|
TPTB_need_war
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 07:52:56 AM |
|
I've come to see a single core as being the single greatest threat to Bitcoin out of all of this. A better situation to me would be a bitcoin P2P network with several separately developed cores that adhere to a common set of rules. The upgrade path is then always put to a vote. Any one core could then propose a change simply by implementing it (with a rule that after x% of blocks back the change it becomes active).
Then if people like the change, more will move to that core. This in turn would cause the other core to adopt the change or lose their users, and that is how consensus is achieved. If a majority did not like the change, they would not move to that core, and the change would never be accepted.
At no point in this do any set of gatekeepers get to dictate terms. Since no core has a majority of users captured, change would always have to come through user acceptance and adoption, and developers would simply be proposers of options.
You just reinvented pegged side chains.
|
|
|
|
sickpig
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1014
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 08:55:08 AM |
|
Well, the facts are that Gavin literally did just that; an alternative, hardforked client with a 20 MB block limit, and anyone from the core deve team that didn't like that could watch while he lobbies miners, services and merchants to accept the new client. That was what he said, he has not retracted it, nor confessed the ulterior motive you are affording him. Those are the facts, are they not?
Sure facts are facts, while speculation is another thing entirely. Gaving did something and community at large react to his stimulation. And I prise community reactions, in particular core devs reaction. From what I can see we're moving forward in the process of finding a way to make bitcoin scale. Just to make an example in the beginning of the debate a lot of devs (core or not) did not acknowledge that a block size increase was needed Now almost everybody, modulo mircea popescu and mpex group, agree about some sort of increase. This is a result of Gavin action, and I say a positive one. Other less measurable, but nonetheless actual result, is the increasing pace at which "layer 2" solutions are developed (Lightning Network, Sidechain, Payment channels implementations etc etc). Speculating about what? I am sorry, but the only speculative statement in the above posts between you and I is the part where you assume Gavin was just acting, just doing this for the effect it would have. Again, that's not what he said, he has not retracted what he did say to confess his secret altruistic plan to get everyone talking, nor confessed the ulterior motive you are affording him. I'm not saying you're speculating and neither do I. In fact I'm not assuming anything, not even that Gavin is just acting. I'm just describing the facts as I see them, just to make clear that even if I want to, and I don't, I can't determine real Gavin's intentions. So the answer to your question How do you know that his intention was not to stage a dev-team coup?
is still: I don't know, because it is impossible to determine his real intention.
|
Bitcoin is a participatory system which ought to respect the right of self determinism of all of its users - Gregory Maxwell.
|
|
|
Carlton Banks
Legendary

Activity: 3430
Merit: 3104
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 08:57:18 AM |
|
So the answer to your question: How do you know that his intention was not to stage a dev-team coup?
is still: I don't know, because it is impossible to determine his real intention. Agreed. It's a fundamental truism, applies pretty much universally. You cannot therefore say that Gavin's conduct was a good idea, only the outcome (which was in stark opposition to his conduct) was laudable.
|
Vires in numeris
|
|
|
NewLiberty
Legendary

