misguided advice. And if it doesn't rise, what's your long term plan for miners to supplement the lost block reward income? If the price does not rise, there's no extra security needed to protect the system... Why pay more to defend a system that's not increasing in value? We see this market force in action right now as the low prices have caused the global hash rate to stagnate. My long term plan is that users will be willing to pay increasing fees due to scarcity of embedding information in the most secure ledger on the planet. When you propose changes to a system that may have an effect on the security profile of such a system, you should expect serious opposition. a goal of increasing fees is a worthy goal. but when you propose to maintain a 1MB choke that was always meant to be a DoS protection mechanism to be removed when Bitcoin is ready, then YOU should expect serious opposition. Aha thank you. Now I understand the vehemence and panic that I sense from most of the people that are trying to push for bigger blocks. The problem here is that you cannot force me to accept your fork; you can't force me to accept your blocks; you can't force me to accept your unspent transactions. You. can't. force. me. You must convince me, but since you lack sufficient logical argument to convince, you resort to coercion, or as in your original post that ruffled my feathers , down right threats. As I posted earlier I am open to compromise or negotiation, and I think that eventually a rational solution will find consensus and bitcoin will move on. I just find the aggressive posturing and fear-mongering methods of many of the people pushing for bigger blocks to be tiresome, and frankly, childish. sorry you weren't able to discern that i merely parroted your very words back at you. so any "aggression" you attempt to smear me with, simply look back in the mirror.
|
|
|
|
|
thezerg
Legendary

Activity: 1246
Merit: 1018
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 02:40:53 AM |
|
Once upon a time when gold was used as currency, silver was also used because you couldn't reasonably mint coin small enough to pay for things like a meal (I heard that this is also why the "bar tab" was invented -- when even silver became too valuable).
With Bitcoin, it seems like 1 Satoshi is small enough to ensure that a "silver to bitcoin's gold" does not happen. However, I think that this is untrue; 1 Satoshi is analogous to 1 atom of gold. The actual minimum bitcoin transfer can be estimated by the point where is becomes inconvenient or expensive to make the transfer. This varies by the individual but I feel it would be a transaction fee of somewhere between 1 and 10 percent.
So the Satoshi is not the smallest effective Bitcoin unit. The smallest practical bitcoin unit is something between 10 and 100 times the transaction fee.
I think that the result of an unscaled bitcoin blockchain is that small-payment niche will open up, allowing a scalable altcoin blockchain to gain market share (lightning network, centralized solutions, and sidechains may block this niche, to an unknown extent -- but note they didn't for gold). This cryptocurrency will begin as the "silver to bitcoin's gold", and a clever implementation might ride Bitcoin's coat-tails to adoption. If Bitcoin becomes extremely successful this new cryptocurrency will overtake it in daily use just like silver overtook gold. But what advantages will Bitcoin have over this new currency? Gold's advantage was essentially its greater value to volume (and weight) ratio. But (as with any crypto-currency), you'll be able to carry and transact large quantities of this new cryptocurrency just as easily as small. So Bitcoin will have no advantage. The new cryptocurrency will ultimately dominate transactions and market cap.
What do you think about this reasoning?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Cconvert2G36
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 02:41:06 AM |
|
This already happened, several years ago in fact. Sorry to be the bearer of bad tidings.
The former already happening substantially negates your second point. Additionally, we are talking about graduated increases here, not 1 to 256MB overnight.
No it doesn't negate the second point unless you think winner-take-all (or at least greater centralization) of the pools is a desired next step. Also the former did not already happen for those with sufficient hashrate (or perhaps hardware NAV economics) such that mining on a pool has undesirable tradeoffs, such as paying fees (or perhaps anonymity timing correlation attacks on onion routing to the known termination node the pool). I don't claim to be omniscient on all the reasons why nodes don't all mine on pools. Also keep in mind P2Pool. You are mistaken if you think solo miners, large enough to reliably mine solo blocks, don't operate very well connected and outfitted nodes already. P2Pool may be another case because of its own architecture, but in reality it's not remotely large enough to justify outsized influence on protocol wide parameters. If miners felt that was wrong, they could work to give P2Pool more share in terms of global hashrate.
|
|
|
|
|
shmadz
Legendary

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1000
@theshmadz
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 02:57:11 AM Last edit: June 29, 2015, 03:07:38 AM by shmadz |
|
Once upon a time when gold was used as currency, silver was also used because you couldn't reasonably mint coin small enough to pay for things like a meal (I heard that this is also why the "bar tab" was invented -- when even silver became too valuable).
