smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
May 19, 2015, 11:58:51 PM |
|
Also I have never seen anyone in the Philippines use a heating device for anything but cooking.
Electric water heating has a significant market share world wide, roughly 40%. Obviously there are other such devices, and markets vary. I guess the Philippines won't be hotbed of Bitcoin mining (that makes logical sense given the waste heat issue, conceivably PV might change that at some point).
|
|
|
|
|
|
phoenix1
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:00:53 AM |
|
EDIT: If the wasted heat from mining can be put to good use in a cost effective way, that would definitely be progress
People are already doing that warming their homes in the winter. But the problem with the economics is the duty cycle of you use of the mining chip is too low if you put it in a toaster or any other personal care drier. The chip has to pay back itself in time as it has a limited period of time that it has cutting edge performance. This is not about boosting efficiency of mining. That was pretty much my original question - the duty cycle of the chips vs life cycle of deomestic appliances and efficiency of the mining
|
"Before you embark on a journey of revenge, dig two graves" - Confucius (China 551BC-479 BC)
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:02:39 AM |
|
Also I have never seen anyone in the Philippines use a heating device for anything but cooking.
Electric water heating has a significant market share world wide, roughly 40%. Afaik, electric heating of anything is incredibly inefficient compared to natural gas or propane. Thus this isn't making the world more energy efficient. This is for people who don't care about efficiency because they can afford the safey and lack of hassles of not using gas.
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:02:42 AM Last edit: May 20, 2015, 12:18:19 AM by smooth |
|
The chip has to pay back itself in time as it has a limited period of time that it has cutting edge performance.
Not really, no. If the effective efficiency is very close to 100% infinite (which it is), the chip continues to be viable far longer than dedicated mining chips do. It doesn't need cutting edge performance. Also, we don't know the cost of the chips, but cheap chips can be very, very cheap (<$1). Part of 21's model is silicon IP that you can license to incorporate into an existing chip design (obviously it would be a new design, by existing I mean a chip that already does something else). In terms of production cost for some products that can be literally free (other than IP license fees), if there is extra space on a convenient die size. It will reduce yield but so what, you just ship those as non-mining chips. The ones that work are free.
|
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:04:04 AM |
|
Also I have never seen anyone in the Philippines use a heating device for anything but cooking.
Electric water heating has a significant market share world wide, roughly 40%. Afaik, electric heating of anything is incredibly inefficient compared to natural gas or propane. Thus this isn't making the world more energy efficient. This is for people who don't care about efficiency because they can afford the safey and lack of hassles of not using gas. That's an strange way of measuring efficiency (yes I know you said "energy efficiency", I just consider that measurement somewhat irrelevant). If it has better safety and fewer hassles, that increases efficiency. The fact is, for whatever reasons, 40% of the water heater market buys electric. Unless that changes, adding mining chips to that is essentially free mining.
|
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:06:48 AM |
|
The chip has to pay back itself in time as it has a limited period of time that it has cutting edge performance.
Not really, no. If the effective efficiency is very close to 100% (which it is), the chip continues to be viable far longer than dedicate mining chips do. Also, we don't know the cost of the chips, but cheap chips can be very, very cheap (<$1). Part of 21's model is silicon IP that you can license to incorporate into an existing chip design. In terms of production cost for some products that can be literally free (other than IP license fees), if there is extra space on a convenient die size. It will reduce yield but so what, you just ship those as non-mining chips. The ones that work are free. If they are only going to put these in personal driers, then I am not concerned. As you admit, a dated chip's market share declines over time and they are used only intermittently. That is such a low use activity it won't compete with full time mining for market share. It is the putting of this into phones that alarms me. They are locking in the masses to one money choice (one hashing algorithm at least and we don't know what requirements governments can require these chips to have in the future).
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:11:10 AM |
|
Also I have never seen anyone in the Philippines use a heating device for anything but cooking.