Activity: 1204
Merit: 1002
Gresham's Lawyer
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 09:04:05 AM |
|
Other less measurable, but nonetheless actual result, is the increasing pace at which "layer 2" solutions are developed (Lightning Network, Sidechain, Payment channels implementations etc etc).
An accelerated delivery is not always a good thing for development quality. I'm more of the opinion that Bitcoin will succeed, provided that it does not fail, and that a misstep can easily be worse than doing nothing. Intelligent people may disagree with this.
|
|
|
|
sickpig
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1014
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 09:21:12 AM |
|
Other less measurable, but nonetheless actual result, is the increasing pace at which "layer 2" solutions are developed (Lightning Network, Sidechain, Payment channels implementations etc etc).
An accelerated delivery is not always a good thing for development quality. I'm more of the opinion that Bitcoin will succeed, provided that it does not fail, and that a misstep can easily be worse than doing nothing. Intelligent people may disagree with this. I agree. Going too fast is never a wise thing to do, especially when you're dealing with ~3.5bn system that could potentially bring a huge change in our society. I don't know if doing nothing is the right thing to do, though. I suppose that all depends on the definition of "success".
|
Bitcoin is a participatory system which ought to respect the right of self determinism of all of its users - Gregory Maxwell.
|
|
|
hdbuck
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1002
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 09:33:15 AM Last edit: June 24, 2015, 09:48:14 AM by hdbuck |
|
Other less measurable, but nonetheless actual result, is the increasing pace at which "layer 2" solutions are developed (Lightning Network, Sidechain, Payment channels implementations etc etc).
An accelerated delivery is not always a good thing for development quality. I'm more of the opinion that Bitcoin will succeed, provided that it does not fail, and that a misstep can easily be worse than doing nothing. Intelligent people may disagree with this. I'd say it depends what you mean by "succeed". Do you mean price-wise, as in making you rich, or changing the face of the world and finance? It appeared to me lately that whilst both outcomes should be complementary, it probably wont be when considering the details of the path we are now on. Explaining myself: Bitcoin, as a disruptive technology, is meant to disrupt, hence, tearing the ambiant status quo in its field - ie. finance. However, it seems lately that the big names in its ecosystem are more concerned about their personal gain and position than working for the greater good: enter Wall Street, banks, ETFs, lobbyists, regulations, intelligencia, politics, etc... Well imho that is a very risky move.. sustaining the old ways and powers in place is denaturing bitcoin's subversive part. I like to refer to myself as a bitcoiner, plain and simple, waging between personal gain and paranoia. The key aspect for bitcoin to success for me is its capacity of giving back a little power to the people, avoiding Big Bro in a lesser extent and its corrupted-to-the-bone establishment. I understand financial freedom has a cost, but it seems we are just turning in circles here: the head of the spear being mortified by power, money, and secrecy. So imho, Bitcoin will probably leave us with a bitter tasting, once they will be done with it. But being a bitcoiner also imply being a little crazy and having a little faith 
|
|
|
|
|
Zarathustra
Legendary

Activity: 1162
Merit: 1004
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 09:58:43 AM |
|
Whether the society and its elite is national or international or both is irrelevant. Relevant is: Do you promote the society (collectivism/paternalism) or the community (anarchy, self-sufficiency). I promote the local and global community with my cryptocoin (and other technology) work and my concept of the coming Knowledge Age. But for you this must be absolute and preclude knowledge sharing in a "global community of exchange / sharing". The latter part is where we differ and you are all tied up into your Mathusianism which clouds your vision. My vision is not clouded. http://www.sciencealert.com/it-s-official-we-re-on-the-brink-of-earth-s-sixth-mass-extinction
|
|
|
|
|
Zarathustra
Legendary

Activity: 1162
Merit: 1004
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 10:18:04 AM |
|
no one cares for your socialist, elitist view around here except for maybe TPTB and a few others. but go ahead, dream on. This is true.
|
|
|
|
|
Zangelbert Bingledack
Legendary

Activity: 1036
Merit: 1000
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 11:45:32 AM |
|
I'm more of the opinion that Bitcoin will succeed, provided that it does not fail, and that a misstep can easily be worse than doing nothing. Intelligent people may disagree with this.
The question is, what more qualifies as "doing nothing": - Letting Bitcoin operate with constantly full blocks, which has never been done before, or
- Continuing to let Bitcoin operate with non-full blocks, effectively uncapped,* as it always has
?* Of course a large part of the debate is over whether the current hard cap is actually doing anything. So the appeal to conservatism implied by "doing nothing" just pushes the question back.
|
|
|
|
|
NewLiberty
Legendary

Activity: 1204
Merit: 1002
Gresham's Lawyer
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 12:32:29 PM |
|
I suppose that all depends on the definition of "success".
My definition of success is perhaps modest to some, but it is still far away: Bitcoin being the protocol and the coin of the internet realm.If it achieves this, it could well become much more, but this is the success for which it is designed.
|
|
|
|
macsga
Legendary

Activity: 1484
Merit: 1002
Strange, yet attractive.
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 01:20:57 PM |
|
I suppose that all depends on the definition of "success".
My definition of success is perhaps modest to some, but it is still far away: Bitcoin being the protocol and the coin of the internet realm.If it achieves this, it could well become much more, but this is the success for which it is designed. Knowing your way of thinking, yes; it is a modest target for something that incorporates so many different things in just one package. Maybe the "beginning of success" would've been more appropriate. 
|
Chaos could be a form of intelligence we cannot yet understand its complexity.
|
|
|
thezerg
Legendary