With Bitcoin, it seems like 1 Satoshi is small enough to ensure that a "silver to bitcoin's gold" does not happen. However, I think that this is untrue; 1 Satoshi is analogous to 1 atom of gold. The actual minimum bitcoin transfer can be estimated by the point where is becomes inconvenient or expensive to make the transfer. This varies by the individual but I feel it would be a transaction fee of somewhere between 1 and 10 percent.
So the Satoshi is not the smallest effective Bitcoin unit. The smallest practical bitcoin unit is something between 10 and 100 times the transaction fee.
I think that the result of an unscaled bitcoin blockchain is that small-payment niche will open up, allowing a scalable altcoin blockchain to gain market share (lightning network, centralized solutions, and sidechains may block this niche, to an unknown extent -- but note they didn't for gold). This cryptocurrency will begin as the "silver to bitcoin's gold", and a clever implementation might ride Bitcoin's coat-tails to adoption. If Bitcoin becomes extremely successful this new cryptocurrency will overtake it in daily use just like silver overtook gold. But what advantages will Bitcoin have over this new currency? Gold's advantage was essentially its greater value to volume (and weight) ratio. But (as with any crypto-currency), you'll be able to carry and transact large quantities of this new cryptocurrency just as easily as small. So Bitcoin will have no advantage. The new cryptocurrency will ultimately dominate transactions and market cap.
What do you think about this reasoning?
Very close, but no cigar. You miss the security gap. This is the real selling point for bitcoin. Silver and gold had very similar security profiles, with gold only being ever-so-slightly better (the value per weight). In crypto, each coin that has it's own chain has a distinctly different security profile. At this point, bitcoin is in the lead when it comes to security of the ledger. Unless this other coin offers better security, or at least very close to equal security, the scenario you theorize is not possible. It could happen, maybe, someday, but not currently possible.
|
"You have no moral right to rule us, nor do you possess any methods of enforcement that we have reason to fear." - John Perry Barlow, 1996
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 03:28:03 AM |
|
Once upon a time when gold was used as currency, silver was also used because you couldn't reasonably mint coin small enough to pay for things like a meal (I heard that this is also why the "bar tab" was invented -- when even silver became too valuable).
With Bitcoin, it seems like 1 Satoshi is small enough to ensure that a "silver to bitcoin's gold" does not happen. However, I think that this is untrue; 1 Satoshi is analogous to 1 atom of gold. The actual minimum bitcoin transfer can be estimated by the point where is becomes inconvenient or expensive to make the transfer. This varies by the individual but I feel it would be a transaction fee of somewhere between 1 and 10 percent.
So the Satoshi is not the smallest effective Bitcoin unit. The smallest practical bitcoin unit is something between 10 and 100 times the transaction fee.
I think that the result of an unscaled bitcoin blockchain is that small-payment niche will open up, allowing a scalable altcoin blockchain to gain market share (lightning network, centralized solutions, and sidechains may block this niche, to an unknown extent -- but note they didn't for gold). This cryptocurrency will begin as the "silver to bitcoin's gold", and a clever implementation might ride Bitcoin's coat-tails to adoption. If Bitcoin becomes extremely successful this new cryptocurrency will overtake it in daily use just like silver overtook gold. But what advantages will Bitcoin have over this new currency? Gold's advantage was essentially its greater value to volume (and weight) ratio. But (as with any crypto-currency), you'll be able to carry and transact large quantities of this new cryptocurrency just as easily as small. So Bitcoin will have no advantage. The new cryptocurrency will ultimately dominate transactions and market cap.
What do you think about this reasoning?
Very close, but no cigar. You miss the security gap. This is the real selling point for bitcoin. Silver and gold had very similar security profiles, with gold only being ever-so-slightly better (the value per weight). In crypto, each coin that has it's own chain has a distinctly different security profile. At this point, bitcoin is in the lead when it comes to security of the ledger. Unless this other coin offers better security, or at least very close to equal security, the scenario you theorize is not possible. It could happen, maybe, someday, but not currently possible. you may be the one missing something. what i think he was saying is that if Cripplecoin is allowed to remain in place even with the addition of SC's or LN, it won't be able to compete with a lighter nimble altcoin that has no such block limit. reason being, that some feel that SC's or LN, esp if Blockstream is allowed to continue it's financial confliction, will result in a centralized, settlement level, high tx value type unusable cryptocurrency only for institutions, geeks, and wealthy elite. that is, if it doesn't just outright die from small niche use. a truly scalable Bitcoin knock off w/o this confliction and centralization might be able to truly take off and fund the masses even at the level of microtx's. let's hope this isn't what has to happen.
|
|
|
|
|
thezerg
Legendary

Activity: 1246
Merit: 1018
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 03:52:36 AM Last edit: June 29, 2015, 12:00:29 PM by thezerg |
|
Once upon a time when gold was used as currency, silver was also used because you couldn't reasonably mint coin small enough to pay for things like a meal (I heard that this is also why the "bar tab" was invented -- when even silver became too valuable).