Electric water heating has a significant market share world wide, roughly 40%. Afaik, electric heating of anything is incredibly inefficient compared to natural gas or propane. Thus this isn't making the world more energy efficient. This is for people who don't care about efficiency because they can afford the safey and lack of hassles of not using gas. That's an strange way of measuring efficiency (yes I know you said "energy efficiency", I just consider that measurement somewhat irrelevant). If it has better safety and fewer hassles, that increases efficiency. The fact is, for whatever reasons, 40% of the water heater market buys electric. Unless that changes, adding mining chips to that is essentially free mining. Free for whom? Those who will spend outrageous amount to heat with electricity are receiving an insignificant amount of gain. You can give me 10 free pennies per month and I don't have the time to pick them up off the ground. They are not free for me to pick up. This doesn't aid mankind in any way unless you argue that getting people to do micropayments with a decentralized model of adoption and choice won't otherwise happen. It is way to lock people into a specific money system, especially one with very long time frames on replacement hardware, thus discouraging any competition on money with the government's coin. And this is why if we are going to offer any decentralized choice for micropayment distribution, we had damn well better release it tomorrow.
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:12:07 AM |
|
If they are only going to put these in personal driers, then I am not concerned. As you admit, a dated chip's market share declines over time and they are used only intermittently. That is such a low use activity it won't compete with full time mining for market share.
It might if there are enough of them. I don't really know how these numbers work out, considering for example electric water heaters, or every home having several of these chips in different devices (clothes dryer, hair dryer, dishwasher, portable heater, etc.) It is the putting of this into phones that alarms me. They are locking in the masses to one money choice (one hashing algorithm at least and we don't know what requirements governments can require these chips to have in the future).
Yes, that's a completely different approach and business model, as I said earlier. There is no free mining to be had on a phone. I'm frankly not too worried (incrementally) because phones are likely already the most thoroughly government controlled and compromised devices in existence.
|
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:14:45 AM |
|
Also I have never seen anyone in the Philippines use a heating device for anything but cooking.
Electric water heating has a significant market share world wide, roughly 40%. Afaik, electric heating of anything is incredibly inefficient compared to natural gas or propane. Thus this isn't making the world more energy efficient. This is for people who don't care about efficiency because they can afford the safey and lack of hassles of not using gas. That's an strange way of measuring efficiency (yes I know you said "energy efficiency", I just consider that measurement somewhat irrelevant). If it has better safety and fewer hassles, that increases efficiency. The fact is, for whatever reasons, 40% of the water heater market buys electric. Unless that changes, adding mining chips to that is essentially free mining. Free for whom? Those who will spend outrageous amount to heat with electricity are receiving an insignificant amount of gain. You can give me 10 free pennies per month and I don't have the time to pick them up off the ground. They are not free for me to pick up. Free in that of 100 customers in the world, 60 won't buy an electric heater. Fine. 40 will. If we divide those into 20 with miner chip (or even quite a few chips) and 20 without, both sets pay the same amount of electricity for the same amount of hot water. One mines Bitcoin, the other does not. Whether you think the 20 mining Bitcoin with no added electricity cost is a good or bad thing is likely going to depend on your opinion of Bitcoin, fair enough. But the fact of mining itself has no operational cost here, and I'm guessing that the chip cost can also be very, very low.
|
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:15:17 AM |
|
It is the putting of this into phones that alarms me. They are locking in the masses to one money choice (one hashing algorithm at least and we don't know what requirements governments can require these chips to have in the future).
Yes, that's a completely different approach and business model, as I said earlier. There is no free mining to be had on a phone. I'm frankly not too worried (incrementally) because phones are likely already the most thoroughly government controlled and compromised devices in existence. The danger is not from phones becoming more controlled, it is from locking in people who are not yet on any electronic money system into the government's preferred one.
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:16:56 AM |
|
Also I have never seen anyone in the Philippines use a heating device for anything but cooking.