Activity: 1246
Merit: 1018
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 02:11:33 PM Last edit: June 24, 2015, 02:28:44 PM by thezerg |
|
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/heres-who-is-most-exposed-to-a-greek-default-2015-06-23“The private sector “has almost no direct exposure to Greece anymore,” wrote strategists at J.P. Morgan Cazenove, in a Monday note urging clients to get back into German stocks. So the whole 2011-2012 Greek loan restructuring was basically a strategy to move the bagholders from rich powerful bankers and investors into the hands of the general population (as taxed by their governments), wasn't it? EDIT: the entire system is broken. Let private lenders lend to eurozone countries at essentially no risk (that's moral hazard of bailouts). Then bail out the country and the private lenders using public money because of political/social concepts like one unified europe. How about letting governments default on loans WITHOUT kicking them out of the eurozone. How about a government bankruptcy -> elect a new govt, fire the top 10 central bankers and any other bankers the other central banks deem responsible and have a 5-10 year probationary period where their local central bank cannot give euro-creating loans.
|
|
|
|
|
sickpig
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1014
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 03:08:45 PM |
|
Update: gavin's BIP has been assigned number 101.
|
Bitcoin is a participatory system which ought to respect the right of self determinism of all of its users - Gregory Maxwell.
|
|
|
hdbuck
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1002
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 03:24:12 PM |
|
Update: gavin's BIP has been assigned number 101. lol as in "blocksize 101"? MIT get out of here! 
|
|
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 03:27:15 PM |
|
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/heres-who-is-most-exposed-to-a-greek-default-2015-06-23“The private sector “has almost no direct exposure to Greece anymore,” wrote strategists at J.P. Morgan Cazenove, in a Monday note urging clients to get back into German stocks. So the whole 2011-2012 Greek loan restructuring was basically a strategy to move the bagholders from rich powerful bankers and investors into the hands of the general population (as taxed by their governments), wasn't it? EDIT: the entire system is broken. Let private lenders lend to eurozone countries at essentially no risk (that's moral hazard of bailouts). Then bail out the country and the private lenders using public money because of political/social concepts like one unified europe. How about letting governments default on loans WITHOUT kicking them out of the eurozone. How about a government bankruptcy -> elect a new govt, fire the top 10 central bankers and any other bankers the other central banks deem responsible and have a 5-10 year probationary period where their local central bank cannot give euro-creating loans. they're lying: 
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
sickpig
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1014
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 03:36:22 PM |
|
|
Bitcoin is a participatory system which ought to respect the right of self determinism of all of its users - Gregory Maxwell.
|
|
|
cypherdoc (OP)
Legendary

Activity: 1764
Merit: 1009
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 03:37:08 PM |
|
oh my: 
|
|
|
|
|
sickpig
Legendary

Activity: 1260
Merit: 1014
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 03:39:38 PM |
|
(sorry for the OT) if memory serves somewhere in the last few dozens of pages there was a debate involving climate change, I've just found this interesting article titled "What's really warming the world" http://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2015-whats-warming-the-world/
|
Bitcoin is a participatory system which ought to respect the right of self determinism of all of its users - Gregory Maxwell.
|
|
|
NewLiberty
Legendary

Activity: 1204
Merit: 1002
Gresham's Lawyer
|
 |
June 24, 2015, 03:40:21 PM |
|
I suppose that all depends on the definition of "success".
My definition of success is perhaps modest to some, but it is still far away: Bitcoin being the protocol and the coin of the internet realm.If it achieves this, it could well become much more, but this is the success for which it is designed. Knowing your way of thinking, yes; it is a modest target for something that incorporates so many different things in just one package. Maybe the "beginning of success" would've been more appropriate.  It merely scratches the surface of the capabilities, but achieving only this satisfies the Whitepaper and thus remains my criteria for success. As a guiding principle for the project, doing anything that reduces this potential in order to achieve something other than this, would be against the spirit of Bitcoin. Thus, those efforts could/should be a different project, or would otherwise naturally follow from the success of this one goal, which remains a long way off.
|
|
|
|
|