With Bitcoin, it seems like 1 Satoshi is small enough to ensure that a "silver to bitcoin's gold" does not happen. However, I think that this is untrue; 1 Satoshi is analogous to 1 atom of gold. The actual minimum bitcoin transfer can be estimated by the point where is becomes inconvenient or expensive to make the transfer. This varies by the individual but I feel it would be a transaction fee of somewhere between 1 and 10 percent.
So the Satoshi is not the smallest effective Bitcoin unit. The smallest practical bitcoin unit is something between 10 and 100 times the transaction fee.
I think that the result of an unscaled bitcoin blockchain is that small-payment niche will open up, allowing a scalable altcoin blockchain to gain market share (lightning network, centralized solutions, and sidechains may block this niche, to an unknown extent -- but note they didn't for gold). This cryptocurrency will begin as the "silver to bitcoin's gold", and a clever implementation might ride Bitcoin's coat-tails to adoption. If Bitcoin becomes extremely successful this new cryptocurrency will overtake it in daily use just like silver overtook gold. But what advantages will Bitcoin have over this new currency? Gold's advantage was essentially its greater value to volume (and weight) ratio. But (as with any crypto-currency), you'll be able to carry and transact large quantities of this new cryptocurrency just as easily as small. So Bitcoin will have no advantage. The new cryptocurrency will ultimately dominate transactions and market cap.
What do you think about this reasoning?
Very close, but no cigar. You miss the security gap. This is the real selling point for bitcoin. Silver and gold had very similar security profiles, with gold only being ever-so-slightly better (the value per weight). In crypto, each coin that has it's own chain has a distinctly different security profile. At this point, bitcoin is in the lead when it comes to security of the ledger. Unless this other coin offers better security, or at least very close to equal security, the scenario you theorize is not possible. It could happen, maybe, someday, but not currently possible. you may be the one missing something. what i think he was saying is that if Cripplecoin is allowed to remain in place even with the addition of SC's or LN, it won't be able to compete with a lighter nimble altcoin that has no such block limit. reason being, that some feel that SC's or LN, esp if Blockstream is allowed to continue it's financial confliction, will result in a centralized, settlement level, high tx value type unusable cryptocurrency only for institutions, geeks, and wealthy elite. that is, if it doesn't just outright die from small niche use. a truly scalable Bitcoin knock off w/o this confliction and centralization might be able to truly take off and fund the masses even at the level of microtx's. let's hope this isn't what has to happen. This is what gives me the fear: This coin provides an integrated BTC wallet on both PC and phone, simply by forking existing open source Bitcoin wallets and adding "new coin" code (so this is not much harder than creating standalone "new coin" wallets). The wallet allows you to make trustless anonymously exchanges between new coin and BTC. This is very easy to do technically: you add a special txn to the new coin which says "only valid if there is a Bitcoin TXN to this public address with N confirmations". Seller of new coin issues this its first, the Bitcoin seller issues its txn when it sees the new coin txn. If the Bitcoin seller's txn is not issued or confirmed, the new coin txn is invalidated (it remains on the new coin blockchain but becomes a no-op).
|
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 03:57:13 AM Last edit: June 29, 2015, 04:10:30 AM by TPTB_need_war |
|
This already happened, several years ago in fact. Sorry to be the bearer of bad tidings.
The former already happening substantially negates your second point. Additionally, we are talking about graduated increases here, not 1 to 256MB overnight.
No it doesn't negate the second point unless you think winner-take-all (or at least greater centralization) of the pools is a desired next step. Also the former did not already happen for those with sufficient hashrate (or perhaps hardware NAV economics) such that mining on a pool has undesirable tradeoffs, such as paying fees (or perhaps anonymity timing correlation attacks on onion routing to the known termination node the pool). I don't claim to be omniscient on all the reasons why nodes don't all mine on pools. Also keep in mind P2Pool. You are mistaken if you think solo miners, large enough to reliably mine solo blocks, don't operate very well connected and outfitted nodes already. P2Pool may be another case because of its own architecture, but in reality it's not remotely large enough to justify outsized influence on protocol wide parameters. If miners felt that was wrong, they could work to give P2Pool more share in terms of global hashrate. So destroy the ability to use P2Pool when we really need later. Illogical to conclude that something underused in one set of constraints is necessarily (without a logical reasoning) no longer need in another set of (lack of) constraints. Sure go ahead and cut off your feet to spite your face (reduce the degrees-of-freedom because you are omniscient and don't need to walk in the future because you have levitron strapped to your back). MAKE MY DAY PLEASE. Hey we already have a fiat financial system. Since everybody is doing it that way, let's just move further that direction right. Intelligent way to frame a debate, that since we are already headed into the toilet bowl outcome with Buttcon, then let's accelerate it. Thanks so much. You are doing my promotion for me. Kudos.