Electric water heating has a significant market share world wide, roughly 40%. Afaik, electric heating of anything is incredibly inefficient compared to natural gas or propane. Thus this isn't making the world more energy efficient. This is for people who don't care about efficiency because they can afford the safey and lack of hassles of not using gas. That's an strange way of measuring efficiency (yes I know you said "energy efficiency", I just consider that measurement somewhat irrelevant). If it has better safety and fewer hassles, that increases efficiency. The fact is, for whatever reasons, 40% of the water heater market buys electric. Unless that changes, adding mining chips to that is essentially free mining. Free for whom? Those who will spend outrageous amount to heat with electricity are receiving an insignificant amount of gain. You can give me 10 free pennies per month and I don't have the time to pick them up off the ground. They are not free for me to pick up. Free in that of 100 customers in the world, 60 won't buy an electric heater. Fine. 40 will. If we divide those into 20 with miner chip (or even quite a few chips) and 20 without, both sets pay the same amount of electricity for the same amount of hot water. One mines Bitcoin, the other does not. Whether you think the 20 mining Bitcoin with no added electricity cost is a good or bad thing is likely going to depend on your opinion of Bitcoin, fair enough. But the fact of mining itself has no operational cost here, and I'm guessing that the chip cost can also be very, very low. Did you crop my post or was I still editing it when you replied? I don't think you responded to my point at all. I did not ask "free in that". I asked "free for whom?". Who gets something free that they even notice?
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:23:03 AM |
|
It is the putting of this into phones that alarms me. They are locking in the masses to one money choice (one hashing algorithm at least and we don't know what requirements governments can require these chips to have in the future).
Yes, that's a completely different approach and business model, as I said earlier. There is no free mining to be had on a phone. I'm frankly not too worried (incrementally) because phones are likely already the most thoroughly government controlled and compromised devices in existence. The danger is not from phones becoming more controlled, it is from locking in people who are not yet on any electronic money system into the government's preferred one. .gov prefers Bitcoin now? What don't I see? If you lock up enough people into Bitcoin, the "winner take all" proposition of network effects and money is more likely. You may be aware of the threat, but I assert most people are clueless. If we have some time to introduce them to the Knowledge Age and find things they like to do that they need a non-Bitcoin system for, then we have a chance to avoid the NWO-everywhere outcome. But this accelerated method of exposing people to Bitcoin via forced mining leapfrogs normal methods and means of discovery and adoption (which rpietila says can normally be a 24 month process for each individual). Tell people they can get free money. Don't tell them their electric bill will increase by $1 per month. They don't notice. They get some free crap for their cell phone such as ring tones. They become enslaved to the government coin. Later they need these credits to access their Facebook. Later you can't board a plane if you don't have these credits. Etc...
|
|
|
|
|
|
Adrian-x
Legendary

Activity: 1372
Merit: 1000
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:33:17 AM |
|
Also I have never seen anyone in the Philippines use a heating device for anything but cooking.
And why would someone in the developing world use an electric heating device when these are much less efficient than propane.
What I am driving at is the playarefully (w here is not about free electricity. It is about fooling people who don't count their electricity chich is most of us) and/or getting people locked into one form of money that the government can takeover.
The advantage of a CPU is that you can reuse it for many tasks. You don't have to be locked into the chip design that Larry Summers decides should go into your mobile device. This is incredibly 666 directed. Now we have fascist merger of Treasury Dept of the USA and chipsets for mobile phones.
I'm not sure they all have cold showers, but you don't need to look far to see electricity heating is very common wherever there isn't natural gas on demand. FYI 3rd World people even those with subsidized electricity don't squander it like you think, many have pay as you go metering and are very conscious of when and where to use electricity, it makes up a much bigger portion of there monthly budget so its treated with more respect. I imagine a network of POS terminals and Wifi hotspots like an internet of things micro hashing away. in some parts of the world hashing can even be used to desalinate water.
|
Thank me in Bits 12MwnzxtprG2mHm3rKdgi7NmJKCypsMMQw
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:42:29 AM |
|
Also I have never seen anyone in the Philippines use a heating device for anything but cooking.
Electric water heating has a significant market share world wide, roughly 40%. Afaik, electric heating of anything is incredibly inefficient compared to natural gas or propane. Thus this isn't making the world more energy efficient. This is for people who don't care about efficiency because they can afford the safey and lack of hassles of not using gas. That's an strange way of measuring efficiency (yes I know you said "energy efficiency", I just consider that measurement somewhat irrelevant). If it has better safety and fewer hassles, that increases efficiency. The fact is, for whatever reasons, 40% of the water heater market buys electric. Unless that changes, adding mining chips to that is essentially free mining. Free for whom? Those who will spend outrageous amount to heat with electricity are receiving an insignificant amount of gain. You can give me 10 free pennies per month and I don't have the time to pick them up off the ground. They are not free for me to pick up. Free in that of 100 customers in the world, 60 won't buy an electric heater. Fine. 40 will. If we divide those into 20 with miner chip (or even quite a few chips) and 20 without, both sets pay the same amount of electricity for the same amount of hot water. One mines Bitcoin, the other does not. Whether you think the 20 mining Bitcoin with no added electricity cost is a good or bad thing is likely going to depend on your opinion of Bitcoin, fair enough. But the fact of mining itself has no operational cost here, and I'm guessing that the chip cost can also be very, very low. Did you crop my post or was I still editing it when you replied? I don't think you responded to my point at all. I did not ask "free in that". I asked "free for whom?". Who gets something free that they even notice? The network does. Difficulty goes up. Security goes up. Profitability goes down. Big farms fade away. Maybe. Who gets those Bitcoins does't even matter much. Burn them for all I care. Of course 21's chips will probably just mine on a pool, which might make things worse than ever. I don't claim this is some kind of cryptonirvana. My comments were focused on the question of efficiency. The rest of your post was most about whether this is a good thing. I don't know. I have nothing to say about that at this point.
|
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:43:19 AM |
|
The only reason to care about energy efficiency is either:
1. You personally care.
2. Society benefits.
I assert neither are true in the case of Westerners using electric water heating. And neither are true in the case of enticing dumb people to adopt Bitcoin so they can get some ringtones and later be enslaved with new requirements for this money.
This is benefiting the utility companies (which the TPTB/government now owns via carbon tax and other regulatory capture) and the enslavement of the dumb, which then pits us who want choice against the inertia.
Of course the way to hide this action is to obscure it in more of the same bullshit as climate change or global warming or environmentalism. This is clearly the fingerprint of the Rockefellers.
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:49:42 AM |
|
The network does. Difficulty goes up. Security goes up.
Security goes down! These nodes are all serving the designated pool. Profitability goes down. Big farms fade away. Maybe. Who gets those Bitcoins does't even matter much. Burn them for all I care.
Myopic. Big farms are just usury. This is same usury that is backing utilities. The real profit comes from a monopoly on money, what we were fighting by supporting crypto. Of course 21's chips will probably just mine on a pool, which might make things worse than ever. I don't claim this is some kind of cryptonirvana. My comments were focused on the question of efficiency.
How can we have a meaningful discussion if you pigeonhole to the irrelevant factors only. This is not about energy efficiency. You argued very hard that is it about efficiency (energy or otherwise).
|
|
|
|
|
pa
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 12:52:31 AM |
|
Monero has lost ~90% of it's value vs. BTC since last September
Uh, no. You are misreading something. My bad, I was looking at the market cap valuation which is off that much. The BTC price is only down ~75% from last Sept. Still not exactly great price performance.... http://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/monero/ (click on "all" for the full history) There's something buggy about coinmarketcap.com's XMR charting. The "All" chart only goes to Feb 15, before the recent increase in XMR price. For a better price chart, see: https://poloniex.com/exchange#btc_xmr
|
|
|
|
|
smooth
Legendary

Activity: 2982
Merit: 1203
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 01:00:25 AM |
|
How can we have a meaningful discussion if you pigeonhole to the irrelevant factors only.
This is not about energy efficiency. You argued very hard that is it about efficiency (energy or otherwise).
Simple, someone asked about efficiency, and whether cheap chips in a water heater, toaster, etc. can compete with cutting edge mining chips. I answered. The answer is yes. That may be irrelevant to you, but it was relevant to the person who asked.
|
|
|
|
|
|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
May 20, 2015, 01:03:16 AM |
|
The real goal here is to extract say $3-5 per month (what ever the end user will not notice) from the electric bill and use this "loan repayment method" to get more smartphones and bitcoin to people in the developing world. This is a way to loan a smartphone in exchange for electricity usage.
This can also help centralize the mining of Bitcoin faster as it will bloat the blockchain and tx rate forcing centralization of mining.
The user may get so few BTC that isn't worth converting to an altcoin investment.
It creates a market for the BTC centralized mining micropayments thus driving network effects against any other altcoin's attempt to do decentralized micropayments.
|
|
|
|
|