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 04:02:59 AM |
|
sorry you weren't able to discern that i merely parroted your very words back at you. so any "aggression" you attempt to smear me with, simply look back in the mirror.
No his point was you asserted that DoS protection is no longer needed without providing a logical proof. Your circumstantial BS and sound bite illogic isn't engineering.
|
|
|
|
shmadz
Legendary

Activity: 1512
Merit: 1000
@theshmadz
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 04:12:09 AM |
|
you may be the one missing something.
what i think he was saying is that if Cripplecoin is allowed to remain in place even with the addition of SC's or LN, it won't be able to compete with a lighter nimble altcoin that has no such block limit. reason being, that some feel that SC's or LN, esp if Blockstream is allowed to continue it's financial confliction, will result in a centralized, settlement level, high tx value type unusable cryptocurrency only for institutions, geeks, and wealthy elite. that is, if it doesn't just outright die from small niche use.
a truly scalable Bitcoin knock off w/o this confliction and centralization might be able to truly take off and fund the masses even at the level of microtx's.
let's hope this isn't what has to happen.
This is what gives me the fear: This coin provides an integrated BTC wallet on both PC and phone, simply by forking existing open source Bitcoin wallets and adding "new coin" code (so this is not much harder than creating standalone "new coin" wallets). The wallet you make trustless anonymously exchanges between new coin and BTC. This is very easy to do technically: you add a special txn to the new coin which says "only valid if there is a Bitcoin TXN to this public address with N confirmations". Seller of new coin issues this its first, the Bitcoin seller issues its txn when it sees the new coin txn. If the Bitcoin seller's txn is not issued or confirmed, the new coin txn is invalidated (it remains on the new coin blockchain but becomes a no-op). @doc it seems I'm missing something indeed... You seem to assume that much bad stuff can happen from blocksteam and sc and ln and all this stuff, but none of that can happen unless we increase the block size, so this would seem to invite caution when assessing changes that increase the block size. -- yet you blindly trust and follow and support Mike Hearn and Gavin Andreessen's proposal to recklessly increase the blocksize? @thezerg how did this new coin achieve greater security and trust than bitcoin? How did "silver" become more trusted than "gold"? I do not understand the fear, or the reason for it.
|
"You have no moral right to rule us, nor do you possess any methods of enforcement that we have reason to fear." - John Perry Barlow, 1996
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
June 29, 2015, 04:14:19 AM |
|
Once upon a time when gold was used as currency, silver was also used because you couldn't reasonably mint coin small enough to pay for things like a meal (I heard that this is also why the "bar tab" was invented -- when even silver became too valuable).
With Bitcoin, it seems like 1 Satoshi is small enough to ensure that a "silver to bitcoin's gold" does not happen. However, I think that this is untrue; 1 Satoshi is analogous to 1 atom of gold. The actual minimum bitcoin transfer can be estimated by the point where is becomes inconvenient or expensive to make the transfer. This varies by the individual but I feel it would be a transaction fee of somewhere between 1 and 10 percent.
So the Satoshi is not the smallest effective Bitcoin unit. The smallest practical bitcoin unit is something between 10 and 100 times the transaction fee.
I think that the result of an unscaled bitcoin blockchain is that small-payment niche will open up, allowing a scalable altcoin blockchain to gain market share (lightning network, centralized solutions, and sidechains may block this niche, to an unknown extent -- but note they didn't for gold). This cryptocurrency will begin as the "silver to bitcoin's gold", and a clever implementation might ride Bitcoin's coat-tails to adoption. If Bitcoin becomes extremely successful this new cryptocurrency will overtake it in daily use just like silver overtook gold. But what advantages will Bitcoin have over this new currency? Gold's advantage was essentially its greater value to volume (and weight) ratio. But (as with any crypto-currency), you'll be able to carry and transact large quantities of this new cryptocurrency just as easily as small. So Bitcoin will have no advantage. The new cryptocurrency will ultimately dominate transactions and market cap.
What do you think about this reasoning?
Very close, but no cigar. You miss the security gap. And so now you know why I think I am sitting on a motherlode silver mine right now. @thezerg how did this new coin achieve greater security and trust than bitcoin? How did "silver" become more trusted than "gold"?
That is for me to know and for you to find out  what i think he was saying is that if Cripplecoin is allowed to remain in place even with the addition of SC's or LN, it won't be able to compete with a lighter nimble altcoin that has no such block limit.
It won't compete either if you raise or don't raise the block size. Go ahead and make my day either way.
|
|
|
|
|